AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants, Nihaal Ahamed (Rank 731) and Gayathri (Rank 551), passed the Higher Secondary Examination in March 2013 and applied for admission to the MBBS course through the Consortium of Tamil Nadu Private Professional Colleges Association, affiliated to the Tamil Nadu Dr M.G.R. Medical University. Both selected the respondent Private Medical College as their first preference.

On 24-9-2013 the appellants personally approached the college seeking admission but were asked to return after 26-9-2013. They immediately complained to the Monitoring Committee. After receiving the Committee’s communication, the college drafted letters dated 24-9-2013 (actually posted on 29-9-2013) calling the appellants for counselling on 26-9-2013. By the time those letters were received (30-9-2013 and 1-10-2013), the seats had been filled.

Each appellant filed a writ petition before the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court seeking a writ of mandamus directing the college to grant admission for the academic year 2013-2014. A learned Single Judge denied admission but awarded ₹3 lakhs compensation to each appellant. The appellants and the college cross-appealed. A Division Bench upheld denial of admission and set aside the compensation. The present appeals challenge that Division Bench ruling.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants, having missed counselling due to the college’s conduct, were entitled to admission to the MBBS course for the academic year 2013-2014.
  2. Whether, in the alternative, they were entitled to monetary compensation for the loss of admission opportunities caused by the respondent Medical College’s fault.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The college acted with mala fide intent by telling them to return after 26-9-2013 and by sending ante-dated call letters posted only on 29-9-2013.
  • Students with lower merit were admitted, demonstrating discriminatory treatment.
  • Precedents on public-law damages (e.g., Krina Ajay Shah) justify either admission or compensation.

Respondent Medical College’s Arguments

  • The appellants were orally informed on 24-9-2013 to report on 26-9-2013 and formal call letters were also dispatched.
  • Because the appellants failed to appear on 26-9-2013, seats were filled strictly according to the merit list; hence there was no wrongful denial.
  • No basis existed for awarding compensation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chandigarh Administration v. Jasmine Kaur (2014) 10 SCC 521 Courts may grant compensation when a candidate loses admission due to institutional fault and the academic year has lapsed. Used as primary authority to justify monetary relief instead of belated admission.
Krina Ajay Shah v. Association of Management of Unaided Private Medical & Dental Colleges (2016) 1 SCC 666 (order dated 2-9-2014) Award of public-law damages (₹20 lakhs each) where students lost admission opportunities through no fault of their own and admission could not be given later. Cited to reinforce that compensation is an appropriate remedy; supports restoring Single Judge’s award.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court accepted the factual findings of the Single Judge that:

  • The college received the Monitoring Committee’s query on 24-9-2013 and only thereafter created letters dated 24-9-2013, posting them on 29-9-2013.
  • This delay made it impossible for the appellants to attend counselling on 26-9-2013, causing loss of admission.

Applying the principle from Jasmine Kaur, the Court held that while admission cannot be granted once the academic schedule has lapsed, the candidates should not suffer without redress when the loss was entirely due to the institution’s fault. The Court characterised the wrong as a public-law breach warranting compensation. It found the Single Judge’s award of ₹3 lakhs each reasonable and concluded that the Division Bench erred in reversing it.

Holding and Implications

Partly Allowed. The Supreme Court set aside the Division Bench’s order insofar as it had overturned the compensation award and restored the Single Judge’s direction that the respondent Medical College pay ₹3 lakhs to each appellant within the specified time.

Implications: The decision reiterates that courts will substitute monetary compensation where admission is no longer feasible and institutional fault is proven. Although no new legal principle was created, it strengthens the precedent that private educational institutions may be held financially accountable for procedural irregularities causing loss of educational opportunity.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    S. Nihaal Ahamed v. Dean, Velammal Medical College Hospital And Research Institute And Others

    Page 1

    1

    REPORTABLE

    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 8067-8068 OF 2015

    [Arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) Nos.3139-3140 of 2015]

    S. Nihaal Ahamed .. Appellant -vs-

    The Dean,

    Velammal Medical College Hospital and Research Institute & Ors. .. Respondents With

    CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 8069-8070 OF 2015

    [Arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) Nos.10354-10355 of 2015]

    J U D G M E N T

    C. NAGAPPAN, J.

    1. Leave granted.

    Page 2

    2. All these appeals have been preferred against the common judgment dated 25.9.2014 passed by the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court in Writ Appeal (MD)Nos. 794, 898, 921 and 923 of 2014.

    3. The facts are briefly as follows: The appellants passed Higher Secondary examination in March 2013 and submitted application for admission to M.B.B.S. Course to the Consortium of Tamil Nadu Private Professional Colleges Association, affiliated to the Tamil Nadu Dr. M.G.R. Medical University which is one of the respondents herein, and both of them had preferred the same Private Medical College which is also one of the respondents herein, as their first choice. On 23.9.2013 results were published in which appellant-Nihaal Ahamed was placed in Rank No. 731 and appellant-Gayathri in Rank No. 551 in the merit list. According to them, they went to the respondent-Medical College on 24.9.2013 and sought admission and they were directed to come after 26.9.2013. Both of them made complaints against respondent-Medical College to the Monitoring Committee which is one of the respondents herein

