AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (3) read with sub-rule (1) thereof, condemning, Rule 60(2) of KCRP as ultra vires Order XVI, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code,
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 and Rule 1-A of Order XVI. Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order XVI
  • Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code and under section 65 of the Evidence Act
  • SECTION 151 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, Order XVI, Civil Procedure Code,
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 1, Order XVI, Civil Procedure Code,
  • Rule 1-A was in derogation of sub-rule (3) of Rule
  • ORDER 16 A RULE 1 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Order XVI, Rule 1(1) of Civil Procedure Code.10.
  • sub-rule (1) of Order 16, Civil Procedure Code,
  • CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE AMENDMENT ACT
  • Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code
  • provisions of sub-rule (3) of Rule 1,
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 and Rule 1-A
  • SECTION 65 A EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 65 B EVIDENCE ACT
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 1,
  • Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (3) read with sub-rule (1) thereof, condemning, Rule 60(2) of KCRP as ultra vires Order XVI, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code,
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 and Rule 1-A of Order XVI. Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order XVI
  • Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code and under section 65 of the Evidence Act
  • SECTION 151 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, Order XVI, Civil Procedure Code,
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 1, Order XVI, Civil Procedure Code,
  • Rule 1-A was in derogation of sub-rule (3) of Rule
  • ORDER 16 A RULE 1 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Order XVI, Rule 1(1) of Civil Procedure Code.10.
  • sub-rule (1) of Order 16, Civil Procedure Code,
  • CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE AMENDMENT ACT
  • Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code
  • provisions of sub-rule (3) of Rule 1,
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 and Rule 1-A
  • SECTION 65 A EVIDENCE ACT
  • SECTION 65 B EVIDENCE ACT
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 1,
  • Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an order dated 12-5-2014 wherein his application under Order 16, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) seeking summons for a witness was rejected by the lower court. The petitioner had earlier filed applications under Order 7, Rule 14(3) CPC and section 65 of the Evidence Act concerning a compact disk and photographs related to the suit property, which were allowed. However, the application under Order 16, Rule 1 CPC was dismissed on the ground that the plaintiff had not filed a list of witnesses within the prescribed 15 days from the framing of issues, and thus could not summon a witness without court permission and proper justification for omission.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a party can summon a witness under Order 16, Rule 1 CPC without having filed a list of witnesses within the stipulated time.
  2. Whether the lower court erred in rejecting the application for summoning a witness on a hyper-technical ground despite allowing related applications concerning the same evidence.
  3. The interpretation and application of sub-rule (1), sub-rule (3), and Rule 1-A of Order 16 CPC in relation to summoning witnesses not named in the original list.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Mangeram v. Brij Mohan (1983) 4 SCC 36, arguing that the lower court's rejection was contrary to settled law.
  • He contended that under section 65-B of the Evidence Act, the statement of the photographer was necessary and the court’s technical approach was unjustified.
  • The petitioner sought interference under Article 227 of the Constitution to set aside the impugned order.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The respondent relied on various clauses of Order 16, Rule 1 CPC, maintaining that the lower court’s order was legally sound and free of error.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mangeram v. Brij Mohan, (1983) 4 SCC 36 Interpretation of sub-rule (1), sub-rule (3), and Rule 1-A of Order 16 CPC regarding summoning witnesses not named in the list. The Court adopted the principle that sub-rule (3) and Rule 1-A operate in different areas and allow summoning witnesses even if not named in the original list, provided sufficient cause is shown.
Vidhyadhar v. Manikrao, (1999) 3 SCC 573 Clarification of the scope of sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 and Rule 1-A of Order 16 CPC in summoning witnesses. The Court reiterated that parties may summon witnesses not named in the list with court permission, supporting a liberal approach to procedural rules.
Rehman Hussain v. Althaf Hussain, AIR 2004 Kar. 172 Application of sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, Order 16 CPC and the invalidity of Rule 60(2) of KCRP if inconsistent. The Court held that even if the correct provision is not cited, the court may entertain the application under sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, and procedural rules should not be a barrier to justice.
Dataram Singh v. Brindawan Singh, 2014 (3) MPLJ 612 Procedural law must facilitate justice and should not be applied in a hyper-technical manner to defeat substantive rights. The Court emphasized that procedural rules are handmaids of justice, not obstacles, and should be interpreted to advance justice rather than defeat it.
Sangram Singh v. 1. Election Tribunal, Kotah, AIR 1955 SC 425 Principle that procedural law is designed to facilitate justice and not to punish or trip litigants. Supported the view that procedural rules should be interpreted with reasonable elasticity to avoid injustice.
Sushil Kumar Sen v. State Of Bihar, (1975) 1 SCC 774 Necessity of procedural law to serve justice and not overpower substantive rights. Reinforced the humanist rule that procedure should be the handmaid of justice.
State of Punjab v. Shamlal Murari, (1976) 1 SCC 719 Procedural law as a servant to justice, not a tyrant. Highlighted that procedural prescriptions are aids to justice, not obstructions.
Ghanshyam Dass v. Dominion of India, (1984) 3 SCC 46 Interpretation of procedural law to advance the cause of justice. Reiterated that procedural law should subserve justice rather than defeat it.
Kailash v. Nanhku, (2005) 4 SCC 480 Procedural provisions should not render courts helpless in extraordinary situations. Held that procedural enactments must be construed to enable courts to meet the ends of justice.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the interplay between sub-rule (1), sub-rule (3), and Rule 1-A of Order 16 CPC as clarified by the Supreme Court in Mangeram v. Brij Mohan and subsequent decisions. It held that sub-rule (3) confers a broader jurisdiction allowing a party to summon witnesses not named in the original list, provided sufficient cause is shown. Rule 1-A allows a party to bring witnesses without summons but subject to court's permission. The Court emphasized that procedural laws are designed to facilitate justice and should not be applied in a hyper-technical manner that would defeat substantive rights. The lower court erred in rejecting the application on the ground that no witness list was filed, especially since related applications concerning the same evidence were allowed. The Court relied on authoritative precedents to hold that the procedural provisions must be interpreted liberally to advance justice rather than obstruct it.

