AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts

    Naveen Kumar Aggarwal and Ors. v. Dove Creation Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.

    "25. In our judgment, the above observations cannot be read to mean that in a criminal case where trial is yet to take place and the matter is at the stage of issuance of summons or taking cognizance, materials relied upon by the accused which are in the nature of public documents or the materials which are beyond suspicion or doubt, in no circumstance, can be looked into by the High Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Section 482 or for that matter in exercise of revisional jurisdiction under section 397 of the code. It is fairly settled now that while exercising inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 or revisional jurisdiction under section 397 of the code in a case where complaint is sought to be quashed, it is not proper for the High Court to consider the defence of the accused or embark upon an enquiry in respect of merits of the accusations. However, in an appropriate case, if on the face of the documents - which are beyond suspicion or doubt - placed by accused, the accusations against him cannot stand, it would be travesty of justice if accused is relegated to trial and he is asked to prove his defence before the trial court. In such a matter, for promotion of justice or to prevent injustice or abuse of process, the High Court may look into the materials which have significant bearing on the matter at prima facie stage."

    20. In the catena of judgments as discussed above, has laid down that the Director who had resigned and was not involved in day to day functioning of the Company, cannot be summoned to face the trial on the ground of vicarious liability, as per section 141 of n.i. act.

    21. The judgment cited by learned counsel for the respondent above are not applicable to the facts of the present case as in these case, the Directors who were made liable under section 141 of n.i. act had not resigned from the Company.

    22. Petitioner-Smriti Thingbaijam had resigned from the Company on 16.02.2013 and the Board of Directors have accepted her resignation on 18.02.2013 and petitioner- Naveen Kumar Aggarwal had tendered his resignation on 21.02.2013 i.e. before the cheque was issued. The Company had informed the Registrar of Societies about the resignation of Smriti Thingbaijam on 16.09.2013, after a gap of 07 months.

    23. The argument has been raised by learned counsel for the respondent that why the company had informed the Registrar of Societies after a gap of 07 months about the resignation of petitioner-Smriti Thingbaijam on 16.09.2013. It was an after thought, as the cheque had been dishonoured on 28.05.2013 and the Company had informed on 16.09.2013 and as per Section As per Section 303 of the Companies Act, 1956, every Company has to sent to the Registrar a return in duplicate containing the particulars specified in the Register. In the change among Directors, Managing Directors, Managers or Secretaries specifying the date of change is also required to be furnished to the Registrar of Companies in the prescribed form within 30 days of such change.

    24. At this stage, reference can be made to judgment of Bombay High Court in a case of Saumildilip Mehta v. State of Maharashtra and others, AIR 2002 Bombay 194 wherein the Court was considering a case under the Companies Act under Section 303(2). Form 32. For all intents and purposes, the Director once gives his resignation, he ceases to be a Director of the Company. He is not required to fill Form No. 32 or issue notice to Registrar of Companies. In paragraph 7, it has been held as under:- "7. When a director has tendered his resignation and the Board of Directors has accepted and has acted on it, such Director cannot be held liable for the liability incurred by the said Company after the date of acceptance of his resignation except the liability which has been incurred by him for purchase of shares of the said company and nothing more."

    25. Hon'ble Delhi High Court in a case of B.N. Kaushik v. Registrar of Companies, 2009 150 Comp Cas 97 (Delhi) was considering the conviction of the Director under Section 162/220 of the Companies Act, who had resigned as Director and his copy of resignation letter was sent to Registrar and receipt of resignation letter was accepted by the Registrar and his conviction was set aside on the ground that sending of resignation letter was sufficient compliance of the provisions of the companies act as well as circular No. 429400)-CL-II-59 dated 29.12.1959. In paragraph 11, it has been held as under:- "11. The aforesaid judgment in Anita Chadha (supra), in my view, has no application to the facts of the present case for the reason that the facts of the said case are clearly distinguishable. The petitioner in the instant case, had tendered his resignation on July 27, 1971 i.e. 11 to 15 years prior to the alleged violations which pertained to the years 1982, 1983, 1984, 1985 and 1986. The receipt of the said resignation is specifically admitted by the respondent and no material has been placed on record by the respondent to show that the same was not accepted or was objected to either by the accused company or by the Registrar of Companies. The complaints are dated July 16, 1993, which goes to show that the same were initiated more than 22 years after the Registrar of Companies had admittedly been communicated the letter of resignation of the petitioner and had accepted the same in terms of its own circular."

    26. In the facts of the present case, Petitioner-Smriti Thingbaijam had resigned from the Company on 16.02.2013 and the Board of Directors have accepted her resignation on 18.02.2013 and petitioner-Naveen Kumar Aggarwal had tendered his resignation on 21.02.2013 i.e. before the cheque was issued, and is full time employee of Bank of America since 11.12.2006. The said change was communicated to the Registrar of Companies in June, 2013. A photocopy of Form 32 is Annexure P-7 colly. In the case of Smriti Thingbaijam, the Registrar of Companies was informed about her resignation on 16.09.2013 and in the case of petitioner- Naveen Kumar Aggarwal, the Registrar of Companies was informed about his resignation in June, 2013. But this gap would not make the petitioners liable for dishonour of the cheques, which was presented on 27.05.2013 and was dishonoured as they had resigned from the post of Directors and their resignation had been duly conveyed to the Registrar of Companies. Thus, they were not involved in day to day affairs of the company and no liability can be thus fastened upon them. In the light of the above discussion, Criminal Complaint No. 20686 of 2013 dated 09.07.2013 and Criminal Complaint No. 20677 of 2013 dated 09.07.2013 and summoning order dated 09.07.2013 passed by learned Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Ludhiana are hereby quashed. Accordingly, the petitions are allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Naveen Kumar Aggarwal and Ors. v. Dove Creation Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.
    (Nov 13, 2014)