AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent joined the appellant Bank as a Field Supervisor in 1981. In 1984 he was charge-sheeted for misconduct and penalised with stoppage of two annual increments. A second charge-sheet, served in November 1987, alleged numerous financial irregularities; fourteen of seventeen charges were ultimately held proved and, on 1-10-1991, the respondent was removed from service. His departmental appeal failed.

The respondent then filed a writ petition in the High Court challenging the disciplinary proceedings, principally on grounds of violation of natural justice due to non-supply of documents and inadequate opportunity to defend himself. A learned Single Judge quashed the removal and granted all consequential benefits. The Bank’s writ appeal was dismissed by a Division Bench, which, while affirming the violation of natural justice, limited back-wages to a lump-sum payment of Rs 5,00,000 plus other consequential benefits. The Bank and its Board of Directors obtained special-leave from the Supreme Court, leading to the present civil appeal; the respondent did not cross-appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the disciplinary proceedings were vitiated because the documents forming the basis of the charges, and the lists of documents and witnesses, were not supplied to the respondent.
  2. Whether, in light of the alleged procedural infirmities, the punishment of removal from service could be sustained.
  3. Whether the High Court’s direction limiting back-wages to Rs 5,00,000 while granting other consequential benefits was justified.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments

  • The second inquiry was incompetent because it was based on charges substantially identical to those in the first charge-sheet.
  • No list of documents or witnesses accompanied the second charge-sheet, nor were the relied-upon documents supplied, denying him a fair opportunity to respond.
  • He was not permitted adequate inspection of relevant records, rendering the inquiry violative of principles of natural justice.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court restricted its scrutiny to the “only controversy” it identified: whether the documents underlying the charges had been furnished to the respondent. It noted that:

  • It was “indisputable” that no documents were supplied with the charge-sheet.
  • Only some documents surfaced during the inquiry, and critical documents (specifically P-19, P-21, P-23, P-25, P-30, P-31, P-32) relied upon to establish guilt were never provided.
  • The lists of documents and witnesses were also withheld.

Given these undisputed omissions, the Court held that the respondent had been denied a reasonable opportunity of defence, an elementary component of natural justice. It agreed with both the Single Judge and the Division Bench that the disciplinary order was legally unsustainable. In view of the respondent’s long period out of service (since 1991) and public-interest considerations invoked by the High Court, the Supreme Court found no cause to disturb the High Court’s equitable relief capping back-wages at Rs 5,00,000.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The judgment of the Division Bench of the Chhattisgarh High Court is affirmed.

Immediate Effect: The respondent remains entitled to a lump-sum payment of Rs 5,00,000 towards salary arrears and to all other consequential benefits ordered by the High Court. The Bank’s dismissal order stands quashed.

Broader Implications: While no new legal principle was articulated, the decision reinforces the settled requirement that, in disciplinary proceedings, the delinquent employee must receive all material relied upon against him. Failure to do so will vitiate the inquiry and any punishment founded upon it.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bilaspur Raipur Kshetriya Gramin Bank And Another v. Madanlal Tandon .

    M. Yusuf Eqbal, J.— Leave granted. This appeal by special leave is directed against the judgment and order dated 17-2-20121, whereby the Division Bench of the High Court of Chhattisgarh in the writ appeal preferred by the appellants upheld the order of the learned Single Judge and directed payment towards the respondent's claim of salary up to Rs 5,00,000 with all consequential benefits.

    2. The factual matrix of the case is that the respondent was working as a Field Supervisor in the appellant Bank since 1981. In February 1984, a charge-sheet was issued to him for having committed misconduct and after a departmental enquiry, an order dated 5-7-1984 was passed by the disciplinary authority imposing punishment of stoppage of his two annual increments. Thereafter a second charge-sheet was issued to the respondent in November 1987 alleging that the respondent had committed several financial irregularities in various loan cases. An inquiry was conducted, wherein fourteen charges were found proved against the respondent and three charges were not found proved. Consequently, the punishment of removal from service was inflicted against the respondent on 1-10-1991. The respondent preferred an appeal before the Board of Directors of the appellant Bank, but the same was dismissed.