Holding and Implications

The Court set aside the impugned order dated 12-5-2014 to the extent it disallowed the application under Order 16, Rule 1 CPC and allowed the application. The lower court was directed to proceed from the stage of summoning the witness as per the allowed application.

The decision directly benefits the petitioner by permitting the summoning of the witness despite the absence of an earlier filed witness list. No new precedent was created; the Court reaffirmed established principles emphasizing a just and liberal approach to procedural rules in civil litigation.

    Mandir Shri Hanuman Murti And Another v. Collector Mahoday, Datia And Another

    The petitioner is aggrieved by order dated 12-5-2014 whereby his application preferred under Order 16, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code for summoning the witness for evidence has been rejected by the Court below.

    2. Shri Raja Sharma, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that petitioner preferred an application under Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code along with another application under section 65 of the Evidence Act. These applications were relating to compact disk (CD) of the photographer and certain photographs of suit property. The Court below allowed the said applications preferred under Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code and under section 65 of the Evidence Act respectively. However, the application under Order 16, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code was rejected on the ground that as per the sub-rule (1) of Order 16, Civil Procedure Code, the plaintiff was required to file list of witnesses within 15 days from the date of framing of issues. As per sub-rule (3) of said Rule, the new witness other than the witnesses whose names are mentioned in the said list, may be called provided leave/permission is granted by the Court. The party seeking such permission needs to assign reason for not mentioning the name of such new witness in the said list. The Court below opined that in the present case the plaintiff did not submit any list of witnesses. Hence, he cannot be permitted to summon the witness through Court.

    3. By placing reliance on (1983) 4 SCC 36, Mangeram v. Brij Mohan, Shri Raja Sharma submits that finding of Court below runs contrary to the settled legal position. He submits that as per requirement of section 65-B of Evidence Act the statement of photographer is necessary. The Court below has taken technical approach after having allowed other two applications relating to the same photograph/CD. The order of Court below was not justifiable and needs interference in this petition under Article 227 of the Constitution.

    4. Shri Kumar Gaurav Sharma placed reliance on various clauses of Order 16, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code and urged that there is no legal error in the order of Court below.

    5. No other point is pressed by learned counsel for the parties.

    6. I have heard the parties and perused the record.

    7. In my view, the Apex Court has drawn curtains on the question involved in this case. In Mange Ram (supra) the Apex Court opined as under:—

    “There is no inner contradiction between sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 and Rule 1-A of Order XVI. Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order XVI confers a wider jurisdiction on the Court to cater to a situation, where the party has failed to name the witness in the list and yet the party is unable to produce him or her on his own under Rule 1-A and in such a situation the party of necessity has to seek the assistance of the Court under sub-rule (3) to procure the presence of the witness and the Court, may if it is satisfied that the party has sufficient cause for the omission to mention the name of such witness in the list filed under sub-rule (1) of Rule 1, the Court may still extend its assistance for procuring the presence of such a witness by issuing a summons through the Court or otherwise which ordinarily the Court could not extend for procuring the attendance of a witness whose name is not shown in the list. Therefore, Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 and Rule 1-A operate in two different areas and cater to two different situations.”

