AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as Act of 1996) and under sub-section(2) of Section 18,
  • Article 226 declaring that Rule 5 of the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council Rules, 2006
  • Rule 5 of the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council Rules, 2006 (hereinafter referred
  • Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as Act of 2006),
  • Enterprises Facilitation Council. Sub-sections (1) to (5) of Section 18
  • ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT 1996
  • Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006
  • Act of 2006 and section 18(2) and 18(3)
  • section 30 read with section 21(3)
  • Act of 2006, specific provisions
  • sub-section(1) of Section 7.5.
  • Act of 1996 only and Rule 5,
  • provisions of Act of 2006.6.
  • sub-section (1) of Section 7
  • COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Rule 18(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as Act of 1996) and under sub-section(2) of Section 18,
  • Article 226 declaring that Rule 5 of the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council Rules, 2006
  • Rule 5 of the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council Rules, 2006 (hereinafter referred
  • Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as Act of 2006),
  • Enterprises Facilitation Council. Sub-sections (1) to (5) of Section 18
  • ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT 1996
  • Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006
  • Act of 2006 and section 18(2) and 18(3)
  • section 30 read with section 21(3)
  • Act of 2006, specific provisions
  • sub-section(1) of Section 7.5.
  • Act of 1996 only and Rule 5,
  • provisions of Act of 2006.6.
  • sub-section (1) of Section 7
  • COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Rule 18(1)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner seeks a declaration that Rule 5 of the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council Rules, 2006 ("Impugned Rule") is invalid and ultra vires the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 ("Act of 2006") and the Constitution of India. The reliefs sought include a declaration of invalidity under Article 226, a writ of certiorari to quash a letter dated April 2, 2016 (Annexure P/10) issued by Respondent No.2 to the Collector, and restraint against Respondent No.2 from taking action pursuant to that letter.

The petitioner is a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, and a fully owned subsidiary of Power Machines OJSC, Russia. Respondent No.3 is Laxmi Engineering Industries (Bhopal) Private Limited, a company engaged in manufacture and supply of heat exchangers. Between 2007 and 2009 the petitioner issued Letters of Intent for three purchase orders to Respondent No.3. Disputes arose, negotiations failed, and the matter was taken up by the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council (Respondent No.2) for adjudication under the Act of 2006. An award for Rs. 1,15,77,630/- was passed and recovery proceedings pursuant to the award have been initiated.

