AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 3-C of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Mah Act 28 of 1971), the Slum Rehabilitation Authority
  • Section 3-A of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (for short the 1971 Act)
  • Section 4(1) of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (for short the Slum Act)
  • Section 3-A of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Mah Act 28 of 1971)
  • Sections 2(15) and 2(19) of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short the 1966 Act)
  • Section 4 of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971
  • Section 3-B;(h-c) Slum Rehabilitation Authority means the Slum Rehabilitation Authority
  • Maharashtra Municipal Councils, Nagar Panchayats and Industrial Township Act, 1965.(c) (i)
  • provisions of Section 159 of the 1966 Act. These Development Control Regulations
  • Section 3-B;10. Section 3-A envisages a Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA)
  • Section 3-A of the 1971 Act by adding sub-section (1-B) to Section 37
  • Section 159 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966
  • 1966 Act and in the Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act, 1888
  • Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949,(b)
  • provisions of the 1971 Act include Section 4
  • sub-section (1) of Section 37 of the 1966 Act
  • Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Mah Act 28 of 1971),
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Slum Rehabilitation Scheme. Section 3-C
  • Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act, 1888
  • SECTION 617 COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Nagpur Municipal Corporation Act, 1948,
  • Section 3-A;(h-d) Slum Rehabilitation
  • Sections 33 and 38 of the Slum Act
  • Bombay Municipal Corporation Act,
  • Area Development Act, 1976,(iii)
  • sub-section (1) of Section 3-C
  • Redevelopment) Act, 1971. Slum
  • sub-section (1) of Section 4
  • Section 3 of the 1971 Act.
  • Section 4 of the 1971 Act
  • Redevelopment) Act, 1971
  • Section 4-A;(h) slum
  • Section 40; and(b)
  • Section 3-B
  • Section 3-C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 3-C of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Mah Act 28 of 1971), the Slum Rehabilitation Authority
  • Section 3-A of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (for short the 1971 Act)
  • Section 4(1) of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (for short the Slum Act)
  • Section 3-A of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Mah Act 28 of 1971)
  • Sections 2(15) and 2(19) of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short the 1966 Act)
  • Section 4 of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971
  • Section 3-B;(h-c) Slum Rehabilitation Authority means the Slum Rehabilitation Authority
  • Maharashtra Municipal Councils, Nagar Panchayats and Industrial Township Act, 1965.(c) (i)
  • provisions of Section 159 of the 1966 Act. These Development Control Regulations
  • Section 3-B;10. Section 3-A envisages a Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA)
  • Section 3-A of the 1971 Act by adding sub-section (1-B) to Section 37
  • Section 159 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966
  • 1966 Act and in the Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act, 1888
  • Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949,(b)
  • provisions of the 1971 Act include Section 4
  • sub-section (1) of Section 37 of the 1966 Act
  • Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Mah Act 28 of 1971),
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Slum Rehabilitation Scheme. Section 3-C
  • Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act, 1888
  • SECTION 617 COMPANIES ACT 1956
  • Nagpur Municipal Corporation Act, 1948,
  • Section 3-A;(h-d) Slum Rehabilitation
  • Sections 33 and 38 of the Slum Act
  • Bombay Municipal Corporation Act,
  • Area Development Act, 1976,(iii)
  • sub-section (1) of Section 3-C
  • Redevelopment) Act, 1971. Slum
  • sub-section (1) of Section 4
  • Section 3 of the 1971 Act.
  • Section 4 of the 1971 Act
  • Redevelopment) Act, 1971
  • Section 4-A;(h) slum
  • Section 40; and(b)
  • Section 3-B
  • Section 3-C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals arose from two writ-petition orders of the Bombay High Court (31-8-2010 in Balasaheb Arjun Torbole v. Administrator & Divisional Commissioner and 10-8-2010 in Arun V. Sapkal v. Collector) dismissing challenges to a Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) scheme in Kurla (West), Mumbai. The scheme, sanctioned on 29-6-2006, covered contiguous slum lands comprising:

  • Municipal Corporation plots bearing CTS Nos. 109 (pt), 110 (pt), 111 (pt) & 112 (pt); and
  • Privately-owned plots bearing CTS Nos. 106, 107 & 108 held by Respondent 8 (owner-cum-developer).

Slum dwellers over both categories of land formed Society Respondent 10 and sought redevelopment through Respondent 8. The Deputy Collector issued eviction orders under Sections 33/38 of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (“1971 Act”). These were unsuccessfully appealed to the Divisional Commissioner and then to the High-Powered Committee, which dismissed Appeal No. 62/2010 on 17-4-2010. The High Court upheld that dismissal, leading to the present civil appeals before the Supreme Court, confined by the appellants to the private plots (CA No. 9363 of 2011). Proceedings revealed that redevelopment work had already commenced, permanent structures erected and a majority of slum dwellers relocated.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether contiguous municipal and private plots could lawfully be clubbed and treated as a single “slum area” for purposes of an SRA redevelopment scheme.
  2. Whether a valid, duly verified Annexure II (the list of eligible occupants and their consent) existed for the private plots.
  3. Consequently, whether the statutory/Regulatory requirement of consent from at least 70% of eligible slum dwellers had been met.
  4. Whether the SRA or only the competent authority had jurisdiction to act on Annexure II and grant final approval.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • Slums on private and municipal plots were illegally merged; each category should constitute a separate slum area, enabling residents of private plots to undertake an independent redevelopment through their own co-operative.
  • No valid Annexure II existed for private plots; the Deputy Collector’s verification showed only 25% consent—far below the mandated 70%.
  • By treating merged consent figures, the authorities diluted appellants’ rights and wrongly presumed the 70% threshold was achieved.

Respondent 10 (Slum Society)

  • Cited the same statutory provisions to submit that ownership is irrelevant; contiguous plots form one viable slum area under the Development Control Regulations, 1991 (DCR).
  • With lawful merger, the composite consent calculation (81.32%) satisfied the 70% rule.
  • High-Powered Committee and High Court found a duly verified Annexure II covering private plots.

