Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The proceedings originated from a news item in The Times of India, Ahmedabad Edition, dated 2-5-2006, reporting that 1200 temples and 260 Islamic shrines had encroached on public space. Acting suo motu, the High Court of Gujarat issued notices to fourteen respondents and directed that encroachments of religious structures on public spaces be removed without discrimination, with reports to be submitted.

In challenge to that interim direction, this Court noted submissions by the learned Additional Solicitor-General (ASG) that such an interim order was in the nature of a final order and could not be issued without hearing the respondents. On 4-5-2006, while issuing notice on the special leave petition, this Court stayed operation of the High Court’s interim order. The ASG also indicated that the Central Government would convene a meeting of State Secretaries to seek a consensual decision on the issue nationwide.

On 31-7-2009, the learned Solicitor General informed this Court that the matter was being scrutinised at the highest level and a consensus among States was being built. He undertook to file an affidavit that henceforth no construction of any religious institution (temple, church, mosque, gurdwara, etc.) would be permitted on public streets or public spaces.

Subsequently, by letter dated 19-9-2009/23-9-2009, the Home Secretary reported consensus emerging from a meeting with State Chief Secretaries on 17-9-2009: (i) no unauthorised construction of religious institutions would be permitted on public streets/public spaces; and (ii) past unauthorised religious constructions would be reviewed by State Governments on a case-to-case basis, with appropriate steps taken expeditiously.

In the present order, after hearing counsel and noting the far-reaching implications and consequences, this Court, on the oral request of the learned Solicitor General, impleaded all States and Union Territories as respondents, directed issuance of notices, required the Union of India to furnish case papers to all Standing Counsel for States/UTs, granted time for replies and rejoinder, and issued interim directions prohibiting unauthorised religious constructions on public places, mandating case-by-case review of existing unauthorised structures, and requiring compliance reports from District authorities through Chief Secretaries/Administrators to this Court. The matter was listed for further directions on 7-12-2009.

Legal Issues Presented

The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.

Arguments of the Parties

Union of India (Submissions by ASG/Solicitor General)

  • The learned ASG submitted that the Gujarat High Court’s interim direction to remove encroachments was in the nature of a final order and should not have been issued at a preliminary stage without hearing the respondents.
  • The learned ASG stated that the Central Government would convene a meeting of State Secretaries to develop a consensual approach to the issue across the country.
  • The learned Solicitor General later submitted that the matter was being carefully scrutinised at the highest level, with a consensus being built among States, and that an affidavit would be filed stating that henceforth no construction of any religious institution would be permitted on public streets/public spaces.
  • At the current hearing, the learned Solicitor General made an oral request to implead all States and Union Territories as respondents, citing the matter’s far-reaching implications.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
(2010) 15 SCC 664 (order dated 25-3-2008) Recorded the High Court of Gujarat’s suo motu action based on a news report on religious encroachments; noted the ASG’s contention that the interim direction resembled a final order; noted that this Court stayed the High Court’s interim order and that the Centre would seek a consensual national approach. Used as procedural background demonstrating how the matter came before this Court and the initial nationwide consensus-building efforts contemplated by the Union of India.
(2011) 14 SCC 65 (order dated 31-7-2009) Noted the Solicitor General’s submission that a consensus among States was being developed and that an affidavit would be filed to prohibit, henceforth, any construction of religious institutions on public streets/public spaces. Referenced to show the progression toward a national consensus, which informed the Court’s decision to issue interim directions and to implead all States and Union Territories.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court anchored its action in the matter’s national scope and “far-reaching implications and consequences.” On the Solicitor General’s oral request, the Court found it appropriate to implead all States and Union Territories to ensure that any directions would have comprehensive participation and accountability across jurisdictions.

In view of the consensus reported by the Home Secretary—(i) barring future unauthorised religious constructions on public spaces, and (ii) case-by-case review of existing unauthorised religious structures—the Court fashioned interim measures consistent with that consensus. Specifically, it prohibited any further unauthorised construction of religious institutions on public streets, public parks, or other public places, and directed States/UTs to review existing unauthorised religious structures case-by-case and take appropriate steps expeditiously.

To secure compliance, the Court created a reporting framework: District Collectors/Magistrates/Deputy Commissioners were directed to ensure total compliance and submit reports within four weeks to the Chief Secretaries/Administrators of Union Territories, who in turn must send consolidated reports to this Court within eight weeks. Procedural timelines were set for notices, replies by States/UTs, and rejoinder by the Union of India, and the matter was scheduled for further directions.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court impleaded all States and Union Territories as respondents, issued notices, set timelines for filings, and, as an interim measure, directed that no unauthorised construction of religious institutions be carried out or permitted on public streets, public parks, or other public places. It further directed States/UTs to review existing unauthorised religious constructions on a case-by-case basis and take appropriate steps expeditiously, and required compliance reporting by District authorities through Chief Secretaries/Administrators to the Court. The matter was listed for further directions on 7-12-2009.