The writ petition challenges the legality of Rule 5, which provides that if no appeal is filed under section 19 of the Act, or such appeal is dismissed, the decree/award/order shall be executed by the District Collector and the amount recovered as arrears of land revenue. The petitioner contends that because Section 18(2) and (3) of the Act of 2006 make the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 ("Act of 1996") applicable, enforcement should proceed under Section 36 of the Act of 1996 and the special recovery procedure in Rule 5 is ultra vires.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Rule 5 of the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council Rules, 2006 is ultra vires the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 and the Constitution of India.
  2. Whether an award rendered under the dispute resolution mechanism of the Act of 2006 must be enforced only under Section 36 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, or whether Rule 5 (recovery as arrears of land revenue) can validly provide an alternative mode of enforcement after the award attains finality.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Section 18(2) and (3) of the Act of 2006 make the dispute resolution procedure subject to the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; thus awards passed are arbitration awards under that Act.
  • Decisions of the Madras and Kerala High Courts (cited) hold that the dispute resolution mechanism under the Act of 2006 results in an award under the Act of 1996; consequently Sections 34, 36 and 37 of the Act of 1996 apply and enforcement must be under Section 36. Rule 5 therefore conflicts with the Act of 1996 and is ultra vires.
  • Rules are delegated legislation; relying on decisions such as Dr. Mahachandra Prasad Singh v. Chairman, Bihar Legislative Council and Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Birla Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills, the petitioner argued that a delegatee cannot make rules beyond powers conferred by the parent Act and the Rule should be struck down if inconsistent with the Act of 2006.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The Act of 2006 and Chapter V's dispute resolution mechanism were enacted to provide early disposal and relief to micro and small enterprises to prevent financial hardship; Rule 5 is in furtherance of that purpose.
  • Rule 5 provides a mechanism for recovery only after an award has attained finality (i.e., after appeals are decided). It is an additional mode of enforcement available to a claimant and therefore not inconsistent with the Act of 1996.
  • The Rule is framed under section 30 read with section 21(3) of the Act of 2006; these sections empower the State to make Rules to implement the Act's purpose, and thus Rule 5 cannot be held ultra vires merely because it provides an alternative enforcement mechanism.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramesh Conductors P. Limited v. M & Se Facilitation Council, 2015 SCC OnLine Mad 13110 Relied on by petitioner to support the proposition that proceedings under the Act of 2006 amount to arbitration under the Act of 1996 (so enforcement should be under Section 36 of the Act of 1996). The Court noted the petitioner's reliance on this decision but did not accept that reliance as grounds to declare Rule 5 ultra vires; the Court concluded Rule 5 may coexist as an alternative enforcement mechanism.
Managing Director, Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation, Kumbakonam Limited v. Radhakrishnan Unnithan, MD, M/s. Rayamands Rubber (P) Ltd., 2015 SCC OnLine Ker 34011 Relied on by petitioner (Kerala High Court decision cited to support the arbitration-characterisation of proceedings under the Act of 2006). The Court recorded the petitioner’s reliance but held that the existence of a procedure under the Act of 1996 does not preclude an additional recovery mechanism under Rule 5 once the award is final.
2015 SCC OnLine Ker 21856 (Kerala High Court decision, name as cited in the opinion) Relied on by petitioner similarly to the other High Court authorities to argue that awards under the Act of 2006 are to be treated as awards under the Act of 1996. The Court acknowledged the citation but concluded that such authorities did not mandate striking down Rule 5; the Rule can operate as an alternative enforcement route after finality.
Dr. Mahachandra Prasad Singh v. Chairman, Bihar Legislative Council, (2004) 8 SCC 747 Cited by petitioner for the principle that a delegatee cannot make rules beyond powers conferred by the parent statute. The Court observed the petitioner’s reliance on this principle but found no basis to hold Rule 5 beyond the powers conferred under the Act of 2006, since Rule 5 was made under section 21(3) read with section 30.
Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Birla Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills, Delhi, (1968) 3 SCR 251 : AIR 1968 SC 1232 Cited for the same general principle that delegated legislation cannot exceed the scope of enabling provisions. The Court considered the principle but concluded Rule 5 was within the scope of delegated powers and in furtherance of the Act's objective.
Madanlal Fakirchand Dudhediya v. Shree Changdeo Sugar Mills Limited, AIR 1962 SC 1543 Authority cited for the maxim that sub-sections and provisions should be read as parts of an integral whole and, where possible, reconciled to avoid repugnancy. The Court relied on this approach of harmonious construction in deciding that Rule 5 can be reconciled with the Act and need not be struck down.
Krishna Kumar v. State of Rajasthan, (1991) 4 SCC 258 : AIR 1992 SC 1789 Cited for the rule of harmonious construction: where two provisions appear to conflict they should, if possible, be interpreted so both have effect. The Court applied the principle of harmonious construction to hold that Rule 5 and the Act of 1996 enforcement provisions can coexist.
The Bihar State Co-operative Marketing Union Limited v. Uma Shankar Sharan, (1992) 4 SCC 196 : AIR 1993 SC 1222 Cited for the proposition that plural remedies can be validly prescribed under law and the principle of election applies if remedies are inconsistent; a person may choose among multiple remedies. The Court relied on this authority to support its conclusion that availability of an additional remedy (Rule 5 recovery) is permissible and the aggrieved party may elect the remedy to pursue.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by analysing the scheme and purpose of the Act of 2006 and the Rules framed thereunder. Key elements of the Court's reasoning, as set out in the opinion, are:

  • The Act of 2006 was enacted to provide benefits and protective mechanisms to micro and small enterprises, including a special and speedy dispute resolution mechanism in Chapter V to prevent financial hardship.
  • Section 18(1)–(5) of the Act of 2006 contemplates dispute resolution using arbitration-like procedures and makes the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 applicable for such proceedings; section 19 provides an appellate procedure akin to sections 34 and 37 of the Act of 1996.
  • Rule 5, however, operates only after the dispute resolution mechanism has run its course and an award/decree has attained finality (i.e., no pending appeal or appeal dismissed). It provides execution by the District Collector with recovery as arrears of land revenue.
  • The existence of a specific Rule for recovery (Rule 5) does not automatically render it ultra vires merely because the Act of 1996 provides an enforcement route (Section 36). The Court emphasised that Rule 5 offers an optional alternative to enforcement under Section 36, usable after finality is attained.
  • Principles of statutory interpretation—particularly harmonious construction—require attempts to reconcile two provisions (or a provision and a rule) so both may operate if possible. The Court cited authorities endorsing this approach and applied it here to avoid a head-on clash between Rule 5 and the Act of 1996 enforcement provisions.
  • The Court referred to the Supreme Court's decision permitting plural remedies and the doctrine of election where two remedies exist; accordingly, the availability of two enforcement routes does not in itself invalidate one of them.
  • The Court observed there was no material presented to show why two sets of recovery proceedings could not operate in the same matter after finality of the award, and that Rule 5 was framed under powers conferred by section 21(3) read with section 30 of the Act of 2006.

In sum, the Court applied the Act's object, the text of relevant sections, and settled principles of statutory interpretation to conclude that Rule 5 can coexist with the enforcement mechanism under the Act of 1996.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

WRIT PETITION DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • Rule 5 of the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council Rules, 2006 is upheld as valid and not ultra vires the Act of 2006 or the Constitution, as applied in this matter.
  • Rule 5 may be invoked only after an award/decree has attained finality (i.e., appeals disposed), and it provides an alternative mode of enforcement—execution by the District Collector and recovery as arrears of land revenue—alongside the enforcement available under Section 36 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
  • The direct effect for the parties in this case is that the recovery proceedings initiated under Rule 5 are not invalidated by this Court's order; the petitioner’s challenge to Rule 5 is dismissed.
  • The Court did not indicate that it was laying down a novel precedent that overrides prior law; rather, it reconciled existing provisions and authorities and applied established principles of interpretation to the facts of this case. The opinion therefore affirms the validity of the State Rule as an available alternative remedy without purporting to displace the Act of 1996's enforcement regime.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Power Machines India Limited v. State Of M.P. And Others.

    1. Seeking a declaration to the effect that Rule 5 of the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council Rules, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Impugned Rule’) is invalid and ultra vires the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Act of 2006’), this writ petition has been filed and the prayer made in the writ petition reads as under:—

    “7.1 Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction under Article 226 declaring that Rule 5 of the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council Rules, 2006 is ultra vires the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 as well as the Constitution of India and hence illegal and unenforceable;

    7.2 Issue a writ of Certiorari or a writ in the nature of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or direction under Article 226 calling for the records of proceedings in or in relation to the letter dated April 2, 2016 - Annexure P/10, issued to the Collector, Noida by Respondent No. 2, initiating recovery proceedings against the Petitioner under the Impugned Rule and upon examining the same, be placed to declare such letter as illegal and unconstitutional and quash such letter and all the proceedings initiated thereunder or pursuant or consequent thereto;

    7.3 Restrain Respondent No. 2 from taking any action pursuant to the letter dated April 2, 2016 issued to the Collector, Noida by Respondent No. 2; and,

    7.4 Pass any other order(s) that this Hon'ble Court may deem fit in light of the facts and circumstances of the present case.”

    2. Petitioner claims to be a Company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956. It is said to be fully owned subsidiary of Power Machines OJSC, Russia, a large power plant engineering company with worldwide subsidiaries. Petitioner claims to be engaged in power engineering including production, supply, erection, maintenance and modernization of equipment for thermal, nuclear, hydel and gas turbine power plants. Registered office of the petitioner is said to be situated in New Delhi. Respondent No. 3 - Laxmi Engineering Industries (Bhopal) Private Limited is also a company registered under the Companies Act with its registered office at 72-A, Sector 1, Govindpura Industrial Area, Bhopal, MP. It is engaged in the business of design, manufacture and supply of heat exchangers for power plants, refineries, fertilizer plants, petrochemicals, chemical plants etc. It is stated that between 2007-2009 petitioner issued Letter of Intent for three purchase orders as detailed in paragraph 5.7 of the writ petition, and filed as Annexure P/2 - collectively. After these purchase orders were issued, certain disputes arose between the parties; negotiation failed; and, thereafter the matter was taken up by the Madhya Pradesh Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council - respondent No. 2, in accordance to the procedure contemplated under the Act of 2006, for adjudication of the dispute. Finally, an award for Rs. 1,15,77,630/- (Rupees One Crore Fifteen Lakhs Seventy Seven Thousand Six Hundred and Thirty Only) has been passed and recovery proceedings in connection with the award have been initiated.

