AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Part XVI and Article 16(4) of the Constitution
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Part XVI and Article 16(4) of the Constitution

    Narayan Bajirao Andraskar And Others (Petitioners) v. The Collector, Yeotmal And Another (S).

    Dharmadhikari, J.:— According to the petitioners Nos. 1 and 2 they were the employees retrenched from the Census Department vide order dated 31-12-1972 issued by the Director of Census Operation, Maharashtra State Bombay. Thereafter by virtue of the Government resolution dated 6th March, 1973 providing for priority to such retrenched employees in the matter of appointment, they were appointed in the Collectorate at Yeotmal. So far as petitioner No. 3 Yeshwant Kalaskar is concerned, according to the petitioners he was appointed in Class III post by the Collector, Yeotmal, because he was a son of a freedom fighter. Admittedly these appointments were temporary until further orders. However, by an order dated 26th September, 1975 their services were terminated with effect from 1st October 1975 with 5 other employees. It is this order of termination which is challenged in this writ petition.

    2. According to the petitioners, several other junior clerks in the Tahsil Offices of Posad, Darwha, Kelapur, Wani and Yeotmal were appointed after them. They further contended that about 26 persons, who are junior to them, are retained in services, and therefore, the respondents have not followed the well established principle of ‘last come first go’ while terminating their services. In the petition, the petitioners have relied upon the Government resolution providing for priority to the staff retrenched from Census Department and the persons belonging to the class of freedom fighters. Therefore, according to the petitioners, their termination from service is illegal, being contrary to the well adopted policy of the Government itself. The petitioners further contended that all of them belong to the other backward classes, and therefore, they were entitled to a preference in service on this count also.

    3. In the return it is contended by the respondents that as per the Government resolution dated 9-4-1965 and 6-6-1972 so far as Yeotmal district is concerned, 14 per cent reservation was contemplated in services for the persons belonging to the Scheduled Tribes etc. in the vacancies which are to be filled in by direct recruitment. On the basis of this percentage, in all 38 persons should have been employed in the service at the Collectorate level whereas only 29 persons are so far employed, and therefore, there is a backlog. The respondents further contended that so far as the quota reserved for other backward classes is concerned, only 28 persons were entitled to be recruited in the said quota whereas there are 120 employees in service of the Collectorate, Yeotmal belonging to the other backward classes. They further contended that the total strength of junior clerks under the control of Collectorate was 279 at the relevant date. Therefore, with an intention to remove the backlog, candidates belonging to the Scheduled Tribes and Nomadic Tribes were retained in service, though they were junior to the petitioners. In substance, therefore, it is contended by the respondents that petitioners and the persons belonging to the Scheduled Tribes and Nomadic Tribes do not belong to the same class. The reservation of posts for these Tribes and the other backward classes is separate and distinct. Therefore, as the petitioners belong to other backward classes, they were not entitled to be retained in the posts reserved for the Scheduled Tribes and Nomadic Tribes. The respondents further contended that the petitioners were employed in service purely on the temporary basis, and therefore, they did not have any right to the posts nor, they were entitled to continue in service. A further contention was also raised in the return that the petitioners have not joined the employees as parties to the petition, who according to the petitioners were junior to them. According to the respondents, they were necessary parties as the petitioners are challenging their retention in Government service and the question raised in this behalf, therefore, cannot be adjudicated in their absence. In support of their contention, the respondents have filed before as the Government resolutions dated 9-8-1947, 9-4-1965, 6-6-1972 and 23-4-1974.

    4. From the bare reading of these various Government resolutions it is obvious that certain posts ID the services were sought to be reserved for various backward Classes. So far as Yeotmal district is concerned, this reservation was contemplated at 14 percent. In the return it is stated by the respondents that in alt there ought to have been 38 employees belonging to these Scheduled Tribes and Nomadic Tribes in Yeotmal district on the basis of said reservation, whereas there were only 29 persons in service belonging to the Scheduled Tribes and Nomadic Tribes. Thus on the relevant date there was a backlog of 9.

    5. The respondents further contended that the Government had directed by a Circular dated 23-4-1974 that this backlog should be filled in and especially so far as categories of Scheduled Tribes, Scheduled Castes, denotified Tribes and Namodic Tribes are concerned. None of the petitioners belonged to the Scheduled Castes or the Tribes referred to hereinbefore. From the record it is quite clear that the petitioners belong to other backward classes and on the establishment of the Colloectorate, though on the basis of the quota reserved for the backward classes is only 28, in all 120 employees belonging to other backward classes are already in employment. There fore, in our opinion, it cannot be said that the Government has not followed any policy while terminating the services of the petitioner.

    6. However, it is contended by Shri Jaiswal that reservation etc. is contemplated while the persons are recruited in services. It has nothing to do when the persons are retrenched. Whenever the question of retrenchment arises the Government should follow the principle of ‘last come first go’ irrespective of the principle of reservation. It is not possible for us to accept this contention.

    7. The reservation contemplated by the Government resolution relates to the posts in the public employment. It is obviously done by that Government having regard to the provisions of Part XVI and Article 16(4) of the Constitution A specific quota is re served for the categories belonging to the Scheduled Tribes and Nomadic Tribes. The petitioners do not belong to the categories known as Scheduled Tribes or Scheduled Castes. In this view of the matter, in our opinion, the petitioners could not be said to be competing with the persons belonging to scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes as they belong to a distinct and different class. If this is so, then it cannot be said that the Government while terminating the services of the petitioners has not followed the declared policy incorporated in the various Government resolutions. Even while retrenching the employees from services, it is open for the Government to take into consideration this policy and in that case the retrenchment will have to be made in such a way so that the quota reserved for the various backward classes is not disturbed. If this is of then, in our opinion, the respondents have given cogent and convincing reasons for not following the principle of ‘last come first go’ in this particular case. In this view of the matter it cannot be said that the order of termination is either arbitrary or illegal.

    8. Apart from this, it cannot be forgotten that petitioners were employed on a purely temporary basis until further orders. Therefore, termination of their services was in terms of their contract of employment. In this view of the matter, in our opinion, there is no substance in this petition.

    9. In the result, the petition fails and is dismissed. However, in the circumstances of the case there will be no order as to costs.

    10. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Narayan Bajirao Andraskar And Others (Petitioners) v. The Collector, Yeotmal And Another (S).
    (Nov 14, 1975)