Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 107 of the Societies Act
  • Section 9 of the Markets Act
  • The Societies Act, Section 107
  • Section 11 of the Markets Act
  • Section 107(1) of the Societies Act
  • Section 11(1)(i) of the Markets Act
  • Section 10 of the Markets Act
  • Section 2(xiii) and Section 2(xiv) of the Markets Act
  • Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Act, 1963
  • Section 110 of the Societies Act
  • Article 226 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 108(2) of the Societies Act
  • The Markets Act
  • Section 11(1) of the Markets Act
  • Section 11(1) of the Constitution
  • Section 107 of the Gujarat Cooperative Societies Act, 1961
  • Section 4 of the Societies Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 107 of the Societies Act
  • Section 9 of the Markets Act
  • The Societies Act, Section 107
  • Section 11 of the Markets Act
  • Section 107(1) of the Societies Act
  • Section 11(1)(i) of the Markets Act
  • Section 10 of the Markets Act
  • Section 2(xiii) and Section 2(xiv) of the Markets Act
  • Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Act, 1963
  • Section 110 of the Societies Act
  • Article 226 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 108(2) of the Societies Act
  • The Markets Act
  • Section 11(1) of the Markets Act
  • Section 11(1) of the Constitution
  • Section 107 of the Gujarat Cooperative Societies Act, 1961
  • Section 4 of the Societies Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals arise from a common judgment of the Gujarat High Court dated 17 March 2015 that allowed eight Special Civil Applications filed by members of the managing committees of eight cooperative credit societies. Those societies were subject to liquidation proceedings initiated under Section 107 of the Gujarat Cooperative Societies Act, 1961 (“Societies Act”). While the Registrar had passed both interim and final winding-up orders, the High Court set aside the final orders and directed a fresh inquiry, which remains pending.

During the 2015 elections to the Sirpur Agricultural Produce Market Committee (“Market Committee”) constituted under the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Act, 1963 (“Markets Act”), the names of the managing committee members of the eight societies were initially included in the voters list prepared under Rule 7 of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Market Rules, 1965. Objections were raised on the ground that liquidation proceedings were pending. The Additional Registrar upheld the objections on 26 February 2015 and ordered deletion of their names. The affected members successfully challenged that order in the High Court, prompting the present appeals by the State authorities.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether members of the managing committees of cooperative societies that are undergoing liquidation proceedings under Section 107 of the Societies Act are entitled to participate in the electoral college and vote for agriculturist members of a Market Committee under Section 11(1)(i) of the Markets Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The eight societies, being in the process of winding up, have ceased to be “cooperative societies dispensing agricultural credit” within the meaning of Section 11(1)(i) of the Markets Act, because Section 110 of the Societies Act limits their business solely to what is necessary for beneficial winding up.
  • Allowing their managing committee members to vote would defeat the spirit of the Markets Act, especially in light of Section 108(2) of the Societies Act, which restricts those officers’ powers during liquidation.
  • The High Court erred in interfering with the Registrar’s order deleting their names from the voters list.

No respondents appeared, and therefore no counter-arguments are recorded in the opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Arunachala Nadar v. State of Madras (AIR 1959 SC 300) Purpose of market-regulation laws is to protect producers from exploitation and secure fair returns. Used to reinforce that representation within Market Committees must further the protective purpose of the Markets Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that Section 11(1)(i) of the Markets Act merely describes the class of societies whose managing committee members form the electoral college; it does not impose a continuous obligation that the societies must be actively dispensing agricultural credit at every moment.

Key steps in the Court’s analysis included:

  • The Societies Act distinguishes between the temporary disability imposed during liquidation proceedings and the ultimate cessation of office, which occurs only upon a final winding-up order (Section 108(3)(b)). Until then, officers legally remain in office.
  • The Gujarat Legislature has expressly curtailed certain rights of officers during liquidation but has not removed the statutory right—conferred by a different statute (the Markets Act)—to participate in Market Committee elections.
  • An interpretation that suspends electoral rights during interim liquidation would create uncertainty about which societies qualify, depending on fluctuating operational status, and could undermine the legislative scheme.
  • Public policy considerations caution against disenfranchising a defined electoral college when liquidation may ultimately be set aside, potentially producing “public mischief.”

