Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 114 A EVIDENCE ACT
  • Sections 302 and 392 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • Sections 302 and 392 of IPC. P.W.13
  • Section.114, illu. (a), Evidence Act,
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 174 Cr.P.C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 114 A EVIDENCE ACT
  • Sections 302 and 392 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • Sections 302 and 392 of IPC. P.W.13
  • Section.114, illu. (a), Evidence Act,
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 174 Cr.P.C.
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Criminal Appeal (Crl.A.No.257 of 2013) — V. Bharathidasan, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants were accused in Sessions Case No.103 of 2012 before the Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tirupur, charged under Sections 302 and 392 of the Indian Penal Code. The Trial Court, by judgment dated 19.02.2013, convicted both accused under Sections 302 and 392 IPC and sentenced each to life imprisonment with a fine for the Section 302 conviction (in default six months rigorous imprisonment) and 10 years rigorous imprisonment with a fine for the Section 392 conviction (in default six months rigorous imprisonment). The accused appealed against the conviction and sentence.

Factual matrix (as presented by prosecution): the deceased, Saraswathi (about 70 years old), was found dead in a well on 27.04.2011 by her son (P.W.1). He noticed injuries to her forehead, jaw and knee and observed that a gold chain (5 sovereigns) belonging to the deceased was missing. P.W.1 lodged a complaint (Ex.P1). Police registered a report under Section 174 Cr.P.C., investigated, and later altered the registration to offences under Sections 302 and 392 IPC. During investigation, there was an extra-judicial confession by the second accused to P.W.5, voluntary confession statements by both accused (recorded by police as Ex.P22 and Ex.P24 in part), and recoveries including money, an iron rod (M.O.2), and a gold chain (M.O.1) which was found pledged in a finance company. A post-mortem (Ex.P8) detailed external abrasions/contusions and internal congestive changes. Fourteen prosecution witnesses were examined, 28 documents and 5 material objects marked. The accused denied charges under Section 313 Cr.P.C., produced no witnesses and no defence documents. The Trial Court convicted; the present judgment is the appellate court's decision on that conviction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a presumption of guilt under Illustration (a) to Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act could be drawn against the accused on the basis of recovery of the deceased's ornament (gold chain) soon after the murder.
  2. Whether the circumstantial evidence relied upon by the prosecution — including testimony that the accused were seen near the scene, extra‑judicial/voluntary confessions, and the recovery/pledging of the chain — cumulatively proved the accused's guilt for offences punishable under Sections 392 and 302 IPC beyond reasonable doubt.
  3. Whether the Trial Court's conviction and sentence under Sections 302 and 392 IPC should be upheld on appeal in light of the appellants' contentions regarding reliability of last-seen evidence, identification of M.O.1, and timing of death.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The prosecution failed to prove the circumstances relied upon with clinching evidence; the case rests on weak circumstantial material.
  • The evidence of P.W.10 — allegedly last seeing the accused and the deceased together near the well — is not reliable and should not be believed.
  • The recovery and identification of M.O.1 (the gold chain) was not properly established.
  • The body of the deceased was floating in the well, indicating the death occurred much earlier than the time alleged by prosecution; in the absence of corroborative materials, conviction based mainly on the recovery of the chain is improper.

Respondent (State) Arguments

  • The prosecution proved the circumstances clinchingly, including recoveries made pursuant to disclosure statements of the accused.
  • Recovery of M.O.1 (the deceased's gold chain) on the basis of disclosure statements of the accused is sufficient, when read with other circumstances, to convict the accused under Sections 392 and 302 IPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Tulsiram Kanu v. The State, A.I.R. 1954 S.C. 1 Explains the operation of the presumption under Illustration (a) to Section 114 Evidence Act: a presumption of guilt from possession of the deceased's ornaments may be drawn if the items are found in a person's possession soon after the murder; the time‑factor is important (a long interval may defeat the presumption). The Court relied on this principle to consider whether the pledge of the deceased's chain by A‑1 within two days of the occurrence justified drawing the inference under Section 114(a) that the accused committed the crime.
Ronny alias Ronald James Alwaris & Others v. State of Maharashtra, (1998) 3 SCC 626 Affirms that recovery of articles belonging to victims from accused soon after robbery/murder, unexplained by the accused, attracts the presumption under Illustration (a) to Section 114 and may lead to the irresistible conclusion that the accused committed the crimes forming the same transaction. The Court applied the reasoning to hold that, because the gold chain of the deceased was pledged by A‑1 within two days and its possession remained unexplained, the presumption under Section 114(a) was attracted and supported conviction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the prosecution case as one primarily dependent on circumstantial evidence and identified the principal circumstances relied upon by the prosecution:

