Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Case Summary — Aruna Suresh, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a petition under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code seeking to set aside the order dated 11.7.2007 of the learned Additional Sessions Judge (ASJ). The impugned order rejected the petitioner's prayer for directions to the police under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. made along with a complaint dated 10.1.2007. The petitioner sought (a) directions to the SHO to lodge an FIR against the accused for offences under the Indian Penal Code, (b) investigation by the police, and (c) issuance of process for summoning the accused, taking cognizance and conducting a trial.

Factual background as stated in the opinion: the complainant purchased a Skoda car in November 2004 from respondent No.1. The vehicle was insured and met with an accident in April 2006. The vehicle was taken to respondents' workshop and a surveyor (respondent No.5) assessed repair cost at approximately Rs. 6 lakhs, while respondents No.1 & 2 prepared an estimate and bill ranging from about Rs. 8.7 lakhs to over Rs. 10.7 lakhs. The insurer (respondent No.4) agreed to pay Rs. 6,03,000/-. The vehicle was not delivered until the complainant paid the alleged balance; the complainant did not take possession. The complainant alleged the bill was exaggerated, raised without his approval, that certain documents (satisfactory letter/discharge voucher and claim form) were forged, and that respondents failed to return original documents despite demand. The complainant complained to the police (who allegedly refused to act), then to the Magistrate with an application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C.

Procedurally, the Magistrate dismissed the application under Section 156(3) and listed the matter for pre-summoning evidence. The complainant challenged that order by way of Criminal Revision No. 34/2007 before the ASJ; the ASJ dismissed the revision by order dated 11.7.2007. The present petition under Section 482 seeks to set aside the ASJ's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the learned Additional Sessions Judge erred in dismissing the petitioner's revision challenging the Magistrate's refusal to direct the police to register an FIR and investigate under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C.
  2. Whether the Magistrate should have exercised his power under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. to direct investigation by the police in the circumstances of this case (i.e., whether police assistance was required because the complainant could not collect/produce material evidence himself).
  3. Whether, alternatively, the Magistrate ought to have issued process for summoning the accused, taken cognizance and proceeded to trial based on the complaint and evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Complainant / Petitioner's Arguments

  • The bill for repairs (Rs. 8,73,900/-) was raised by respondents No.1 & 2 without the complainant's information, knowledge, approval or permission and was exaggerated.
  • The bill and related documents (satisfactory letter/discharge voucher and claim form) were never signed by the complainant and are alleged to be forged or manipulated.
  • The respondents failed and refused to hand over original documents (registration certificate, insurance policy and other relevant documents) despite a demand letter dated 30.11.2006.
  • The complainant alleges he was cheated and that the police at Moti Nagar refused to take action on his complaint dated 14.12.2006.
  • Accordingly, he sought directions under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. to direct registration of an FIR and investigation, and alternatively sought summoning of accused, cognizance and trial.

State / Respondent's Arguments (Learned APP)

  • There is no infirmity or illegality in the orders of the learned Magistrate or the ASJ dismissing the application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C.
  • It is within the Magistrate's discretion either to proceed with inquiry himself or, in exercise of Section 156(3), direct the police to register an FIR and investigate; the power is discretionary.
  • Powers under Section 156(3) are generally to be exercised where the court considers it not feasible to hold the inquiry and where police assistance is required to discover evidence the complainant cannot collect on his own.
  • Accordingly, the petition should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gulab Chand Upadhyaya v. State of U.P., 2002 CrJ. L.J. 2907 Explains reasons for non-registration of FIRs and outlines when a Magistrate should direct police investigation under Section 156(3): specifically where investigation is needed that cannot be done by the private complainant (examples given, including unknown accused, recoveries requiring raids/searches, or collection/preservation of evidence). The court relied on this authority to explain that Section 156(3) should be exercised where police skills/ powers are necessary and not where the complainant already possesses or can produce the relevant evidence at pre-summoning stage.
Gangadhar Janardan Mhatre v. State of Maharashtra, JT 2004 (8) SC 208 Discusses the scheme of Chapter XII and XV of the Cr.P.C.: when a Magistrate after recording evidence may either direct police to investigate under Chapter XII, dismiss under Section 203 if no offence is disclosed, or take cognizance and issue process; also states a writ petition in such matters is not to be entertained. The court cited this Supreme Court decision to support the proposition that the Magistrate has a structured role: to record evidence, judge if police investigation is necessary, or take cognizance/issue process. The principle supported the Magistrate's and ASJ's approach in the present case.
All India Institute of Medical Sciences Employees' Union (Reg.) through its President v. Union of India Referenced as highlighting aspects of Chapter XII and XV; specifically noted the observation that writ petitions in such cases should not be entertained. The opinion notes this authority as reinforcing the correct procedural approach (i.e., not to bypass the Magistrate's role by writ), and the court observed that the previously cited authorities were considered by the Magistrate and ASJ.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the statutory framework: Chapter XII (information to the police and police power to investigate) and Chapter XV (complaints before a Magistrate and the Magistrate's procedure after taking cognizance). The opinion explains that Section 156(3) permits a Magistrate empowered under Section 190 to order a police investigation, while a complaint under Sections 190/200 provides an alternative remedy where the police either do not entertain or the complainant is dissatisfied with police investigation.

