Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules, 1990,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules, 1990,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals before the Supreme Court challenged a 22-10-2008 judgment of the Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court (Gwalior Bench), which had affirmed an earlier Single-Judge decision dated 16-10-2007. The underlying dispute concerns lecturers/teachers employed by the Education and Tribal Welfare Department of the Government of Madhya Pradesh who sought the benefit of the State’s “Kramonnati Scheme” (a scheme granting two higher pay scales for employees who have completed 12 and 24 years of service). The teachers claimed the second Kramonnati with effect from 19-04-1999, while the State (appellants) agreed to grant it only from 01-08-2003 and initiated recovery proceedings for amounts already disbursed for the earlier period.

Earlier, under the Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules, 1990, teachers became eligible for one higher pay scale after 12 years. A Government circular dated 19-04-1999 extended two time-bound pay upgradations (Kramonnati) to all State employees. Although a 02-11-2001 communication sanctioned the second Kramonnati for teachers from 19-04-1999, the Finance Department’s approval was allegedly absent, and a corrective order dated 11-10-2006 restricted the benefit. A subsequent policy decision on 03-09-2005 granted the second Kramonnati to teachers from 01-08-2003, prompting litigation.

Separate writ petitions were decided favourably for teachers by Single-Judge Benches at Indore (26-04-2007, Prerna v. State of M.P.) and Gwalior (16-10-2007). The State’s intra-court appeals failed, culminating in the present Supreme Court proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether teachers are entitled to the second Kramonnati pay-scale benefit with effect from 19-04-1999 or from 01-08-2003.
  2. Whether excluding or postponing the benefit for teachers, while granting it to other State employees, violates Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
  3. The extent to which courts may review and strike down a State policy decision alleged to be arbitrary or irrational.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (State of Madhya Pradesh)

  • The 19-04-1999 Kramonnati circular excluded the teacher cadre because they already enjoyed time-bound benefits under the 1990 Pay Rules.
  • The Commissioner’s sanction dated 02-11-2001 extending Kramonnati to teachers from 19-04-1999 was issued without Finance Department concurrence and was therefore erroneous.
  • A clarificatory notification stated that departments with their own Kramonnati provisions were outside the 1999 Scheme’s scope.
  • The 03-09-2005 policy granting the second Kramonnati from 01-08-2003 was a matter of executive policy, not subject to judicial interference.
  • Recoveries were necessary to correct over-payments made for the period prior to 01-08-2003.

Respondents (Teachers)

  • They are entitled to the second Kramonnati from 19-04-1999 because the Scheme applied uniformly to all government servants.
  • Restricting the benefit to a later date discriminates against teachers vis-à-vis other State employees and undermines the purpose of alleviating career stagnation.
  • The State’s change of date (01-08-2003) is arbitrary, unsupported by any rational basis or material on record.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Federation of Railway Officers Association v. Union of India, (2003) 4 SCC 289 Court’s power of judicial review over policy decisions that are contrary to law, unconstitutional, arbitrary or irrational. Relied upon to reject the State’s plea that the issue was a pure policy matter immune from judicial scrutiny and to justify striking down arbitrary discrimination against teachers.
Prerna v. State of M.P., WP No. 6773 of 2006 (M.P. High Court, decided 26-04-2007) A coordinate Single-Judge decision granting similar relief to teachers under the Kramonnati Scheme. Cited to emphasize that coordinate Benches should follow earlier decisions or refer the matter to a larger Bench, bolstering the consistency of the High Court’s rulings in favour of the teachers.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first examined the purpose of the Kramonnati Scheme—to mitigate stagnation and motivate employees lacking promotional avenues. Viewing teachers as pivotal to societal advancement, the Court held that the Scheme’s object precluded discriminatory treatment between teachers and other government servants.

