AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — J.V. Gupta, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners (Jarnail Singh and others) were appointed as Surveyors on an ad hoc basis in the Soil Conservation Department, Punjab during 1976–77. Their services were terminated on 31 January 1981. They filed writ petitions (Nos. 476 and 484 of 1981) in the High Court, which were dismissed. The matter was taken to the Supreme Court, which on 7 May 1986 set aside the High Court's order in Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab (1986 (2) SLR 278), quashing the termination orders and directing reinstatement.

The petitioners were reinstated on 4 August 1986 and the State paid back wages, although the Supreme Court did not specifically direct payment of back wages. The petitioners then filed a writ petition in the High Court seeking (a) regularisation of their services as Surveyors in accordance with departmental instructions (including Annexures P-1, P-3 and P-4) and (b) payment of interest at the rate of 12% per annum on arrears of pay arising from delayed payment of arrears.

The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition by the impugned judgment dated 16 March 1989, directing regularisation in accordance with the relevant instructions and awarding interest at 12% per annum on arrears of pay up to date of payment. The State appealed against that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution is maintainable to claim interest on back wages when the Supreme Court, while setting aside termination orders and reinstating employees, did not direct payment of back wages or interest and where the State subsequently paid back wages voluntarily.
  2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to be regularised in service in view of departmental instructions and the precedent of Piara Singh v. State of Haryana (1988) 4 SLR 739.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State) — Principal Submissions

  • The writ petition sought regularisation only by reference to departmental instructions (Annexures P-1, P-2 and P-3); at most the Court could direct the authorities to consider the petitioners' cases, but could not itself pass an order of regularisation.
  • Even if Piara Singh v. State of Haryana were applicable, it was delivered during pendency of the writ petition and the petitioners did not rely on it; therefore they were not entitled to automatic regularisation.
  • The Supreme Court did not award back wages; the State voluntarily paid back wages as a consequence of the termination order being set aside. Consequently, petitioners are not entitled to interest on those amounts because there was no statutory rule or equitable basis for interest in these circumstances.
  • Cases relied on by the Single Judge concern pension and gratuity matters and are on different footing from back wages; back wages are discretionary upon the court and not an absolute right.
  • The Interest Act (1978) does not make interest payable on back wages in these circumstances.
  • Divisional Bench authority (Santa Singh) shows that even where reinstatement occurred in view of Jarnail Singh, back wages were not invariably granted.

Respondents (Writ Petitioners) — Principal Submissions

  • The petitioners are entitled to regularisation under the departmental instructions and under Piara Singh v. State of Haryana; if their service records are found adverse subsequently, the State may proceed with lawful action after enquiry.
  • Cited Gainda Ram v. M.C.D. (1988 (1) SLR 327) to show the Supreme Court has given directions for regularisation in similar cases.
  • Back wages are a right and not a bounty; since back wages were withheld illegally they attract interest. Under Section 3 of the Interest Act unpaid salary becomes a debt and interest can be allowed.
  • Cited State of Punjab v. Radha Ram (1989 (2) ILR 1984) to support the proposition that interest can be awarded on unpaid salary/back wages.
  • Argued parity with pension and gratuity cases (where interest was awarded) — if interest is allowed in those cases then interest on unpaid salary should equally be permitted.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court (as stated in the opinion)
Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab, 1986 (2) SLR 278 Supreme Court set aside High Court order, quashed termination and directed reinstatement. Forms the factual basis: petitioners were reinstated pursuant to this decision; the Supreme Court did not, however, specifically direct payment of back wages or interest.
R.S. Sehgal v. Union of India, 1985 (2) SLR 285 Authority relied upon by the Single Judge for awarding interest (in a case concerning pension) based on State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair. The Court held this case distinguishable on facts because it related to pension payments and involved a Delhi High Court order which the Union of India had not complied with.
State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair, (1985) 1 SCC 429 : AIR 1985 SC 356 Supreme Court authority allowing interest at 12% per annum for amounts withheld by authorities (in pension context). Identified as the principal Supreme Court authority for awarding interest in pension cases; the present case was distinguished from it.
Piara Singh v. State of Haryana, (1988) 4 SLR 739 Foundational authority for regularisation in similar factual situations. The Court held petitioners are entitled to regularisation in view of this judgment and directed authorities to pass appropriate orders for regularisation thereunder.
Santa Singh v. State of Punjab, W.P. No. 618 of 1987 (decided 18 May 1987) Illustrates that reinstatement does not inevitably carry with it an award of back wages; back wages may be withheld at court's discretion. Cited by the State to show that back wages are discretionary and that the Supreme Court did not always grant back wages even when reinstatement was directed.
Gainda Ram v. M.C.D., 1988 (1) SLR 327 Supreme Court decisions in support of directions for regularisation in comparable cases. Invoked by petitioners' counsel as authority showing the Supreme Court has issued such regularisation directions; used to support petitioners' entitlement to regularisation.
State of Punjab v. Radha Ram, 1989 (2) ILR 1984 Authority cited to support allowance of interest on unpaid salary/back wages and treatment of unpaid salary as debt under Section 3 of the Interest Act. Cited by petitioners' counsel to support entitlement to interest on back wages; the Court recorded this citation but distinguished the present facts for the ultimate decision on maintainability.
Des Raj Pahwa v. State of Punjab, CWP No. 436 of 1982 (decided 19 Feb 1985) Case concerning non-payment of pension and salary where 12% interest was allowed because the petitioner was deprived of amounts without justification. Used by the Court to illustrate factual differences: Des Raj Pahwa involved clear deprivation and failed disciplinary proceedings; the present case was distinguished on those factual grounds.
Suganmal v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1965 SC 1740 Principle that a High Court under Article 226 ordinarily should not be used solely for claims for refund (e.g., of tax), since such claims are more appropriately pursued in ordinary suits where fuller defences can be raised. The Court applied the same principle by analogy to petitions seeking interest payments: a writ petition solely for interest on amounts not granted by a higher court is generally not maintainable under Article 226.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court identified the critical question as whether a writ petition under Article 226 can be maintained for claiming interest on back wages when the Supreme Court, while setting aside termination orders and reinstating employees, did not grant back wages or interest, and when the State subsequently paid the back wages voluntarily.

