AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 11(6) of the Arbitration Act, 1996
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 11(6) of the Arbitration Act, 1996
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration Act, 1996, alleging that the appointing authority had failed to appoint an arbitrator. The parties' agreement contained Clause 34 (Arbitration) which first required disputes to be addressed by a Dispute Settlement Committee and provided for arbitration only for disputes unresolved by that Committee.

The petitioner wrote to the respondent's Managing Director on 31 May 2006 invoking the arbitration clause. A Dispute Settlement Committee was constituted and, by Minutes dated 2 March 2009, resolved some disputes and recorded that unresolved disputes could be referred to arbitration by appointing an arbitrator. The petitioner contended that despite those Minutes no arbitrator was appointed and therefore sought court appointment under Section 11(6).

The respondent's counsel informed the court that the Managing Director had, by order dated 9 September 2009, appointed Mr S.P. Marwah, IAS (Retd) as sole arbitrator. That order post-dated the institution of the petition (first listed on 10 July 2009). The petitioner contended that the order had not been communicated and that the appointing authority had forfeited its right to appoint (relying on Union Of India v. Bharat Battery Manufacturing Co. (P) Ltd. (2007) 7 SCC 684).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under the arbitration clause, the petitioner was required to exhaust the Dispute Settlement Committee mechanism and thereafter approach the Chairman-cum-Managing Director before instituting a petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration Act, 1996.
  2. Whether the appointing authority (the Chairman-cum-Managing Director) forfeited its right to appoint an arbitrator upon institution of the petition under Section 11(6), given the facts of this case.
  3. If the appointing authority had not forfeited its right, whether the appointment of Mr S.P. Marwah by the Managing Director after institution of the petition was valid or unauthorized.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner averred that the appointing authority failed to appoint an arbitrator and sought appointment by the court under Section 11(6).
  • The petitioner relied on its letter of 31 May 2006 as invoking the arbitration clause.
  • The petitioner contended that the order dated 9 September 2009 appointing an arbitrator had not been communicated to it, and that by the time of instituting the petition the appointing authority had forfeited its right to appoint (relying on Union Of India v. Bharat Battery Manufacturing Co. (P) Ltd.).

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent's counsel stated that the Managing Director appointed Mr S.P. Marwah, IAS (Retd) as sole arbitrator by order dated 9 September 2009.
  • Implicit in the respondent's position was that the appointment by the Managing Director was within authority and therefore the court need not appoint an independent arbitrator.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union Of India v. Bharat Battery Manufacturing Co. (P) Ltd.(2007) 7 SCC 684 The proposition that on the institution of a petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration Act the appointing authority loses the right to appoint an arbitrator. The court acknowledged the principle but found it inapplicable on the facts because, interpreting the arbitration clause, the petitioner had not exhausted the Dispute Settlement Committee mechanism nor approached the Chairman-cum-Managing Director after the Committee's Minutes dated 02.03.2009; therefore the petition was premature and the appointing authority had not forfeited its right.
M.K Shah Engineers and Contractors v. State of Madhya Pradesh AIR 1999 SC 950 That the mechanism provided in the agreement preceding arbitration is mandatory unless waived by the parties. The court relied on this authority to support the view that the Dispute Settlement Committee procedure in Clause 34 was mandatory and not an empty formality, reinforcing that arbitration could follow only after that mechanism was exhausted.
Sushil Kumar Bhardwaj v. U.O.I MANU/DE/1324/2009 Holding that a contractual clause requiring sequential approaches to specified officials before seeking arbitration is mandatory. The court referred to this decision (of the same court) to analogise and confirm that a pre-arbitration mechanism (here, the Dispute Settlement Committee) must be followed before arbitration is invoked.
ACE Pipeline Contracts Ltd. v. BPCL 2007 (5) SCC 304 Interpretation of Section 11(8) indicating that in Section 11(6) applications the court can appoint the arbitrator specified by the agreement or direct the authority to appoint; independent arbitrators are appointable only when reasons to depart from the agreement exist. The court used this principle to hold that even if approached under Section 11(6), the court may uphold an appointment in line with the agreement; thus the petitioner would not necessarily be prejudiced by the Managing Director's appointment.
Northern Railway Administration, Ministry of Railway New Delhi v. Patel Engineering Co. Ltd (2008) 10 SCC 240 Same interpretative principle of Section 11(8) as indicating judicial deference to the parties' agreed mechanism for appointment unless good reasons exist to depart. The court cited this authority alongside ACE Pipeline to support the view that adherence to the contractual appointment mechanism is permissible and that an independent arbitrator is not automatically required.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by construing Clause 34 of the contract. Clause 34 places the Dispute Settlement Committee before any reference to arbitration; arbitration is expressly provided only for disputes "which have not been settled in the said Dispute Settlement Committee." The court interpreted the sequential placement of the Committee within the arbitration clause to mean that the mechanism of the Committee must be exhausted before arbitration may be invoked.