The Court rejected the State’s contention that the earlier 1990 Pay Rules excluded teachers from the later, more generous Scheme. It considered the Rules and the Scheme as complementary, not mutually exclusive, and found the State’s selective postponement to 01-08-2003 “arbitrary and devoid of any logical foundation.”

A clarificatory Government circular dated 03-05-2000/17-05-2000 was interpreted as protective—ensuring employees already enjoying Kramonnati would not suffer a reduction—not as excluding teachers from additional benefits.

Invoking Federation of Railway Officers Association, the Court reiterated that policy decisions are justiciable when arbitrary or violative of constitutional guarantees. Because the State offered no reasonable explanation for excluding teachers, the policy offended Articles 14 and 16.

The Court also remarked on the importance of judicial discipline: coordinate Benches should follow each other or refer doubts to a larger Bench, noting that this principle had been properly observed in the High Court litigation history.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED. The Supreme Court upheld the High Court’s decision that teachers are entitled to the second Kramonnati with effect from 19-04-1999 and struck down the contrary State policy. No costs were imposed, and all pending applications were dismissed.

Implications: The immediate effect is restoration of the earlier date for the second Kramonnati benefit to the respondents and similarly situated teachers, nullifying recovery proceedings for the interim period. While the judgment does not establish a novel legal doctrine, it reinforces the principle that executive policy cannot arbitrarily discriminate among employees and remains subject to constitutional scrutiny.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others v. Mala Banerjee .

    Vikramajit Sen, J.— Delay condoned. Leave granted. These appeals assail the judgment of the learned Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Gwalior, delivered on 22-10-20081, which upheld the judgment dated 16-10-2007 of the learned Single Judge.

    2. Very briefly stated, the dispute pertains to the eligibility of the respondents, all of whom are lecturers/teachers in the employment of the Education and Tribal Welfare Department, Government of Madhya Pradesh, for increased pay scales. The respondents claim the benefits of the Kramonnati Scheme with effect from 19-4-1999, whereas the appellants assert that they are willing to grant the benefit of the Kramonnati Scheme to them, and obviously others similarly placed as they are, but with effect from 1-8-2003.

    3. Under the Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules, 1990, the respondents, were eligible for a higher pay scale on completion of 12 years of service. Subsequently, a policy dated 19-4-1999 known as the said Kramonnati Scheme came to be introduced entitling all government servants to the benefit of two higher pay scales, the first on completion of 12 years of service, and the second on the further completion of another 12 years (24 years in all). The appellants contend that this circular applied to all their employees except the Teacher cadre, since the latter had already enjoyed the benefit of the Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules. On 2-11-2001, the Commissioner, Public Instructions sanctioned the second Kramonnati for teachers with effect from 19-4-1999. The stand of the appellants is that this was erroneously extended without obtaining the consent of the Finance Department, and was accordingly corrected by the order dated 11-10-2006. However, despite this stance, the State Government took a policy decision on 3-9-2005 granting the benefit of a second Kramonnati to teachers, but with effect from 1-8-2003. Recovery proceedings were initiated against teachers who had been bestowed Kramonnati from the earlier date.

    4. The object of the Kramonnati Scheme must be noted, as this sheds light on its application. The Scheme was introduced to remove frustration among the employees who had stagnated at a particular scale for many years without promotional avenues, with the endeavour of removing any adversity in their performance. Keeping this purpose in perspective, there is no basis or justification for discriminating between teachers and all other employees. The fact that the Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules were already in place at the time the Kramonnati Scheme was introduced indicates that the appellants accepted that increase in pay scale are salutary and indeed important for educators on whose motivation and dedication the future of the country and of society is almost entirely dependent. We do not agree with the appellants' submission that the respondents are not entitled to claim the benefit of the Kramonnati Scheme because they were already covered under the Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules, as there is no basis for the two being mutually exclusive. Indeed, we find it logical that the application of the Madhya Pradesh Revision of Pay Rules regarding the eligibility of increased pay scales should be replaced by the Kramonnati Scheme, which is more generous in the benefits it provides. This is all the more so since the appellants have themselves ordained that the said Scheme can be availed by the respondents but from 1-8-2003, which we find to be arbitrary and devoid of any logical foundation.

