M.R Agnihotri, J.:— This judgment shall dispose of C.W.P Nos. 13657, 12839, 13059,13132,13213,13239,13280,13452,12703,14290,14387,14399,15175,15382, 15450,15514,15928,15959, 16209,16210 and 16229 of 1989, as also 1541 of 1990, in which common questions of fact and law are involved. All the petitioners in these petitions are aggrieved of the same impugned action of the State of Haryana by which their selection/appointment to the post of Constable/Lady Constable has been cancelled.
2. In August, 1989, Police Department of the State of Haryana decided to fill 3500 vacancies of Constables for the Haryana Armed Police, Wireless Section, to strengthen its police force. For this purpose, the following advertisement in the form of news item appeared in the Daily Tribune:—
CHANDIGARH, Aug 8.—The Haryana Government had decided to fill 3500 Vacancies of Constables for the Haryana Armed Police and Wireless Section to strengthen its police force.
The recruitment will be held at each district police headquarters and Police Recruitment and Training Centre, Panchkula, from August 17 to 19. However, the recruitment for constables wireless operators will be conducted on August 18 only.
3. The candidates will be considered for this recruitment at their respective home district headquarters. The wards of serving police personnel who are residents of Haryana have been asked to appear for recruitment at their home district headquarter. Those not having any home district in Haryana may appear in district where the official or father of the ward is serving. The minimum standard required by those candidates who apply for the post of constable drivers, other constables and constable wireless operators are: 5ft to 7ft, chest 33″- 34 ½″ and age between 18 to 27.
4. The academic qualification required for constable driver is matriculation and he should possess a valid driving licence. For other constables, the qualifications is matriculation. However, for constable wireless operators the academic qualification should be B.Sc or matriculation with a radio and TV diploma from an ITI. For this category even those females are eligible. Also those who are matriculates and have a typing speed of 40 words per minute are eligible. A typing lest has been prescribed for such candidates.
“These standards are relaxable in case of the reserved categories as per the instructions of Government in this regard. However, no relaxation will be given in academic qualifications.”
5. In pursuance of this decision, Mr. Chiranji Lal Sharma, the then Superintendent of Police, Wireless, Haryana, called upon the interested candidates to report for selection on 18th August, 1989, at 7 A.M Accordingly, the petitioners along with a number of other candidates reported for interview and other tests. The selection was held by the Selection Committee headed by Mr. Chiranji Lal Sharma, Su-perintendent of Police, Wireless. After selection, all the petitioners were deputed to appear before the Chief Medical Officer concerned for medical examination. The memo, issued by the Superintendent of Police for this purpose is reproduced below:—
The Superintendent of Police,
Wireless, Haryana, Chandigarh.
The Chief Medical Officer,
____________________
No…., Dated, Chandigarh, the…….
Subject:— Medical examination.
Shri…….s/o Shri………resident of……………. Police Station…………….considered for enlistment as temporary constable RT Opr./messenger/Lady Const. He is being sent to you for medical examination and opinion if he is fit for enlistment in this Section and is also free from all contagious diseases.
Superintendent of Police,
Wireless, Haryana, Chandigarh.”
6. Thereafter, the petitioners were duly examined by the Medical Officer concerned and were found fit and their fitness certificate were received by the police authorities on 21st August, 1989. Thereupon, the petitioners were directed to report for training by 31st August, 1989, along with necessary clothings, beddings, etc., as the training was to start from Ist September, 1989.
7. After that all the petitioners reported for training on 31st August, 1989. On that day, constabulary numbers were allotted to them and orders of appointment were issued by the Superintendent of Police. One such orders reads as under:—
Shri/Miss/Mrs……….s/o or d/o or w/o Shri…………………………. Caste……………R/ov……………P.O………. Police Station…………. Distt………….qualification……….height………. Chest…………….date of Birth………………………………….declared medically fit by C.M.O is hereby appointed as temporary const./Lady constable provisionally against an existing vacancy in this Section with effect from…………in the Pay Scale of Rs. 950-25-1200-30-1560-40-1800 with Page: 119initial start of Rs. 1000/- P.M He is liable to be discharged from service without notice under P.R 12.21 if he is found unlikely to prove an efficient Police Officer at any time within three years of his/her enrolement.