    3. The respondent, therefore, moved the High Court by way of writ petition, inter alia contending that both the charge-sheets being identical, the second inquiry was not competent. It was also contended that along with the second charge-sheet, neither the list of documents nor were the documents sought to be relied upon supplied. It was also contended by the respondent-writ petitioner that appropriate opportunity was not afforded to him to have inspection of the relevant documents and as such the respondent was not in a position to reply to the said show-cause notice effectively and to defend him in the inquiry. The learned Single Judge of the High Court rejected his first contention and held that the charges were not identical and, therefore, the second inquiry was competent. However, it was held that along with the charge-sheet and imputation of charges, there was no list of documents and list of witnesses was also not supplied as such the respondent was not afforded an opportunity to put forward his case in response to the show-cause notice along with the charge-sheet. Observing that the object of rules of natural justice is to ensure that a government servant is treated fairly in proceedings which may culminate in imposition of punishment including dismissal/removal from service, the learned Single Judge of the High Court quashed the orders of removal passed by the appellant and allowed the writ petition of the respondent with all consequential benefits.

    4. Aggrieved by the aforesaid decision, the appellants preferred writ appeal, wherein the Division Bench of the High Court, after perusing the record, found that although the show-cause notice was served along with seventeen charges, but no documents were supplied along with the show-cause notice to the respondent. Even the list of documents sought to be relied upon during the inquiry was not supplied along with the show-cause notice. The Division Bench opined that it is trite law that when a delinquent employee is facing disciplinary proceeding, he is entitled to be afforded with a reasonable opportunity to meet the charges against him in an effective manner. If the copies of the documents are not supplied to the employee concerned, it would be difficult for him to prepare his defence and to cross-examine the witnesses and point out the inconsistencies with a view to show that the allegations are false or baseless.

    5. The Division Bench of the High Court further observed that in the instant case neither the list of witnesses nor the list of documents was supplied to the respondent along with the charge-sheet. Though during the course of inquiry some documents were supplied to him but those documents, on which the reliance was placed by the inquiry officer for holding various charges proved, were not supplied to the respondent. The High Court further observed that the respondent is out of employment since 1-10-1991 and his claim for arrears of salary, as stated by the counsel for both the parties, would be more than Rs 45-50 lakhs. The Bank's money is public money and a huge amount cannot be paid to anyone for doing no work. The principle of “no work no pay” has been evolved in view of the public interest that an employee who does not discharge his duty is not entitled to arrears of salary at the cost of public exchequer. By way of impugned judgment, the High Court, therefore, concluded that in the facts and circumstances of the case a lump sum payment of Rs 5,00,000 towards the claim of salary, would be just and proper in this matter. The respondent was also held to be entitled to all other consequential benefits.

    6. Hence, the present appeal by special leave by the appellant Bank and its Board of Directors. It is worth to mention here that the respondent has not come to this Court against the impugned judgment passed by the High Court.

    7. We have heard Mr Akshat Shrivastava, learned counsel for the appellants and Mr T.V.S Raghavendra Sreyas, learned counsel for the respondent. We have also perused the impugned order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court. The only controversy that falls for our consideration is as to whether the documents, which were the basis of the charges levelled against the respondent, were supplied to the respondent or not?

    8. Indisputably, no documents were supplied to the respondent along with the charge-sheet on the basis of which charges were framed. Some of the documents were given during departmental enquiry, but relevant documents on the basis of which findings were recorded were not made available to the respondent. It further appears that the lists of documents and witnesses were also not supplied and some of the documents were produced during the course of inquiry.

    9. Admittedly, the show-cause notice was served along with seventeen charges, but all the documents were not supplied to the respondent. A perusal of the impugned order will show that when the Division Bench, during the course of arguments, asked the learned counsel appearing for the appellants whether documents viz. P-21, P-25, P-23, P-19, P-30, P-31 and P-32 were supplied to the respondent, on the basis of which various charges have been held to be proved, the learned counsel was not able to demonstrate that the above documents were supplied to the respondent even during the course of inquiry. The Division Bench then following a catena of decisions of this Court came to the conclusion that the order of punishment cannot be sustained in law. However, taking into consideration the fact that the respondent was out of employment since 1991, a lump sum payment of Rs 5,00,000 towards salary would meet the ends of justice.

    10. After giving our anxious consideration, we do not find any reason to differ with the finding recorded by the learned Single Judge and also the Division Bench of the High Court in the writ appeal. Therefore, this civil appeal is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bilaspur Raipur Kshetriya Gramin Bank And Another v. Madanlal Tandon .
    (May 15, 2015)