    3. Various allegations are made in this writ petition with regard to passing of the award in question; illegality committed in the matter of passing of the award and other aspects of the matter. However, when recovery proceedings have been initiated in the matter under Rule 5 of the Act of 2006, this writ petition has been filed for declaring the rules as ultra vires to the constitution and the Act of 2006.

    4. Learned counsel for the petitioner invited our attention to Section 18 of the Act of 2006; sub-section (2) and (3) thereof, and argued that when a dispute arises, the same is adjudicated or resolved by respondent No. 2 under the Act of 2006, the entire dispute resolution mechanism undertaken is in accordance to the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Act of 1996’) and under sub-section(2) of Section 18, it is stated and provided for that the conciliation proceedings and other dispute resolution would be undertaken as per the Act of 1996; and, further under sub-section (3) it is stipulated that the Act of 1996 shall apply to a dispute as if an arbitration proceeding is being held in pursuance to the Arbitration Agreement referred to in sub-section(1) of Section 7.

    5. Accordingly, learned counsel for the petitioner by placing reliance on the following judgments-Ramesh Ramesh Conductors P. Limited v. M & Se Facilitation Council), 2015 SCC OnLine Mad 13110; Managing Director, Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation, Kumbakonam Limited v. Radhakrishnan Unnithan, MD, M/s. Rayamands Rubber (P) Ltd., 2015 SCC OnLine Ker 34011; and, v. , 2015 SCC OnLine Ker 21856, argued that the entire proceedings held for resolution of the dispute and the award passed with regard to the dispute is nothing but an award under the Act of 1996, and all the procedure contemplated under the Act of 1996 would apply in the matter of resolution of a dispute. Learned counsel for the petitioner refers to the judgments of the Madras High Court and the Kerala High Court, in the aforementioned cases, to say that the dispute resolution mechanism provided for in the Act of 1996 as per the judgments rendered by the Madras and the Kerala High Court is nothing but an arbitration award and once it is an award passed under the Act of 1996, the provisions of section 34, 36 and 37 of the Act of 1996 would become applicable and the only remedy available for enforcement of the award would be the one provided under Section 36 of the Act of 1996 and, therefore, the special procedure now contemplated under Rule 5 is ultra vires and inconsistent to the provisions. Rule 18(1) and (2) which clearly contemplates that dispute is an arbitration dispute adjudicated under the Act of 1996 and when entire procedure for resolution of dispute as provided in the Act of 1996 has been made applicable, the resolution of dispute and the recovery of the amount has to be as per the aforesaid Act of 1996 only and Rule 5, which provides for a special procedure for recovery by resorting to recovering the amount as if it is arrears of land revenue is ultra vires the provisions of Act of 2006.

    6. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Rules are framed by virtue of the powers delegated under the Act of 2006 and in view of the judgments of the Supreme Court in the cases of Dr. Mahachandra Prasad Singh v. Chairman, Bihar Legislative Council, (2004) 8 SCC 747; and, Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Birla Cotton, Spinning and Weaving Mills, Delhi, (1968) 3 SCR 251: AIR 1968 SC 1232, the delegatee cannot bring into force a Rule which is beyond the powers conferred or the Scheme contemplated under the Act of 2006. Accordingly, learned counsel argues that the Rule be declared as ultra vires.

    7. Shri Samdarshi Tiwari, learned Deputy Advocate General; and, Shri Shashank Shekhar, learned counsel for respondent No. 3, refute the aforesaid contentions. They took us through the purpose for which the Act of 2006 was incorporated and argued that this Act was incorporated to give certain benefit to the small scale industries and the entire Act of 2006 and the dispute resolution mechanism provided under Chapter V, in the matter of delayed payment to micro and small enterprises is a dispute resolution system incorporated with the sole purpose of early disposal of dispute, so that delay in resolution of the dispute should not result in financial crisis to the small scale industries. They argue that with the aforesaid intention in mind, the Act was enacted and Rule 5 has been incorporated for the purpose of speedy recovery of the amount as awarded under the dispute resolution mechanism.