  1. Presence of both accused near the scene of occurrence at about 9:15 p.m., supported by P.W.10's testimony that the accused were consuming liquor near the well. The Court noted that P.W.10's evidence was not shaken in cross-examination.
  2. Recovery of jewels and money pursuant to disclosure statements: the prosecution produced evidence that the first accused (A‑1) pledged the deceased's gold chain (M.O.1) at Manapuram Gold Finance on 29.04.2011 (two days after the occurrence), obtaining Rs.70,000 and a receipt (documentary evidence). The pledging was corroborated by the finance company manager (P.W.9) and identification of the chain by P.W.8 (daughter‑in‑law).
  3. Extra‑judicial and voluntary confessions: the second accused made an extra‑judicial confession to P.W.5, and both accused gave voluntary statements to police in which disclosures led to recovery of money and other articles (seizure mahazars Ex.P21, Ex.P25, Ex.P26 etc.).

The Court posed the central legal question whether a presumption of guilt under Illustration (a) to Section 114, Evidence Act, could be raised on the basis of the recoveries. It examined binding precedents (Tulsiram Kanu and Ronny) emphasizing the importance of the time interval between the occurrence and the accused's possession of the deceased's articles. Applying those authorities, the Court found that the gold chain was pledged by A‑1 within two days of the occurrence, that documentary records and witness evidence tied the pledged chain to the accused, and that the accused offered no plausible explanation for possession of the chain.

The Court therefore held that the presumption under Section 114(a) was properly attracted. Although the presumption is rebuttable, the Court found it remained unrebutted on the record. Coupled with the other circumstantial elements (presence near the scene, confessions and related recoveries, identification of the jewel), the Court concluded that the cumulative evidence established the guilt of the accused for the offences charged.

The Court did not accept the appellants' contention about the timing of death (based on the body floating) or the alleged insufficiency of corroborating materials; instead, it relied on the proximity in time of recovery and the absence of explanation to sustain the presumption and conviction.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is DISMISSED. The conviction and sentence recorded by the Trial Court in S.C. No.103 of 2012 (convictions under Sections 302 and 392 IPC with the respective sentences as earlier imposed) are confirmed.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the appellants remain convicted and must serve the sentences imposed by the Trial Court. The appellate court directed that, if the appellants are not in custody, the Trial Court should take steps to secure them and commit them to prison to serve the sentences.
  • The Court relied on established principles (as in Tulsiram and Ronny) about drawing a presumption under Illustration (a) to Section 114 Evidence Act when victim's articles are found in accused's possession soon after the offence; the decision applies those precedents to the facts of this case but does not purport to lay down new law or an expanded rule beyond the cited authorities.

This summary is prepared exclusively from the provided judgment text and does not include information beyond that opinion.

    R.Navaneetha Krishnan v. Inspector of Police

    (Judgement of the Court was delivered by V.Bharathidasan, J.) The appellants in this appeal are the accused in Sessions Case No.103 of 2012, on the file of the learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tirupur. They stood charged for offences punishable under Sections 302 and 392 of the Indian Penal Code. The Trial Court, by judgement dated 19.02.2013, convicted the appellants/accused both under Sections 302 and 392 of the Indian Penal Code, and sentenced them to undergo life imprisonment and also imposed a fine of Rs.2000/- each, in default, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for six months for the offence under Section 302 of IPC, and to undergo 10 years rigours imprisonment and also imposed a fine of Rs.1500/- each, in default, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for six months for the offence under Section 392 of IPC. Challenging the above said conviction and sentence, the appellants/accused have filed this present appeal.

