AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 5(2) of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure.10.
  • Rule 5(2) of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order VIII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Order VIII Rule 10 of Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Order VIII, Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 5(2) of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure.10.
  • Rule 5(2) of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure
  • Order VIII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Order VIII Rule 10 of Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Order VIII, Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant is the original defendant No. 3 in Special Civil Suit No. 284/95, which was filed by non-applicant No. 1 (plaintiff) for recovery of Rs. 2,70,000. The applicant and certain non-applicants are related (brothers and their mother is also a party). The plaintiff is described as a lessor and co-owner of a Ginning and Pressing Factory, holding specified fractional shares, and the applicant and other non-applicants are partners in a partnership firm with offices at Adilabad and Akola.

At trial, the applicant failed to file a written statement by the deadline (21-11-1997), and an order of no written statement was passed. The plaintiff's evidence was recorded on 12-12-1997, arguments were advanced on 18-12-1997, and the matter was fixed for judgment on 29-12-1997. On 29-12-1997 the applicant submitted an application (Exh. 50) seeking recall of the plaintiff for cross-examination; on 5-3-1998 the applicant filed another application (Exh. 51) seeking to have a written statement taken on record (the written statement was annexed). The Civil Judge, Senior Division, Akola rejected both applications by common order dated 27-3-1998. The applicant filed the present civil revision challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Court has the power to entertain and accept a written statement filed by the defendant after the trial Court concluded ex parte hearing of the suit and adjourned the matter for delivery of judgment.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant asserted that the non-applicants had been served (by hamdast) and that no one appeared on their behalf when the rule was heard.
  • The applicant noted family and property relationships relevant to the dispute (brotherhood and mother relationship; partnership firm involvement; details about ownership shares and prior suits).
  • The applicant admitted failure to file the written statement by the deadline but contended that the trial Court erred in rejecting applications Exh. 50 and Exh. 51 and in not permitting the written statement to be taken on record.
  • Legal argument: The trial Court failed to properly apply Order VIII of the Code of Civil Procedure. Specifically, Rule 5(2) of Order VIII does not positively mandate a bar on accepting written statements under all circumstances, and Rule 10 of Order VIII vests discretion in the Court to permit filing of a written statement at any stage prior to pronouncement of judgment.
  • The applicant contended that under Rule 10 the Court may either pronounce judgment against a defendant who failed to file a written statement or "pass any order as it thinks fit", which includes admitting a written statement even after ex parte hearing but before pronouncement of judgment.
  • Reliance was placed on two authorities to substantiate the contention: Ramesh Chandra Bhattacharyya v. Corporation of Calcutta, AIR 1987 Cal 111 (Calcutta High Court), and Vithal Ramchandra Patil v. Bhagwat Waman Gaikwad ((1996) 2 Mah LJ 1064) (this Court).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramesh Chandra Bhattacharyya v. Corporation of Calcutta, AIR 1987 Cal 111 Relied on by the learned counsel for the applicant in support of the contention that a Court may admit a written statement in appropriate circumstances. The opinion records that the learned counsel relied on this judgment; the Court's written analysis does not expressly record reliance on or further application of that judgment's specific holding.
Vithal Ramchandra Patil v. Bhagwat Waman Gaikwad, (1996) 2 Mah LJ 1064 Supports the proposition that "for the ends of justice, if necessary, the written statement can be admitted on the record till the Court proceeds to deliver the judgment" (as observed in para (7) of that judgment). The Court expressly referenced this judgment and noted that a similar view was taken by this Court; the Court relied on it to support admitting the written statement before pronouncement of judgment where justice requires.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis focused on the purport and operation of Order VIII, Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The Court observed that:

  1. Order VIII, Rule 10 plainly gives the trial Court discretion to permit the defendant to file a written statement at any stage prior to pronouncement of judgment. By its terms the Rule permits the Court to either pronounce judgment against a defendant who has not filed a written statement or to "pass any order as it thinks fit".
  2. Because of that discretion, a trial Court can admit a written statement even after ex parte evidence has been recorded and arguments heard, provided the written statement is filed before judgment is pronounced.
  3. In the instant case, the trial Court recorded that on the date fixed for judgment (29-12-1997) it had not pronounced judgment but adjourned the matter for passing orders on the applications Exh. 50 and Exh. 51. Therefore, the trial Court had not exhausted the jurisdiction contemplated by the first part of Rule 10 (i.e., pronouncing judgment for failure to file a written statement).
  4. Because the matter had been adjourned for consideration of the applications, the Court interpreted that as an exercise of the latter part of Rule 10 ("or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit"), and hence the trial Court retained jurisdiction to accept the written statement.
  5. The Court therefore concluded that it was not correct to hold that the trial Court was incompetent to accept the written statement filed by original defendant No. 3 merely because the suit had proceeded to ex parte hearing and a date for judgment had earlier been fixed.
  6. The Court noted that the written statement contained material allegations (including reference to a prior suit No. 21/94 filed by the applicant seeking partition and separate possession) which the trial Court ought to have had before it for a just decision on merits; accordingly, the trial Court should have allowed the written statement in the interests of justice.
  7. The Court also stated that, having reached its conclusion on the scope of Rule 10, it was unnecessary to consider the applicant's separate contentions regarding Rule 5(2) of Order VIII.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The civil revision application is allowed. The impugned order dated 27-3-1998 passed by the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Akola in Special Civil Suit No. 284/95 (rejecting Exhs. 50 and 51) is set aside. The written statement filed by the applicant (original defendant No. 3) is to be taken on record. The trial Court is directed to proceed with the suit, including allowing the applicant to cross-examine the plaintiff. No order as to costs.

