AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act
  • Section [no section number] of the [no act/article title]
  • Section 5-A(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (implied, but not explicitly mentioned)
  • (no specific act/article title mentioned)
  • Section 2(f) of the Act
  • Heading No. 2108 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985
  • Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act, 1944
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act
  • Section [no section number] of the [no act/article title]
  • Section 5-A(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (implied, but not explicitly mentioned)
  • (no specific act/article title mentioned)
  • Section 2(f) of the Act
  • Heading No. 2108 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985
  • Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act, 1944
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The assessee manufactures and markets a product called “Rice and Spice”, described as a mixture of raw rice, dehydrated vegetables and spices. A show-cause notice dated 4-8-1997 proposed to classify this product under Heading 21.08 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 (miscellaneous edible preparations). The Additional Commissioner, by order dated 17-3-1999, confirmed the demand after holding that the mixing process constituted “manufacture”. The Commissioner (Appeals) and thereafter the Customs, Excise & Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal (CEGAT) upheld that view by a final order dated 10-10-2002. The present civil appeal challenges CEGAT’s order before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the assessee’s process of blending raw rice with dehydrated vegetables and spices amounts to “manufacture” within the meaning of Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act, 1944.
  2. If not manufacture, whether the product is classifiable under Heading 11.01 (products of the milling industry attracting NIL duty) rather than Heading 21.08.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The process only involves mixing; no new commodity emerges and rice retains its essential character, remaining raw and requiring normal cooking.
  • Because there is no manufacture, no excise duty is leviable.
  • Under the Rules for Interpretation of the Tariff (Rule 3(b)), the essential character is given by rice; hence the product should fall under Heading 11.01 which carries nil duty.
  • Relied on judicial precedents (e.g., Crane Betel Nut, Laljee Godhoo, Pio Food Packers) to contend that mere value addition without change in essential character does not constitute manufacture.

Revenue’s Arguments

  • All authorities below have found that a commercially distinct product emerges; rice “does not remain rice at all” after blending.
  • Once a new edible preparation is created, excise duty is attracted and classification under Heading 21.08 is correct.
  • Transformation into a product known separately in the market satisfies the test of manufacture.

Table of Precedents Cited

PrecedentRule or Principle Cited ForApplication by the Court
Crane Betel Nut Powder Works v. CCE (2007) 4 SCC 155 Mere processing that does not change the essential character of the product is not manufacture. Used as primary authority to show that cutting, mixing and sweetening did not create a new commodity; analogy drawn to rice mixture.
CCE v. Laljee Godhoo & Co. (2015) 13 SCC 430 / (2001) 132 ELT 287 (Tri.) Compounding of asafoetida with additives did not amount to manufacture because essential character remained unchanged. Cited to reinforce that adding other substances without chemical reaction or character change is not manufacture.
CST v. Pio Food Packers 1980 Supp SCC 174 Processing must result in a commercially distinct article; mere slicing and canning fruit is not manufacture. Formed the conceptual foundation for applying the “commercially distinct article” test to the present facts.
Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd. AIR 1963 SC 791 Definition of manufacture requires transformation into a new article with distinctive name, character or use. Quoted (via Crane Betel Nut) to elucidate the transformation requirement.
Anwarkhan Mehboob Co. v. State of Bombay AIR 1961 SC 213 Example where processing produced a new commodity (raw tobacco into bidi patti). Referenced in Pio Food Packers to contrast cases where manufacture is found.
A. Hajee Abdul Shukoor & Co. v. State of Madras AIR 1964 SC 1729 Change in identity constitutes manufacture. Part of comparative survey in Pio Food Packers; distinguished.
State of Madras v. Swasthik Tobacco Factory AIR 1966 SC 1000 Processing raw tobacco into chewing tobacco constitutes manufacture. Cited within Pio Food Packers list; distinguished.
Ganesh Trading Co. v. State of Haryana (1974) 3 SCC 620 Paddy dehusked into rice—manufacture found. Referenced as contrast; not applicable because rice mixture retains identity.
Tungabhadra Industries Ltd. v. CTO AIR 1961 SC 412 Hydrogenated groundnut oil still groundnut oil; no manufacture. Supported assessee’s position that change in form alone insufficient.
CST v. Harbilas Rai & Sons (1968) 21 STC 17 (SC) Processed bristles retained original identity; no manufacture. Reinforced requirement of identity change.
East Texas Motor Freight Lines v. Frozen Food Express, 351 US 49 (1956) Dressed and frozen chicken not commercially distinct from original chicken. Cited in Pio Food Packers; used to counter argument that higher price implies new commodity.
Anheuser-Busch Brewing Assn. v. United States, 207 US 556 (1908) Defines manufacture as requiring transformation into an article with distinctive name, character or use. Quoted to articulate transformation test applied by Supreme Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court restated the settled principle that a process qualifies as “manufacture” only if it results in a new commercial commodity, the original product losing its identity. Surveying past jurisprudence, the Court emphasised that:

  • Value addition or improved marketability alone is irrelevant; the decisive factor is change in essential character.
  • Precedents such as Crane Betel Nut, Laljee Godhoo and Pio Food Packers illustrate that mere mixing, blending or minor processing does not constitute manufacture when the core identity persists.

Applying these principles, the Court found that:

  • The assessee’s product is still recognised and marketed as rice; cooking instructions on the pouch treat it as uncooked rice.
  • Addition of dehydrated vegetables and spices neither chemically transforms rice nor destroys its essential attributes.
  • Consequently, no new commodity emerges; the Tribunal’s contrary finding of transformation was erroneous.
  • Absence of manufacture obviates any excise duty liability. Even on classification, if manufacture is negated, the product remains one of the milling industry and appropriately falls under Heading 11.01 attracting NIL duty.

Holding and Implications

HELD: The appeal is allowed; the orders of CEGAT and the consequential excise duty demand are set aside.

Implications: The assessee owes no excise duty on “Rice and Spice”, and the product remains classifiable under Heading 11.01 at NIL rate. The decision reinforces existing jurisprudence that mixing or blending which leaves the original commodity’s identity intact does not amount to manufacture, but it does not create new precedent beyond affirming that settled principle.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Satnam Overseas Limited v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, New Delhi .

    Dr A.K. Sikri, J.— The appellant assessee challenges the correctness and validity of the final order dated 10-10-2002 (2003) 151 ELT 401 (Tri) passed by the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal (Cegat), New Delhi in the appeal which was preferred by the assessee against the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) who had upheld the order-in-original dated 17-3-1999 passed by the Additional Commissioner pursuant to the show-cause notice dated 4-8-1997 issued by him. In the said show-cause notice the Additional Commissioner had proposed to classify the product of the appellant assessee under Heading No. 2108 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, as miscellaneous edible preparation not elsewhere specified or included.

    2. It may be stated that the assessee is engaged in the packing combination of mixture of raw rice, dehydrated vegetables and spices in the name of “Rice and Spice”. The exact process which is taken note of by the Tribunal as explained by Cl. R.L. Mehta, Deputy General Manager of the assessee, is as follows:

    “This product i.e. Rice and Spice is a combination of raw rice, dehydrated vegetables and certain spices and condiments mixed in a predetermined proportion and that blended together in a mixer for uniformity and the blended mixer is heated, if required, to sterilise the product. The mixed product is then packed in pouches with Nitrogen flushing for a longer shelf life.”

    3. The defence put forth by the assessee to the show-cause notice issued by the Additional Commissioner was that the aforesaid process does not amount to “manufacture” within the meaning of Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act, 1944. It was also argued that, in any case, the product was not classifiable under Heading No. 2108 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 as claimed by the Revenue but it should be covered under Heading No. 11.01. That heading applies to products of the milling industry, including flours, groats, meal and grains of cereals, and flour, meal or flakes of vegetables on which nil duty is payable. It was, thus, contended that in no case the assessee was under any obligation to pay the duty on the aforesaid process.

    4. The Additional Commissioner did not agree with the contention of the assessee holding it to be a manufacturing process, and opinion of the Additional Commissioner is accepted by the Commissioner (Appeals) as well as by Cegat.

    5. Ms Charanaya, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant argued before us that the authorities committed serious error in holding the aforesaid process of the assessee as “manufacturing process”. Her argument was that from the reading of the process described above, it would be manifest that it only involved mixing of raw rice, dehydrated vegetables with some spice and did not bring about any new product. It was submitted that the aforesaid mixture, which is sold in a packaged form, is raw food and still needs to be cooked to make it edible. She pointed out that on the packing/pouch of the product even the cooking instructions are mentioned in the following manner:

    “All cooking appliances vary in performance, these are guidelines only. Empty contents into 375 ml (2/3 pints) of cold water, stir well. Add 1 tablespoon of butter or margarine. Bring to boil, uncovered, in a small saucepan. Reduce heat, cover the saucepan and simmer gently for approximately 15 minutes or until all water is absorbed.”