Respondent 8 (Owner-cum-Developer)

  • Emphasised statutory recognition of owners in Appendix IV (DCR 33(10)), asserting no illegality in granting approval where the owner had consented.

Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA)

  • Argued that a slum is area-specific, not plot-specific (Section 4, 1971 Act); therefore clubbing contiguous land is permissible.
  • Clauses 1.3, 1.15, 3.14, 7.7 and 7.8 of Appendix IV explicitly allow amalgamation and common consent over a “viable stretch”.

Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai

  • Submitted that Development Control Regulations framed under Section 159 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 are binding; the impugned scheme adhered to them.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Om Sai Darshan Coop. Housing Society v. State of Maharashtra, 2006 SCC OnLine Bom 480 Approval of Annexure II vests in the competent authority, not the SRA. Accepted as correct in principle; distinguished because Annexure II here had been verified by the competent authority, and the later clubbing decision lay within SRA’s remit.
Pramila Suman Singh v. State of Maharashtra, (2009) 2 SCC 729 In that case, composite declaration over private and municipal land was invalid owing to absence of Annexure II and other deficiencies. Held inapplicable; facts materially different—Annexure II existed and consent threshold was satisfied in the present matter.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court systematically addressed each contention:

  1. Existence and Validity of Annexure II: Documentary evidence (Annexure P-6) showed a verified list of 124 occupants for private plots. Appellants themselves pleaded its existence. No prayer had been made before the High Court to quash it. Hence, the allegation of non-existence failed.
  2. 70% Consent Requirement: Once municipal and private plots were rightly amalgamated, aggregate consent stood at 81.32%; the Deputy Collector’s earlier objection (25% on private plots) was based on a mistaken assumption that ownership required segregation.
  3. Legality of Clubbing Plots: The Court interpreted Clause 1.15 of Appendix IV—“slum or pavement in a viable stretch at one place”—to apply equally to slums and pavements. Clauses 3.14, 7.7 and 7.8 further authorise natural amalgamation and combined development. Section 4 of the 1971 Act defines slum with reference to an area, not individual plots. Therefore, treating contiguous municipal and private lands as one slum area was lawful.
  4. Jurisdictional Challenge: While competence to verify Annexure II lies with the designated authority, strategic decisions on whether consent suffices for the unified slum area fall within SRA’s statutory powers under the amended 1966 Act, 1888 Act and the 1971 Act.
  5. Equitable Considerations: Substantial redevelopment had already progressed; 82% of 443 dwellers had consented, many had relocated, and 26 appellants settled during the litigation. The Court stressed that beneficial schemes should not be derailed by technical objections absent demonstrable legal injury.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED. The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s judgment and the High-Powered Committee’s order, thereby upholding:

  • The legality of amalgamating private and municipal plots into a single slum area for redevelopment.
  • The validity of Annexure II and the finding that the 70% consent threshold was achieved.

Implications: The decision reinforces the statutory interpretation that “slum area” is area-centric rather than plot-centric and confirms that Development Control Regulations, particularly Appendix IV, permit clubbing of contiguous lands irrespective of ownership. It provides precedent for future SRA projects, signalling judicial reluctance to obstruct rehabilitation schemes on purely procedural grounds when substantive statutory requirements and majority consent are met.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Balasaheb Arjun Torbole And Others v. Administrator And Divisional Commissioner And Others

    Shiva Kirti Singh, J.— These civil appeals are directed against the judgment of the Bombay High Court dated 31-8-2010 passed in Balasaheb Arjun Torbole v. Administrator and Divl. Commr. Balasaheb Arjun Torbole v. Administrator and Divl. Commr., 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 1279 and dated 10-8-2010 passed in Arun V. Sapkal v. Collector Arun V. Sapkal v. Collector WP C No. 316 of 2010, order dated 10-8-2010 Bom respectively whereby the writ petitions preferred by the appellants were dismissed. For the sake of brevity facts have been taken from CA No. 9363 of 2011. The High Court negatived all the five contentions advanced on behalf of the appellants and upheld the order dated 17-4-2010 passed by the High-Powered Committee of the Government of Maharashtra dismissing Appeal No. 62 of 2010 preferred by the appellants to challenge the sanction of a scheme by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority of lands bearing CTS Nos. 106, 106/1 to 5, 107/1 to 9, 108 (Part), 111 (Part), 111/1 to 77, 80 to 132 and 112 (Part) of Village Kurla, Hutatma Prabhakar Keluskar Marg (Match Factory Lane), Kurla (West), Mumbai and also the orders for their eviction from the private lands.

    2. On behalf of the appellants, only CA No. 9363 of 2011 was argued at length by the learned Advocate Mr Sanjay Parikh. He made it clear that this appeal relates not to the municipal plots but only to private plots which are owned privately bearing Plot Nos. 106, 107 and 108. It is the appellants' case that a total of 124 families occupied dwellings in the slums existing over said plots. According to Mr Parikh the respondent authorities committed error of law in treating the slum area over municipal plots and those over private plots as one slum area. This, according to Mr Parikh, deprived the slum residents over private plots of having their own redevelopment activity limited to private plots as per the wishes of 70% of its occupants. As per his submission, by illegally declaring a common slum area over two different kinds of lands, one owned by municipal authority and the other by private persons, the rights of the petitioners to have their own say has been diluted and adversely affected. In other words, the major grievance of the appellants is that the respondents have wrongly treated that there exists a consent for redevelopment from 70% of the occupants. Such claim, according to the appellants, must be rejected and the appellants should be allowed to have the redevelopment through a cooperative of occupants of private plots exclusively. The other contention of the appellants is that there does not exist any valid Annexure II with respect to the private plots.

    3. On the other hand, Mr Shyam Divan, Senior Advocate, appearing for Respondent 10 relied upon the very same legal provisions which were highlighted by Mr Parikh to submit that there is no requirement in law to divide a slum area on the basis of nature of ownership of the plots concerned and since the private plots and municipal plots are contiguous, hence, for the purpose of redevelopment, slum over both was rightly treated as one slum area and the same is permissible under the regulations. As a corollary, it was submitted that if the so-called merger is permissible then the requirement of consent of 70% of the occupants stands fully complied. It was further submitted that as a fact the High-Powered Committee and the High Court have found that there exists valid Annexure II issued even in respect of slums over private plots.

