AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Sections 11(6) and 11(8) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 was filed by the Petitioners seeking the appointment of an independent, impartial, and qualified Arbitrator. The sole Arbitrator initially appointed by the Respondent made disclosures regarding his appointments in multiple arbitration matters involving the Respondent and related entities. The Petitioner raised concerns about the Arbitrator’s independence and impartiality based on these disclosures and subsequent contradictory statements made by the Arbitrator. The Court examined these facts and the declarations made by the Arbitrator to determine whether the Arbitrator was disqualified from continuing in the matter.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sole Arbitrator’s failure to fully and accurately disclose his appointments in arbitration matters involving the Respondent and related entities gives rise to justifiable doubts as to his independence and impartiality under Section 12(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended.
  2. Whether the conduct of the Arbitrator in making misleading declarations amounts to de jure disqualification under Section 14(1)(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
  3. Whether the Court should terminate the mandate of the sole Arbitrator and appoint a new Arbitrator in light of the above findings.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The sole Arbitrator gave a misleading declaration that he was presiding over 20 arbitration matters involving “group companies” instead of disclosing that he was appointed in 20 matters directly involving the Respondent, Religare Finvest Limited.
  • The Arbitrator later revealed he was presiding over 27 matters related to the Respondent, which was withheld initially.
  • Such conduct defeats the purpose of the amended Section 12 and the Fifth Schedule of the Act, which require full disclosure to avoid justifiable doubts regarding independence and impartiality.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The Arbitrator made the required disclosures by way of the letter in the Sixth Schedule format.
  • The Petitioner could challenge the Arbitrator under Section 13 of the Act if dissatisfaction persisted.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the declarations made by the sole Arbitrator in the format prescribed by the Sixth Schedule and compared them with the facts known from the Arbitrator’s own statements. The Court found that the Arbitrator deliberately withheld material information regarding his appointments in arbitration matters directly involving the Respondent. The declarations that he was presiding over matters involving “group companies” rather than the Respondent itself were misleading. Further, the Arbitrator’s disclosure that he was presiding over 27 matters related to the Respondent was only made after the Petitioner’s inquiry and was inconsistent with his earlier statements.

The Court referred to the amended Section 12(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which mandates disclosure of any relationship or interest that could give rise to justifiable doubts as to independence or impartiality, guided by the grounds enumerated in the Fifth Schedule. Clauses 22 and 24 of the Fifth Schedule were directly attracted in this case, as the Arbitrator had been appointed multiple times by the Respondent and was presiding over related arbitration matters.

The Court held that such misleading conduct was unbecoming of an Arbitrator expected to maintain impartiality and independence. This conduct defeated the legislative purpose of ensuring transparency and trust in arbitration proceedings. Consequently, the Court concluded that the Arbitrator was de jure disqualified under Section 14(1)(a) of the Act.

Holding and Implications

The Court terminated the mandate of the sole Arbitrator and appointed Justice P.K. Bhasin, a former Judge of the Delhi High Court, as the new sole Arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the parties.

The arbitration shall proceed under the aegis of the Delhi International Arbitration Centre (DIAC) and comply with the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended. The fees of the newly appointed Arbitrator will be governed by the Delhi High Court Arbitration Centre (Arbitrators' Fees) Rules.

This decision directly affects the parties by removing the existing Arbitrator for lack of impartiality and appointing a new Arbitrator to ensure a fair arbitration process. The Court did not establish any new precedent but applied the amended statutory provisions to uphold the standards of independence and impartiality in arbitration.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Dream Valley Farms Private Limited & Anr. Petitioners v. Religare Finvest Limited & Ors. S

    S. Muralidhar, J.

    IA No. 12845/2016 (for exemption)

    1. Exemption allowed subject to all just exceptions.

    Arb.P 635/2016

    2. This is a petition under Section 11(6) and (8) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (‘Act’) filed by the Petitioners seeking the appointment of an independent impartial and qualified Arbitrator.

    3. Notice. Mr. Niraj Singh, learned counsel accepts notice on behalf of the Respondents. Although learned counsel for the Respondents sought time for filing a reply, the Court does not consider it necessary for the reason that the facts brought to the notice of the Court, as a result of the statements of the Arbitrator himself, are self evident and beyond contest.

