AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent-plaintiff filed Title Suit No. 4 of 1993 before the Civil Court at Howrah seeking specific performance of an agreement dated 4-2-1992 for the sale of land measuring 8 cottahs 14 chitaks 24 sq ft (recorded as 16 shataks in Dag No. 271, Khatian No. 74). The agreed price was Rs 15,000 per cottah; the defendant accepted Rs 60,000 as earnest money with the balance payable at execution of the sale deed. When the defendant later refused to execute the deed and instead offered to return the earnest money, the suit was instituted.

The trial court (Civil Judge, Sr. Division, 3rd Court, Howrah) on 29-6-2002 ordered refund of the earnest money. On appeal, the 3rd Additional District Judge, Howrah (Title Appeal No. 139 of 2002) reversed that decision on 22-12-2003 and directed execution of the sale deed upon the plaintiff’s payment of the balance Rs 73,125.

The defendants’ Second Appeal No. 430 of 2004 was partly allowed by the Calcutta High Court on 1-8-2013; while upholding specific performance, the High Court permitted a fresh survey through a court-appointed Commissioner, failing which the earlier measurements would stand.

The defendants obtained special leave and appealed to the Supreme Court, challenging the High Court’s modified decree.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in the circumstances of the case, a decree for specific performance should be granted or the plaintiff should merely receive refund of the earnest money with interest under Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined the discretionary nature of relief under Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963. Sub-section (2) lists situations where specific performance should be declined, notably when performance imposes unforeseeable hardship on the defendant that non-performance does not impose on the plaintiff.

  • The Court noted that possession of the land had never been delivered to the plaintiff, and the precise area to be conveyed remained uncertain; the High Court itself had ordered a fresh survey.
  • Because no construction or other substantial acts had been undertaken by the plaintiff, there was no evidence of irreversible detriment that would justify compelling transfer of title.
  • The agreement’s clause allowed adjustment of price if the land measured less than 10 cottahs, indicating that exact measurement was fundamental to the bargain and still unresolved.
  • Given these facts, the Court held that enforcing the contract would create hardship for the defendants while non-performance would not comparably prejudice the plaintiff, satisfying Section 20(2)(b).

Consequently, equity favoured monetary restitution rather than compulsory conveyance.

Holding and Implications

HELD: The decree for specific performance is set aside. The appellants (legal heirs of the vendor) are directed to refund the earnest money of Rs 60,000 to the respondent-plaintiff with interest at 18% per annum from 4-2-1992 until payment, to be made within three months. The plaintiff may withdraw the Rs 73,125 already deposited after the appellants comply.

Implications: The decision resolves the dispute by granting restitution instead of specific performance, affecting only the parties to this litigation and setting no new precedent beyond a routine application of Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act.

    Hemanta Mondal And Others v. Ganesh Chandra Naskar .

    Prafulla C. Pant, J.— Leave granted. This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 1-8-2013, passed by the High Court of Judicature at Calcutta in Hemanta Mondal v. Ganesh Chandra Naskar 2013 SCC OnLine Cal 22899, (2013) 3 Cal LJ 546, whereby the said Court has modified the decree passed by the 3rd Additional District Judge, Howrah in Title Appeal No. 139 of 2002.

    2. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the papers on record.

    3. Brief facts of the case are that respondent-plaintiff filed Title Suit No. 4 of 1993 for specific performance of agreement, possession and injunction before the Civil Court at Howrah, in respect of “Danga” land measuring 8 cottahs 14 chitak 24 sq ft, recorded as 16 shatak in RS Dag No. 271, Khatian No. 74, and in recent settlement record the same has been recorded in Dag No. 273, Khatian No. 602 within Mouza Pakuria, PS Domjur, District Howrah. As per the agreement dated 4-2-1992, the defendant (Mishrilal Mondal) agreed to sell the land at the rate of Rs 15,000 per cottah in favour of the plaintiff (Ganesh Chandra Naskar), and received Rs 60,000 as earnest money, and rest of the consideration was agreed to be paid at the time of the execution of sale deed. It was also stipulated in the agreement that, if entire area comes out as 10 cottahs, the lump sum consideration would be Rs 1,50,000. According to the plaintiff, measurements were made on 7-3-1992, by surveyors in the presence of the parties, and it was found that the area of land was 8 cottahs 14 chitak 24 sq ft, as such amount of consideration was Rs 1,33,125 i.e. @ Rs 15,000 per cottah. It is pleaded in the suit that the plaintiff was/is always ready and willing to pay the balance amount of Rs 73,125 to get the sale deed executed, but the defendant declined to execute the same. On this, the plaintiff gave notice to the defendant to execute the sale deed but he questioned the correctness of the measurements, and offered to pay back Rs 60,000 accepted by him as earnest money. Consequently, the suit for specific performance, possession and injunction was filed by the plaintiff.