Accordingly, the Court held that pending liquidation does not strip the societies of their character as “cooperative societies dispensing agricultural credit” for purposes of Section 11(1)(i), nor does it disenfranchise their managing committee members.

Holding and Implications

Appeals DISMISSED.

Consequently, the High Court’s decision stands, and the names of the managing committee members of the eight cooperative credit societies must remain on the voters list for the Sirpur Market Committee elections. The ruling clarifies that interim liquidation proceedings do not, by themselves, extinguish the statutory electoral rights granted to society officers under the Markets Act. The decision turns on statutory interpretation and does not announce a new constitutional principle.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Vineshkumar Mavjibhai Parmar v. Dethali Gopalak Vividh Karyakari Sahakari Mandali Limited And Others

    Jasti Chelameswar, J.— All these eight appeals are preferred by the unsuccessful respondents in various special civil applications (writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution) before the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad disposed of by a common judgment dated 17-3-2015 2015 SCC OnLine Guj 6195.

    2. Whether the members of the Managing Committees of the Cooperative Societies (against whom proceedings under Section 107 of the Gujarat Cooperative Societies Act, 1961 are pending) have a right to participate in the election process of an Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee constituted under the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Act, 1963. The two enactments mentioned above are referred to hereinafter as “the Societies Act” and “the Markets Act”.

    3. The facts leading to the present litigation: Section 9 of the Markets Act contemplates the establishment of a “Market Committee” for every “market area”. Both expressions are defined under Sections 2(xiii) and 2(xiv). Section 10 of the Markets Act declares market committees to be bodies corporate with perpetual succession and a common seal. Section 11 stipulates that every Market Committee shall consist of 17 members falling into 5 categories. Section 11(1)(i) stipulates that eight agriculturist members shall be elected by an electoral college consisting of the members of the Managing Committees of the “cooperative societies dispensing agricultural credit” (hereafter “the Credit Societies”) in the market area.

    4. Section 11(1)(i) of the Markets Act reads as follows:

    “11. (1)(i) eight agriculturists who shall be elected by members of managing committees of cooperative societies (other than cooperative marketing societies and milk produce cooperative societies) dispensing agricultural credit in the market area;”
    (emphasis supplied)

    5. The activity of cooperative societies in the State of Gujarat is regulated by the Societies Act. Section 107 of the Societies Act provides for the liquidation and winding up of the societies functioning under the Act. Section 107(1) authorises the Registrar to pass an interim order directing a cooperative society to be wound up for any one of the reasons specified in clauses (a), (b) and (c) of Section 107(1). Sub-section (3), thereof authorises the Registrar to pass a final order after granting a hearing to the society against which an interim order under sub-section (1) is made. Such a final order could be one either finally winding up the society by confirming the interim order or vacating the interim order passed earlier, whichever is appropriate in law having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case.

    6. In exercise of the power under Section 107 of the Societies Act proceedings were initiated by the Registrar against eleven Cooperative Societies (established for the purpose of dispensing agricultural credit) operating in the market area of a Market Committee known as Sirpur Market Committee, the details of which are not necessary for the present purpose.

    7. We are concerned with only eight of the eleven Cooperative Societies mentioned above. Admittedly, with reference to each of the said eight Cooperative Societies, interim orders were passed initially under Section 107(1) of the Societies Act directing them to be wound up. Subsequently, final orders directing the winding up of each one of the said Cooperative Societies were also passed. The said orders were challenged before the appellate authority. The matters eventually reached the High Court, complete details of the litigation may not be necessary except to say that the High Court had set aside the final orders with a further direction to the Registrar to conduct an inquiry afresh under Section 107 of the Societies Act and pass appropriate final orders. Admittedly, the said enquiry is pending.