Key steps in the Court's analysis (as stated in the opinion):

  1. The Supreme Court, in Jarnail Singh, set aside the terminations and reinstated the petitioners but did not specifically direct payment of back wages or interest. The State paid back wages later on its own (4 August 1986).
  2. Because the Supreme Court did not grant back wages or interest, the court below could not convert what was not granted by the Supreme Court into a separate writ entitlement under Article 226. The Court emphasized the principle that "what has not been granted by the Supreme Court cannot be made the subject-matter of a writ petition" in this Court under Article 226.
  3. The Court examined and distinguished the authorities relied upon by the learned Single Judge (R.S. Sehgal and State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair). Those cases principally dealt with pensionary claims or involved circumstances where a prior court order directing payment had not been complied with; thus they were found to be factually distinguishable.
  4. The Court drew an analogy to Suganmal v. State of Madhya Pradesh, observing that a writ petition "solely praying" for monetary relief (refund or, by extension, interest) is not ordinarily maintainable because the appropriate forum for such monetary claims is a suit where complete defences can be raised and considered.
  5. Applying these principles, the Court concluded that neither law nor equity entitled the petitioners to invoke Article 226 for claiming interest on back wages that the State had paid voluntarily without any direction from the Supreme Court ordering interest.
  6. Separately, the Court accepted that petitioners are entitled to regularisation in view of Piara Singh v. State of Haryana and directed the authorities to pass appropriate orders for regularisation under that authority; the Court left open the possibility for the State to take subsequent lawful action (including termination after enquiry) if records were found adverse.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Appeal partly allowed.

Direct consequences for the parties (as stated in the opinion):

  • The writ petition insofar as it sought interest at the rate of 12% per annum on the back wages is not maintainable under Article 226; the award of interest by the Single Judge was set aside.
  • The petitioners are entitled to be regularised in service in view of Piara Singh v. State of Haryana; the authorities are directed to pass appropriate orders for regularisation in accordance with that judgment and the departmental instructions cited by the petitioners.
  • If the petitioners' service records are found unsatisfactory by the State, action may be taken thereafter in accordance with law (for example, after holding an enquiry); the present decision does not preclude lawful action based on adverse records.
  • The appeal succeeds to the extent indicated (i.e., concerning the payment of interest) and the matter is otherwise directed as above. There was no order as to costs.

Broader implications: The Court confined its ruling to the facts and procedural posture before it — specifically the absence of any Supreme Court direction for interest or back wages — and applied established principles about the limits of writ jurisdiction in respect of purely monetary claims. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new general principle beyond these applications to the facts of this case.

Disposition: Appeal partly allowed.