Applying that interpretation to the facts, the court noted that the Dispute Settlement Committee had in fact resolved several disputes and, in its Minutes dated 02.03.2009, recorded that the unresolved disputes could now be referred to an arbitrator. Given that the Committee's mechanism had been triggered and had produced Minutes referring unresolved disputes to arbitration, the court held that the petitioner was required to approach the Chairman-cum-Managing Director after those Minutes. Only if the Managing Director failed to act at that stage would a cause of action for Section 11(6) arise.

Because the petitioner had not approached the Managing Director after the 02.03.2009 Minutes, the court concluded the petition was premature. Consequently, the Managing Director had not forfeited his right to appoint an arbitrator, and the appointment made on 9 September 2009 could not be said to be unauthorized.

The court reinforced its conclusion by reference to precedent: (a) M.K. Shah and Sushil Kumar Bhardwaj supported the proposition that pre-arbitration contractual mechanisms are mandatory; and (b) ACE Pipeline and Patel Engineering established that in Section 11(6) proceedings the court may appoint the arbitrator agreed by the parties (or direct the authority to do so), and an independent arbitrator is warranted only when reasons to depart from the agreement exist. On that basis the court held that the petitioner would not suffer prejudice from the Managing Director's appointment.

The court also rejected the petitioner's contention that the Managing Director's appointment could arise only if the 31 May 2006 letter were treated as an invocation; the court observed that, in light of the Committee Minutes, the Managing Director's appointment did not depend on that earlier invocation.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration Act, 1996 is dismissed.

Implications:

  • The court held that the petition was premature because the contractually mandated Dispute Settlement Committee mechanism had not been exhausted by the petitioner prior to seeking a court appointment under Section 11(6).
  • The Managing Director of the respondent had not forfeited his right to appoint an arbitrator; the appointment made on 9 September 2009 cannot be said to be unauthorized.
  • The court relied on existing precedents to emphasize that pre-arbitration contractual mechanisms are mandatory and that, in Section 11(6) proceedings, courts may give effect to the parties' agreed appointment mechanism; an independent arbitrator is appointed only when reasons to depart from agreement exist. The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal precedent beyond applying these principles to the facts.
  • Direct practical effect: the petition is dismissed and the appointment by the Managing Director stands. No order as to costs was made.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Shivaai Industries (P) Ltd. Petitioner v. Delhi Transport Corporation

    Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.:—The petition is preferred under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration Act, 1996 averring the failure of the appointing authority to appoint the arbitrator. The arbitration clause in the agreement between the parties is inter alia as under:

    “34. ARBITRATION

    There shall be a Dispute Settlement Committee which shall try to settle all disputes at the first stage. The Dispute Settlement Committee shall consist of CGM, Addl. CAO, concerned Dy CGM and Sr Manager Law. If the Committee fails to resolve the issue, it shall be referred for arbitration. Chairman-cum-M.D shall be the final authority in all litigation/arbitration. He can nominate any arbitrator for settlement of disputes. Chairman-cum-M.D's decision shall be final and binding on all the parties.

    All questions and disputes between the parties, the settlement of which has not been herein specifically recorded, shall be referred to the Sole arbitration of the Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Delhi Transport corporation or any other officer so nominated and appointed by him. There shall be no bar to the reference of dispute to the arbitration of such an officer of the Corporation appointed by the Chairman-cum-Managing Director even though the said officer may have dealt with the matter and had expressed his opinion thereon.”

    2. It is the case of the petitioner that it had as far back as on 31st May, 2006 invoked the arbitration clause by writing to the Managing Director of the respondent and pursuant thereto a Disputes Settlement Committee was constituted which vide its Minutes dated 2nd March, 2009 resolved some of the disputes which had arisen between the parties and in the said Minutes itself, qua the unresolved disputes it is recorded “As per the contractual mechanism provided in the agreement, these disputes can now be referred to arbitrator for adjudication by appointing an arbitrator.”

    3. It is contended that inspite of the Minutes aforesaid, no arbitrator was appointed and hence the petitioner applied to this court for appointment of an independent arbitrator.