    4. The original defendant contested the suit and filed his written statement. It appears that during the pendency of the suit due to the death of the original defendant his heirs were substituted. The case of the appellants as contained in amended written statement is that Mishrilal Mondal had undivided share in the property and he was owner in respect of only 16½ shataks of the land out of 33 shataks of Dag No. 271.

    5. The trial court framed issues, and after recording evidence of the parties disposed of the suit directing the defendant to refund the earnest money of Rs 60,000 to the plaintiff. The said judgment and decree dated 29-6-2002, passed by the Civil Judge (Senior Division), 3rd Court, Howrah, was challenged by the plaintiff who filed Title Appeal No. 139 of 2002. The same, after hearing the parties, was allowed, and it was directed by the first appellate court that the defendants shall execute sale deed after accepting balance amount of Rs 73,125 from the plaintiff.

    6. The judgment and decree dated 22-12-2003, passed in Title Appeal No. 139 of 2002 was challenged by the defendants in Second Appeal No. 430 of 2004, and the High Court passed impugned judgment 2013 SCC OnLine Cal 22899, (2013) 3 Cal LJ 546, modifying the decree passed by the first appellate court. It is directed by the High Court that the decree of specific performance of contract shall stand affirmed in respect of the agreement dated 4-2-1992, but not on the basis of measurements taken by PW 2. The High Court remanded the matter to the first appellate court, with further direction that the defendant shall be allowed to apply for appointment of a Commissioner for doing the survey of the land to be transferred. It is also clarified by the High Court that if no such application is moved the suit shall stand decreed, as per the measurements made by PW 2. Unsatisfied with the modified decree, passed by the High Court, the defendants are before us, in this appeal, through special leave.

    7. A copy of the agreement between the plaintiff Ganesh Chandra Naskar and the original defendant Mishrilal Mondal (since dead) is annexed as Annexure P-8 with affidavit dated 16-9-2014, filed by Dilip Mondal (Appellant 2), which discloses that Mishrilal Mondal agreed to sell 16 shataks or 10 cottahs of land mentioned in the schedule to the plaintiff, on payment of Rs 15,000 per cottah which was the market rate. It is also mentioned in the agreement that Mishrilal Mondal (the original defendant) accepted Rs 60,000 as part-payment. The terms and conditions mentioned in the agreement contains the following relevant stipulation:

    “3. After executing this advance agreement, while measuring the land if it is found that the total area of the land which will be sold is less than 10 cottahs as mentioned in the schedule below, you will pay the balance amount which will be calculated for the less area of land @ Rs 15,000 and I along with my heirs and representatives shall remain bound to register the sale deed in your favour for the land as mentioned in the schedule below.”

    8. The description of the schedule property for which advance is taken, gives following details at the end of the terms mentioned in the agreement (Annexure P-8):

    “description of schedule property for which advances taken
    Under District Howrah, District Registrar Office, Howrah, Sub-Registry Office, Domjur, PS Domjur and within Mouza Pakura mentioned in old ‘parcha’ (record) in Khatian No. 177 (one hundred seventy-seven) in Dag No. 271 (two hundred seventy-one), high land measuring 33 (thirty-three) shataks under permanent tenancy right, half portion from the western side which is according to Revisional Settlement's ‘parcha’ (record) in Khatian No. 746 (seven hundred forty-six), Dag No. 271 (two hundred seventy-one) and in parcha (record) of present Revisional Settlement it is recorded in Khatian No. 602 (six hundred two), Dag No. 273 (two hundred seventy-three) under permanent tenancy right as high land measuring 16 (sixteen) shataks.”