    State Of Punjab & Another v. Jarnail Singh & Others

    J.V Gupta, J.:— This appeal is directed against the judgment of the learned Single Judge dated March 16, 1989 by which Writ Petition was allowed and directions were issued to the respondent to regularise the petitioners as per instructions dated October 28, 1980 (Annexure P.1) and to pay interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum on the arrears of pay to the petitioners upto the date of payment.

    2. The Writ petitioners Jarnail Singh and others were appointed as Surveyors on ad hoc basis in Soil Conservation Department in Punjab during the years, 1976-77. Their services were terminated on January 31, 1981. They challenged these orders by filing two writ petitions No. 476 and 484 of 1981 in this Court which were dismissed. However, the matter was taken to the Supreme Court, where order of the High Court was set aside on May 7, 1986. The said judgment of the Supreme Court is reported in Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab, 1986 (2) SLR 278; whereby the order terminating the services of the petitioners was quashed and direction was given to reinstate the petitioners. In compliance with the aforesaid order of the Supreme Court, the petitioners-were reinstated on August 4, 1986 and were also paid their back-wages though there was no specific; direction of the Supreme Court in this behalf but the State in its wisdom taking it to be the consequence of the termination order having been set aside paid the back-wages as well. The petitioners filed the writ petition giving rise to this appeal, directing the respondents for regularising their services as Surveyors w.e.f the date when the petitioners, were regularised in accordance with the instructions Annexures P-1, P-3 and P-4 and also sought direction to pay them interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum on the arrears of salary on account of delayed payment of arrears of pay. The stand taken by the respondents-State was that there was no direction in the order of the Supreme Court for payment of interest on the arrears of pay. Further, since the petitioners did not ask for regularisation and since their juniors had already been regularised, the case of the petitioners was not considered.

    3. The learned Single Judge relying upon the judgment in R.S Sehgal v. Union of India, 1985 (2) SLR 285 in which reliance was placed on the Supreme Court judgment in State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabharfi Nair, (1985) 1 SCC 429 : AIR 1985 SC 356 allowed interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum for the period the amounts were withheld by the authorities.

    4. The learned counsel for the: appellant-State submitted that in the Writ Petition for regularisation was being sought on the basis of the instructions Annexures-P-1. P-2 and P-3 and at the most direction could be given to consider the cases of the petitioners for regularisation under those instructions. According to the learned counsel order for regularisation as such could not be parsed. In any case argued the learned counsel even if taking into consideration the judgment of this. Court, in Piara Singh v. State of Haryana, (1988) 4 SLR 739 the cases of the petitioners could be considered ??? regularisation thereunder, but since the said judgment was de???vered during the pendency of the writ petition, no reliance was placed by the petitioners on the said judgment.

    5. As regards the interest of 12 per cent allowed by the learned Single Judge, the learned counsel submitted that as a matter of fact the Supreme Court itself did not award any backwages while reinstating the writ petitioners. The State of its own while reinstating them has paid the backwages being a consequential relief and therefore, in these circumstances, the petitioners were not entitled to any interest on the said wages as there was neither any rule regarding interest nor there was any equity in favour of the petitioners to claim interest by way of writ petition. According to the learned counsel, the cases relied upon by the learned Single Judge are the cases of pension and gratuity which are altogether on different footings than the backwages. He also submitted that even the grant of backwages is not a matter of right but is in the discretion of the court while reinstating the petitioners and even in Writ Petition No. 618 of 1987, decided on May 18, 1987 Santa Singh v. State of Punjab, the Division Bench of this Court did not allow any backwages though they were reinstated in view of Jarnail Singh's case (supra) by the Supreme Court. According to the learned counsel even the Supreme Court did not chose to grant the backwages and did not pass specific order to that effect. Even in the Interest Act of 1978 no interest was payable to the petitioners on the back wages which were/paid as a consequence of termination having been set aside.

    6. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondents (writ petitioners) submitted that the petitioners were entitled to be regularised in view of the instructions as well as in view of the judgment in Piara Singh's case (supra). In case the records of the petitioners were bad, their services could be terminated after holding an enquiry, because even after regularisation they continued to be temporary Government servants, whose services could be terminated in accordance with law. He has also cited Gainda Ram v. M.C.D, 1988 (1) SLR 327; judgme???t of the Supreme Court contending that such like directions for regularisation were given by the Supreme Court itself.