    8. The said view was followed by Supreme Court in Vidhyadhar v. Manikrao, reported in (1999) 3 SCC 573 : AIR 1999 SC 1441, the Apex Court opined as under:—

    “30. These two Rules read together clearly indicate that it is open to a party to summon the witness to the Court or may, without applying for summons, bring the witnesses to give evidence or to produce documents. Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 provides that although the name of a witness may not find place in the list of witnesses filed by a party in the Court, it may allow the party to produce a witness though he may not have been summoned through the Court. Rule 1-A which was introduced by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1976 with effect from 1-2-1977 has placed the matter beyond doubt by providing in clear and specified terms that any party to the suit may bring any witness to give evidence or to produce documents. Since this Rule is subject to the provisions of Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, all that can be contended is that before proceeding to examine any witness who might have been brought by a party for that purpose, the leave of the Court may be necessary but this by itself will not mean that Rule 1-A was in derogation of sub-rule (3) of Rule 1. The whole position was explained by this Court in Mange Ram v. Brij Mohan, AIR 1983 SC 925 : (1983) 4 SCC 36 : (1983) 3 SCR 525, in which it was held that Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 and Rule 1-A operate in two different areas and cater to two different situations.”

    9. The said Supreme Court's judgments were considered by Division Bench of Karnataka High Court in AIR 2004 Kar. 172, Rehman Hussain v. Althaf Hussain. The High Court opined as under:—

    “14. In the present case, of course, the plaintiff has not filed the application under Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, Order XVI, Civil Procedure Code, but he has filed an application purported to be under Rule 60(2) of KCRP read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code. It is well settled that if a Court has jurisdiction to entertain an application in law, simply because the mover of the application has not stated correct provision of law or has stated wrong or incorrect provisions of law, that circumstance will not divest the power of the Court to entertain the application and pass appropriate order on merit. Therefore, the application already filed by the plaintiff could be regarded as the application filed under Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, Order XVI, Civil Procedure Code. Since, we have held that even in a case where a party has not filed list of witnesses envisaged under sub-rule (1) of Rule 1, Order XVI, Civil Procedure Code, he can make an application under sub-rule (3) read with sub-rule (1) thereof, condemning, Rule 60(2) of KCRP as ultra vires Order XVI, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code, would not arise. In other words, Rule 60(2) of KCRP proviso is ultra vires Order XVI, Rule 1(1) of Civil Procedure Code.”

    10. In view of aforesaid legal position, there is no difficulty to hold that Court below has erred in examining the matter with a hyper technical point of view. As per said judgments, a witness can be brought by party even if no list is filed earlier or name of said witness does not figure in the said list. It needs to be remembered that procedural law is made to advance the cause of justice. The same is not made to strangulate the litigant on hyper technical ground. This Court considered this aspect in 2014 (3) MPLJ 612, Dataram Singh v. Brindawan Singh and opined as under:—

    “This is settled in law that all the rules of procedure are the handmaid of justice. The Apex Court in AIR 1955 SC 425, Sangram Singh v. 1. Election Tribunal, Kotah opined that A Code of Civil Procedure must be regarded as such. It is “procedure”, something designed to facilitate justice and further its ends: not a penal enactment for punishment and penalties; not a thing designed to trip people up. Too technical a construction of sections that leaves no room for reasonable elasticity of interpretation should therefore be guarded against. The Apex Court in (1975) 1 SCC 774, Sushil Kumar Sen v. State Of Bihar opined that the mortality of justice at the hands of law troubles a Judge's conscience and points an angry interrogation at the law reformer. The processual law so dominates in certain systems as to overpower substantive rights and substantial justice. The humanist rule that procedure should be the handmaid, not the mistress, of legal justice compels consideration of vesting a residuary power in Judges to act ex debito justitiae where the tragic sequel otherwise would be wholly inequitable. Justice is the goal of jurisprudence-processual, as much as substantive. In (1976) 1 SCC 719, State of Punjab v. Shamlal Murari, the Apex Court held that processual law is not to be a tyrant but a servant, not an obstruction but an aid to justice. Procedural prescriptions are the handmaid and not the mistress, a lubricant, not a resistant in the administration of justice. In (1984) 3 SCC 46, Ghanshyam Dass v. Dominion of India the Apex Court reiterated the need for interpreting a part of the adjective law dealing with procedure alone in such a manner as to subserve and advance the cause of justice rather than to defeat it as all the laws of procedure are based on this principle. In (2005) 4 SCC 480, Kailash v. Nanhku the Apex Court held that the provisions of Civil Procedure Code or any other procedural enactment ought not to be construed in a manner which would leave the Court helpless to meet extraordinary situations in the ends of justice.”

    11. As analyzed above, the Court below was not justified in disallowing the application preferred under Order 16, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code. More so when related applications preferred under Order 7, Rule 14(3), Civil Procedure Code and under section 65 of the Evidence Act were allowed. The impugned order of the Court below runs contrary to settled legal position. Consequently, the impugned order dated 12-5-2014 to the extent application preferred under Order 16, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code was disallowed, is set aside. The application stands allowed. The Court below is directed to proceed from that stage.

    12. Petition is allowed.

    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mandir Shri Hanuman Murti And Another v. Collector Mahoday, Datia And Another
    (Sep 9, 2015)