    2. The case of the prosecution, in brief, is as follows:

    (i) The deceased one Saraswathi, mother of P.Ws.1 and 6, was aged about 70 years. At the time of occurrence, she was residing alone at Pannaiyar Thottam, Chettipalayam, and P.Ws.1 and 6 were living separately in the same village. On 26.04.2011, P.W.1 went to the house of the deceased, spent half an hour with her and then left her house. Again on 27.04.2011, at about 6.30 am., he went to the house of the deceased but she was not present in the house. So, P.W.1 searched for the deceased and found her chappel near a well. On suspicion, he looked into the well and found the body of his mother inside the well, in between the two pipes attached to pump sets. Immediately, he informed his brother P.W.6 and others then lifted the dead body out of the well and found injuries on her forehead, jaw and knee. P.W.1 also found that 5 sovereign of gold chain belonged to the deceased was missing. Thereafter, he lodged a complaint Ex.P1 before the respondent police at about 12.00 pm.

    (ii) P.W.12, Special Sub Inspector of Police, attached to the Mangalam Police Station, received the compliant and registered a case in Crime No.1288 of 2012 under Section 174 Cr.P.C. and sent the FIR Ex.P11 to the higher officials and the Judicial Magistrate Court. After registering the case, P.W.12 visited the scene of occurrence and prepared observation Mahazar Ex.P3 and drew rough sketch Ex.P12 in the presence of witnesses. He conducted inquest over the dead body in the presence of panchayatars. He examined P.Ws.1 to 3 and other witnesses and recorded their statements. Thereafter, he sent the dead body to the hospital for post-mortem through P.W.13, Head Constable. During the investigation of the case, he found that it is a case of murder and altered the case into one under Sections 302 and 392 IPC and sent the altered report, Ex.P14, to the Judicial Magistrate Court. Then, P.W.14, the Inspector of Police, took up the investigation.

    (iii) In the meantime, the second accused appeared before P.W.5, a resident of Chettipalayam, and gave extra-judicial confession before him. In the confession statement, the second accused stated that he, along with the first accused, murdered the deceased, stolen the gold chain belonged to the deceased, pledged the jewels and the first accused gave Rs.20,000/- to him. P.W.5, after recording such confession, produced the second accused before the Inspector of Police along with his report Ex.P2. P.W.14 arrested the second accused and recorded his voluntary confession statement. The admissible portion of the said statement is Ex.P24. Based on the disclosure statement, P.W.14 seized Rs.17,000/- M.O.3(seris), under Ex.P21. He arrested the first accused at Palladam Bus Stand, near Aavin, and on such arrest, the first accused voluntarily gave a confession statement Ex.P22, which was recorded in the presence of witnesses and the first accused also submitted Rs.17,000/- M.O.3 and the same was recovered under Ex.P21 Mahazar. Thereafter, based on the disclosure statement of the accused, P.W.14 recovered a sum of Rs.35,000/- and iron rod M.O.2 from his house under Ex.P25 seizure mahazar. Thereafter, the first accused identified the finance company, where he pledged the jewel and P.W.14 seized the gold chain M.O.1 under Ex.P26 in the presence of witnesses from the finance company.

    (iv) In the meantime, P.W.11, Doctor, working in Thiruppur Government Hospital, conducted post-mortem on the dead body and he found the following injuries. External Injuries:

    1) 5 cm x 1 cm red coloured abrasion over right side of the forehead. 5 cm above the right eye (Lateral 1/3).

    2) 3 cm x 1.5 cm abrasion over right cheek (Red in colour).

    3) 3 cm x 1 cm red coloured abrasion over right side of upper lip, 1 cm above lip margin.

    4) 2cm x 1 cm re coloured abrasion in middle part of right side of the nose.