    7. As regards the payment of interest, he submitted that the back wages are to be paid as a matter of right and is not bounty as such. Since the backwages were withheld illegally, the petitioners were entitled to interest thereon. According to the learned counsel even under S. 3 of the Interest Act the unpaid salary becomes a debt every month and interest could be allowed thereon. In support of thi??? contention, he referred to State of Punjab v. Radha Ram, 1989 (2) ILR 1984. He also contended that if the interest could be allowed on pension and gratuity, which according to him, was on a lower footing, there was no question as to why the interest was not allowed on unpaid salary. Thus, argued the learned counsel both in law and equity the petitioners were entitled to interest on backwages.

    8. The question to be decided in this appeal is as to whether a writ petition can be filed for claiming the interest on the back wages whe no such interest was allowed earlier either while allowing the backwages or not allowing at all, but were to be paid as a consequence of the termination order being set aside. Admit-tedly, in the present case no direction was given by the Supreme Court for payment of backwages, while setting aside the termination order of the petitioners. The amount of backwages was paid by the State itself as a consequence of the judgment of the Supreme Court on August 4, 1986. Under these circumstances neither under law nor in equity the petitioners are entitled to invoke the writ jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of Inida for claiming interest on the amount of backwages paid by the State itself without being there any direction in this behalf by the Supreme Court. The judgment relied upon by the learned Judge in this respect are clearly distinguishable. In R.S Sehgal v. Union of India, 1985 (2) SLR 285, the case related to the payment of pension for which already Delhi High Court had granted relief to the petitioner even inspite of that the Union of India did not make the payment and therefore the learned Judge relying upon the Supreme Court judgment State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair, (1985) 1 SCC 429 : AIR 1985 S.C 356 observed that “these observations, to my mind, apply with full force to the facts of the instant case; more so in the light of the conclusion recorded by the Delhi High Court”. Thus, on the facts and circumstances of this case the said case is clearly distinguishable. Similarly in CWP No. 436 of 1982 Des Raj Pahwa v. State of Punjab, decided on February 19, 1985 the case related to the non payment of pension and salary. It was therefore, observed therein that “the petitioner has all through been deprived of his hard earned money for no justifiable reasons. As already pointed out, the disciplinary enquiry initiated against him resulted in fiasco and he was kept under suspension for no justifiable cause. Then again a cut wa imposed on his pensionary amount without any plausible reason. Even the recommendations made by this Court on February 2, 1979 vide Annexure P-4 and November 2, 1979, vide Annexure P-10 requiring the Government to pay interest on the above-noted amounts remained unheaded.” It was in view of these observations that it was held that there was no justification for depriving the petitioners for enquitable relief by payment of interest @ 12 per cent per annum on the two amounts claimed therein, which related to pension and salary. by the Supreme Court that no writ petition is maintainable merely for the refund of tax. In Suganmal v. State of Madhya “Pradesh, AIR 1965 Supreme Court 1740, Raghubar Dayal, 3., speaking for the Bench, observed:—

    “Though the High Courts have power to pass any appropriate order in the exercise of the powers conferred on them under Art. 226 of the Constitution, a petition solely praying for the issue of a writ of mandamus directing the State to refund the money alleged to have been illegally collected by the State as tax is not ordinarily maintainable for the simple “reason that a claim for such a refund can always be made in a suit against the authority which had illegally collected the “money as a tax and in such a suit it is open to the State to raise all possible defences to the claim, defences which cannot in most cases, be appropriately raised and considered in the exercise of writ jurisdiction.”

    9. In my opinion, the same principle will apply where a petitioner is raising merely a claim for interest in a writ petition. The Supreme Court in exercise of its discretion, only sef asi??? the order which resulted in the reinstatement of the petitioners. It did not give further direction for payment of back wages or interest. What has not been granted by the Supreme Court cannot be made the subject-matter of a writ petition in this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution. I am clearly of the opinion that the present writ petition for the aforesaid claim of interest is not maintainable.

    10. As regards the regularisation, the petitioners are entitled to be regularised in view of the judgment in Piara Singh's case (supra). The authorities will pass appropriate orders for regularisation thereunder. In case the record of the petitioners is not found to be good in the opinion of the State Government action could be taken against the petitioners in accordance with law, but at present they are entitled to regularisation of their services in view of the judgment in Piara Singh's case (supra). Consequently, this appeal succeeds to the extent indicated above, as regards the payment of interest, and is allowed accordingly with no order as to costs.

    11. Appeal partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Punjab & Another v. Jarnail Singh & Others
    (Nov 20, 1989)