Implications: The direct effect is that the applicant's written statement is admitted and the trial will continue on merits, including cross-examination of the plaintiff. The opinion does not discuss broader doctrinal changes beyond applying the Court's view of Order VIII, Rule 10 in this case; no new precedent beyond the Court's ruling in this instance is articulated in the text.

Application allowed.

    Vimalkumar Nathmal Goenka…Applicant; v. Vinod Kumar Nathmal Goenka And Others…

    1. Heard Shri Shelat, the learned counsel for the applicant (original defendant No. 3) at length. This Court on 5-5-1998 issued rule and the same was made returnable on 15-6-1998. The learned counsel submitted that the non-applicants were served by hamdast. Even otherwise, the note of office of this Court also shows that the non-applicants were served. However, none appears for the non-applicants.

    2. The learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the present applicant is the original defendant No. 3 and non-applicant No. 1 Vinod Kumar is the plaintiff. Applicant Vimal Kumar and non-applicant Nos. 1 Vinod Kumar and 3 Vimal Kumar are the real brothers. Non-applicant No. 4 Smt. Gulabdevi is mother of applicant and non-applicant Nos. 1 and 3. It is further submitted that non-applicant No. 1.original plaintiff filed Special Civil No. 284/95 against the present applicant and others for recovery of amount of rupees two lacs and seventy thousand.

    3. The non-applicant No. 1.plaintiff is a lessor and co-owner of Ginning and Pressing Factory situated at Adilabad (Andhra Pradesh). He is having ¼th share in the entire Ginning and Pressing Factory and he is the owner and landlord in respect of ½th share in the suit property. The present non-applicant No. 2 is a partnership firm of which present applicant and non-applicant Nos. 3 and 4 are its partners. The partnership firm is carrying on its business at Adilabad and Akola and offices of the said firm are situated at Adilabad and Akola.

    4. The learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the applicant/original defendant No. 3 did net file written statement on or before 21-11-1997 and, therefore, order of no written statement was passed against the applicant and the suit proceeded without written statement. The plaintiff examined himself and during his examination-in-chief, proved documents on 12-12-1997. The matter was fixed on 18-12-1997 for arguments. The Counsel for the plaintiff advanced his arguments on that day and the matter was fixed for judgment on 29-12-1997. The learned counsel further submitted that the present applicant submitted application (Exh. 50) on 29-12-1997 for recalling the plaintiff for the purpose of cross-examination by the applicant/defendant No. 3. The present applicant thereafter submitted another application (Exh. 51) on 5-3-1998 for taking written statement on record. The written statement was annexed to the said application. However, Civil Judge, Senior Division, Akola by common order dated 27-3-1998 rejected both the applications (Exhs. 50 and 51). Hence, the applicant has preferred this civil revision application.

    5. The learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the impugned order is not just and proper and same is also not sustainable in law. The learned counsel contended that the trial Court has not taken into consideration the purport of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure, which deals with written statement. It is submitted that Rule 5(2) of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure does not contain any specific and positive mandate not to accept written statement under any circumstances. It is also submitted that the trial Court is not precluded from entertaining an application for taking written statement on record nor defendant is debarred from making such an application. It is further submitted that Rule 10 of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure gives discretion to the Court to permit the defendant to file written statement at any stage prior to pronouncement of judgment. It is the contention of the learned counsel that under Rule 10, the Court can either pronounce judgment against the defendant on his failure to file written statement or pass any order as it thinks fit, which gives discretion to the Court to admit the written statement even at the stage when ex parte hearing was concluded and the Court has fixed the matter for delivery of judgment. The learned counsel contended that the impugned order is, therefore, not just and proper and same is liable to be set aside. In order to substantiate the contentions raised before me, reliance is placed by the learned counsel for the applicant on the judgment of Calcutta High Court in Ramesh Chandra Bhattacharyya v. Corporation of Calcutta, AIR 1987 Cal 111, and judgment of this Court in Vithal Ramchandra Patil v. Bhagwat Waman Gaikwad, (1996) 2 Mah LJ 1064.

    6. In view of the facts and circumstances of the present case, the question which requires consideration by this Court is “whether the trial Court has a power to entertain the written statement filed by the defendant after the trial Court concluded ex parte hearing of the suit and adjourned the matter for delivery of judgment”.