The court emphasized that the power under Section 156(3) must be exercised judiciously and not mechanically. The Magistrate should direct police investigation only after proper application of mind and only in cases where the complainant cannot collect or produce necessary evidence and police assistance is therefore required. The court also noted that police assistance can be sought under Section 202(1) after taking cognizance and proceeding with inquiry under Section 200.

The court considered the precedents cited (Gulab Chand Upadhyaya and Gangadhar Janardan Mhatre) which delineate circumstances requiring police investigation (e.g., unknown accused, need for raids/searches, collection/preservation of evidence) and the Magistrate's options on recording evidence. The opinion records that these authorities were discussed by the learned Magistrate and the ASJ.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court found that the complainant was fully aware of the facts and was in possession of the evidence necessary to be adduced at the pre-summoning stage before the Magistrate. There was no material showing that evidence essential for successful prosecution could only be procured by the police through special investigative powers. Because the complainant could himself produce the evidence during the Magistrate's inquiry, the court concluded that directing the police to investigate under Section 156(3) was unnecessary. Thus the ASJ's dismissal of the revision petition was correct and did not exhibit illegality or infirmity.

The court also noted that the complainant had made an alternative prayer for summoning the accused and taking cognizance; the court found this alternative grievance to be "without any basis" on the facts.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED. The petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is dismissed.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The order of the Additional Sessions Judge dated 11.7.2007 (which dismissed the revision and refused to direct the police under Section 156(3)) stands; no interference was made with that order.
  • The Magistrate's discretion to either hold inquiry himself or to direct police investigation under Section 156(3) was affirmed as properly exercised in this case; the court found no need for police assistance given the complainant's possession of the relevant evidence.
  • The opinion does not state any broader legal change or new precedent created; it applies established principles to the facts and upholds the lower court's exercise of discretion.

This summary is derived exclusively from the text of the provided opinion. No additional facts or inferences have been added.

    Brahm Prakash Gupta v. State .

    Aruna Suresh, J.:— In this petition filed under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code (hereinafter referred to as Code) the petitioner has sought setting aside of the order dated 11.7.2007 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge thereby rejecting the prayer of the petitioner for directions to the police under Section 156(3) of the Code filed along with his complaint dated 10.1.2007 for investigation with further prayer to direct the SHO of the concerned police station to lodge an FIR against the accused persons for the criminal offences which they allegedly committed, under appropriate provisions of the Indian Penal code. Further relief sought is issuance of the order for summoning of the accused person and to take cognizance and conduct the trial.