    6. It was further submitted that there was no new product which came into existence as that product was still known as rice which did not lose its essential character and therefore it could not be treated as “manufacture”. In support of the aforesaid submission Ms Charanaya referred to certain judgments which shall be discussed by us at the later stage.

    7. In support of her other submission viz. that the product would still be classified under Heading No. 11.01, the learned counsel referred to the “rule of interpretation” contained in the Schedule of Excise Tariff known as “Rules for the Interpretation of this Schedule”. In this behalf Rule 3 and in particular clause (b) thereof was pressed into service. Therefore it would be apposite to take note of this clause as well which we reproduce below:

    “3. When by application of sub-rule (b) of Rule 2 or for any other reason, goods are, prima facie, classifiable under two or more headings, classification shall be effected as follows:
    (a) The heading which provides the most specific description shall be preferred to headings providing a more general description. However, when two or more headings each refer to part only of the materials or substances contained in mixed or composite goods or to part only of the items in a set put up for retail sale, those headings are to be regarded as equally specific in relation to those goods, even if one of them gives a more complete or precise description of the goods.
    (b) Mixtures, composite goods consisting of different materials or made up of different components, and goods put up in sets for retail sale, which cannot be classified by reference to (a), shall be classified as if they consisted of the material or component which gives them their essential character, insofar as this criterion is applicable.
    (c) When goods cannot be classified by reference to (a) or (b), they shall be classified under the heading which occurs last in the numerical order among those which equally merit consideration.”

    8. Mr A.K. Sanghi, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the Revenue, countered the aforesaid submission by pointing out that a specific finding was arrived at by the Tribunal, affirming the finding of the quasi-judicial authorities below to the effect that a new product had come into existence as a result of the processes undertaken by the assessee. It was specifically held by Cegat that rice did not remain rice at all as a mixed product containing rice, vegetable and spices emerges after the specific process was undertaken by the assessee. He also referred to those observations of Cegat where it has remarked that there is a transformation of a new commodity commercially known as distinct and separate commodity having its own character, use and name. Be it the result of one process or several processes in fact “manufacture” had taken place. He, thus, argued that when a new commodity had come into existence as held by Cegat, this was the trigger point for the levy of excise duty under the Excise Act. He further submitted that in view of the aforesaid viz. coming into existence a new product, that particular edible product had to be fallen under Chapter 11 of the Tariff as it is not a product of milling industry not classifiable under Chapter 11 of the Tariff.

    9. From the aforesaid arguments advanced by the counsel on the either side, it is clear that there is no dispute about the legal proposition that the process would be treated as “manufacture” only if new product known to the market comes into existence with original product losing its original character.

    10. The only question is as to whether this test is satisfied on the facts of the present case. Before we embark on the discussion on this issue and answer the same, it would be advisable to take note of few judgments wherein legal position that prevails on this subject is stated with elaboration.

    11. The first judgment which we want to mention, which was cited by Ms Charanaya, is Crane Betel Nut Powder Works v. Commr. of Customs & Central Excise (2007) 4 SCC 155, (2007) 210 ELT 171. In the said case the assessee was engaged in the business of marketing betel nuts in different sizes after processing them by adding essential/non-essential oils, menthol, sweetening agent, etc. Initially, the assessee cleared the goods under Chapter Sub-Heading No. 2107 of the Central Excise Tariff and was paying duty accordingly. However, the assessee filed a revised classification declaration under Rule 173-B of the Central Excise Rules, 1944, with effect from 17-7-1997, claiming classification of its product under Chapter Sub-Heading No. 0801.00 of the Central Excise Tariff. It was contended by the assessee that the crushing of betel nuts into smaller pieces with the help of machines and passing them through different sizes of sieves to obtain goods of different sizes/grades and sweetening the cut pieces did not amount to manufacture in view of the fact that mere crushing of betel nuts into smaller pieces did not bring into existence a different commodity which had a distinct character of its own.