    8. Elections to the Sirpur Market Committee fell due in the year 2015. A voters list (under Rule 7 of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Market Rules, 1965) came to be prepared consisting the names of the members of the Managing Committee of the abovementioned 8 Cooperative Societies (along with other societies) operating within the market area of the Sirpur Market Committee.

    9. In view of the pendency of the liquidation proceedings, objections for the inclusion of the names of the members of the Managing Committees of the 8 Cooperative Societies were raised. Objections were upheld by the proceedings dated 26-2-2015 of the Additional Registrar and Cooperation Officer (Market), Patan, directing the deletion of the names of the members of the Managing Committee of the abovementioned 8 Cooperative Societies. The operative portion of the order dated 26-2-2015 with reference to one of the 8 Societies reads:

    “I, Mr H.G Rawal, authorised officer & Cooperation Officer [Market], Patan and in exercise of the powers conferred in me and as per the provisions of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Act, 1963 and the Market Committee Rules, 1965 allow the application by the objector Mr Parmar Vineshkumar Mavjibai and Prajapati Manishbai Khemabhai for deleting the names of the Managing Committee members of Shri Kalyana Group Gopalak Vividh Karyakari Sahkari Mandali Ltd. at Kalyana, Taluka Siddhpur from the Agriculturist constituency voters list and accept the just and proper objections raised, and in the voters list Sl. Nos. 259 to 279 voters names are ordered to be deleted. The said orders will be subject to the orders passed by the Hon'ble High Court and Additional Registrar[Appeal], Cooperative Society, Gujarat State, Gandhinagar.
    sd/-
    [S.G Rawal]
    Additional Registrar and Co-operation Officer [Market]
    Patan

    10. Aggrieved by such a decision, the members of the Managing Committee of the said Society filed special civil applications invoking Article 226 of the Constitution of India. By the judgment impugned in these appeals, the special civil application was allowed setting aside the orders of the Additional Registrar dated 26-2-2015.

    11. We are informed that the facts relating to the other 7 Societies are substantially similar.

    12. It is argued by the appellant:

    12.1 Since the 8 Societies in question are in the process of being wound up, they ceased to be Credit Societies within the meaning of Section 11(1)(i) of the Markets Act because their activities are limited under Section 110 of the Societies Act i.e the business of the societies can be carried on only so far as may be necessary for the beneficial winding up of the society. It is, therefore, submitted that the members of the Managing Committees of these 8 Societies would be disentitled to be voters at an election for the Agricultural Market Committee.

    12.2 According to the appellants, permitting the members of the Managing Committees of the Credit Societies which are in the process of being wound up, to participate in the election process and elect agriculturist members to the Market Committees, would be inconsistent with the spirit of the Markets Act, in view of the declaration contained in Section 108(2) of the Societies Act.

    12.3 It is, therefore, submitted that the High Court erred in interfering with the orders of the Registrar directing the deletion of the names of the members of the Managing Committees of the 8 Societies from the voters list.

    13. None appears for any one of the respondents.

    14. The purpose of the establishment of the Market Committees was examined and explained by this Court in Arunachala Nadar v. State of Madras AIR 1959 SC 300. A Constitution Bench of this Court made an elaborate inquiry into the legislative history of the subject and held that: (AIR p. 303, para 6)

    “6. … The object of such legislation is to protect the producers of commercial crops from being exploited by the middlemen and profiteers and to enable them to secure a fair return for their produce.”

    15. For achieving the said purpose, Market Committees are constituted under the laws made by the legislatures of various States giving representation considered appropriate by the legislature concerned to various classes of persons who have an interest in achieving the purpose of the Market Committees.