    4. One of the positive features of the amendments made to the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (‘Act’) with effect from 23rd October, 2015 is the re-casting of Sections 12 and 13 of the Act. section 12(1) now makes it mandatory for a person who is approached in connection with his possible appointment as an Arbitrator to disclose in writing any circumstances

    “(a) such as the existence either direct or indirect, of any past or present relationship with or interest in any of the parties or in relation to the subject matter in dispute, whether financial, business, professional or other kind, which is likely to give rise to justifiable doubts as to his independence or impartiality”.

    5. Explanation I to section 12(1) states that “the grounds stated in the Fifth Schedule shall guide in determining whether circumstances exist which give rise to justifiable doubts as to the independence or impartiality of an arbitrator.”

    6. Turning to the Fifth Schedule, it is seen that it begins with the sentence “the following grounds give rise to justifiable doubts as to the independence or impartiality of arbitrators.” Clauses 22 and 24 thereof read as under:

    “22. The arbitrator has within the past three years been appointed as arbitrator on two or more occasions by one of the parties or an affiliate of one of the parties.

    24. The arbitrator currently serves, or has served within the past three years, as arbitrator in another arbitration on a related issue involving one of the parties or an affiliate of one of the parties.”

    7. The only exception to the above circumstances is Explanation 3 to the Fifth Schedule which states that “it may be the practice in certain specific kinds of arbitration, such as maritime or commodities arbitration, to draw arbitrators from a small, specialised pool.” It may be noted straightway that the present dispute between the parties is about the repayment of a loan which certainly is not in the category of “maritime or commodities arbitration” requiring arbitrators from “a small, specialized pool”.

    8. At the very beginning, at the time of entering upon reference some time in June 2016, the sole Arbitrator, in the present case wrote to the Petitioner informing it of his appointment as such and inter alia made the following declaration:

    “I have accepted my appointment as sole Arbitrator and have entered upon the matter. I am not aware of my circumstance nor have any interest that prevents me from arbitrating this matter. As per the term of Agreement the venue of Arbitration is at Delhi.”

    9. Thereafter, on 21st June, 2016 the Petitioner wrote to the sole Arbitrator drawing his attention to Section 12 of the Act and requested him to provide a declaration in the following terms:

    “(i) In how many cases has your goodself been previously appointed/nominated as an Arbitrator (either sole or nominee) of/by Religare Finvest Limited;

    (ii) The present status of such previous cases, whether pending or decided;

    (iii) In case of decided cases, to supply/provide an authenticated copies of the Awards so rendered;

    (iv) Has your goodself previously appeared as a counsel/lawyer in any Court or Forum on behalf of the Religare Finvest Limited. If so, kindly provide the details thereof;

    (v) Has your goodself at any point of time given written or oral opinion or legal advise to Religare Finvest Limited. If so, to kindly provide the details thereof;

    (vi) Any existence either direct or indirect, of any past or present relationship with or in interest in Religare Finvest Limited or in relation to the subject matter in dispute, whether financial, business, professional or other kind;”

    10. The Petitioner also drew the attention of the sole Arbitrator to the Fifth Schedule to the Act as amended with effect from 23 October, 2015.

    11. By his letter dated 21 July 2016 addressed to learned counsel for the Petitioners, the sole Arbitrator made the following disclosure in the format of the Sixth Schedule where inter alia he stated as under:

    NUMBER OF ON-GOING ARBITRATIONS:The arbitrator is presently presiding over in 20 arbitrations out of which majority forms part of dispute in connection with group companies and majority of the matter are at the stage of appearance and completion of pleadings.CIRCUMSTANCES DISCLOSING ANY PAST OR PRESENT RELATIONSHIP WITH OR INTEREST IN ANY OF THE PARTIES OR IN RELATION TO THE SUBJECT MATTER IN DISPUTE, WHETHER FINANCIAL, BUSINESS, PROFESSIONAL OR OTHER KIND, WHICH IS LIKELY TO GIVE RISE TO JUSTIFIABLE DOUBTS AS TO YOUR INDEPENDENCE.Ground 22 of the Fifth Schedule of 2015 Ordinance: The Arbitrator has within the past three years never been appointed as arbitrator by one of the parties or an affiliate of one of the parties. I have been appointed as arbitrator by the Claimant very recently and earlier not acted as an arbitrator in any of the matter in the past three years. Ground 24 of the Fifth Schedule of 2015 Ordinance: The arbitrator currently serves, but not served within the past three years, as an arbitrator in another arbitration on a related issue involving one of the parties or an affiliate of one of the parties. I am not acting as an arbitrator in any of the matters filed by the Claimant on a related issue on or before June 2016.