    7. In the instant case, admittedly the applicant/defendant No. 3 did not file any written statement even though he was given enough opportunity by the trial Court. The suit was fixed for ex parte hearing and evidence of the plaintiff was recorded by the trial Court on 12-12-1997. The matter was fixed on 18-12-1997 for arguments and thereafter it was fixed for judgment on 29-12-1997. It is an admitted position that on 29-12-1997, the trial Court had neither delivered nor pronounced the judgment. On the other hand, it appears that the matter was adjourned for passing necessary orders on Exh. 50. Thereafter, on 5-3-1998, the applicant filed an application for taking written statement on record (Exh. 51) and the written statement was annexed to that application. Both the above referred applications filed by the applicant were considered by the trial Court on 27-3-1998 and came to be rejected by the trial Court. Exh. 50 was rejected as not maintainable while exh. 51 was rejected on the ground that matter was fixed for judgment on 29-12-1997 and once the matter was fixed for judgment, written statement could not be allowed to be filed nor could be accepted.

    8. In order to consider the issue in question, it will be meaningful to consider purport of Order VIII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure. There is no difficulty in coming to the conclusion that Rule 10 gives discretion to the Court and the Court can permit the defendant to file written statement at any stage prior to pronouncement of judgment. Plain reading of Rule 10 makes it clear that the Court can either pronounce judgment against the defendant in the absence of written statement or pass any order as it thinks fit. In view of the above referred legal position vis a vis Rule 10 of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure, the trial Court could have exercised discretion even at the stage when ex parte hearing was concluded and matter was fixed for delivery of judgment on 29-12-1997. However, in the instant case, admittedly the same had not been done by the trial Court and the matter was posted for passing necessary orders on the applications (Exhs. 50 and 51) preferred by the applicant. Since judgment was not pronounced in the matter by the trial Court on the date on which it was fixed for pronouncement of judgment, i.e 29-12-1997 and the matter was adjourned for passing necessary orders on Exhs. 50 and 51, it cannot be said that the trial Court had exhausted the jurisdiction vested in it as per Order VIII, Rule 10 of Code of Civil Procedure, nor can it be construed that the trial Court had no jurisdiction to accept the written statement. In the present case, the trial Court did not reject Exh. 50 on 29-12-1997 and did not pronounce judgment on-29-12-1997 (date fixed for delivery of judgment) and adjourned the matter to a future date. The entire exercise undertaken by the trial Court clearly shows that it did not exercise jurisdiction vested in it by the first part of Order VIII, Rule 10 of Code of Civil Procedure, i.e by pronouncing the judgment on failure to file written statement as required under Order VIII, Rule 1 of Code of Civil Procedure. The present case would fall within the ambit of latter part of Rule 10 of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure, i.e “or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit”. Hence once the case/suit was adjourned to a future date, it is impliedly clear that the trial Court had exercised discretion contemplated in the above referred latter part of Rule 10 of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure. It is, therefore, not possible in the facts and circumstances of the present case to hold that the trial Court was not competent to accept written statement filed by the original defendant No. 3.

    9. Since I have already recorded my finding referred above, regarding purport of Order VIII Rule 10 of Code of Civil Procedure, it is not necessary for me to consider the contentions raised by the learned counsel for the applicant in respect of Rule 5(2) of Order VIII of Code of Civil Procedure.

    10. Similar view was taken by this Court in its judgment in Vithal Ramchandra Patil v. Bhagwat Waman Gaikwad (1996) 2 Mah LJ 1064. In para (7) of the said judgment of this Court, it is specifically observed by the single Judge that “for the ends of justice, if necessary, the written statement can be admitted on the record till the Court proceeds to deliver the judgment”.

    11. In the instant case, the applicant has annexed written statement along with civil revision application. In para (12) of the written statement, it is stated that applicant (defendant No. 3) filed Civil Suit No. 21/94 before the District Judge, Adilabad with regard to the suit property on or about 25-8-1994 and claimed partition and separate possession of his undivided share in the various properties including the suit property involved in the present Special Civil Suit No. 284/95. The present non-applicant No. 1.plaintiff is defendant No. 3 in the above referred suit bearing No. 21/94. It is further stated that the said suit is decreed and it is also directed by the Court that separate ¼th share of the present applicant/defendant No. 3 be earmarked and to be put in possession of his separate share. It is further stated in the said para of the written statement that present non-applicant No. 1 plaintiff has not intentionally made reference to the suit bearing No. 21/94 and has suppressed the material facts from the Court. After going through the pleadings in Para (12) of the written statement, the trial Court ought to have allowed filing of the written statement, which is, in my opinion, necessary for the just decision on merits in the suit as well as in the interest of justice.

    12. In the result, civil revision application is allowed. The impugned order dated 27-3-1998 passed by the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Akola in Special Civil Suit No. 284/95 on Exhs. 50 and 51 is hereby set aside. The written statement filed by the applicant defendant No. 3 be taken on record. The trial Court is directed to proceed with the suit including allowing the applicant to cross-examine the non-applicant No. 1 plaintiff. No order as to costs.

    Application allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vimalkumar Nathmal Goenka…Applicant; v. Vinod Kumar Nathmal Goenka And Others…
    (Jun 18, 1998)