    16. The legislature of the State of Gujarat thought it fit to give representation under the Markets Act to 5 classes of persons: (i) agriculturists, (ii) traders holding general licences, (iii) representatives of the Cooperative Marketing Societies 1961 (Guj 10 of 1962), (iv) a nominated member by the local authority concerned 1949 (Bom 59 of 1949), 1901 (Bom 3 of 1901), 1925 (Bom 18 of 1925), 1959 (Bom 3 of 1959), 1961 (Guj 6 of 1962) within whose jurisdiction the “principal market yard” is situated, and (v) two nominated members of the State Government.

    17. Of the abovementioned 5 classes of members, the first three classes consist of elected members and the latter two are of nominated. Three distinct electoral colleges are created under sub-clauses (i), (ii) and (iii) of Section 11(1) for electing the three classes of elected members:

    “11. Constitution of Market Committee.—(1) Every Market Committee shall consist of the following members, namely—
    (i) eight agriculturists who shall be elected by members of managing committees of cooperative societies other than cooperative marketing societies and milk produce cooperative societies dispensing agricultural credit in the market area;
    (ii) four members to be elected in the prescribed manner from amongst themselves by the traders holding general licences;
    (iii) two representatives of the cooperative marketing societies situate in the market area and holding general licences, to be elected from amongst the members (other than nominal, associate or sympathiser members) of such societies by the members of the Managing Committees of such societies:
    Provided that where the number of cooperative marketing societies so situate does not exceed two, only one representative shall be so elected.”

    18. While the elected representatives to the Market Committee belonging to classes (ii) and (iii) mentioned above are required to be members of the electoral college concerned, the Act does not insist upon such requirement with reference to those who are to be elected under class (i) mentioned above. In other words, the members of the Market Committee belonging to the first of the abovementioned five classes need not be members of the electoral college which elects them.

    19. The right to elect “agriculturists” to a Market Committee is conferred under Section 11 of the Markets Act upon the electoral college consisting of members of the Managing Committees of the cooperative societies operating in the market area which are dispensing agricultural credit (hereafter Credit Societies).

    20. The reason for the above, as we understand, is that those who seek election under the category of agriculturists belong to a very nebulous class, whereas the persons falling under classes (ii) and (iii) mentioned above can be identified with certainty based upon public records. Therefore, the legislature, in its wisdom, thought it fit to create an electoral college which, by virtue of its very activity, would be in a better position to identify agriculturists eligible to contest for the membership of a Market Committee. By the very nature of the office held by them, members of the Managing Committees of “cooperative societies dispensing agricultural credit” would have an opportunity to interact with the agriculturists.

    21. The pendency of the liquidation proceedings in law, compels the elected members of the Managing Committee (officers of the society) of a cooperative society to hand over the custody and control of all the property and assets, etc. of the society to the liquidator appointed under Section 107(1) of the Societies Act. According to the appellants, the necessary implication flowing therefrom is that the members of the Managing Committee of a society facing liquidation proceeding are debarred from in any way dealing with the affairs of their society. Therefore, they should also not be permitted to exercise the right to participate in the election of a Market Committee.

    22. The powers of the liquidator are specified under Section 110, the details of which may not be necessary except to state that the liquidator virtually becomes the caretaker manager of the society whose winding up is impending. At the same time it is equally important to note that Section 108(3)(b) stipulates that the officers of the cooperative society vacate their offices only on the passage of the final order of winding up. Obviously, they continue to be the office-bearers but are disabled from enjoying certain rights attached to the office and performing certain functions to be performed by the holders of the office.

    23. The rights and functions of the officers of a cooperative society are many. Some of them are created by the statute under which the office is created. Others could be the creation of subordinate legislation (in the context of the present case, even the bye-laws of the society). The existence or lack of such rights and functions depend upon the scheme and tenor of the Societies Act and the subordinate legislation made thereunder. Such rights and functions are put an end to only by the operation of law i.e the Societies Act. Apart from that, nothing prevents the legislature from conferring by another law additional rights or functions on a person holding an office created under the Societies Act.