This order be booked and compliance ensured. He/she is allotted constabulary No……………
Superintendent of Police,
Wireless, Haryana, Chandigarh.
No.Dated
Copies to
8. They were also issued the uniform kits and tokens by the Superintendent of Police, respondent No. 3.
9. However, on 31st August, 1989, Shri Chiranji Lal Sharma, Superintendent of Police, Wireless, Haryana, retired from service on attaining the age of super annuation, and in his place Shri C.P Bansal, I.P.S, was appointed as the Super intendent of Police, Wireless, Haryana. When the petitioners found that they were not being deputed for training, they made enquiries about the same and were told that the question of deputing them for training did not arise as the successor to Shri Chiranji Lal Sharma, Superintendent of Police, Wireless, had not been supplied the merit list of the selected candidates. It was further learnt by them that the selections made by Shri Chiranji Lal Sharma stood cancelled. The petitioners, after waiting for some time, have approached this Court against the alleged cancellation of their selection/appointment as Constable/Lady Con stable in Haryana Police, Wireless Department; and for the issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to depute them for necessary training.
10. In the written statement filed on behalf of respondent Nos. 2 and 3, the facts have been broadly admitted and the impugned action is sought to be justified on the ground that since the selection made by the earlier Committee was not based on merits and no merit list was prepared, the same was bad; hence, could not be adhered to. In nutshell, the defence is that it was only later that the successor to Shri Chiranji Lal Sharma, former Superintendent of Police, Wireless, Haryana had prepared the merit list and it was on that basis that some other persons had been already selected and deputed for training. Therefore, according to the respondents, as the petitioners were never selected for appointment legally, there was no question of deputing them for training.
11. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and after going through the relevant records which have been shown to me by the learned Advocate-General, Haryana I am of the considered view that the impugned action is neither legally tenable nor justifiable on the principles of natural justice, equity and fair
12. Appointments to the rank of Constables/Lady Constables in the Police Department, Haryana in Radio or Wireless Wing, Armed Police, Railway Police or C.I.D etc., is governed by the statutory rules framed under Sections 7 and 12 of the Police Act, 1861. These rules were framed in the erstwhile State of Punjab in 1934 and are classified for the sake of convenience in Volume I, II and III. Being statutory in nature, they have been made applicable to the State of Haryana on its formation under the Punjab Re-organisation Act, 1966, with effect from Page: 120Ist November, 1966. A Constable being the lowest in rank in the Police Force, appointment to the service is made by the enlistment to the Force under Rule 12.1 of the Punjab Police Rules, Volume II as applicable to the State of Haryana. According to these Rules, a duly constituted Selection Committee headed by the Superintendent of Police is entrusted with the task of making selection on the basis of written test, physical test, typing test, or parade, etc wherever necessary, followed by interviews. It is only thereafter that when the candidates are found physically fit that constabulary numbers are allotted and formal orders of appointment are issued to make them members of the Police service.
13. In the present case, the petitioners have undergone and completed all these stages and are well within their rights to treat themselves as members of the Police Force having been duly selected and appointed by a legally constituted and competent Selection Committee. If in a stray case, one or the other procedural requirement or formality had not been completed, meaning thereby that the con stabulary number was not allotted or the order has not been handed over by 31st August, 1989, when the then Superintendent of Police, Shri Chiranji Lal Sharma, had to retire, it neither confers on the State of Haryana any legal right to disown or disentitle that candidate from being treated as a member duly appointed to the Police Force nor does it give any credit to, the State for taking such an action. The petitioners having crossed all these stages have come to possess the necessary ingredients required, in law, for appointment as Police Constable and it is now not open to the respondents to treat their selection/appointment as cancelled. If the respondents had found some procedural infirmities in the selections already made, the proper course should have been to give the petitioners an opportunity of being heard or to issue notice to them to explain the position. But in the present case, no notice whatsoever was issued to the petitioners and the impugned-cancellation of the selection stands vitiated by the violation of the principles of natural justice.
