Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 46 of C.P.C,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 46 of C.P.C,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Appellants challenged an order dated 26 March 2015 in Chamber Summons No. 400 of 2015 in which the Single Judge continued an ad‑interim order for one week. The chamber summons was filed by the Award Holder seeking leave to amend an execution application to add the Appellants as party Respondents and to add certain properties belonging to Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 (the Appellants). Although Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 were named in the cause title, the prayer/schedule did not reference them. An ex parte interim order dated 9 March 2015 had been granted directing the Appellants not to dispose of or create third party rights in properties listed in the schedule. The Appellants contended they are not judgment debtors, are not established to be sister concerns of the judgment debtor, and that the chamber summons was disposed of; despite this, the ad‑interim order was extended. The Award Holder also filed a precept under Section 46 of the C.P.C., which remained pending.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an ad‑interim injunction, passed ex parte against persons who are not judgment debtors and whose liability has not been established, should have been continued without hearing.
  2. Whether appellants could be restrained and added as parties by amendment where the schedule/prayer did not explicitly reference them.
  3. What is the effect of a pending precept filed under Section 46 of the C.P.C. on continuation of an ad‑interim order restraining non‑judgment debtors.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Single Judge improperly continued the ex parte ad‑interim order of 9 March 2015 despite the chamber summons' schedule not referring to Respondent Nos. 2 and 3.
  • The Appellants are not judgment debtors and it was not established that they are sister concerns of the judgment debtor; this was recorded by the Single Judge.
  • They were not given a hearing before the injunction was passed; the injunction has caused their factory to stand still because coal essential to operations was attached.

Judgment Debtors / Award Holder's Position (as recorded)

  • The judgment debtors opposed the submissions, noting Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 chose not to appear despite service and that an order had been passed against a third party to whom the judgment debtor had transferred properties during the pendency of the Award.
  • The Award Holder filed a precept under Section 46 of the C.P.C., which is pending.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court found merit in the Appellants' submissions. It noted the judgment debtors' opposition but held that an injunction restraining persons who are not judgment debtors should not have been continued without hearing and without a determination of their liability. The court observed that the Award Holder had filed a precept under Section 46 of the C.P.C. and that the precept was pending; consequently, continuation of the ad‑interim order was inappropriate. The court also considered the practical prejudice to the Appellants (their factory having ceased operations due to attachment). On this basis the court vacated the continuation of the ad‑interim order dated 9 March 2015 while noting that the Award Holder remains free to approach the Single Judge for modification or clarification, subject to the appellate order.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; continuation of the ad‑interim order dated 9 March 2015 is vacated.

Consequences:

  • The impugned order continuing the ad‑interim injunction is vacated to the extent it continued the order of 9 March 2015.
  • The Award Holder may approach the learned Single Judge for modification or clarification of the order, subject to the appellate order.
  • Notice of Motion (L) No. 823 of 2014 and No. 824 of 2014 do not survive and are disposed of.
  • No broader precedent or novel legal principle was pronounced beyond the direct effect on the parties as described.

    Bhatia Coke And Energy Ltd. v. Vitol S.A. & Anr. S

    P.C

    1. Appellants are aggrieved by an order dated 26th March, 2015 passed in Chamber Summons No. 400 of 2015 whereby the learned Single Judge while disposing the chamber summons, has continued an ad-interim order for a period of one week. It is submitted that the chamber summons was taken out by the Award Holder and an application was made for leave to amend the execution application to add the Appellants as party Respondents and also to add certain additional properties belonging to said Respondent Nos. 2 and 3, who are appellants herein. It is submitted that though the chamber summons mentions name of Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 in the cause title, in the prayer clause, they sought leave to amend the execution application as per the schedule, which did not make reference of Respondent Nos. 2 and 3. It is submitted that though this fact was brought to the notice of the learned Single Judge, an exparte interim order was granted against the appellants, who are supposed to be added as Respondent Nos. 2 and 3, directing them not to dispose off, alienate, encumber, part with possession, transfer or create any third party rights in any of their properties mentioned in the schedule of the chamber summons. It is submitted that, admittedly, the Appellants are not the judgment debtors. It has not been established that the Appellants are the sister concern of the judgment debtor. It is submitted that this fact has been recorded by the learned Single Judge in the order. It is submitted that in fact the chamber summons which was taken out by the Award Holder was disposed of.

    2. It is submitted that in spite of this, ad-interim order which was passed exparte on 9 March, 2015 was extended for a period of one week. It is submitted that admittedly the Appellants are not the judgment debtors, and are not parties to the award was passed in favour of the Award Holder. Secondly, there is no order passed by any Court, holding that Appellants are sister concern of the judgment debtors; therefore, without giving hearing to the Appellants and before coming to the conclusion that they are sister concern of the judgment debtors, an order of injunction should not have been passed, restraining them from disposing of the properties, mentioned in the schedule of the chamber summons.

    3. In our view, there is much substance in the submission made by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellants. Though this submission is vehemently opposed by the judgment debtors, by pointing out that Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 chose not to appear in spite of service and that order came to be passed against the third party to whom the judgment debtor had transferred properties during pendency of the Award. In our view, in the present case unless in the precept, which is filed under Section 46 of C.P.C, the Appellants who are not judgment debtors are heard and it is held that they are liable to pay the said amount and an order of injunction, should not have been passed, while disposing of the chamber summons. The Award Holder has filed precept under Section 46 of the C.P.C and the said precept is pending. That being the position, there was no question of continuing the ad-interim order. We are informed by the learned senior counsel appearing for the Appellants that as a result of the said order of injunction, the entire factory of the Appellants has come to stand still, since the coal which is essential for running the said factory has been attached by virtue of the order of this Court. Hence, appeal is allowed and the impugned order to the extent it continues ad-interim order dated 9 March, 2015 is vacated. It is open for the Award Holder to approach the learned Single Judge, if so advised, for modification or clarification of the order. This however, shall be subject to the order passed by us in the appeal. Appeal is accordingly disposed of.

    4. In view of disposal of this appeal, the notice of motions filed therein viz. Notice of Motion (L) No. 823 of 2014 and 824 of 2014 do not survive, and are accordingly disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhatia Coke And Energy Ltd. v. Vitol S.A. & Anr. S
    (Mar 30, 2015)