Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts

    Chander Dev Petitioner v. Raj Kumar Bhatia

    REKHA MITTAL, J

    The present petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (in short, ‘the Code’) has been directed against orders dated 10.06.2008 (Annexure P1), passed by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sirsa and dated 11.08.2011, passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court, Sirsa, whereby the complaint filed by the petitioner under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (in short, ‘the Act’) has been dismissed by the trial Court and the order of dismissal affirmed by the revisional Court.

    Chander Dev-petitioner filed criminal complaint in regard to dishonour of cheque allegedly issued by the respondent, in discharge of his legally enforceable liability. The complaint was filed on 18.04.2004 After conducting preliminary inquiry in compliance with provisions of Section 202 of the Code, the accused (respondent herein) was summoned to face proceedings for offence punishable under Section 138 of the Act. The accused appeared before the trial Court. Notice of accusation was served upon him and the case was posted for recording evidence of the complainant. On 10.07.2008, due to failure of the complainant or his representative to put in appearance before the trial Court, the impugned order was passed, whereby the accused (respondent herein) was ordered to be discharged. Subsequent thereto, the complainant filed an application for restoration of the complaint, which was later dismissed as withdrawn. The complainant (petitioner herein) preferred a revision petition before the Court of Sessions which was ultimately dismissed on 11.08.2011

    Feeling aggrieved by the orders passed by the Courts below, the present petition has been filed.

    The crucial question for adjudication is ‘whether the petitioner can file a petition under Section 482 of the Code to challenge order dated 10.06.2008, whereby the complaint was ordered to be dismissed in his absence as remedy of filing special leave to appeal under Section 378(4) of the Code is available.’

    Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that even if the petitioner has an alternative remedy of filing an appeal under Section 378(4) of the Code, it in itself cannot be a ground to reject the petition if the Court is otherwise convinced that an order passed by the trial Court has resulted in miscarriage of justice. In support of his contention, he has relied upon judgment of Hon'ble the Supreme Court of India in Punjab State Warehousing Corporation Faridkot v. Shri Durga Ji Traders, 2012 (1) R.C.R (Criminal) 358. He has also referred to a judgment of this Court in Om Parkash… v. Golden Forest India Ltd.…., 2008 (4) R.C.R (Criminal) 445.

    Counsel for the respondent, on the contrary, would argue that the only remedy available to the petitioner was to challenge the order of dismissal of the complaint by seeking special leave to appeal from this Court, by invoking the provisions of Section 378(4) of the Code. In support of his contention, he has referred to a latest judgment of Hon'ble the Supreme Court of India in Subhash Chand v. State (Delhi Administration), 2013 (1) R.C.R (Criminal) 1013.

    I have heard counsel for the parties and perused the records.

    There cannot be any dispute about the settled position of law that dismissal of a complaint for want of prosecution, in a summons case results in acquittal of the accused as has been provided in Section 256 of the Code. Equally true is that the complainant can challenge the order of acquittal by filing an application for special leave to appeal in the High Court and not in the Court of Sessions as has been laid down by Hon'ble the Supreme Court in Subhash Chand's case (supra).

    The question for examination and adjudication is ‘whether the complainant can file a petition under Section 482 of the Code seeking setting aside order of dismissal or in other words, restoration of the complaint dismissed in default.’

    Hon'ble the Supreme Court of India in Punjab State Warehousing Corporation Faridkot's case (supra) was dealing with a matter wherein the High Court has dismissed the petition under Section 482 of the Code for setting aside order of dismissal of complaint in default and restoration thereof holding that dismissal in default of a private complaint amounts to acquittal of the accused and since against such an order, a specific statutory remedy exists in the Code, a petition under Section 482 of the Code cannot be entertained. Hon'ble the Supreme Court, while noticing various judgments passed by the said Court from time to time has summed up its conclusion in para 9. A relevant extract from para 9 is usefully quoted hereinbelow:-

    “We are convinced that in the instant case, rejection of appellants petition under Section 482 of the Code has resulted in miscarriage of justice. Availability of an alternative remedy of filing an appeal is not an absolute bar in entertaining a petition under Section 482 of the Code. As aforesaid, one of the circumstances envisaged in the said Section, for exercise of jurisdiction by the High Court is to secure the ends of justice. Undoubtedly, the trial court had dismissed the complaint on a technical ground and therefore, interests of justice required the High Court to exercise its jurisdiction to set aside such an order so that the trial court could proceed with the trial on merits.

    In Om parkash's case (supra), this Court, while dealing with a similar issue of exercise of jurisdiction under Section 482 of the Code to examine an order passed by the trial court dismissing a criminal complaint under Section 138 of the Code in default, has allowed the petition and set aside the order, dismissing the complaint in default.

    In Subhash Chand's case (supra) referred to by counsel for the respondent, the Apex Court has neither adverted itself to the question of maintainability of a petition under Section 482 of the Code against an order dismissing the complaint in default resulting in acquittal of the accused nor that question has otherwise been answered.

    In view of judgment passed by Hon'ble the Supreme Court of India in Punjab State Warehousing Corporation Faridkot's case (supra), the existence of an alternative remedy of filing an appeal cannot create an absolute bar in entertaining a petition under Section 482 of the Code if the circumstances so warrant.

    Now coming to the facts of the case in hand, the criminal complaint was filed in April 2004. The accused was ordered to be summoned after recording evidence during preliminary inquiry. The complaint was dismissed in default due to absence of the complainant on 10.06.2008 There is nothing on record to suggest that the complainant earlier also absented from the proceedings much less his conduct lacked bona fide. In case, the order passed by the trial Magistrate is not set aside, the entire efforts of the complainant to bring the criminal proceedings to its logical end for the last four years would result in futility and he would be condemned unheard without getting effective opportunity of being heard on the merits of the controversy. On the other hand, a single default on the part of the complainant would enure to the benefit of the accused in escaping his liability subject matter of the criminal proceedings. No-doubt, it would have been better if the complainant had been advised properly to straightway file an appeal, in place of initially filing an application for restoration of the complainant, then the revision before the Court of Sessions and now the present petition under Section 482 of the Code, in accordance with law. The present petitioner is a victim of wrong legal advice on a number of occasions and he cannot be permitted to suffer any longer in the circumstances of the present case. In this view of the matter, I am of the considered opinion that it is a fit case, where the Court should exercise its jurisdiction under Section 482 of the Code in place of relegating the petitioner to his alternative remedy of filing an application for special leave to appeal before this Court at this belated stage. In this view of the matter, I find force in the contention of the petitioner that the petitioner can be allowed to maintain a petition under Section 482 of the Code, despite existence of an alternative remedy of filing an appeal.

    The complainant became absent from the proceedings on 10.06.2008 Just after four days on 14.06.2008, he submitted an application for restoration of the complaint. A single default on the part of the complainant cannot be allowed to entail serious consequence of termination of the proceedings.

    In view of the foregoing reasons, the petition is allowed. Consequently, orders dated 10.06.2008 (Annexure P1), passed by the Additional Judicial Magistrate, Sirsa and dated 11.08.2011 (Annexure P2), passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court, Sirsa, are ordered to be set aside and the complaint filed by the petitioner is ordered to be restored at the stage from where it was dismissed by the trial Court.

    Parties through their respective counsel are directed to appear before the trial Court on 13.01.2014

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chander Dev Petitioner v. Raj Kumar Bhatia
    (Dec 11, 2013)