    8. Learned counsel for the respondents argue that Rule 5 only provides for a mechanism for recovery of the amount after the award passed had attained finality, in as much as the appeal filed has been decided and the award has attained finality. They argue that if for the purpose of enforcement of an award or a decree passed, an additional mode of recovery is provided for under the Rules in addition to the one available under the Act of 1996, the Rule cannot be termed as ultra vires. It is said that the Rule in question has been framed by virtue of the powers conferred under section 30 read with section 21(3) and as both these sections empower the Rule making authority to make the Rule for implementing the purpose for which the Act and the Rules have been framed, the same cannot be termed as ultra vires to the Constitution.

    9. We have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and have perused the record.

    10. The Rule in question reads as under:—

    “5. Recovery of amount due as arrears of land revenue:

    If a buyer does not file any appeal under section 19 of the Act for setting aside any decree, award or other order made either by the council itself or by any institution or centre or if such appeal is dismissed, in that situation such decree, award or order shall be executed by the Collector of the District concerned and the amount due shall be recovered as arrears of land revenue.”

    11. This Rule has been incorporated by the Government of Madhya Pradesh by virtue of the powers vested in it under section 21(3) read with section 30 of the Act of 2006. There is no dispute that the Rule has been made by virtue of the powers and the jurisdiction available to the competent legislative authority in the State of MP. The only grievance of the petitioner that once the Act of 2006 and section 18(2) and 18(3) thereof contemplates that the dispute resolution mechanism is to be undertaken in accordance to the procedure contemplated under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and when the dispute is said to be one referred for arbitration as if it is by virtue of the arbitration agreement as is provided for in sub-section (1) of Section 7 and when the judgments of the Madras and Kerala High Courts say that an award passed is an award under the Act of 1996 and all the provisions of the Act of 1996 apply and when there is a specific provision for execution of the award under section 36 of the Act of 1996, further mechanism provided contrary to this section is ultra vires the Act of 2006, as it is inconsistent to the main Act. This is in sum and substance the contention of the petitioner.

    12. However, nothing is brought to our notice to indicate as to why there cannot be two sets of recovery proceedings in a matter after the dispute resolution mechanism has come to an end and the award passed as per the dispute resolution mechanism has attained finality. The Act of 2006 was enacted to give benefit to small scale industries, to provide for reservation of items, exclusively to be manufactured by such industry and for bringing into place a composite statutory policy to enable the growth of small and micro industry establishment by adopting better and higher level of technology and to achieve higher production and to enable such industry to remain competent in a fast globalization area. It provides for various mechanism and facilities to be granted to the small scale units for uplifting them and for granting them certain benefits to stay in the competitive world in this age of globalization. With that purpose in view, the National Board for Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises has been created and various provisions have been made to grant benefit to such class of industries under the Act of 2006. Under Chapter V of the Act of 2006, specific provisions have been made where a buyer from these Industries is required to ensure payment of dues and a special procedure is contemplated for resolution or adjudication of any dispute in this regard by the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council. Sub-sections (1) to (5) of Section 18 contemplates a procedure which is the dispute resolution mechanism and as indicated hereinabove, the said mechanism contemplates that a dispute for which settlement is not arrived at has to be adjudicated by utilizing the services of arbitration or by following the procedure for arbitration and such arbitration is deemed to be a proceeding under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act of 1996.

    13. Thereafter, under section 19, provision for appeals have been provided and the appellate procedure is nothing but is the same procedure as is contemplated under the Act of 1996 i.e…. the procedure contemplated under sections 34 and 37. However, in the matter of recovery, Rule 5 lays down a specific provision and this provision can be brought into force only after the entire dispute resolution mechanism comes to an end, the award or the decree passed has attained finality.

    14. This is the Scheme of the Act, and the same is to ensure early resolution of the dispute and recovery of the amount awarded so that financial hardship and financial crisis to a small scale industry is ruled out. Merely because a separate Rule for recovery under Rule 5 is contemplated under the Rules, in the absence of there being any conflict between the aforesaid Rule or the Constitution, we cannot declare the said Rule as ultra vires.