    2. Complainant had purchased a car vide No. DL-2F AH 0100 make Skoda in the month of November 2004 from respondent No. 1 the Managing Director of M/s Silvertone Motors Pvt. Ltd. which was insured with respondent No. 4 Tata AIG Insurance Company Ltd. vide police No. 0195293018 in October 2005. The policy was to expire on 2.11.2006 In April, 2006, the said vehicle met with an accident at Alipur, Delhi and was taken to the workshop of respondent No. 1 & 2. The said car was inspected by respondent No. 5 authorized surveyor who submitted his report and prepared the claim. This claim was sent to respondent No. 4. The surveyor assessed the total amount to be spent on repairs of the said car as approximately Rs. 6 lacs. However, respondent No. 2 preapared the estimate amount including labour charges and costs of spare parts etc. at Rs. 10,70,311/-. Subsequently, petitioner received repair bill for Rs. 8,73,900/- to which he objected on the plea that the insurance company was ready to pay Rs. 5,78,946/-. The possession of the vehicle was not to be delivered to the petitioner till he cleared the balance amount of Rs. 3,33,650/- as the respondent No. 4 had finally agreed to pay Rs. 6,03,000/-. The petitioner has not taken the possession of the vehicle he has not paid the balance amount. It is argued by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the bill for Rs. 8,73,900/- was raised by respondents No. 1 & 2 without any information, knowledge or approval or permission of the complainant and the said bill is exaggerated which has been prepared with the connivance of the respondents. The respondent No. 1 & 2 have failed to satisfy the petitioner about their claim as raised in the bill. It is further alleged that on 22.11.2006 when complainant approached respondent No. 2 to enquire about status of his car and for taking other relevant documents, he was only handed over the copy of the bill and it was then that he was told that respondent No. 4 paid only Rs. 6,03,000/-. It is also submitted that the satisfactory letter/discharge voucher and claim form was never got signed from the complainant and therefore the said documents are forged and manipulated by the accused persons. Despite demand by the complainant vide his letter dated 30.11.2006 he has not been handed over original documents like registration certificate, insurance policy and other relevant documents. It is further submitted that petitioner has been cheated by the respondents but the police refused to take any action on his complaint dated 14.12.2006 which was sent to police station Moti Nagar. Thereafter, he filed the complaint before learned metropolitan magistrate alongwith an application under Section 156 (3) of the Code seeking directions to the police to register a case against the respondents and investigate the matter. However, learned trial court dismissed the application of the petitioner under Section 156(3) of the Code and listed the matter for recording of pre summoning evidence on 5.5.2007 This order was challenged by the complainant by way of a revision petition being Criminal Revision No. 34/2007. This revision petition was also dismissed by the learned ASJ by a detailed order dated 11.7.2007

    3. Learned APP for the State has submitted that there is no infirmity or illegality in the order of the learned MM as well as of the learned ASJ vide which the application of the petitioner under Section 156(3) of the Code was dismissed. He has urged that it is the discretion of the court either to proceed with the inquiry himself or in exercise of its power under Section 156(3) of the Code direct the police to register an FIR and investigate the matter. He further argued that generally the power under Section 156(3) of the Code are to be exercised where the Court is of the opinion that it is not feasible to hold inquiry itself and assistance of the police is required for breaking the case and discovering some evidence which the complainant was unable to collect of his own. Therefore, he has prayed that the petition be dismissed.

    4. I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the petitioner and learned APP for the State.

    5. Chapter XII of the Code deals with information to the police and its power to investigate the offences. Chapter XV of the Code deals with complaint filed before a Magistrate and the procedure to be adopted by the Magistrate after taking cognizance of an offence. section 156 of the code contained in Chapter XII speaks of the powers of the police officers to investigate cognizable cases and sub clause 3 of the said section gives power to the Magistrate having power under section 190 of the code to order such an investigation. Complaint filed under Section 190 read with 200 of the Code before a Magistrate provides an alternative as well as an additional remedy to a complainant whose complaint either is not entertained by the police or who is not satisfied by the investigation being conducted by the police.

    6. Powers vested in a Magistrate to direct police officer to investigate a matter under Section 156(3) of the Code is to be exercised judiciously on appropriate grounds and not in a mechanical manner. There may be cases where the allegations are not very serious and the complainant himself is in possession of evidence to prove his allegations, there is no need to pass an order under Section 156(3) of the Code. The Magistrate has to exercise power under Section 156(3) of the Code only after proper application of mind and only in those cases where the Magistrate feels that the nature of allegations in the complaint are such that complainant himself may not be able to collect and produce evidence before the court and feels the necessity of the police stepping in to help the complainant. Police assistance can also be taken by a Magistrate under Section 202(1) of the Code after taking cognizance and proceeding with the enquiry of the complaint filed under Section 200 contained in Chapter 15 of the Code. Section 156(3) of the Code curtails and controls the arbitrariness on the part of the police authorities in the matter of registration of FIRs and not taking up investigation even in those cases where the same are warranted. However, complainant cannot be allowed to misuse this provision to get police case registered even if the allegations in the complaint are not serious in nature and the Magistrate can hold inquiry himself and proceed against the accused if required.

    7. In Gulab Chand Upadhyaya v. State of U.P, 2002 CrJ. L.J 2907, it was held by this Court:

    “7. The causes for non-registration of FIR at police stations in cognizable case can vary widely. The overworked police may be indifferent to the common man's woes, the accused may be influential, registering of FIRs may be refused to keep the crime statistics of that police station low. Also, in some cases the police may be aware of the true state of affairs and may refuse to register false or pre-emptive FIRs.