    4. Mr C.A Sundaram, Senior Advocate, appearing for Respondent 8 who is the developer as well as owner of private lands, highlighted the rights and liabilities of owners of land declared as slum area and submitted that there was no violation of law in grant of approval to the rehabilitation scheme in the instant case to which Respondent 8 had given his consent. Mr Sishodia, Senior Advocate appearing for the Slum Rehabilitation Authority as well as Mr Atul Chitale, Senior Advocate for Respondent 12 Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai also defended the action of the authorities as well as order of the High Court upholding the decision taken by the High-Powered Committee.

    5. The relevant facts and relief sought by the appellants can very usefully be culled out from paras 1, 2 and 3 of the judgment under appeal: (Balasaheb Arjun Torbole case, SCC OnLine Bom)

    1. “What is challenged in this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is the order dated 17-4-2010 of the High-Powered Committee of the Government of Maharashtra, dismissing Appeal No. 62 of 2010 of the present petitioners. In the appeal, the petitioners challenged the sanction of a scheme by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority on lands bearing CTS Nos. 106, 106/1 to 5, 107/1 to 9, 108 (pt), 111 (pt), 111/1 to 77, 80 to 132 and 112 (pt) of Village Kurla, Hutatma Prabhakar Keluskar Marg (Match Factory Lane), Kurla (West), Mumbai. A letter of intent was issued for the whole plot on 29-4-2006. Out of the above plots, Plot Nos. 106, 107 and 108 are the plots in question which were earlier owned by Respondent 8 and were subsequently declared as slums. The other lands are of the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai. The petitioners herein are residents in the slums on private plots owned by Respondent 8.
    2. The competent authority declared the above private plots as well as Mumbai Municipal Corporation plots to be slum areas under Section 4(1) of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (for short ‘the Slum Act’) by a Notification dated 29-1-2003. The slum dwellers residing on both municipal plots and private plots formed a society in the name of Respondent 10 and requested Respondent 8 to implement the Slum Scheme. Respondent 8 is owner-cum-developer and Respondent 10 being their developer as per their own proposal to the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (for short ‘SRA’). On 30-6-2004, the competent authority decided the eligibility of the slum dwellers of the private plots and held that out of the occupants of 124 structures, occupants of 76 structures were eligible and that out of those, only 19 had given consent which amounted to 25%. Thereupon, on 13-1-2004, the respondent Municipal Corporation issued Annexure II for BMC plots certifying that out of 367 slum dwellers, 251 were eligible and all of them have given their consent which represented 100% of the eligible slum dwellers. Since there was one proposal submitted by Respondents 8 and 10 for both the plots i.e BMC plots and private plots, the officers of SRA prepared a report and on taking the consent of the slum dwellers of both BMC plots and private plots, came to the conclusion that the consent was given by 81.32% of the slum dwellers of all the plots taken together for which one common scheme was submitted. On 29-6-2006, SRA approved the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme and issued a letter of intent in favour of Respondents 8 and 10. On 14-2-2007, SRA approved the building plans for composite development of the municipal plots as well as private plots. On 9-9-2009, SRA issued a revised letter of intent with a condition that Respondents 8 and 10 shall rehabilitate all eligible slum dwellers as held by the competent authority/Municipal Corporation. Condition No. 23 of the letter of intent provides that individual agreements of at least 70% of the eligible slum dwellers shall be submitted prior to the commencement certificate.
    3. In the meantime, the petitioners who are residents in the slums on the private plots, were not shifting to the transit tenements. The Deputy Collector, Kurla issued show-cause notices to the petitioners and after hearing them, passed the impugned order dated 25-5-2009 under Sections 33 and 38 of the Slum Act requiring the petitioners to vacate the slums. Aggrieved by the said order, the petitioners filed an appeal before the appellate authority viz. Divisional Commissioner, Konkan Division, Mumbai who dismissed the appeal on 13-8-2009 after hearing the petitioners. The petitioners thereafter filed a writ petition before this Court and the petitioners were relegated the alternative remedy for filing an appeal before the Committee. The petitioners, accordingly, filed Appeal No. 62 of 2010 before the High-Powered Committee on 15-3-2010. The High-Powered Committee issued notice to the respondents and Respondents 8 and 10 filed their reply. The petitioners as well as Respondents 8 and 10 filed their written statement. After the hearing concluded on 17-4-2010, by an order dated 17-4-2010, the High-Powered Committee dismissed the appeal. Hence the present writ petition which came to be filed on 17-8-2010.”

    6. At the outset it is deemed proper to take note of the relevant legal provisions. Sections 2(15) and 2(19) of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short “the 1966 Act”) define “local authority” and “planning authority” in following terms:

    “2. (15) ‘local authority’ means—
    (a) the Bombay Municipal Corporation constituted under the Bombay Municipal Corporation Act, or the Nagpur Municipal Corporation constituted under the City of Nagpur Municipal Corporation Act, 1948, or any Municipal Corporation constituted under the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949,
    (b) a Council and a Nagar Panchayat constituted under the Maharashtra Municipal Councils, Nagar Panchayats and Industrial Township Act, 1965.
    (c) (i) a Zila Parishad constituted under the Maharashtra Zila Parishads and Panchayat Samitis Act, 1961,
    (ii) the Authority constituted under the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Act, 1976,
    (iii) the Nagpur Improvement Trust constituted under the Nagpur Improvement Trust Act, 1936,
    which is permitted by the State Government for any area under its jurisdiction to exercise the powers of a Planning Authority under this Act;
    (19) ‘Planning Authority’ means a local authority; and shall include—
    (a) a Special Planning Authority constituted or appointed or deemed to have been appointed under Section 40; and
    (b) in respect of the slum rehabilitation area declared under Section 3-C of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Mah Act 28 of 1971), the Slum Rehabilitation Authority appointed under Section 3-A of the said Act;”

    It is relevant to note that “Planning Authority” not only means a local authority but also includes by reference, the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) appointed under Section 3-A of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (for short “the 1971 Act”) in respect of a slum rehabilitation area.

