Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 122, 123 and 124 of the Evidence Act, 1872. Rule 14 of Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Rule 14 of Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Order XI Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Rule 12 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 122, 123 and 124 of the Evidence Act, 1872. Rule 14 of Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Rule 14 of Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Order XI Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Rule 12 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the defendant in Civil Suit No. 23 of 2007, filed by the respondent for recovery of Rs. 3,98,747.23. During the suit the respondent applied for an order directing the petitioner to produce specified documents for the years 2004-05 and 2005-06 (balance sheets, ST. VII returns, sale/purchase vouchers, credit notes from Malhotra Electronics Garhshankar, and receipts of payments). The respondent alleges he supplied electronic goods worth Rs. 2,85,546/- which remain unpaid; the petitioner alleges payment was made. The petitioner opposed the application and the trial Court, by order dated 11.4.2013, allowed the application and directed production of the listed documents. The petitioner filed this civil revision challenging that order. An earlier application by the respondent (for better particulars) was dismissed on 24.4.2009.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Court rightly directed the petitioner to produce the documents sought by the respondent under Order XI Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. Whether the documents sought are privileged or whether the order would amount to an impermissible fishing and roving inquiry.
  3. Whether the earlier dismissal of an application for better particulars affects the present application for production of documents.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The earlier similar application was dismissed (24.4.2009) and the present application was incorrectly allowed without due consideration of merits.
  • The respondent must prove his case independently; the petitioner is not obliged to produce the documents sought.
  • Relied on Punj Star Industries (P) Ltd. v. Atna Investment Pvt. Ltd. to contend that the plaintiff cannot compel production of documents showing where the defendant invested money and that fishing/roving inquiries are impermissible.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The petitioner never averred that the documents sought are privileged; since they are not privileged the petitioner should produce them to assist adjudication of the dispute.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Punj Star Industries (P) Ltd. v. Atna Investment Pvt. Ltd., (Delhi), 2001 (4) RCR (Civil) 628 Proposition that a plaintiff cannot require a defendant to produce documents showing where the defendant invested money; fishing and roving inquiry is not permissible. The Court held the facts of Punj Star were not akin to the present case and that the principle in Punj Star did not apply to deny production here.
Sharvan Kumar v. Sumeet Kumar Garg, 2003 (1) Civil Court Cases 456 Held that Court may issue directions under Rule 12 for discovery on oath; production under Order XI Rule 14 should not be declined if documents relate to a fact in issue; refusal only for privileged documents. The Court relied on this decision to support ordering production under Order XI Rule 14 and to note that only privileged documents (Evidence Act ss. 122–124) may be excepted.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court considered the parties' contentions and relevant law. It noted Rule 14 of Order XI CPC empowers the Court to order production of documents in a party's possession or power that relate to any matter in question, and that the Court may deal with produced documents as appears just. The Court referenced Sharvan Kumar to observe that production requests under Order XI Rule 14 are ordinarily granted where documents relate to facts in issue, with refusal limited to privileged documents under Sections 122–124 of the Evidence Act. The Court distinguished Punj Star as not analogous and concluded production would not result in an impermissible roving or fishing inquiry in the present facts. It found the documents sought relevant to the recovery suit—potentially bearing on whether the petitioner discharged his payment obligations—and noted the earlier application (dismissed in 2009) had been for better particulars, not for production of documents. On this basis the Court found no illegality in the trial Court's order and upheld it.

Holding and Implications

Civil revision dismissed; impugned order dated 11.4.2013 upheld.

Direct effects: the petitioner is directed to produce the listed documents in the trial Court; the civil revision fails and is dismissed with no order as to costs, and the decision is without prejudice to the merits of the main suit. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new precedent beyond application of existing provisions (Order XI Rule 14 CPC and the privileged-documents exceptions under the Evidence Act).

    Onkar Singh Petitioner v. Ravinder Malhotra

    S.P BANGARH, J.

    Petitioner, herein, is defendant in Civil Suit No. 23 of 2007, that has been filed against him by the respondent, before the trial Court, for recovery of Rs. 3,98,747-23.

    During the pendency of the suit, the respondent, herein, filed an application for directing the petitioner to produce the following documents:-

    i) Certified copies of balance sheets of defendant shop for the years 2004-05 and 2005-06.

    ii) Copies (Certified or attested) of ST. VII return for the years 2004-05 and 2005-06.

    iii) Sale and purchase vouchers of his shop for the years 2004-05 and 2005-06.

    iv) Copies or original credit notes issued by the Malhotra Electronics Garhshankar (Business conception of plaintiff) to the defendant for the years 2004-05 and 2005-06.

    v) Receipt of payments issued by plaintiff to the defendant during the period for the years 2004-05 and 2005-06.”

    It is the case of the respondent that he supplied electronic goods to the petitioner for a sum of Rs. 2,85,546/-, that have not been paid, but the petitioner has been alleging that he had already paid the said amount to the respondent. The petitioner is an income tax payee and is holding Permanent Account Number. An income tax payee is required to show the payments in his balance-sheet, filled annually. These documents are in possession of the petitioner and are essential documents for deciding the real controversy between the parties. So, prayer was made that the petitioner may be directed to produce the documents (supra), on the file of the suit.