    15. Petitioner wants this Court to hold that once the dispute resolution mechanism system under the Act of 2006 is the one contemplated under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, then enforcement of an award passed under this Act of 1996 has to be in accordance to the provisions of section 36. Section 36 contemplates that an award passed shall be enforced as if it is a decree under the Code of Civil Procedure. Judicial notice can be taken of the fact and it is an admitted position that for getting a decree executed by following the procedure under the Code of Civil Procedure, there are various procedural and other impediments and if taking note of all these aspects and in furtherance to the intention for which the Act of 2006 was enacted, if a specific Rule like Rule 5 is enacted, we find no reason to hold the same to be ultra vires. It only gives an optional choice to a claimant who has a decree in his favour on the basis of adjudication conducted under the Act of 2006, to get the decree enforced. He may take recourse to the remedy available under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act or can take recourse to the remedy of recovering the amount as if it is arrears of land revenue and in case any illegality is being conducted in the matter of recovery, the aggrieved person can always challenge the recovery proceedings. Merely because a dual procedure for recovery is contemplated under the Rules framed, we see no reason to interfere into the matter.

    16. We may also profitably refer to various aspects pertaining to Principles of Statutory Interpretation of Statute in this regard. It is a cardinal principle of Interpretation of Statute that the Court should make all endeavour to give effect to the legislative intent for which a provision is made, harmonious construction should be evolved to reconcile the conflict, if any, between two provisions operating with regard to same aspects of the matter and when it comes to cases pertaining to procedure or statute regulating procedures, the Court has to ensure that the provision is interpreted in such a manner that it advances the cause of justice and as far as possible the intention of legislature in furtherance to the cause of justice should be given effect to. Inconsistency and repugnancy should be avoided and harmonious construction applied. In his book on Principle of Statutory Interpretation, Justice G.P Singh has discussed this aspect of the matter in Chapter II, in detail, and after referring to various judgments on the subject, the author lays down the principle by saying that the Courts should avoid a head on clash between two sections of the same Act or two provisions of two different Acts. Wherever it is possible to do so, the Court should construe the provision which appear to be conflicting in a manner so as to harmonize them. The author further says that the provisions of one section of a statute cannot be used to defeat those of another section until and unless it is impossible to effect reconciliation between the two. The author refers to certain observations made by Justice Gajendragadkar in this regard, which reads as under:—

    “The sub-sections must be read as parts of an integral whole and as being interdependent; an attempt should be made in construing them to reconcile them if it is reasonably possible to do so, as to avoid repugnancy.”

    17. Similarly, the author also refers to certain observations made by Justice Venkatarama Aiyar, which reads as under:—

    “The rule of construction is well settled that when there are in an enactment two provisions which cannot be reconciled with each other, they should be so interpreted that, if possible, effect should be given to both. This is what is known as the rule of harmonious construction.”

    18. The aforesaid observations are made by the learned Hon'ble Judges in the cases of Madanlal Fakirchand Dudhediya v. Shree Changdeo Sugar Mills Limited, AIR 1962 SC 1543; and, Krishna Kumar v. State of Rajasthan, (1991) 4 SCC 258 : AIR 1992 SC 1789.

    19. It is indicated in the principle laid down that apart from resolving conflicts between two provisions of an Act, this principle can be used for resolving all conflicts between a provision in the Act; two different Acts or in the Act and a Rule made under the Act. In this regard, reference can be made to a judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of The Bihar State Co-operative Marketing Union Limited v. Uma Shankar Sharan, (1992) 4 SCC 196 : AIR 1993 SC 1222, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court in paragraph 6 holds that validity of plural remedies can be prescribed under law. The Hon'ble Supreme Court applies the principle of election in such cases where two or more remedies are available to a person. It is held if the two remedies happen to be inconsistent, they can still continue and it is for the person concerned to chose amongst them and once he elects one of them and can commence action accordingly.

    20. In the present case also, the position is akin to the aforesaid principle laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. In view of the aforesaid also, we see no reason to allow the prayer made by the petitioner.

    21. We are of the considered view that as Rule 5 is in strict conformity with the Act of 2006, and is in furtherance to the legislative intent for which the Act was brought into force, the Rule formulated in addition to the statutory rule for execution available under section 36 cannot be termed as ultra vires or illegal to the Constitution or the Act of 2006. The averments made by the learned counsel for the petitioner are misconceived.

    22. Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Power Machines India Limited v. State Of M.P. And Others.
    (Jul 18, 2016)