    7. The power available to the Planning Authority to modify final development plan under sub-section (1) of Section 37 of the 1966 Act has also been now vested in the SRA appointed under Section 3-A of the 1971 Act by adding sub-section (1-B) to Section 37 through an amendment of 1996. This sub-section reads as follows:

    “37. (1-B) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), if the Slum Rehabilitation Authority appointed under Section 3-A of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Mah Act 28 of 1971) is satisfied that a modification of any part of, or any proposal made in, a final Development Plan is required to be made for implementation of the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme declared under the said Act, then, it may publish a notice in the Official Gazette, and in such other manner as may be determined by it, inviting objections and suggestions from any person with respect to the proposed modification not later than one month from the date of such notice; and shall also serve notice on all persons affected by the proposed modification, and after giving a hearing to any such persons, submit the proposed modification (with amendments, if any) to the State Government for sanction.”

    8. The Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act, 1888 was also amended in 1996 to insert Section 354-AAA which enables vesting of power of the Commissioner and the Corporation relating to building regulations, etc. in the SRA appointed under the 1971 Act. It reads as follows:

    “354-AAA. Empowerment of Slum Rehabilitation Authority for implementation of Slum Rehabilitation Scheme.—Notwithstanding anything contained in any other provisions of this Act, the State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, direct that the powers of the Commissioner under this Chapter and the powers of the Corporation and the Committees of the Corporation under this Act, if any, relating to building regulations and matters ancillary or consequential thereto, shall be exercised by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority appointed under the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Mah Act 28 of 1971), for the slum rehabilitation area declared under that Act.”

    9. The Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 was enacted to make better provision for the improvement and clearance of slum areas in the State and their redevelopment and for the protection of occupiers from eviction and distress warrants. Its following provisions are deemed relevant and, therefore, reproduced hereinbelow:

    “2. (ga) ‘slum area’ means any area declared as such by the competent authority under sub-section (1) of Section 4 and includes any area deemed to be a slum area under Section 4-A;
    (h) ‘slum clearance’ means the clearance of any slum area by the demolition and removal of buildings therefrom;
    (h-a) ‘slumlord’ means a person, who illegally takes possession of any lands (whether belonging to Government, local authority or any other person) or enters into or creates illegal tenancies or leave and licence agreements or any other agreements in respect of such lands, or who constructs unauthorised structures thereon for sale or hire, or gives such lands to any persons on rental or leave and licence basis for construction, or use and occupation, of unauthorised structures, or who knowingly gives financial aid to any persons for taking illegal possession of such lands, or for construction of unauthorised structures thereon, or who collects or attempts to collect from any occupiers of such lands rent, compensation or other charges by criminal intimidation, or who evicts or attempts to evict any such occupiers by force without resorting to the lawful procedure, or who abets in any manner the doing of any of the abovementioned things;
    (h-b) ‘slum rehabilitation area’ means a slum rehabilitation area, declared as such under sub-section (1) of Section 3-C by the competent authority in pursuance of the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme notified under Section 3-B;
    (h-c) ‘Slum Rehabilitation Authority’ means the Slum Rehabilitation Authority or Authorities appointed by the State Government under Section 3-A;
    (h-d) ‘Slum Rehabilitation Scheme’ means the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme notified under Section 3-B;”

    10. Section 3-A envisages a Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) for implementing slum rehabilitation schemes. Section 3-B provides for slum rehabilitation scheme. The power to frame a general rehabilitation scheme is vested in the State Government or the SRA concerned with the previous sanction of the State Government for rehabilitation of slums and hutment colonies in such areas. Section 3-C vests power in the Chief Executive Officer of the SRA concerned to declare an area as slum rehabilitation area if such declaration is found justified in the light of an already published Slum Rehabilitation Scheme. Section 3-C runs as follows:

    “3-C. Declaration of a slum rehabilitation area.—(1) As soon as may be after the publication of the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, the Chief Executive Officer on being satisfied that circumstances exist in respect of any area, justifying its declaration as slum rehabilitation area under the said Scheme, may by an order published in the Official Gazette, declare such area to be a ‘slum rehabilitation area’. The order declaring slum rehabilitation area (hereinafter referred to as ‘the slum rehabilitation order’) shall also be given wide publicity in such manner as may be specified by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority.
    (2) Any person aggrieved by the slum rehabilitation order may, within four weeks of the publication of such order prefer an appeal to the Special Tribunal; and the decision of the Special Tribunal shall be final.
    (3) On the completion of the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, the slum rehabilitation area shall cease to be such area.”

    11. The other relevant provisions of the 1971 Act include Section 4 which vests power in the competent authority to declare an area to be a slum area. Against such declaration in the Official Gazette, appeal is provided to the tribunal provided it is filed within 30 days. The competent authority under the Act has also been vested with power under Section 11 to declare any slum area to be a clearance area from which buildings found to be not fit for human habitation may be cleared in accordance with the provisions of the Act. It is not in dispute that for its own lands the Bombay Municipal Corporation has been appointed as the competent authority under Section 3 of the 1971 Act. For private lands, the Deputy Collector (Encroachment) concerned has been appointed as the competent authority.