    24. The legislature of Gujarat by Section 11(1) of the Markets Act conferred on the officers of a class of the Credit Societies an additional function of electing members of the Market Committees. Such function is neither conferred on the officers of all the societies functioning under the Societies Act nor such function includes the right to elect every member of the market committee concerned. Such a function obviously creates a right in the officers of the societies. Such a statutory right could not be taken away in the absence of any express authority of law.

    25. The Gujarat Legislature expressly provided under the Societies Act for the curtailment of certain rights of the officers of the societies facing liquidation proceedings. It must be remembered that at the same time it also declared that such officers cease to be the officers of the society only when a final order of winding up is passed. In a given case if the Registrar after an appropriate enquiry following the interim order of winding up decides not to finally wind up the society, the officers of the society would once again be entitled to exercise all the rights associated with it and perform all the functions attached to the office. Therefore, merely because the officers of the Credit Society facing liquidation are disabled from enforcing certain rights attached to the office or perform certain obligations appended to the office, it does not necessarily follow that they are disabled from performing every function entrusted by law to such office.

    26. We now deal with the submission that the society ceased to be a Credit Society in view of the pendency of the winding-up proceedings.

    27. We are of the opinion that the phrase “cooperative societies dispensing agricultural credit in the market area” in Section 11(1)(i) of the Markets Act is only descriptive of the purpose for which the societies are established. Section 11(1)(i) cannot be construed as imposing an incessant obligation of “dispensing agricultural credit” in order to enable the members of the Managing Committee of the Credit Societies to participate in the election to the Market Committee. The obligation, if any, to “dispense agricultural credit” arises under the bye-laws of the society subject of course to the availability of funds and various other factors. We are of the opinion that the abovequoted words are only descriptive of the class of the society, the members of whose Managing Committees are entitled to participate in the election of the Market Committee. It is obvious from the language of the sub-section that there can exist more than one class of cooperative societies functioning under the Act. The very fact that the legislature took care to expressly exclude members of the Managing Committees of two classes of societies i.e “Cooperative Marketing Societies” and “Milk Produce Cooperative Societies”, definitely indicates that there can exist more than one class of societies — apart from the common knowledge.

    28. Section 4 of the Societies Act contemplates that societies could be registered for different purposes. They are — “the promotion of the economic interests of its members or general welfare of its members or economic interest of the general welfare of the public”.

    29. Since Section 11(1)(i) of the Markets Act is establishing an electoral college for the election of a certain class (agriculturists) of members of the Market Committees, the legislature thought it fit that only the members of the Managing Committees of those cooperative societies which have a nexus to agricultural activity should be members of the electoral college.

    30. The submission of the appellant that Section 11(1)(i) imposes a legal obligation that the members of the Managing Committees of only those cooperative societies which are currently dispensing agricultural credit in the market area are entitled to participate in the electoral process of the Market Committee concerned (in other words, the phrase “cooperative societies dispensing agricultural credit” is indicative of the current activity of the societies but not the purpose for which the society is established), would lead to various difficult questions:

    30.1 What is the period to which the currency of such activity would relate to? Whether the activity should be current when the voters list is prepared or the activity should continue even on the date of voting?

    30.2 Whether the Credit Societies which do not dispense agricultural credit for a certain period of time because of either paucity of funds or borrowers are debarred from “dispensing agricultural credit” because of some legal prohibition or any other reason operating temporarily cease to be societies whose objective is to provide agricultural credit?

    31. The Credit Societies against which there is an “interim order” of winding up are temporarily debarred from dispensing agricultural credit, by virtue of the operation of law. The embargo imposed by such interim order may or may not fructify into a final order of winding up. (We have already discussed this aspect of the matter at para 22 supra.) On the face of such possibility of the society resuming its activity of “dispensing agricultural credit” — to debar its Managing Committee members from discharging their statutory obligation under the Markets Act would be productive of public mischief. Such an interpretation of the statute must be avoided.

    32. For the above reasons, we do not see any merit in the appeals. Therefore, the appeals are dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vineshkumar Mavjibha... v. Dethali Gopalak Vivi...
    (Nov 16, 2016)