    This application, on the other hand, was opposed by the petitioner by filing written reply, thereto, averring, therein, that the suit filed by the respondent, as also, the facts mentioned in the suit and in the application, are absolutely wrong. It is the duty of the respondent to prove his case independently and he has no right to obtain any document from the petitioner, who is not liable to produce any document stated in the application. Consequently, prayer for dismissal of the application was, thus, made.

    After hearing both the sides, the trial Court, vide impugned order dated 11.4.2013 (Annexure P-3), allowed the application and directed the petitioner, herein, to produce the documents mentioned in the application, that have been reproduced in the earlier part of this judgment.

    Aggrieved against the order (supra), the petitioner, who is defendant before the trial Court, has come up in this civil revision with prayer for acceptance, thereof, and for dismissal of the application, that was allowed by the trial Court, vide the impugned order.

    Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that a similar application was filed by the respondent earlier, that was dismissed vide order dated 24.4.2009 He further contended that after about four years i.e on 9.8.2012, the respondent filed the present application, on similar grounds, for direction to the petitioner to produce documents, whereto, detailed reply was given, which was allowed vide the impugned order, without considering the merits and demerits of the application. He further contended that the impugned order passed by the trial Court is against law and facts of the case and, therefore, is liable to be set aside.

    He also placed reliance upon the judgment of the Delhi High Court in Punj Star Industries (P) Ltd. v. Atna Investment Pvt. Ltd., (Delhi), 2001 (4) RCR (Civil) 628, wherein, it was held that the plaintiff cannot ask for production of documents in possession of defendant, as to where the latter invested the money in question. It was further held in this judgment that fishing and roving inquiry is not permissible. So, the learned counsel for the petitioner, in view of this judgment, contended that the impugned order may be set aside and the application for production of documents filed by the respondent before the trial Court, may be dismissed.

    On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent contended that it has nowhere been averred by the petitioner in the reply that the documents sought to be produced, are privileged documents. He further contended that since the documents sought to be summoned from the petitioner are not privileged documents, there should have been no hesitation by him to produce those documents, for adjudicating the controversy between the parties.

    Thoughtful consideration has been given to the contentions raised by the learned counsel for the parties.

    Learned counsel for the respondent placed reliance upon the judgment of this Court in Sharvan Kumar v. Sumeet Kumar Garg, 2003 (1) Civil Court Cases 456, wherein, it was held that the Court may issue direction under Rule 12 of the Code of Civil Procedure, to any party to the suit, to make discovery on oath, of documents which are or have been in his possession or power. If, such discovery is found to be unnecessary, then such a prayer can be declined on the ground that it is not necessary for disposing of the suit. It was held that request for production of documents, in terms of under Order XI Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure, is never declined, if documents relate to any fact in issue or relevant facts. It was held that refusal can only be in regard to privileged documents.

    In the judgment of this Court (supra), it was further held that the judgment in the case of Punj Star Industries (P) Ltd. (supra), has no application to the facts of that case.

    The production of documents by the petitioner shall not lead to roving and fishing inquiry. So, the facts and circumstances of the judgment in the case of Punj Star Industries (P) Ltd. (supra), are not akin to the case in hand, especially, when it has been enshrined in Rule 14 of Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure, that it shall be lawful for the Court, at any time, during the pendency of any suit, to order the production by any party thereto, upon oath of such of the documents in his possession or power, relating to any matter in question in such suit, as the Court shall think right; and the Court may deal with such documents, when produced, in such manner as shall appear just.

    In view the rule (supra), there is hardly any scope for dismissal of such an application, that is filed under Order XI Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure. As already noticed, only exception could be raised with regard to the privileged documents under Sections 122, 123 and 124 of the Evidence Act, 1872. Rule 14 of Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure, is confined to production of only those documents that relate to any fact in issue or relevant fact. Under Rule 14 of Order XI of the Code of Civil Procedure, all the documents listed in the application are required to be produced by the petitioner in the Court and for assisting it to arrive at right conclusion in the suit. At this stage, it is arduous to hold that the documents sought to be produced, are not germane for just decision of the suit.

    The recovery suit, that has been filed by the respondent against the petitioner, is based on certain documents. The petitioner has been claiming that no amount is due for payment to the respondent. He had a business transaction with the respondent. He must be holding documentary proof to prove that he may have discharged his obligation towards the electronic goods that have been purchased by him from the respondent and the documents sought to be produced, will be relevant for decision of the suit and even, on the basis of those documents, the trial Court may reach at a conclusion that, in view of the documents of the petitioner, that are being sought to be produced from him, no amount is outstanding against him for payment to the respondent, relating to the business transaction, that had taken place between the parties, regarding sale and purchase of electronic goods.

    Earlier application, that was not pressed and dismissed, on 24.4.2009, moved by the respondent, was for supplying better particulars. So, this application was not for production of documents, like the application in question.

    There is, thus, no illegality or impropriety in the impugned order, and the same is, hereby, upheld and affirmed.

    Resultantly, the civil revision fails and is, hereby, dismissed with no order as to costs, sans prejudice to the merits of the main suit.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Onkar Singh Petitioner v. Ravinder Malhotra
    (Dec 3, 2013)