    12. The Bombay Municipal Corporation has framed the Development Control Regulations for Greater Bombay under the provisions of Section 159 of the 1966 Act. These Development Control Regulations for Greater Mumbai, 1991 (for brevity “DCR”) came into force on 25-3-1991. Regulation 33(10) was inserted later in 1997. Its salient features are as follows:

    “I. Eligibility for Redevelopment Scheme.—(a) For redevelopment of slums including pavements, whose inhabitants' names and structures appear in the electoral roll prepared with reference to 1-1-1995 or a date prior thereto, but where the inhabitants stay at present in the structure, the provisions of Appendix IV shall apply on the basis of a tenement in exchange for an independently numbered structure.
    (b) Subject to the foregoing provisions, only the actual occupants of the hutment shall be held eligible and the so-called structure-owner other than the actual occupant, if any, even if his name is shown in the electoral roll for the structure, shall have no right whatsoever to the reconstructed tenement against that structure.
    II. Definition of slum, pavement and structure of hut.—(i) For this purpose, slums shall mean those censused, or declared and notified, in the past or hereafter under the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971. Slum shall also mean areas/pavement stretches hereafter notified as slum rehabilitation areas.
    (ii) If any area fulfils the conditions laid down in Section 4 of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 to qualify as slum area and has been censused or declared and notified shall be deemed to be and treated as slum rehabilitation areas.
    (ii) Slum rehabilitation area shall also mean any area declared as such by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority though preferably fulfilling conditions laid down in Section 4 of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 to qualify as slum areas and/or required for implementation of any slum rehabilitation project. Any area where a project under Slum Rehabilitation Scheme has been approved by CEO/SRA shall be deemed slum rehabilitation area.
    (iv) Any area required or proposed for the purpose of construction of temporary or permanent transit camps and so approved by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority shall also be deemed to be and treated as slum rehabilitation areas and projects approved in such areas by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority shall be deemed to be Slum Rehabilitation Projects.
    (v) A pavement shall mean any Municipal/Government/semi-government pavement and shall include any viable stretch of the pavement as may be considered viable for the purpose of Slum Rehabilitation Scheme.
    (vi) A structure shall mean all the dwelling areas of all persons who were enumerated as living in that one numbered house in the electoral roll of the latest date, up to 1-1-1995 and regardless of the number of persons, or location of rooms or access.
    (vii) A composite building shall mean a building comprising both rehab and free sale components or parts thereof in the same building.
    (viii) Censused shall mean those slums located on lands belonging to Government, any undertaking of Government, or Brihan Mumbai Municipal Corporation and incorporated in the records of the land owning authority as having been censused in 1976, 1980 or 1985 or prior to 1-1-1995.
    III. Joint ownership with spouse.—The reconstructed tenement shall be of the ownership of the hutment dweller and spouse conjointly, and shall be so entered and be deemed to be so entered in the records of the cooperative housing society, including the share certificates or all other relevant documents.
    IV. Denotification as slum rehabilitation area.—Slum Rehabilitation Authority on being satisfied that it is necessary so to do, or when directed by the State Government, shall denotify the slum rehabilitation area.”

    13. Appendix IV contains various guidelines as indicated in Regulation 33(10) and some of the relevant guidelines are extracted hereinbelow:

    “Right of the hutment dwellers
    1.1 Hutment dwellers, in the slum or on the pavement eligible in accordance with the provisions of Development Control Regulation 33(10) shall, in exchange for their structure, be given free of cost a residential tenement having a carpet area of [20.90 sq m (225 sq ft)] including balcony, bath and water closet, but excluding common areas.
    1.3 All eligible hutment dwellers taking part in the slum rehabilitation scheme shall have to be rehabilitated according to the provisions in this Appendix. It may be in situ and in the same plot as far as possible.
    1.7 The individual agreement entered into between hutment dweller and the owner/developer/cooperative housing society/NGO shall be in the joint names of pramukh hutment dweller and spouse for every structure.
    1.15 Where 70% or more of the eligible hutment dwellers in a slum or pavement in a viable stretch at one place agree to join a rehabilitation scheme, it may be considered for approval:
    Provided that nothing contained herein shall apply to slum rehabilitation projects undertaken by the State Government or public authority or as the case may be a government company as defined in Section 617 of the Companies Act, 1956 and being owned and controlled by the State Government.
    2. Building permission for Slum Rehabilitation Projects.—
    2.1 The proposal for each slum rehabilitation project shall be submitted to the Slum Rehabilitation Authority with all the necessary documents, no-objection certificates, and the plans as may be decided by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority from time to time.
    2.2 The approval to the project shall be given by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority within a period of 30 days from the date of submission of all relevant documents. In the event of a failure by Slum Rehabilitation Authority to do so, the said approval shall be deemed to have been given, provided the project is in accordance with the provisions in this Appendix.
    3.14 Amalgamation/Sub-division of plots and balancing of FSI thereon.—Any land declared as slum rehabilitation area or on which slum rehabilitation project has been sanctioned, if it is spread on part or parts of CS Nos. or CTS Nos. or S. Nos. shall be treated as natural amalgamation/sub-division(s) of that CS or CTS or S. No. or FP No. for which no separate approval for amalgamation/sub-division of land would be necessary.
    3.16 The Chief Executive Officer, Slum Rehabilitation Authority may if required adjust the boundary of the plot declared as slum rehabilitation area so as to suit the building design and provide proper access to the Project.
    7.7 Wherever slum and municipal/Mhada property are found together or adjoining it would be eligible for redevelopment using provisions of both DCR 33(7) and DCR 33(10). Development of slum and contiguous non-slum area under any other provisions of Regulations may be allowed together in order to promote flexibility of design as well as to raise more resources, provided that the FSI of non-slum quantum of area shall be restricted to that permissible in the surrounding zone inclusive of admissible TDR on non-slum area. Such a project shall be deemed to be a slum rehabilitation project and plans for non-slum area including the plans for admissible TDR shall be approved by CEO, SRA. The power under DC Regulation 11(4) for shifting and/or interchanging the purpose of designations/reservations shall be exercised by the Chief Executive Officer, Slum Rehabilitation Authority in respect of slum rehabilitation areas/projects.
    7.8 In case of two or more number of slums taken up for development by same owner/developer/NGO/cooperative society of the slum dwellers, both rehab and free sale components of the said slums can be combined and located in any proportion in those plots provided in any plot, the FSI does not exceed 2.5 subject to the condition that the said slums have the same ratio of rehab component to free sale component as laid down in the Clauses 3.3 to 3.5 of this Appendix.”