    12. Though the authorities below had decided against the assessee, this Court reversed the said view holding that the said process would not amount to “manufacture” as the process involving manufacture does not always result in the creation of a new product. In the instant case notwithstanding the manufacturing process, it could not be said that a transformation had taken place resulting in the formation of a new product. The relevant portion of the judgment is reproduced below: (Crane Betel Nut Powder Works case (2007) 4 SCC 155, (2007) 210 ELT 171)

    “31. In our view, the process of manufacture employed by the appellant Company did not change the nature of the end product, which in the words of the Tribunal, was that in the end product the ‘betel nut remains a betel nut’. The said observation of the Tribunal depicts the status of the product prior to manufacture and thereafter. In those circumstances, the views expressed in Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd. AIR 1963 SC 791 and the passage from the American judgment 207 US 556 (1908) become meaningful. The observation that manufacture implies a change, but every change of not manufacture and yet every change of an article is the result of treatment, labour and manipulation is apposite to the situation at hand. The process involved in the manufacture of sweetened betel nut pieces does not result in the manufacture of a new product as the end product continues to retain its original character though in a modified form.”

    What is to be highlighted is that even after the betel nuts which had been cut to different sizes and had undergone the process, the Court did not treat it as “manufacture” within the meaning of Section 2(f) of the Act on the ground that the end product was still a betel nut and there was no change in the essential character to that article even when it was the result of treatment, labour and manipulation, inasmuch as even after employing the same it had not resulted in the manufacture of a new product as the end product continued to retain its original character.

    13. Another judgment which was referred to by the learned counsel for the appellant is CCE v. Laljee Godhoo & Co. (2015) 13 SCC 430, (2007) 216 ELT 514 (SC) Vide this judgment the Court affirmed the view taken by Cegat, holding that the process of subjecting raw asafoetida (hing) resulting in formation of compounded asafoetida does not amount to manufacture, even when this process has undergone chemical change, because of the reason that the said chemical change had not brought even after it underwent a process, any new product as the product remained the same at starting and terminal points of the process. Though the exact process undertaken is not discernible from the judgment, the learned counsel pointed out that this process is described in the order passed by Cegat against which the appeal was preferred by the Department. The order of Cegat is reported in Laljee Godhoo & Co. v. CCE (2001) 132 ELT 287 (Tri). The process noted in the judgment of Cegat runs thus: (ELT p. 288, para 1)

    “1. … ‘The gum Arabic and wheat flour are blended in the sigma mixers. Filtered water mixed asafoetida is then poured slowly into the mixer over the gum and wheat flour. This gets the product ready. Further the resultant product is given a heat treatment by suction in pipes through which a heater is attached and the moisture is sucked out. The powder is then passed through a hammer mill where it is crushed thoroughly. This powder is then passed through a sieve, which contains magnet balls absorbing any fine iron particles. The compounded asafoetida in powder form is then packed in different grammage bottles. In case of lump form, the gum and wheat flour along with filtered water mixed with asafoetida is poured into the sigma mixer. This process takes about 40 minutes. After this the mixture, which has by now made into lumps, is extracted and put into the aluminium trays and dried for a day before it is packed in cartons.’”

    14. We would like to reproduce para 5 of the order of Cegat, since this judgment was upheld by this Court in the said case. This para is to the following effect: (Laljee Godhoo & Co. case (2001) 132 ELT 287 (Tri), ELT p. 288)

    “5. It is common ground that the processes to which the raw asafoetida is subjected, resulting in the lump or powder which is sold does not bring about any chemical change in the asafoetida. The process, as we have seen, is nothing more than the addition to the asafoetida of wheat flour and gum arabic. It is stated that gum arabic is added in order that the particles of the asafoetida and wheat flour adhere to each other. Neither the gum arabic nor the wheat flour reacts chemically with the asafoetida. The contention is that while the raw asafoetida itself is used in cases where its very strongly pungent flavour is required, for example, in the making of pickles and papad, it is compounded in order to render it more suitable for use in day-to-day cooking where a lighter flavour is desired. The essential character of the product therefore does not change. It is used in both its concentrated and blended form only as an addition to food preparation, flavouring agent or for the medicinal properties that it is reputed to possess.”

    Again the test which was applied was that essential character of the product did not change and, therefore, it would not amount to manufacture. It was so held even when gum arabic as well as wheat flour were mixed in the process. A pertinent aspect which was noted was that mixing of these articles did not result in chemical reaction with asafoetida.