    9. In the second paragraph of the agreement, following declaration is made by the original defendant:

    “I am the absolute owner and possessor of the said property. Besides me, there is no co-sharer or heir. I have never transferred or joint liability with any person. It is absolutely free from all sorts of liability and encumbrances. If any type of liability reveals, you will get time till it is made free from liability and encumbrances and in this condition I and my successors are bound to execute the deed.”

    10. Admittedly, Appellants 1 to 4 are sons, Appellant 5 is the widow and Appellant 6 is the daughter of Mishrilal Mondal (the original defendant). Appellant 8 and Appellant 9 are son and daughter of Netai Mondal (brother of Mishrilal Mondal), Appellant 10 is the wife of Basudev Nasakar and Appellant 11 is the wife of Natabar Mondal, the relatives of the original defendant.

    11. On behalf of the respondent-plaintiff, copy of challan depositing Rs 73,125 on 13-1-2004/16-1-2004 with the civil court, in favour of the appellants, is annexed with the counter-affidavit.

    12. Though the appellants have pleaded that Mishrilal Mondal was not the absolute owner of the land, however, the said plea appears to have not been accepted by none of the courts below. Moreover, the legal heirs of the original defendant are not only bound by the agreement executed by him, but also by the pleas taken by the original defendant in his written statement before the trial court.

    13. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, we are not inclined to interfere with the findings affirmed by the High Court. On consideration of the submissions of the rival parties in the present appeal the only point before us is whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, a decree of specific performance of agreement of sale should have been passed, or the decree of refund of part consideration received by the defendant, with interest, would have served the ends of justice.

    14. Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 gives discretion to the court, and provides that the court is not bound to grant relief of specific performance merely because it is lawful to do so. It further provides that the discretion is not to be exercised arbitrarily but guided by judicial principles. Sub-section (2) of Section 20 enumerates three conditions when discretion is not to be exercised to grant decree of specific performance:

    “20. (2)(a) where the terms of the contract or the conduct of the parties at the time of entering into the contract or the other circumstances under which the contract was entered into are such that the contract, though not voidable, gives the plaintiff an unfair advantage over the defendant; or
    (b) where the performance of the contract would involve some hardship on the defendant which he did not foresee, whereas its non-performance would involve no such hardship on the plaintiff;
    (c) where the defendant entered into the contract under circumstances which though not rendering the contract voidable, makes it inequitable to enforce specific performance.”

    15. Explanation 1 to sub-section (2) provides that mere inadequacy of consideration shall not be deemed to be an unfair advantage within the meaning of clause (a) or hardship within the meaning of clause (b). Explanation 2 provides that the question whether the performance of a contract when involved hardship on the defendant within the meaning of clause (b) shall, except in cases where the hardship has resulted from any act of the plaintiff subsequent in the contract, be determined with reference to the circumstances accepting at the time of contract. Sub-section (3) provides that the court may properly exercise discretion to decree specific performance in any case where the plaintiff has done substantial acts or suffered losses in consequence of a contract capable of specific performance.

    16. In the present case, it appears that possession was not given to the plaintiff at the time of execution of the agreement, nor the area of land agreed to be sold was clear, as such, it cannot be said that the plaintiff has done substantial acts or suffered losses due to expenditure in constructions, etc., in consequence of a contract capable of specific performance. The direction given by the High Court in the impugned order 2013 SCC OnLine Cal 22899, (2013) 3 Cal LJ 546 shows that the measurements of land actually agreed to be sold, are not final.

    17. In the above facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the view that instead of affirming the decree of specific performance as modified by the High Court, it will be equitable, just and proper to direct the appellants to pay back the amount of Rs 60,000 accepted by the original defendant with interest @ 18% p.a. to the respondent-plaintiff from 4-2-1992 till date, within a period of three months from today, failing which this appeal shall stand dismissed. We order accordingly. The amount of Rs 73,125 deposited by the plaintiff may also be withdrawn by him after the appellants pay or deposit the sum in favour of the plaintiff as directed above. The appeal stands disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hemanta Mondal And Others v. Ganesh Chandra Naskar .
    (Sep 23, 2015)