    4. The counsel for the respondent has appeared pursuant to notice and has stated that the Managing Director of the respondent has vide order dated 9th September, 2009 appointed Mr S.P Marwah, IAS (Retd) as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes. The said order of the Managing Director of the respondent is admittedly of a date after the institution of this petition which came up first before this court on 10 July, 2009. The counsel for the petitioner has contended that the aforesaid order has not been communicated to the petitioner as yet and that the appointing authority had, as on the date of the said order forfeited its rights to appoint an arbitrator. Reliance in this regard is placed on Union Of India v. Bharat Battery Manufacturing Co. (P) Ltd.(2007) 7 SCC 684.

    5. There can be no dispute with the proposition of law that on the institution of the petition under Section 11(6) of the Act the appointing authority loses the rights to appoint. However, the question which arises in this case is whether the petitioner was under the arbitration clause aforesaid, upon the disputes remaining unresolved before the Disputes Settlement Committee, required to approach the Chairman-cum-Managing Director, who besides being the appointing authority is also entitled to act as the named arbitrator. If the aforesaid clause is to be interpreted as requiring the arbitration to commence only after the disputes remain unresolved before the Disputes Settlement Committee, then admittedly the petitioner has not approached the Chairman-cum-Managing Director and the petition under Section 11(6) of the Act would then be not maintainable. However, if as contended by the counsel for the petitioner, the invocation of the arbitration prior to the reference of the matter to the Disputes Settlement Committee is enough, then undoubtedly the appointment of the arbitrator now by the Managing Director of the respondent is without any authority whatsoever.

    6. Clause 34 in the agreement under the heading Arbitration does not immediately provide for arbitration. It first provides for a Disputes Settlement Committee and arbitration is provided only for those disputes which have not been settled in the said Dispute Settlement Committee. The placing of the Dispute Settlement Committee in the arbitration clause, before the said clause leads me to hold that invocation of arbitration has to be after the mechanism of the Dispute Settlement Committee has been exhausted. Admittedly in this case also several disputes have been settled in the said Committee and thus the question of seeking arbitration with respect thereto does not arise. Had the intent of the parties been that the Dispute Settlement Committee would come into play after the invocation of the arbitration, the clause could have been worded accordingly. However, the parties having provided for arbitration only of unresolved disputes, on an interpretation of the agreement, in my view the petitioner was required to approach the Chairman-cum-Managing Director after the Minutes dated 02.03.2009 of the Dispute Settlement Committee (supra) and only upon the failure of the Managing Director of the respondent to act at that stage could the cause of action for an application under Section 11(6) of the Act have accrued to the petitioner.

    7. The petitioner having admittedly not done so, there is no option but to hold that the petition is premature. Once the petition is held to be premature, the Managing Director of the respondent has not forfeited his right to appoint the arbitrator and the appointment made now cannot be said to be unauthorized.

    8. The Supreme Court in M.K Shah Engineers and Contractors v. State of Madhya Pradesh AIR 1999 SC 950 has held that mechanism provided in the agreement preceding the arbitration is mandatory unless waived by the parties. I have also in Sushil Kumar Bhardwaj v. U.O.I MANU/DE/1324/2009 held clause 25 of the contract in that case requiring the contractor to approach the Engineer Incharge, then Superintending Engineer and finally Chief Engineer for settlement of disputes, before seeking arbitration, to be mandatory. In this view of the matter also, it cannot be said that the mechanism provided of the Dispute Settlement Committee is an empty exercise.

    9. Even otherwise, the Supreme court in ACE Pipeline Contracts Ltd. v. BPCL2007 (5) SCC 304 and Northern Railway Administration, Ministry of Railway New Delhi v. Patel Engineering Co. Ltd(2008) 10 SCC 240 has held on an interpretation of Section 11(8) of the Act that even in an application under Section 11(6) of the Act the court can appoint the same arbitrator as provided under the agreement or mandate the authority to appoint the arbitrator and an independent arbitrator can be appointed only when reasons for not so abiding by the agreement of the parties are found. In this view of the matter also, it cannot be said that the petitioner will suffer any prejudice by the action of appointment of the arbitrator now.

    10. The counsel for the petitioner has contended that the question of the Chairman-cum-Managing Director of the respondent appointing the arbitrator, as has been done now, could have arisen only if the letter dated 31 May, 2006 is treated as the invocation letter. However, in my view, for the Managing Director to appoint the arbitrator, the invocation by the petitioner was not necessary in the light of the Minutes aforesaid of the Dispute Settlement Committee.

    11. The petition is dismissed. No order as to costs.

    RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shivaai Industries (P) Ltd. Petitioner v. Delhi Transport Corporation
    (Sep 11, 2009)