    5) 3 cm x 1.5 cm x 0.2 cm contusion over right side of mandible 3 cm latero inferior to angle of mouth. contusion red in colour. Internal Examination: Thorax and neck No fracture of ribs. Heard congested. 15 ml of clothed blood in chamber both ling congested. On pressure, blood stained frothy discharge present in cut section. Hyoid bone intact. Abdomen: The stomach contain about 700 gm of partially digested food particle. Liver, spleen and kidney congested.Small intestine time distended with Gas. Uterus normal in size and cavity empty. Head: a subscalpad contusion of 10 cm x 7 cm over left side of head in temperoparietal region. It situated above the laft ear. 10 cm from centre of head in parietal region. 10 cm from centre of occipital region. Both intact. Membrane intact. Brain congested. He has given post morterm certificate Ex.P8. Subsequently, P.W.14 examined the witnesses and recorded their statements. After completing the investigation, he filed a charge sheet for the offence under sections 302 and 392 of ipc against the accused.

    3. Based on the above materials, the Trial Court framed charges as detailed above and the accused denied the same as false. In order to prove the case of prosecution, as many as 14 witnesses were examined and 28 documents and 5 material objects were marked.

    4. In this case, P.W.1 is son of the deceased. He found the dead body of the deceased inside the well and also given the complainant Ex.P1. P.W.2-Shanmugasundaram, is a resident of Chettipalayam Village and he has also seen the dead body in the well. P.W.3 is also a resident of Chettipalayam Village and he saw the dead body in the well and found the chappels of the deceased near the well. P.W.5 is another resident of Chettipalayam Village and he know both A-2 and the deceased. According to him, the second accused appeared before him and gave extra-judicial confession. P.W.6 is the another son of the deceased and brother of P.W.1 and he is also a friend of first accused. According to him, on 26.04.2011 at about 7.00 pm., he saw both the accused consuming liquor and he also joined with them. Thereafter, they took the bike of P.W.6 for purchasing liquor. Once again, he consumed liquor with them and thereafter the accused left for home. P.W.7 is Mahazar witness. P.W.8 is the wife of P.W.1 and daughter-in-law of the deceased. She identified M.O.1 chain, worn the deceased. P.W.9 is the Assistant Branch Manager, working in Mallapuram Gold Finance and Leasing limited. He has spoken about the pledging of jewel (M.O.1) by A-1 on 29.04.2011, and also issuance of receipt for the same. P.W.10 is living near the house of the deceased. He saw the accused taking brandy bottles near the well and after some time both accused leaving place. P.W.11 is the Doctor, who conducted post mortem and issued post mortem certificate Ex.P8. P.W.12, the Special Sub Inspector of Police, has spoken about registration of case on the basis of the complaint given by P.W.1, preparation of observation mahazar and rough sketch and conducting preliminary investigation and alteration of FIR into Sections 302 and 392 of IPC. P.W.13 is the Head Constable. He has spoken about taking the dead body of the deceased to the hospital for post-mortem. P.W.14 Is the investigation officer, who investigated the case and filed the charge sheet for the offence under sections 302 and 392 of ipc against the accused.

    5. When the above incriminating materials were put to the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C., they denied the same as false. The accused did not examine any witness and no document was marked on their side.

    6. Having considered all the above, the Trial Court convicted the accused for the offences as stated in the first paragraph of this judgement. Challenging the above conviction and sentence, the accused are before this Court.

    7. We have heard Mr.P.M.Duraiswamy, learned counsel for the appellants and Mr.Maharaja, learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the State and we have also perused the records carefully.

    8. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants would submit that the prosecution did not prove the circumstances relied on by them with clinching evidence. The evidence of P.W.10, said to have last seen the accused and deceased together, cannot be believed, and recovery of M.O.1 chain was also not properly identified. Hence, the accused cannot be found guilty for the offence under Section 392 of IPC and consequently under Section 302 IPC. He further submitted that the body of the deceased was floating in the well and hence the occurrence should have taken place much earlier than the time stated by the prosecution. Hence, in the absence of any other corroborating materials, the Court below, has wrongly convicted the accused based on the recovery of chain alone.

    9. Per contra, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the State would submit that the prosecution has proved all the circumstances clinchingly and M.O.1 chain belonged to the deceased was recovered on the basis of the disclosure statement of A-1, which alone is sufficient to noted the accused guilty under Sections 392 and 302 IPC.