    Page 3

    and the said Committee called for remarks from the Medical College. Meanwhile the respondent-Medical College drafted letters dated 24.9.2013 addressed to both the appellants which were posted on 29.9.2013 directing them to appear for counselling on 26.9.2013. The appellants received the said letters on 1.10.2013 and 30.9.2013 respectively and immediately approached the respondent-Medical College to allot seats and same was refused on the ground that they did not approach them within the stipulated time. Both the appellants filed independent writ petitions on the file of the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court seeking for issuance of writ of mandamus to direct the respondent-Medical College to admit them in the first year M.B.B.S. Course for the academic year 2013-14 in their college. Learned Single Judge heard both the writ petitions and by common order held that the appellants- writ petitioners were not entitled for admission in the M.B.B.S. Course and on the other hand they are each entitled to a sum of Rs. 3 lakhs as compensation payable by the respondent-Medical College within a period of 8 weeks. Challenging the denial of relief of admission, both the appellants preferred independent

    Page 4

    writ appeals and challenging the grant of compensation, the respondent-Medical College preferred two writ appeals. The Division Bench affirmed the view of the learned Single Judge that the appellants were not entitled for the admission in the M.B.B.S Course and dismissed the writ appeals preferred by them. It further held that the appellants are not entitled for compensation and allowed the writ appeals preferred by the respondent-Medical College. Aggrieved by the same, appellants have preferred the present appeals.

    4. Mr. M. Ajmal Khan, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant-Nihaal Ahamed contended that the appellants approached the respondent-Medical College on 24.9.2013 itself and the college with a malafide intention directed them to come after 26.9.2013 and on the complaint lodged by the appellants with the Monitoring Committee, in order to wriggle out, the respondent-Medical college drafted ante dated letters dated 24.9.2013 and posted it calling upon the appellants to appear for counselling at a prior date and in fact the college had given admission to students who had secured lesser marks than that

    Page 5

    of the appellants and the appellants are entitled for the relief sought for in the writ petitions. We also heard the submission of the learned counsel appearing for the appellant-Gayathri. Mr. Krishnan Venugopal, learned senior counsel appearing for the respondent-Medical College contended that the appellants were orally told on 24.9.2013 to report on 26.9.2013 in the college and the call letters dated 24.9.2013 were also sent and since they were not present in the college on 26.9.2013, the vacancies were filled up according to merit list and there is no denial of admission to the appellants and they are not entitled to any relief. We also heard learned counsel appearing for the other respondents.

    5. It is not in dispute the Consortium of Medical Colleges issued a prospectus for admission to the M.B.B.S. Course and as per the instruction therein, preference would be given to first choice opted by the candidate. In the merit list published by them on 23.9.2013 the names of the appellants found place at Sl. Nos. 731 and 551 respectively. It is also not in dispute that both the appellants had opted the respondent-Medical College

    Page 6

    as their first choice. Both of them had in fact approached the respondent-Medical College on 24.9.2013 for admission and they were directed to come after 26.9.2013. Annoyed by the reply they immediately sent complaints to the Monitoring Committee which now in turn called for the remarks of the respondent-Medical College. The learned Single Judge in his order has observed that the respondent-Medical College admitted the receipt of the communication from the Committee on the very same day in the evening and there is also a specific admission to that effect in the counter affidavit filed by them. Thereafter the respondent-Medical College drafted letters dated 24.9.2013 directing the appellants to appear for counselling on 26.9.2013 and marked copy of the same to the Monitoring Committee. The said letters have been posted only on 29.9.2013 as evident from the post office seal affixed on the envelope produced by the appellants. The finding of the learned Single Judge that the respondent-Medical College is at fault in not sending call letters in time is based on proper appreciation of factual matrix.

    Page 7

    6. After having culled out the broad principles from the previous decisions, this Court in the decision in Chandigarh Administration and another Vs. Jasmine Kaur and others;

    (2014) 10 SCC 521) held as follows:

    "If a candidate is not selected during a particular academic year due to the fault of the institutions/authorities and in this process if the seats are filled up and the scope for granting admission is lost due to eclipse of time schedule, then under such circumstances, the candidate should not be victimized for no fault of his/her and the court may consider grant of appropriate compensation to offset the loss caused, if any."

    The appellants herein though placed in the merit list could not secure admission due to the fault of the respondent-Medical College. As rightly held by the High Court they are not entitled to the relief of admission sought for by them in the writ petition due to lapse of time.

    Page 8

    7. Reliance was placed by the appellants on the order of this Court dated 2.9.2014 in Krina Ajay Shah and Ors. v. The Secretary, Association of Management of Unaided Private Medical and Dental Colleges, Maharashtra and ors. (SLP No. 31900 of 2013 etc). The said bunch of SLPs was filed in 2013 and the petitioners therein were students who appeared for the entrance examination conducted by the Association of Private Medical Colleges and Dental Colleges, Maharashtra and the petitioners were heard together and this Court held that inspite of the pendency of the SLPs for over a year, the State of Maharashtra never thought it fit to file any affidavit explaining its stand in the matter and the grievance of the petitioners was fully justified but the petitioners cannot be granted admission in view of the long lapse of time but they are entitled to public law damages and awarded a sum of Rs. 20 lakhs to each one of the petitioners as public law damages. In the present case the learned Single Judge after elaborately considering the facts and circumstances held that the appellants-writ petitioners are entitled to a sum of Rs. 3 lakhs each as compensation payable by the respondent-Medical College and directed to pay within a

    Page 9

    period of 8 weeks. The said direction has been erroneously reversed by the Division Bench. In our view the order of the learned Single Judge has to be restored.

    8. In the result the appeals are partly allowed and the impugned judgment in so far as setting aside the order of the Single Judge awarding compensation to the appellants is, set aside and the order of the Single Judge awarding compensation of Rs. 3 lakhs to each of the appellants is restored alongwith time schedule for payment.

    ………………….J. (M.Y. Eqbal)

    .

    …………………J. (C. Nagappan) New Delhi; September 30, 2015.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S. Nihaal Ahamed v. Dean, Velammal Medical College Hospital And Research Institute And Others
    (Sep 30, 2015)