Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Forest (Conservation) Act
  • MMDR Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Forest (Conservation) Act
  • MMDR Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion is a composite order disposing of and giving directions on numerous Interlocutory Applications (IAs) and contempt petitions arising out of earlier writ proceedings concerning forest conservation, mining operations, hydro-electric projects, road construction and related matters. The Central Empowered Committee (CEC) and the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) play central advisory roles, and time extensions, notices, and conditional clearances are granted in relation to their reports. Each numbered paragraph in the order addresses a discrete IA, indicating whether it is listed for further hearing, disposed of, or subject to specific conditions.

Legal Issues Presented

The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants in IAs Nos. 2177-84 (Mining Lessees)

  • Expressly agreed to each recommendation of the CEC, including payment of Net Present Value (NPV), compensatory afforestation, and penal compensatory afforestation where applicable.
  • Undertook not to transfer leases in violation of statutory provisions and to cease operations upon lease expiry.
  • Offered to furnish undertakings for any additional charges that may be stipulated at the time of formal approval.

State of Chhattisgarh (PIL on Road Construction)

  • Argued that surfacing and construction of rural roads is essential to counter internal security threats and to enable police and administrative access to remote villages.
  • Requested that CEC’s suggestion for disciplinary action against officers be omitted, asserting that tree felling was necessitated by pressing security concerns.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court adopted an administrative approach, largely deferring to the technical expertise of the CEC and the statutory mandate of the MoEF:

  • Where parties accepted CEC recommendations (e.g., IAs Nos. 2177-84), the Court simply “accepted” those recommendations and directed the MoEF to process licences accordingly.
  • For the Teesta Hydroelectric Project (IA No. 2163), the Court accepted the Forest Advisory Committee’s recommendation, making final clearance conditional on MoEF’s examination.
  • In disputes over forest classification (IAs Nos. 1500 & 2235), the Court authorised a CEC inspection to produce a clarifying report.
  • With respect to the Chhattisgarh road construction PIL, the Court approved every CEC condition except the proposal to initiate disciplinary proceedings against officers, acknowledging the State’s security-related justifications.
  • Several IAs were adjourned, notices were issued to CEC and concerned States, and time extensions were granted to MoEF and CEC to file reports, reflecting an incremental, report-driven decision-making process.

Holding and Implications

VARIOUS IAs DISPOSED OF OR LISTED FOR FURTHER ACTION AS DIRECTED

Immediate effects include: (i) conditional acceptance of CEC recommendations for specified mining leases; (ii) permission for MoEF to grant or refuse clearances subject to stated conditions; (iii) authorisation for CEC inspections and further reports; and (iv) approval of CEC guidelines for rural road projects in Chhattisgarh, minus disciplinary measures. The order settles no new question of law and sets no binding precedent beyond its case-specific directions.

    T.N Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union Of India And Others

    Order

    Haryana Mining

    IAs Nos. 828, 839, 840, 850, 853-56, 866-82, 891-92, 900, 905, 1276-77, 1465, 1488 in 891-92, 1590, 1612-13, 2007-08 and 2138-39 in 891-92, 2205, 1700-03 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995 and IA No. 1785 in WP (C) No. 4677 of 1985 and other IAs and contempt petitions

    1. MoEF seeks further time to file a report regarding the impact of mining on water level. Four weeks' time is granted for filing the same. List on 18-7-2008.

    IA No. 2270

    2. Issue notice to CEC. Learned amicus curiae may file his views within four weeks. List on 18-7-2008.

    IA No. 2167

    3. List on 18-7-2008.

    IAs Nos. 2177-84

    4. The applicants who are engaged in mining, have agreed to the recommendations made by CEC. Learned counsel appearing for the applicants submits that they are agreeable for the following recommendations:

    1. to pay NPV (if not already paid) for entire forest area included in mining lease approved under the MMDR Act, 1957;
    2. to pay compensatory afforestation for the entire forest area excluding the forest area broken before/prior to 25-10-1980;
    3. to pay penal compensatory afforestation — if the mine has operated in the past in violation of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980;
    4. no transfer of mining lease has taken place in violation of the provisions of the MMDR Act/Forest (Conservation) Act;
    5. the mine was actually in operation and not closed during the validity of mining lease; however, mines were closed and mining operations stopped as soon as the mining leases expired;
    6. they agree to give undertaking to pay additional charges, if any, payable as per the conditions imposed at the time of formal approval.

    We accept the recommendations. MoEF may consider the applications of the applicants and pass appropriate orders in the matter of grant of licences to these applicants. Applications are disposed of accordingly.

    IA No. 2163

    5. Teesta Hydroelectric Project Stage VI has been recommended by the Forest Advisory Committee. MoEF may examine and pass appropriate orders as regards clearance in respect of 89.4266 ha of forest land. We accept the recommendations, subject to the clearance by MoEF. IA is disposed of accordingly.