    14. Besides the statutory provisions and statutory Regulations of 1991 which have been modified from time to time, the authority concerned has also issued Guidelines for the Implementation of Slum Rehabilitation Scheme in Greater Mumbai and also circulars reflecting policy decisions. The Guidelines, inter alia, indicate the procedure for submission, processing and approval of slum rehabilitation schemes. For the purpose of deciding the controversy at hand Paras 2, 3, 4, 5, 8 and 11 of Clause IV relating to the procedure for submission indicate that 70% or more of the eligible hutment dwellers in a slum or pavement in a viable stretch at one place have to show their willingness to join slum rehabilitation scheme and come together to form cooperative society of all eligible hutment dwellers through a resolution to that effect. The chief promoter, office-bearers and the members of the proposed society should collect the necessary documents and get the plot surveyed/measured and prepare map of the plot showing slum structures with the help of surveyors attached to the Office of Additional Collector (Encroachment) or the Deputy Collector (Encroachment) of the zone.

    15. The procedure for submission, processing and approval of slum rehabilitation schemes also contains a guideline that by undertaking the survey, information of the proposed members/slum dwellers should also be collected and Annexure II prescribed by SRA should be filled up so as to give the details of land occupied by the slum dwellers, number and type of structures such as residential, industrial, etc. and the list of eligible and ineligible occupants and consent to join the scheme. The Guidelines also disclose that earlier the procedure of filling up Annexure II format was required to be carried on by competent authorities but by way of subsequent simplification of procedure it is now required to be filled up by the promoter/cooperative housing society itself for submitting building proposal to SRA. The decision to search a competent developer to act as a promoter can be taken up by the proposed cooperative housing society of slum dwellers but it has been clarified that the society itself or NGO/developer/owner can take up slum rehabilitation scheme as a promoter. The promoter has to appoint an architect to prepare the plans of the development of the slum area as per DCR 33(10). All required documents such as building plan, layout plan, etc. along with Annexure I, Annexure II and Annexure III are to be submitted to SRA by the architect along with the application for approval of the slum rehabilitation scheme. The proposal so submitted is subjected to a pre-scrutiny by a designated engineer of SRA to ensure that it is complete with all documents and then the proposals are accepted. Thereafter the scrutiny of Annexures I, II and III begins in different wings such as building permissions, eligibility certification and accounts and finance respectively.

    16. The Guidelines also indicate that Circular No. 4 dated 27-8-1997 had been issued by SRA to give details of the simplified procedure in the form of Appendix D. Inter alia, this Circular provides that in order to facilitate the disposal of slum rehabilitation schemes submitted for approval, the architect/developer or society bearers may submit Annexure II in duplicate, as prepared by them in the prescribed pro forma signed by owner/developer/CP/NGO. A copy of the same will be then forwarded to the competent authority for getting it certified. The proposal will be scrutinised on the basis of Annexure II submitted by the architect but approval will be on the basis of certified Annexure II from the competent authority and for this the SRA will follow up with the respective competent authority.

    17. While replying to the arguments of Mr Sanjay Parikh, counsel for the appellants in both the appeals, Mr Shyam Divan highlighted the basic facts first from the records of Civil Appeal No. 9147 of 2011 to show that Plot Nos. 106, 107 and 108 are the private plots concerned which are the subject-matter of Civil Appeal No. 9363 of 2011. The remaining plots i.e Plot Nos. 109 (pt), 110 (pt), 111 (pt) and 112 (pt) are the municipal plots concerned which are the subject-matter of the other civil appeal. His stand is that the Notification dated 13-2-2003, no doubt contained a declaration of slum area under Section 3 of the 1971 Act even in respect of plots of Municipal Corporation but that will not make any difference. He referred to various documents to point out that the plots concerned of Municipal Corporation were censused slum colony as per municipal records and hence they were covered under the definition of “slum” recognised under Regulation 33(10) which is part of Development Control Regulations for Greater Mumbai, 1991 (DCR). It was also pointed out that the Chief Executive Officer of SRA approved the slum development scheme covering the slum over municipal plots as well as private plots on 26-3-2006 resulting into issuance of letter of intent on 29-6-2006 and first intimation of approval (planning permission) on 14-2-2007. Thereafter only 6 persons preferred an appeal before the Maharashtra Slum Areas Tribunal with a prayer to quash the Notification dated 13-2-2003 containing declaration of slums in respect of municipal plots. This appeal bearing No. 22 of 2009 suffered from delay of 6 years which was not condoned by the Tribunal but while dismissing the same on 11-8-2009, the Tribunal noted the lacuna in the case of appellants that they had failed to support even their claim that they were residents of the municipal plots or that there did not exist any slum over the area and how they were affected by the declaration when the owner of the land, the Municipal Corporation, had no objection to such declaration with respect to its own land. The writ petition bearing No. 316 of 2010 preferred against the order of the Tribunal was dismissed by the order dated 10-8-2010, under appeal in Civil Appeal No. 9147 of 2011. The High Court noticed that out of 6 petitioners only Petitioner 1 was an occupant of structure over the Municipal Corporation land whereas Petitioners 2 to 4 resided on private lands and being not concerned with the municipal plots could not maintain the writ petition. With respect to Petitioner 1, the Court noticed that his name was included in Annexure II of the SRA scheme and he had accepted an amount of Rs 60,000 as rent in lieu of temporary transit accommodation and hence the High Court held that Petitioner 1 was estopped from challenging the notification declaring Municipal Corporation plot as slum area.

    18. No reply to the grounds mentioned by the High Court for dismissing the writ petition has been offered on behalf of the appellants in CA No. 9147 of 2011 and as noted earlier, Mr Parikh has confined his submissions and arguments only against SRA scheme for the private plots which is the subject-matter of CA No. 9363 of 2011. The main two contentions of Mr Parikh that there is no valid Annexure II for the private plots; and there was no valid consent of 70% of slum dwellers because the consent was not counted separately for residents of private plots have been addressed and replied at length.