Implications: Immediately, all authorities nationwide are restrained from permitting any new unauthorised religious construction on public places, and administrative machinery is obligated to conduct reviews of existing unauthorised structures and report compliance within set timelines. The order operates as an interim, supervisory directive; it addresses the parties’ conduct and administrative enforcement but does not purport to set out a new legal precedent beyond these directions.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Union Of India v. State Of Gujarat And Others

    Order

    1. On 25-3-2008 (2010) 15 SCC 664, this Court took note of a newspaper item published in The Times of India, Ahmedabad Edition, and passed the following order:

    “1. Taking note of the fact in a news item published in The Times of India, Ahmedabad Edition, dated 2-5-2006 to the effect that 1200 temples and 260 Islamic shrines had encroached on public space, the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad, while taking suo motu action, issued notice to the fourteen persons/authorities who were arrayed as the respondents. While doing so, the High Court gave the following interim direction:
    ‘Meanwhile, all the respondents are directed to take immediate steps for removal of encroachment of religious structures on the public space without any discrimination and submit their reports.’
    2. Mr Gopal Subramanium, learned ASG appearing for the Union of India contends that this interim direction is in the nature of final direction which could be issued only after hearing the respondents and no such direction could be issued at a preliminary stage without hearing the respondents.
    3. This Court, while issuing notice on the special leave petition on 4-5-2006 had stayed the operation of the impugned order.
    4. The learned ASG states that the Central Government after convening a meeting of all the Secretaries concerned of the respective States would try to take a consensual decision to deal with the problems such as in the present case all over the country and seeks time for this purpose.”

    2. The matter again came up before this Court on 31-7-2009 (2011) 14 SCC 65 when this Court passed the following order:

    “1. Mr Gopal Subramanium, learned Solicitor General appearing for the Union of India submits that the entire matter is being carefully scrutinised at the highest level and a consensus is being built up among all the States. The learned Solicitor General would also take instructions and file an affidavit that henceforth no construction of any religious institution, namely, temple, church, mosque or gurdwara, etc. shall be permitted on the public street/public space.
    2. Let this affidavit be filed by a senior officer, preferably a Secretary to the Government of India within eight weeks.”

    3. The learned Solicitor General has brought to our notice a letter dated 19-9-2009/23-9-2009 of the Home Secretary, addressed to the learned Solicitor General of India. The relevant portion of the letter reads as under:

    “I had taken a meeting with the Chief Secretaries of the States on 17-9-2009 with a view to evolve consensus on the problem of encroachment of public spaces by religious structures. I am glad to report that after the meeting, the following consensus emerged:
    (i) No unauthorised construction of any religious institution, namely, temple, church, mosque or gurdwara, etc. shall be permitted on public street/public space.
    (ii) In respect of unauthorised constructions of any religious nature which has taken place in the past, the State Governments would review the same on a case-to-case basis and take appropriate steps. This will be done as expeditiously as possible.”

    4. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties. Looking to the far-reaching implications and consequences of the orders of this Court, on the oral request of the learned Solicitor General of India, we deem it appropriate to implead all the States and the Union Territories as the respondents to this petition. The Registry is directed to issue notices to all the States and the Union Territories within three days. The Union of India is directed to supply the entire set of papers to all the Standing Counsel appearing for the State Governments and the Union Territories. The States and the Union Territories may file replies within four weeks and the Union of India is granted liberty to file rejoinder within two weeks thereafter.

    5. As an interim measure, we direct that henceforth no unauthorised construction shall be carried out or permitted in the name of temple, church, mosque or gurdwara, etc. on public streets, public parks or other public places, etc. In respect of the unauthorised construction of religious nature which has already taken place, the State Governments and the Union Territories shall review the same on case-to-case basis and take appropriate steps as expeditiously as possible.

    6. In order to ensure compliance with our directions, we direct all the District Collectors and Magistrates/Deputy Commissioners in charge of the Districts to ensure that there is total compliance with the order passed by us. They are directed to submit a report within four weeks to the Chief Secretaries or the Administrators concerned of the Union Territories who in turn will send a report to this Court within eight weeks from today.

    7. List this matter for further directions on 7-12-2009.

    Court Masters

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India v. State Of Gujarat And Others
    (Sep 29, 2009)