    12. The sole Arbitrator further stated that “I further disclose that I do not fall within any of the grounds/circumstances contemplated under the Seventh Schedule (as referred in Section 12(5) of the Act) thereby imposing a bar on my appointment/acting as Arbitrator in the present matter.”

    13. On 1 August, 2016 the Petitioner then addressed another letter enquiring whether by virtue of the above disclosure whether any of the 20 arbitrations which were to be considering the disputes “in connection with the group companies”, any of them related to the Respondent herein i.e, Religare Finvest Limited.

    14. Thereafter proceedings took place before the sole Arbitrator on 20th August, 2016 when he passed an order referring to the fact that the Petitioner had sent a letter dated 1 August 2016. In response thereto, in para 2 of the said order of the sole Arbitrator stated as under:

    “Although the relationship is disclosed by way of earlier letter however, it is once again clarified that I have been appointed as Sole Arbitrator on 4 June 2016 by Religare Finvest Limited in 20 matters (including the present matter). I am presently presiding in 27 arbitration matters related to Religare Finvest Limited, and majority of which are at initial stage for completion of pleadings. No judgment/award have yet been passed in any of the matters. I have never been the Arbitrator for the claimant company prior to 4 June 2016.”

    15. In the very next paragraph the Arbitrator stated as under:

    ï have no past relationship with Claimant, i.e, Religare Finvest Limited or counsel for the Claimant prior to 4 June 2016.”

    16. It is plain to the Court that the sole Arbitrator misled the Petitioner when making a declaration in the form in Schedule 6 on 21 July 2016 that he was an arbitrator in 20 matters involving ‘group companies’ when in fact he knew that he had been appointed as a sole arbitrator by the Respondent i.e Religare Finvest Limited in 20 matters. Further, subsequently in the impugned order dated 20 August, 2016 the Arbitrator stated that “I am presently presiding in 27 arbitration matters relating to Religare Finvest Limited ………”

    17. The above conduct of the Arbitrator in withholding at the very outset the information that he was an Arbitrator in 20 matters of the Respondent itself and instead giving a false declaration that he was involved in 20 arbitration matters involving ‘group companies’ is totally unacceptable. To compund this is his further revelation in the proceedings of 20 August 2016 that he was in fact presiding over 27 arbitration matters relating to this very Respondent i.e, Religare Finvest Limited. This conduct of the Arbitrator is unbecoming and does not behove an Arbitrator who is expected to be impartial and independent.

    18. The above misleading declaration defeats the very purpose of the amended Act which re-casts section 12(1) and includes the Fifth Schedule which sets out the grounds that give rise to justifiable doubts as to the independence or impartiality of the arbitrator. Two of the said grounds as set out at Item Nos. 22 and 24 (extracted hereinabove) are straightaway attracted in the facts and circumstances of the case and give rise to a justifiable doubts about the independence and impartiality of the sole Arbitrator appointed by the Respondent.

    19. It was urged by learned counsel for the Respondent that with the above declaration having been made by the sole Arbitrator, it is now open to the Petitioner to challenge the Arbitrator under Section 13 of the Act and thereafter seek appropriate reliefs.

    20. While in the normal course, that would be one option, in the present case not only are Clauses 22 and 24 of the Fifth Schedule attracted giving rise to justifiable doubts as to the independence and impartiality of the Arbitrator, but the conduct of the Arbitrator in seeking to mislead the Petitioner and suppress in the first instance the fact of his being a presiding Arbitrator in 27 arbitration matters relating to the Respondent smacks of dishonesty that is unbecoming of an Arbitrator.

    21. The Court is satisfied that the for the purposes of Section 14(1)(a) of the Act the Arbitrator becomes de jure disqualified from continuing as an arbitrator. His mandate is accordingly terminated.

    22. The Court appoints Justice P.K Bhasin (Mobile No. 9871300032), a former Judge of this Court as a sole Arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the parties including theri claims and counter-claims of the parties. The arbitration shall take place under the aegis of the Delhi International Arbitration Centre (‘DIAC’). The fees of the learned Arbitrator will be in terms of the Delhi High Court Arbitration Centre (Arbitrators' Fees) Rules. The requirements of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended with effect from 23 October, 2015 shall be complied with.

    23. The petition is disposed of in the above terms. A copy of this order be communicated to the learned Arbitrator as well as Additional Coordinator, DIAC forthwith

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dream Valley Farms Private Limited & Anr. Petitioners v. Religare Finvest Limited & Ors. S
    (Oct 19, 2016)