    19. In respect of Annexure II, Mr Divan has placed reliance upon Annexure P-6 to CA No. 9363 of 2011 and some other materials from the very same record. He pointed out that in the synopsis, against the date 5-3-2004 the appellants have averred in following words:

    “Deputy Collector (E/I)-Chembur recorded the findings of his enquiry conducted on 20-11-2004 in the list of Annexure II that not a single person on private plots gave consent in favour of Jan Kalyan Society. A true and correct copy of the eligibility list of Annexure II as verified by the Deputy Collector (E/I)-Chembur, purportedly acting as competent authority, dated 5-3-2004 is Annexure P-6”.

    In continuation of the above the appellants have also averred that 17 residents were not present on 20-1-2004 and on the basis of their consents allegedly given in the year 2001, the Deputy Collector (E/R)-Chembur wrongly treated them to have given consent to the slum rehabilitation scheme. It was pointed out that the document Annexure P-6 dated 5-3-2004 bears the signature of the Deputy Collector concerned and discloses a verified list of 124 persons containing all the required details including consent, etc. and on that basis it has been submitted that the appellants' contention that there exists no Annexure II for the private plots is against their own pleadings and contrary to records. By referring to the prayers made in the writ petition, it was also shown that there was no prayer to set aside or quash Annexure II for the private plots.

    20. The appellants have failed to produce any worthwhile material to show that there was no Annexure II submitted before the SRA or that there was no verification made by the competent authority. The records clearly disclose that there was an objection raised by the verifying authority that only 25% slum dwellers of private plots have consented to the rehabilitation scheme and not the 70% as required by the Regulations and the Guidelines. However, such objection was considered and overruled by the competent authority under the 1971 Act by holding that there was no illegality or error in clubbing the adjoining municipal plots and private plots and treating the same as a slum area and permitting slum rehabilitation scheme for such slum area in aggregate as consent of 70% of the slum dwellers was found existing. In such a situation, we do not find merit in the stand of the appellants that their writ petition should have been allowed on the ground that there was no Annexure II available for the private plots.

    21. When in aggregate consent of 70% or more slum dwellers has been obtained, the essential purpose of slum rehabilitation scheme cannot be put to peril on the ground that certain procedures were not strictly followed or some steps were against the procedures prescribed in the guidelines for preparation of Annexure II in a prescribed format. From the documents submitted and shown at the stage of hearing it has been noticed that even subsequent claims of some slum dwellers that they are eligible for rehabilitation have been verified and many have been allowed on the basis of relevant documents because it is not infrequent that at the time of one particular checking or verification some dwellers may be absent and might have gone to some other place. Clearly the process of preparation of the list described as Annexure II and its verification is meant to find out the claims of genuine slum dwellers who may be eligible for benefits under the slum rehabilitation scheme. Such beneficial provisions meant to ameliorate the poor condition of slum dwellers, in our considered view, should not be jettisoned only on technical grounds or procedural infirmities unless the persons coming to the court and seeking relief through writ petition are able to show that they have suffered injustice or legal injury.

    22. In the present case, the only legal injury to the appellants as per submissions of Mr Parikh is that if the private plots were treated as a separate slum area, the residents of these plots alone could have formed and carried out development scheme through their own cooperative society and gained some advantages including monetary. Such a plea is too far-fetched to establish legal injury to the appellants who claim to be slum dwellers and on such plea, in our considered view the appellants could not have been granted relief in writ jurisdiction which has been rightly denied to them, albeit for other reasons, after considering all their pleas on merits.

    23. The only other substantial issue raised by Mr Parikh that there could have been no clubbing of private lands with municipal lands for purpose of counting consent of 70% of the slum dwellers is also found to be without any merits. Mr Divan rightly relied upon the DCR 1991 and particularly Clause 1.15 of Appendix IV which clearly shows that 70% or more of the eligible hutment dwellers in a slum or pavement in a viable stretch at one place can agree to join a rehabilitation scheme. There is no merit in the submission on behalf of the appellants that the clause “in a viable stretch at one place” should be read only in conjunction with the word “pavement” and not the word “slum” although the use of the word “or” between slum and pavement clearly shows both have to be treated at same footing and therefore both are qualified by the clause “in a viable stretch at one place”. Clause 3.14 providing for amalgamation/sub-division of plots of Appendix IV of the DCR 1991 also goes a long way to support the submission that the statutory provisions clearly permit natural amalgamation/sub-division of plots for the sanction of slum rehabilitation project as well as for planning of floor space index (FSI) thereto. Clauses 7.7 and 7.8 in the same Appendix D lend further support to the aforesaid arguments of Mr Divan.

    24. Although it is not directly related to issues under consideration already noticed earlier, Mr Sundaram has placed reliance on several provisions of Appendix IV noted above which is part of the DCR 1991 to highlight that in respect of private plots the owner has been given a recognition and role. The relevant provisions to support the aforesaid submission are in the introductory Para 1 of Appendix IV as well as in the Schedule annexed to the general slum rehabilitation scheme notified by the Government of Maharashtra in the Gazette dated 9-4-1998. The relevant provisions such as 2(B) and 11(B) and (C) do show that the owner can also be the developer for implementing slum rehabilitation scheme and before carrying out the redevelopment work of the slum located over private lands, the consent of owner is required otherwise in given circumstances the Government will have to acquire such land if slum rehabilitation scheme is to be implemented.

    25. Mr Shishodia, learned Senior Advocate for the Slum Rehabilitation Authority also placed reliance upon Section 4 of the 1971 Act to submit that slum contemplated under the Act is over an area and not plot and that the plot numbers are relevant only for the limited purpose of identification of the area over which a slum may be found existing. He supported the submission of Mr Divan by referring to Clauses 1.3 and 1.15 of Appendix IV of the DCR 1991. According to him, the use of the term “… in the same plot as far as possible” in Clause 1.3 supports the interpretation advanced by Mr Divan to the expression “in a viable stretch at one place” in Clause 1.15 and these provisions, according to him, go to show that a slum is not plot specific but area specific and hence there is nothing wrong in the action of SRA in treating the contiguous area comprising of municipal plots as well as private plots as a slum area and approving a slum rehabilitation scheme for the same after ascertaining that consent of at least 70% of the residents of such slum area was available in favour of the rehabilitation scheme.