    10. Section 41 Cr.P.C gives the power to the police to arrest without warrant in cognizable offences, in cases enumerated in that Section. One such case is of receipt of a “reasonable complaint” or “credible information” or reasonable suspicion” [see section 41(a) & (g)]. When a Magistrate directs registration of FIR and investigation, it would be a little difficult for the police officer of the rank of inspector or sub-inspector to still contend that the complaint or suspicion is not “reasonable” or that the information (in the FIR) is not “credible”. Although the use of the word “may” in Section 41 Cr.P.C indicates that, it is not obligatory for police to make arrest in every case. But if arrest is made, it does not require any, much less strong, reasons to be recorded or reported by the police. Thus so long as the information or suspicion of cognizable offence is “reasonable” or “credible”, the police officer is not accountable for the discretion of arresting or no arresting. At best the arrested person can be granted bail, or maybe in extreme cases remand can be refused U/s 167 Cr.P.C

    It was observed:

    “22. The scheme of Cr.P.C and the prevailing circumstances require that the option to direct the registration of the case and its investigation by the police should be exercised where some “investigation” is required, which is of a nature that is not possible for the private complainant, and which can only be done by the police upon whom statute has conferred the powers essential for investigation, for example

    (1) where the full details of the accused are not known to the complainant and the same can be determined only as a result of investigation, or

    (2) where recovery of abducted person or stolen property is required to be made by conducting raids or searches of suspected places or persons, or

    (3) where for the purpose of launching a successful prosecution of the accused evidence is required to be collected and preserved. To illustrate by example cases may be visualized where for production before Court at the trial(a) sample of blood soaked soil is to be take and kept sealed for fixing the place of incident; or (b) recovery of case property is to be made and kept sealed; or (c) recovery under Section 27 of the Evidence Act; or (d) preparation of inquest report; or (e) witnesses are not known and have to be found out or discovered through the process of investigation.”

    8. In Gangadhar Janardan Mhatre v. State of Maharashtra, JT 2004 (8) SC 208, Division Bench of the Supreme Court while discussing the entire scheme contained in Chapter XII and XV of the Code held:

    “When the information is laid with the Police, but no action in that behalf is taken, the complainant is given power under Section 190 read with Section 200 of the Code to lay the complaint before the Magistrate having jurisdiction to take cognizance of the offence and the Magistrate is required to enquire into the complaint as provided in Chapter XV of the Code. In case the Magistrate after recording evidence finds a prima facie case instead of issuing process to the accused, he is empowered to direct the Police concerned to investigate into offence under Chapter XII of the Code and to submit a report. If he finds that the complaint does not disclose any offence to take further action, he is empowered to dismiss the complaint under Section 203 of the Code. In case he finds that the complaint/evidence recorded prima facie discloses an offence, he is empowered to take cognizance of the offence and would issue process to the accused. These aspects have been highlighted by this Court in All India Institute of Medical Sciences Employees' Union (Reg.) through its President v. Union of India. It was specifically observed that a writ petition in such cases is not to be entertained.”

    9. Both these judgments (supra) have been discussed in right prospective by the learned MM in his order dated 8.3.2007 as well as learned ASJ in her order dated 11.7.2007

    10. Coming to the facts of this case, complainant is in the knowledge of the entire facts and circumstances of this case. He is in possession of the evidence which he can adduce at pre summoning stage in the inquiry of the complaint by the Magistrate. The facts narrated in the complaint clearly indicate that no assistance of the police is required either by directing it to register a case and investigate the same when Magistrate himself can hold an inquiry in view of the fact that there is no such evidence required to be produced on record which the complainant may not be able to procure or produce it before the Magistrate during inquiry. Therefore, learned ASJ rightly dismissed the revision petition being without merits. I do not find any infirmity or illegality in the said order. Hence, no interference is required.

    11. It is pertinent to mention here that in the alternative complainant made a prayer requesting the Magistrate to issue order for summoning of the accused persons and take cognizance of the offences and conduct trial against the respondents. Therefore, even otherwise, the grievance of the petitioner in view of his alternative prayer is without any basis.

    12. Hence, the petition is hereby dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Brahm Prakash Gupta v. State .
    (May 23, 2008)