    10. It is a case of circumstantial evidence and the prosecution has strongly relied upon three main circumstances. The first and the foremost circumstances is that both the accused were found near the scene of occurrence at about 9.15 p.m. P.W.10 is a resident of Chettipalayam Village and residing near the well where the dead body was found. PW10 has deposed that he found the accused consuming liquor near the well. It is the case of prosecution that A-2 is the relative of the deceased and A-1 and A-2, are close friends and they know the deceased very well. The evidence of P.W.10 is not, in any way, shattered by way of cross examination.

    11. The next important circumstance is recovery of jewels. Based on the disclosure statement of A-1 and A-2, gold chain M.O.1 and money were recovered. P.W.9, who is the Assistant Branch Manager of Manapuram Gold Finance and Leasing Limited, in his evidence has stated that on 29.04.2011, i.e., two days after the occurrence, the first accused came to their office and pledged M.O.1 gold chain and received a sum of Rs.70,000/- and he issued a receipt for the same. The above said gold chain and receipt were recovered from the finance company under Ex.P.5. At the time of pledging the jewel, A-1 has given 'voter I.D. card' which, was marked as Ex.P.6, and the same was also recovered from the above finance company. Hence, it is clearly established that A-1 alone had pledged the jewel and the said jewel was also identified by P.W.8, the daughter-in-law of the deceased.

    12. The question now remains to be decided is whether a presumption of guilt could be drawn against the accused on the basis of recovery made based on his disclosure statement. The Hon'ble Supreme Court Judgment in TULSIRAM KANU Vs. THE STATE reported in A.I.R. 1954 S.C. 1, has held as follows:- The presumption permitted to be drawn under Section.114, illu. (a), Evidence Act, has to be read along with the important time factor. If ornaments or things of the deceased are found in the possession of a person soon after the murder, a presumption of guilty may be permitted. But, if several months expire in the interval, the presumption may not be permitted to be drawn having regard to the circumstance of the case. In yet another judgment, reported in RONNY ALIAS RONALD JAMES ALWARIS AND OTHERS Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA, [(1998) 3 SCC 626], the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as follows: Apropos the recovery of articles belonging to the Ohol family from the possession of the appellants soon after the robbery and the murder of the deceased.(Mr.Mohan Ohal, Mrs. Ruhi Ohol and Mr.Rohan Ohol) which possession has remained unexplained by the appellants, the presumption under Illustration (a) of Section 114 of the Evidence Act will be attracted. It needs to discussion to conclude that the murder and the robbery of the articles were found to be part of the same transaction. The irresistible conclusion would, therefore, but that the appellants and no one else had committed the three murders and the robbery.

    13. In the instant case, it is clearly established by the prosecution that M.O.1 gold chain, which belonged to the deceased, was pledged by the first accused in the finance company within two days of the occurrence. Hence, the presumption under Section 114(a) of the Evidence Act can be raised that it was the accused, who had committed the crime. The appellants/accused have not come forward with any plausible explanation for the possession of the jewel. The said presumption raised under Section 114(a) of the Evidence Act is of course rebuttable, but the said presumption remains unrebutted. Hence it clearly proves the guilt of the accused.

    14. In such circumstances, there is no merit in this appeal and the same fails and consequently it is dismissed. The conviction and sentence passed in S.C.No.103 of 2012 by the learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tirupur, stands confirmed. If the appellants/accused are not in custody, the trial Court is directed to take appropriate steps to secure them and commit them to prison so as to serve the sentence imposed on them. (S.N.J.,) (V.B.D.J.,) 01.06.2016 1.The Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tirupur. 2.The Inspector of Police, Mangalam Police Station, Mangalam, Tirupur District. 3.The Public Prosecutor, High Court, Madras. S.NAGAMUTHU.J.,

    V.BHARATHIDASAN.J., rrg Crl.A.No.257 of 2013 01.06.2016

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    R.Navaneetha Krishnan v. Inspector of Police
    (Jun 1, 2016)