    26. In our considered view, the submissions advanced by Mr Divan, Mr Sundaram and Mr Shishodia deserve to be accepted as having merit. Mr Atul Chitale, learned Senior Advocate for the Municipal Corporation has referred to Section 159 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 for showing that it vests power to make regulations and, therefore, the Development Control Regulations framed under such statutory provision have to be followed by the authorities concerned and such regulations providing for eligibility for redevelopment scheme, definitions of slum, qualification as slum area on account of being censused or declared as such, their treatment as deemed slum rehabilitation areas, etc. cannot be ignored by the authorities concerned be it the Municipal Corporation or the SRA until a particular provision is challenged and found to be ultra vires on account of lack of power to frame the regulations or conflict with any superior law. According to Mr Chitale, in the present case the authorities have acted in accordance with law and, therefore, neither the Committee nor the High Court found it fit to interfere with the approved rehabilitation scheme which will benefit all the slum dwellers of the slum area comprising of lands belonging to the Municipal Corporation as well as private lands and for which consent of more than 70% of such slum dwellers was found available after proper verification.

    27. In view of the discussions made above and on finding merit in the submissions advanced on behalf of the respondents we record our agreement with the views expressed by the High Court that there is no illegality in clubbing of private land and Municipal Corporation land for declaring a contiguous area as a slum area for the purposes of approving a slum rehabilitation scheme for such area. As discussed earlier, we find no merit in the submission on behalf of the appellants that the required particulars were not compiled and were not available in the form of Annexure II for the private lands or it led to illegality and vitiated the approval of the particular slum rehabilitation scheme for the slum area in question. In our view, the authorities had verified the particulars contained in Annexure II and thereafter they were entitled to treat the entire slum area existing over private lands as well as Municipal Corporation lands as one slum area and since consent of 70% or more of slum dwellers of such area was available, the authorities did not commit any illegality so as to vitiate the grant of approval for slum development scheme in question.

    28. The appellants have relied upon the judgment of the Bombay High Court in Om Sai Darshan Coop. Housing Society v. State of Maharashtra 2006 SCC OnLine Bom 480 in support of the proposition stated in para 15 of that judgment that so far as grant of approval to Annexure II is concerned, the power vests in the competent authority and not in the SRA. There is no quarrel with the aforesaid proposition. In this case the facts reveal that Annexure II was verified by the competent authority and it found after verification that only 25% of the slum dwellers over private plots had given their consent for the rehabilitation scheme. The opinion regarding adequacy of consent and its legal implications in the context of a larger slum area extending to private as well as municipal lands was beyond the competence of the authority having power to verify the actual state of affairs in respect of particulars of Annexure II. The opinion of the competent verifying or certifying authority that consent was only of 25% slum dwellers was based upon a wrong premise that the slum area was required to be divided in at least 2 parts, based upon ownership of the lands comprising the entire slum area. This view was rightly not accepted by the SRA. When the entire slum area was treated as one slum area on which more than 70% slum dwellers were found to have given their consent, there was no legal impediment in acting upon the particulars already verified as per Annexure II available with the authorities. Hence in the facts of the case the judgment noted above does not help the appellants.

    29. Mr Parikh, has also placed reliance upon a judgment of this Court in Pramila Suman Singh v. State of Maharashtra 2009 2 SCC 729 in support of the proposition that a composite slum area could not be declared as such when it covered private lands as well as Municipal Corporation lands. The facts of that case were quite different and as noted in para 29, the SRA had rejected the plan of the appellant of that case for as many as five reasons including the reason that the appellant had not submitted proper Annexure II. In para 52 this Court had recorded its satisfaction that the appellant had not annexed Annexure II in respect of the plot concerned along with her original application and therefore this Court found no legal infirmity in the impugned order of the authority. Clearly the issue decided in that case was quite different and hence the judgment is not of any help to the appellants in this case. It may however be useful to note that in para 50 this Court made observations to the effect that (i) Annexure II may not have any statutory force as it was a requirement under the Guidelines, and (ii) a conformity with the Guidelines is required to be maintained unless the Guidelines are found to be ultra vires. In the context of facts of the present case it is sufficient to observe that non-statutory provisions can hardly be treated as mandatory unless their non-observance is shown to have caused legal injury by affecting some valuable rights of the writ petitioners. As discussed earlier no such case could be made out by the appellants so as to require interference on account of alleged shortcomings in preparation or verification of Annexure II.

    30. The written submissions raise some other minor issues too but these were not raised before and decided by the High Court. Hence we refrain from going into such issues. It is, however, necessary to record that in the light of statutory provisions brought about through amendments in the 1966 Act and in the Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act, 1888 and in the light of provisions of the 1971 Act, the SRA was competent to approve the scheme by taking the required ancillary decisions.

    31. In the course of arguments, it has been shown to us by filing details of the appellant-petitioners that out of a total of 97, 60 are eligible and 33 non-eligible. Name of 4 petitioners i.e 90, 91, 93 and 97 are not in Annexure II to which several other persons have been added after further verification of later claims, during the pendency of the litigation. It has also been shown through a summary that pending the hearing of this appeal, 26 appellants have settled their dispute and handed over possession of their respective structures. The impugned judgment of the High Court also records in para 25 that out of a total of 443 slum dwellers, 82% slum dwellers had already given consent for redevelopment of the slum and redevelopment is going on by allotment of permanent alternative accommodation to the slum dwellers. Majority of occupants of the municipal plots as noted in the High Court judgment had vacated their structures long back. Photographs produced before us show that redevelopment activity is going on and permanent structures have come up on a large area. Such facts also, in our estimate, were rightly considered by the High Court as relevant for dismissing the writ petitions.

    32. In the result, we find no merit in the appeals and the same are dismissed but without any order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Balasaheb Arjun Torbole And Others v. Administrator And Divisional Commissioner And Others
    (Apr 1, 2015)