    15. The last judgment to which we would like to refer to is CST v. Pio Food Packers 1980 Supp SCC 174, (1980) 6 ELT 343. In that case, the process undertaken by the assessee was to wash the pineapple, after purchase, and then remove inedible portion, the end crown as well as skin and inner core. After removing those inedible portions the pineapple fruit used to be sliced and the slices were filled in cans after adding sugar as preservative. Thereafter, cans would be sealed under temperature and then put in a boiled water for sterilisation. Identical question was posed viz. whether this process amounted to “manufacture”. Giving the answer in the negative, the Court held that even when with each process suffered, the original commodity experienced a change, such a change would not amount to “manufacture” unless it ceased to be the original commodity and a new and distinct article was produced therefrom. This is explained in detail in paras 5 and 6 of the said judgment and therefore we would like to reproduce the same as under:

    “5. Section 5-A(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act envisages the consumption of a commodity in the manufacture of another commodity. The goods purchased should be consumed, the consumption should be in the process of manufacture, and the result must be the manufacture of other goods. There are several criteria for determining whether a commodity is consumed in the manufacture of another. The generally prevalent test is whether the article produced is regarded in the trade, by those who deal in it, as distinct in identity from the commodity involved in its manufacture. Commonly, manufacture is the end result of one or more processes through which the original commodity is made to pass. The nature and extent of processing may vary from one case to another, and indeed there may be several stages of processing and perhaps a different kind of processing at each stage. With each process suffered, the original commodity experiences a change. But it is only when the change, or a series of changes, take the commodity to the point where commercially it can no longer be regarded as the original commodity but instead is recognised as a new and distinct article that a manufacture can be said to take place. Where there is no essential difference in identity between the original commodity and the processed article it is not possible to say that one commodity has been consumed in the manufacture of another. Although it has undergone a degree of processing, it must be regarded as still retaining its original identity.
    6. A large number of cases has been placed before us by the parties, and in each of them the same principle has been applied: Does the processing of the original commodity bring into existence a commercially different and distinct article? Some of the cases where it was held by this Court that a different commercial article had come into existence include Anwarkhan Mehboob Co. v. State of Bombay AIR 1961 SC 213 (where raw tobacco was manufactured into bidi patti), A. Hajee Abdul Shukoor and Co. v. State of Madras AIR 1964 SC 1729 (raw hides and skins constituted a different commodity from dressed hides and skins with different physical properties), State of Madras v. Swastik Tobacco Factory AIR 1966 SC 1000 (raw tobacco manufactured into chewing tobacco) and Ganesh Trading Co. v. State of Haryana (1974) 3 SCC 620 (paddy dehusked into rice). On the other side, cases where this Court has held that although the original commodity has undergone a degree of processing it has not lost its original identity include Tungabhadra Industries Ltd. v. CTO AIR 1961 SC 412 (where hydrogenated groundnut oil was regarded as groundnut oil) and CST v. Harbilas Rai and Sons (1968) 21 STC 17 (SC) (where bristles plucked from pigs, boiled, washed with soap and other chemicals and sorted out in bundles according to their size and colour were regarded as remaining the same commercial commodity, pigs bristles).”

    16. Another important aspect which needs to be highlighted from this judgment is that the argument of the Revenue that the sale of pineapple slices after the aforesaid process, was at a higher price in the market than the original fruit and, therefore, it constituted a different commercial commodity. The Court negatived this contention as well by observing that the process undertaken by the assessee may have made value addition to the product but the essential character of the product did not undergo any change, which is the determinative factor, inasmuch as pineapple remained the pineapple; albeit in slice form and continued to be known as pineapple in the market. For this proposition the Court decided 1980 Supp SCC 174, (1980) 6 ELT 343 to rely upon a foreign judgment where the US Supreme Court had held 351 US 49 (1956) that dressed and frozen chicken was not a commercially distinct article from the original chicken. Detailed discussion of the said judgment appears in paras 8-13 which reads as follows: (Pio Food Packers case 1980 Supp SCC 174, (1980) 6 ELT 343)

