RAKESH KUMAR GARG, J.
This is tenant's revision petition challenging the impugned order dated 12.3.2013 whereby his appeal against the order of eviction has been dismissed being time-barred.
The respondents filed an application under Section 13 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 (for short, “the Act”) for ejectment of the petitioner-tenant from the demised premises on the ground of non-payment of rent w.e.f 1.1.2004 The Rent Controller assessed the provisional rent @ Rs. 700/- per month and arrears of rent at Rs. 80,600/-. However, the petitioner failed to make payment of the provisionally assessed rent. Thus, in view of judgments Rakesh Wadhawan v. Jagdamba Industrial CorporationAIR 2002 SC 2004 and Rajan @ Raj Kumar v. Rakesh Kumar2010 (1) RCR (Rent) 386, the Rent Controller passed an order of ejectment against the petitioner on 25.10.2011
It may be noticed that under the provisions of the Act, an appeal can be filed against an order of ejectment of the Rent Controller within a period of limitation of 15 days. The petitioner filed an appeal against the aforesaid order on 19.1.2012 i.e after a delay of 71 days (excluding the 15 days of limitation period, as provided). Along with the appeal, the petitioner also filed an application for condoning the aforesaid delay. In the application for condonation of delay, the petitioner averred that he was advised by his counsel that appeal can be filed within 60 days whereas he was later advised by another counsel that the appeal could be preferred within 15 days of passing of the eviction order and thus, there were sufficient grounds to condone the delay.
The aforesaid application was contested by the respondents and after considering the pleadings of the parties, the Appellate Authority framed following issues for adjudication of the aforesaid controversy:
“1) Whether there are sufficient grounds to condone the delay in filing the appeal? OPA
2) Relief.”
After appreciating the evidence led by the parties, the Appellate Authority rejected the prayer of the petitioner for condoning the delay, observing as under:-
“The law provides period of limitation during which a person is required to approach the court for redressal of his grievances and if such litigant is unable to approach the court within the stipulated period, then he may be permitted to knock the doors of the court by way of extension of prescribed period provided he satisfies the court that he has sufficient cause for not referring the appeal or making the application within such time. Hence in the present case there is no cogent and convincing reasons to condone the delay. In the present case the delay in approaching the court is of 50 days. It is settled law that each day's delay is to be explained which the applicant failed to do in the present case. Further it is settled proposition that ignorance of law is no excuse. The contention of the applicant that he was informed that limitation for filing appeal was 60 days, though as a matter of fact it was 15 days, cannot be accepted. Accordingly, the issue is decided against the applicant.”
Resultantly, the appeal filed by the petitioner was also dismissed, being time barred.
The aforesaid order of the Appellate Authority, whereby prayer of the petitioner for condoning the delay in filing the appeal has been rejected and resultantly, the appeal has also been rejected, is under challenge in the instant revision petition.
Challenging the aforesaid order, learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued that there were sufficient reasons for condoning the delay and moreover, the Courts below should have adopted a more liberal approach in condoning the delay which has occurred without any fault on the part of the petitioner.
However, counsel for the respondents has supported the impugned order and has submitted that there is no merit in this petition and the same be dismissed.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the impugned orders as well as other documents placed on record of this petition.
There is no dispute with the proposition of law, as canvassed before this Court on the basis of various judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, wherein it has been observed that the Courts should adopt a liberal approach while condoning the delay and the matter should be heard on merits.
However, it is equally settled that there must be sufficient reasons for condoning the delay and each case has to be decided on its own facts. In the instant case, the plea of ignorance of law has been taken, seeking condonation of delay.
It is well settled that ignorance of law is not an excuse for condoning the delay. Moreover, it may further be noticed that the petitioner, admittedly, was having the services of a lawyer at his disposal, as according to his own pleadings, he was advised by his earlier lawyer that the period of limitation is 60 days and therefore, it does not lie in his mouth that he was ignorant about the period of limitation. At this stage, it may further be noticed that counsel for the respondents has brought to the notice of this Court that the petitioner was having the services of a leading lawyer of the area at his disposal, who is handling the rent cases daily and the argument raised on behalf of the petitioner does not inspire confidence. It may also be noticed that to support the plea, “that the petitioner was advised by his counsel with regard to the period of limitation”, no such affidavit of the said lawyer has been placed on record of this petition. It may further be noticed that the order of eviction was passed on 25.10.2011 against the petitioner i.e two years back. Not only this, it may further be noticed that eviction of the petitioner was ordered on the ground of non-payment of provisionally assessed rent. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has authoritatively laid down in case of Rakesh Wadhawan v. Jagdamba Industrial Corporation (supra) that in such a case, nothing more is to be done by the rent authorities and eviction is the automatic consequence.
In view thereof, I find no merit in this petition.
Dismissed.