    IA No. 2166

    6. List on 16-5-2008.

    IA No. 2126

    7. List on 2-5-2008.

    IA No. 2212

    8. List on 2-5-2008.

    IAs Nos. 1500 and 2235

    9. The applicant obtained a licence for carrying out mining activity in 263.25 acres of land. According to the applicant, out of this only 7.85 acres of land is forest land and the rest of the area is not covered by forest and for 7.85 acres of land the applicant has got clearance from MoEF. Stand taken by the State Government is that the entire 263.25 acres are forest land. According to the applicant, there was earlier a joint survey conducted and it was found therein that whole area was not forest land. But according to the District Level Committee, the whole area is forest land. The applicant requests that the representatives from CEC may make inspection of the land and give a report. The applicant may make an application for inspection before CEC in this regard.

    10. List on 25-7-2008.

    IAs Nos. 2186-87

    11. Issue notice to CEC as well as to the State of U.P The State of U.P to file its reply/response regarding setting up of furniture units by the applicant, within four weeks. List on 25-7-2008.

    IAs Nos. 2191-93

    12. Issue notice to CEC as well as to the State of Haryana. The State of Haryana may file its reply/response regarding setting up of herbal park by the applicant, within four weeks. List on 25-7-2008.

    IAs Nos. 2199-200

    13. Learned counsel for the petitioner seeks permission to withdraw the applications with liberty to move an appropriate application. Permission sought for is granted. The applications are dismissed as withdrawn.

    IA No. 2201

    14. Application for impleadment is dismissed.

    IAs Nos. 2202-03

    15. Issue notice to CEC. CEC to file response within four weeks. List on 25-7-2008.

    IA No. 2208

    16. Issue notice to CEC. CEC to file its response within four weeks. The applicant is permitted to file an additional application suggesting the ways and means by which they would prevent the illicit use of timber/forest trees.

    17. List on 18-7-2008.

    18. The applicant would be at liberty to file additional documents, if any, before CEC.

    IAs Nos. 2213-15 in IA No. 948-48-A

    19. List on 25-7-2008.

    IAs Nos. 1424-25, 2218 and 2211

    20. CEC seeks further time to file a report/response. It is submitted that already inspection has been carried out.

    21. List on 25-7-2008.

    IA No. 1179 in IAs Nos. 675-76 and 957

    22. List on 8-8-2008.

    IAs Nos. 1291-92

    23. The applicants filed a petition purporting to be a public interest litigation alleging that in the State of Chhattisgarh. It was stated that there are serious violations in forest land and the State is constructing several roads by destroying the forests.

    24. The matter was examined by CEC, which has given the following recommendations:

    “(a) for each of the road being constructed under Pmgsy the existing width of the road, the number of trees required to be felled, the source of earth, murrum, metal, etc., the legal status of the road and the other relevant details should be verified by the team(s) consisting of the representative of the Forest Department, the Revenue Department and the Panchayat and Rural Development Department under the direct supervision, and guidance of the Regional CCF, MoEF, Bhopal, Regional Office. Based on the reliable government documents, it should be decided whether this was an existing forest road or some other road such as PWD road, etc.;
    (b) the construction of the road passing through the forest area should be undertaken only after obtaining the requisite approvals under the Forest (Conservation) Act except in respect of the identified existing road which do not involve any widening, felling of trees, black-topping or use of earth/murrum/metal from the forest area;
    (c) in respect of the roads passing through the national parks/sanctuaries the construction/upgradation work shall be undertaken only after obtaining the permission from this Hon'ble Court;
    (d) the filing of the consolidated proposal for seeking approval under the Forest (Conservation) Act for the construction/upgradation/widening of the roads and the decisions thereon by MoEF shall be taken in a time bound manner so that the construction of the roads is not unnecessarily hampered. The safeguards/conditions stipulated by MoEF shall be strictly complied with;”

    Learned counsel appearing for the State of Chhattisgarh submits that these roads had to be surfaced properly to avoid illegal land mines and it is submitted that the police and administration are not able to reach remote village areas due to the absence of these village roads.

    25. The recommendations suggested by CEC are acceptable to the State Government. It is submitted that suggestion that the State Government may be directed to take disciplinary action against the officers for construction of the roads, may not be accepted. The felling of trees have been necessitated because of the absence of roads in these remote village areas and also because of serious internal security threats which are prevalent in these areas.

    26. Subject to fulfilment of the above conditions stipulated by CEC except relating to action against officers, the application is disposed of.

    WPs (C) Nos. 36 of 2003 and 85 of 2007

    27. Adjourned.

    IAs Nos. 36, 75, 89 and 103 in WP (C) No. 337 of 1995

    28. List in July 2008.

    Court Masters

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    T.N Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union Of India And Others
    (Apr 25, 2008)