14. It has been argued by the learned Advocate-General, Haryana, that by mere selection no right whatsoever stood conferred on the petitioners. No doubt it was held earlier by the Supreme Court in The State of Haryana v. Subhash Chander Marwaha, 1973 (2) S.L.R 137, that mere selection of a person does not confer upon him any right for appointment and it is open to the State Government to fill the post by making an appointment or not but this view has been later on diluted by their Lordships of the Supereme Court in Neelima-Shangla v. State of Haryana, 1986 (3) S.L.R 389. In that case, it was held, that the selection can not arbitrarily be restricted to a few candidates notwithstanding the number of vacancies and the availability of qualified candidates, unless there were very stsong reasons for the Government for not making the—appointments. But in the present case, the position is wholly different. It has been stated by the learned Advocate General, that after cancelling the selection of the petitioners, a number of other candidates-about 181 in number, have already been selected and sent for the training. Therefore, it is not the case of the State of Haryana that it has finally decided not to fill up the posts of Constables/Lady Constables. Rather, the fact is that the petitioners have been left out and some other persons. have been selected and even deputed for training.
15. It has further been pleaded by the learned Advocate-General, Haryana that a number of persons having already been selected and deputed for training, any disturbance at this stage by way of selection of the petitioners would certainly jeopardize the working of the Police Department, because, it had not only limited seats of Constables/Lady Constables and it would be difficult for the Department to accommodate all the petitioners.
16. With respect to the learned Advocate-General, the argument is not legally tenable. The claim of the petitioners is not against the persons who have been selected by the respondents but they only want their own service rights to be protected, that is, their selection should not have been cancelled. I think with the huge number of seats available with the respondents, it is neither difficult nor impracticable for the respondents to adjust those persons also in service, who have been selected and deputed for training after 31st August, 1989, that is, after the retirement of Shri Chiranji Lal Sharma, former Superintendent of Police.
17. Another important circumstance which strengthens the case of the petitioners is that after the writ petitions were admitted, all the petitioners have been deputed to undergo the training course under orders of the Motion Bench and at present the petitioners are duly trained, having completed their training successfully. At this stage, to treat their selection/appointment as Constable/Lady Constable can— celled, amounts to violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. Not only that, if this cancellation has the effect of removing the petitioners from the post of enlisted Constable/Lady Constable under Rule 12.1 ibid, it also amounts to violation of the Punjab Police Rules, 1934, Volume II, and Article 311(2) of the Constitution, as the services of the petitioners cannot be terminated without affording them an opportunity of being heard.
18. In any case, it has been settled by the Privy Council in the case reported as R.T Rangachari v. Secretary of State, A.I.R 1937 Privy Council 27, that once a benefit has been conferred on a Government servant by a competent authority, the successor-in-office cannot review the same and withdraw that benefit. This celebrated judgment of their Lordships of the Privy Council has since been followed with approval by almost all the High Courts in the country as also the Supreme Court in a number of cases during the last half a century. In this Court also, a Division Bench consisting of D.K Mahajan and Bhopinder Singh Dhillon, JJ. in the case, the General Manager, Northern Railway, Baroda House, New Delhi v. Madan Lal Chopra, etc, 1971 (1) S.L.R 629, following the law laid down in the aforesaid judgment of the Privy Council, permitted the Railway employees to retain the service benefit granted to them by the Railway authorities which the successor authorities, on reconsideration, wanted to withdraw. Consequently, I allow this writ petition and by issuing a writ of certiorari, strike down the decision of the respondents to cancel the selection/appointment of the petitioners on the posts of Constable/Lady Constable made on 31st August, 1989, by the then Superintendent of Police, Wireless, Haryana, and by issuing a writ of mandamus direct the respondents to appoint the petitioners as Con stables/Lady Constables forthwith. Since the petitioners have already completed their training and have been found medically fit, the respondents are directed to do the needful within a period of one month. The petitioners shall also be entitled to the costs of their writ petitions which are quantified as Rs. 500/- in each case. Those petitioners in these writ petitions who have not been sent for training so far, shall now be deputed for training within one month from today.
19. Petition allowed.