    “8. While on the point, we may refer to East Texas Motor Freight Lines v. Frozen Food Express 351 US 49 (1956), where the US Supreme Court held that dressed and frozen chicken was not a commercially distinct article from the original chicken. It was pointed out: (L Ed p. 923)
    ‘… Killing, dressing and freezing a chicken is certainly a change in the commodity. But it is no more drastic a change than the change which takes place in milk from pasteurizing, homogenizing, adding vitamin concentrates, standardizing and bottling.’
    9. It was also observed: (Frozen Food Express case 351 US 49 (1956), L Ed p. 923)
    ‘… there is hardly less difference between cotton in the field and cotton at the gin or in the bale or between cottonseed in the field and cottonseed at the gin, than between a chicken in the pen and one that is dressed. The ginned and baled cotton and the cottonseed, as well as the dressed chicken, have gone through a processing stage. But neither has been “manufactured” in the normal sense of the word.’
    10. Referring to Anheuser-Busch Brewing Assn. v. United States 207 US 556 (1908) the Court said: (Frozen Food Express case 351 US 49 (1956), L Ed p. 923)
    “‘… Manufacture implies a change, but every change is not manufacture and yet every change in an article is the result of treatment, labour and manipulation. But something more is necessary…. There must be transformation; a new and different article must emerge, ‘having distinctive name, character, or use’. (Anheuser-Busch Brewing Assn. case 207 US 556 (1908), L Ed p. 338)'”
    11. And further: (Frozen Food Express case 351 US 49 (1956), L Ed p. 924)
    ‘At some point processing and manufacturing will merge. But where the commodity retains a continuing substantial identity through the processing stage we cannot say that it has been “manufactured”….’
    12. The comment applies fully in the case before us. Although a degree of processing is involved in preparing pineapple slices from the original fruit, the commodity continues to possess its original identity, notwithstanding the removal of inedible portions, the slicing and thereafter canning it on adding sugar to preserve it. It is contended for the Revenue that pineapple slices have a higher price in the market than the original fruit and that implies that the slices constitute a different commercial commodity. The higher price, it seems to us, is occasioned only because of the labour put into making the fruit more readily consumable and because of the can employed to contain it. It is not as if the higher price is claimed because it is a commercially different commodity. It is said that pineapple slices appeal to a different sector of the trade and that when a customer asks for a can of pineapple slices he had in mind something very different from fresh pineapple fruit. Here again, the distinction in the mind of the consumer arises not from any difference in the essential identity of the two, but is derived from the mere form in which the fruit is desired.
    13. The learned counsel for the Revenue contends that even if no manufacturing process involved, the case still falls within Section 5(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, because the statutory provision speaks not only of goods consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale but also goods consumed otherwise. There is a fallacy in the submission. The clause, truly read, speaks of goods consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale or goods consumed in the manufacture of other goods for purposes other than sale.”

    17. It follows from the above that mere addition in the value, after the original product has undergone certain process, would not bring it within the definition of “manufacture” unless its original identity also undergoes transformation and it becomes a distinctive and a new product.

    18. When we apply the aforesaid principle to the facts of this case, it is clear that mere addition of dehydrated vegetables and certain spices to the raw rice, would not make it a different product. Its primary and essential character still remains the same as it is continued to be known in the market as rice and is sold as rice only. Further, this rice, again, remains in raw form and in order to make it edible, it has to be cooked like any other cereal. The process of cooking is even mentioned on the pouch which contains cooking instructions. Reading thereof amply demonstrates that it is to be cooked in the same form as any other rice is to be cooked. Therefore, we do not agree with Cegat that there is a transformation into a new commodity, commercially known as distinct and separate commodity.

    19. Since we are holding that the activity undertaken by the assessee does not amount to manufacture, this appeal is liable to succeed on this ground itself inasmuch in the absence of any manufacture there is no question of payment of any excise duty. We may, however, remark that even otherwise the classification of the product by the Revenue under Sub-Heading No. 21.08 may not be correct. In fact, Cegat has accepted that classification only on the ground that the product after mixing of raw rice with dehydrated vegetables and spice, has become a new product as it amounts to “manufacture” and on that basis it has held that it no longer remains product of milling industry. As we have held that it does not amount to “manufacture” as the essential characteristics of the product, still remains the same, namely, rice, a natural corollary would be that it continues to be the product of the milling industry and would be classifiable under Sub-Heading No. 11.01. Rate of duty on this product, in any case, is “nil”.

    20. This appeal, accordingly, succeeds and is allowed. The order of Cegat as well as demand of excise duty by the Revenue are hereby set aside. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Satnam Overseas Limited v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, New Delhi .
    (Mar 18, 2015)