    5. The appellants have claimed that its notifications indicated with clarity that the Scheme would not apply to those departments where a provision of Kramonnati was already available in their recruitment rules. However, a perusal of the relevant Clarification issued by the State Government dated 3-5-2000/17-5-2000 makes it clear that its purpose was to protect employees who were working in the departments that had a provision of Kramonnati in their recruitment rules, by preventing any reduction in Kramonnati pay scale as a consequence of the new 19-4-1999 Policy. It is our understanding that the clarification intended to prevent the class of employees envisaged therein from facing any monetary loss and not to disadvantage any class of employee.

    6. We also find ourselves unable to agree with the appellants' submission that this is a policy matter and, therefore, should not be interfered with by the courts. In Federation of Railway Officers Assn. v. Union of India 2003 4 SCC 289, this Court has already considered the scope of judicial review and has enumerated that where a policy is contrary to law or is in violation of the provisions of the Constitution or is arbitrary or irrational, the courts must perform their constitutional duties by striking it down. The appellants have not been able to explain why it chose to deny teachers the benefit of the second Kramonnati while granting this benefit to all the other employees, thus discriminating against them and violating their fundamental rights enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. It is indeed paradoxical that teachers who prepare persons for employment and leadership are dealt with in a parodical attitude by the State. Further, we reiterate that no explanation is forthcoming for granting the second Kramonnati with effect from 1-8-2003. This is neither the date in the original Scheme nor justifiable on the basis of any other material available on the record. Many employees had completed twenty-four years of service by 1999; therefore, in postponing their second Kramonnati by four years, the appellants have departed from the basic object of the Scheme. The 3-9-2005 Order failed to explain the basis of this decision, and is thus arbitrary in nature and discriminatory towards the respondents and others in their position.

    7. The annals of this litigation also need to be considered in some detail. The arguments ventilated before us were considered in detail by the Writ Court in Prerna v. State of M.P WP No. 6773 of 2006, decided on 26-4-2007 MP, which were decided on 26-4-2007 by a learned Single Judge of that High Court at its Indore Bench. Thereafter, another learned Single Judge of that High Court at its Gwalior Bench decided the present writ petitions from which these appeals/petitions arise in favour of the respondents vide its judgment dated 16-10-2007. Although the reasoning that has persuaded the second learned Single Judge to decide in favour of the respondents is evident from the perusal of that judgment, reliance on the judgment dated 26-4-2007 passed in Prerna had been duly considered. We must immediately emphasise that a Bench should ordinarily follow the decision of a coordinate Bench or else should forward the matter to the learned Chief Justice for constituting a larger Bench in case the reasoning and conclusion of the coordinate Bench is not acceptable. The appeal from the judgment dated 16-10-2007, has been dismissed by the Division Bench in terms of the judgment impugned before us, and that is how the special leave petitions (now appeals) came to be filed. In this interregnum, an appeal that had been preferred from the order of the learned Single Judge, Indore Bench has also been decided on 18-12-20084 in favour of the respondents, taking note of the judgment by a coordinate Bench presently impugned before us. We had made this clarification because one of the arguments that has been ventilated before us is that the two sets of petitions had not been considered threadbare by the two Benches located at Indore and Gwalior. This has not led to any legal irregularity, in that the learned Single Judge, as well as the learned Division Bench have sequentially considered the matter in detail.

    8. We do not find any illegality in the impugned judgment and the appeals are dismissed, but we desist from imposing costs. Since these appeals are being dismissed, it would be a futile and wasteful exercise to take up all pending applications. To remove possible doubts, all the applications are dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Madhya Pradesh And Others v. Mala Banerjee .
    (Mar 17, 2015)