AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 17 October 1998, at approximately 2:15 p.m., Jagsir Singh left his house in Village Ganga, District Sirsa (Haryana) to purchase chewing tobacco. His house was adjacent to that of the accused brothers Gurjit Singh alias Gora and Surjit Singh alias Sukha. Minutes later, hot words were exchanged, and eyewitnesses Mander Singh (brother of the deceased) and Sukhwinder Kaur (widow of the deceased) saw the accused surround Jagsir Singh. Gurjit Singh struck the back of Jagsir Singh’s head with a kassi (spade) and Surjit Singh struck his face with another kassi, after exhortations by their parents Gurdial Singh and Surjit Kaur. The victim was taken first to Community Health Centre, Dabwali, and then to General Hospital, Sirsa, where he was declared dead.

The police filed a charge-sheet under Sections 302 and 341 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The Trial Court acquitted Surjit Singh entirely and convicted Gurjit Singh only under Section 304 Part II IPC, accepting a plea of private defence. On the State’s appeal, the Punjab & Haryana High Court reversed the acquittals and convicted both brothers under Section 302/34 IPC. Gurjit Singh and Surjit Singh appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in reversing the Trial Court’s acquittal/partial conviction and convicting the appellants under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC.
  2. Whether the appellants’ plea of private defence, grave and sudden provocation, or absence of common intention could reduce the offence to Section 304 Part II IPC or result in acquittal.
  3. Whether the prosecution’s failure to explain the injuries found on Gurdial Singh weakened its case.
  4. Whether the testimony of close relatives of the deceased (PW 13 and PW 14) was reliable and sufficient for conviction.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The Trial Court’s view was a possible and plausible appreciation of evidence; therefore, following Chandrappa v. State of Karnataka and similar precedents, the High Court should not have interfered with the acquittal.
  • The incident occurred in the heat of the moment when Gurjit Singh acted to save his father from an armed attack by the deceased; at most, the offence falls under Section 304 Part II IPC, relying on Arun Raj v. Union of India and Kapildeo v. State of U.P.
  • The prosecution failed to explain injuries on Gurdial Singh, casting doubt on its version and supporting the defence of private defence.
  • The second injury to the deceased was accidental—caused when he fell on a fallen kassi—and not inflicted by Surjit Singh.

Respondent (State) Arguments

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chandrappa v. State of Karnataka (2007) 4 SCC 415 Limited interference with acquittal unless the Trial Court’s view is perverse. Held inapplicable; High Court demonstrated that the Trial Court’s view was indeed perverse.
State of M.P. v. Ramesh (2011) 4 SCC 786 Same principle as Chandrappa regarding appeals against acquittal. Dismissed for the same reason—Trial Court’s reasoning was perverse.
Ranjitham v. Basavaraj (2012) 1 SCC 414 Non-interference with reasonable acquittal. Court found the acquittal unreasonable; precedent did not aid appellants.
Arun Raj v. Union of India (2010) 6 SCC 457 Distinction between Section 302 and culpable homicide not amounting to murder. Facts of present case differed; Court rejected downgrading to Section 304.
Kapildeo v. State of U.P. 1983 SCC (Cri) 311 Conversion of conviction from Section 302/304 Part I to Section 304 Part II. Held distinguishable; circumstances here warranted Section 302.
Anwar Ali v. State of U.P. (2011) 15 SCC 360 Evidence of relatives cannot be discarded solely for being related. Relied upon to accept eyewitness accounts of PW 13 and PW 14.
Kartik Malhar v. State of Bihar (1996) 1 SCC 614 “Interested witness” concept; natural relatives are not automatically discredited. Cited to substantiate reliance on family-member eyewitnesses.
Ashok Rai v. State of U.P. (2014) 5 SCC 713 Credibility of interested witnesses. Further supported acceptance of PW 13 and PW 14’s testimony.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court undertook an independent appraisal of the evidence. It agreed with the High Court that:

  • The two fatal injuries—one to the back of the head and one to the face—were inflicted by Gurjit Singh and Surjit Singh, both armed with kassis. The Trial Court’s inference that both blows were by Gurjit Singh was contrary even to the defence version and unsupported by evidence.
  • The alleged injury to Gurdial Singh was probably self-inflicted. He sought medical attention nearly five hours later, refused radiological examination, and offered no history to the doctor. The weapon (a gandasi) supposedly used by the deceased was never recovered.
  • Non-explanation of the minor injuries on Gurdial Singh did not erode an otherwise trustworthy prosecution case.
  • The eyewitnesses were natural witnesses present at the scene; their relationship to the deceased was not a ground for rejection, consistent with the principles in Anwar Ali, Kartik Malhar, and Ashok Rai.
  • The defence plea of private defence and sudden provocation was untenable: the appellants were the aggressors who deliberately confronted and attacked the deceased after being exhorted by their parents. The incident was not a spontaneous quarrel but a targeted assault over a land-demarcation dispute.
  • Consequently, the ingredients of murder under Section 302 IPC, committed in furtherance of common intention under Section 34, were clearly established.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED – conviction and sentence under Section 302/34 IPC upheld.

The Supreme Court restored the High Court’s verdict and set aside the Trial Court’s acquittal of Surjit Singh and the lesser conviction of Gurjit Singh. The immediate effect is that both appellants remain convicted of murder and continue to serve the sentences imposed. The judgment reinforces two principles: (1) appellate interference with an acquittal is justified where the Trial Court’s view is perverse or ignores material evidence, and (2) testimony of close relatives, if cogent and credible, is sufficient for conviction. No new legal doctrine was created, but the decision underscores the evidentiary value of natural eyewitnesses and the limits of the private-defence plea.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Gurjit Singh Alias Gora And Another v. State Of Haryana .

    S.A Bobde, J.— This appeal has been preferred by the accused Gurjit Singh alias Gora and Surjit Singh alias Sukha, from the judgment of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh, convicting the appellant-accused under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”) for the murder of Jagsir Singh on 17-10-1998 at about 2.15 p.m at Village Ganga (Dabwali), District Sirsa, Haryana.

    2. The relationship between the parties is as follows:

    3. According to the prosecution, on 17-10-1998 at about 2.15 p.m, Jagsir Singh left his home to go to a shop for purchasing zarda (chewing tobacco). His house was adjacent to the house of the accused. Soon thereafter, his brother Mander Singh (PW 13), his wife Sukhwinder Kaur (PW 14) and Paramjit Kaur heard hot words being exchanged between Jagsir Singh (deceased) and the accused. Mander Singh along with Sukhwinder Kaur went out of their house to see as to what had happened. They saw that the accused had surrounded Jagsir Singh. Accused Gurjit and Surjit were armed with kassis (spades) whereas Gurdial Singh, the father of the accused and Surjit Kaur, their mother, were unarmed. Gurdial Singh and Surjit Kaur exhorted Gurjit and Surjit that Jagsir Singh be taught a lesson for bringing the Kanungo (revenue inspector) to the village for demarcation of their property. Gurjit then struck Jagsir Singh on the back of his head with a kassi, causing him to fall. Thereafter, Surjit also struck Jagsir Singh on his face with a kassi. Accused Surjit Kaur then dragged Jagsir Singh towards the village lane.

    4. As per the prosecution, Mander Singh (PW 13), the brother of the deceased and Sukhwinder Kaur (PW 14) had been restrained by the accused Gurdial Singh and his wife Surjit Kaur from approaching the site where Jagsir Singh had been cornered by the accused brothers. Mander Singh and Sukhwinder Kaur made frantic calls for help, thereby attracting many people from the locality to the scene of the incident. The accused escaped from the scene with their weapons.

    5. Jagsir Singh was immediately removed to Community Health Centre, Dabwali. The doctor there provided first aid and referred him to General Hospital at Sirsa, which is at a distance of about 60 km, where he was declared as brought dead.

    6. After completion of the investigation, a report under Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “CrPC”) was presented in court. The accused were charged under Sections 302 and 341 read with Section 34 IPC. An autopsy was conducted by Dr Jagdish Choudhary (PW 4) along with Dr Yogesh Sangwan. At the trial, the prosecution examined 15 witnesses including Mander Singh (PW 13), brother of Jagsir Singh (deceased) and Sukhwinder Kaur (PW 14), widow of the deceased. After the closure of the prosecution evidence, statements of the accused were recorded under Section 313 CrPC, in which they denied the allegations and pleaded false implication. The accused examined Kuldeep Kaur (DW 1) and Dr Bhushan Garg (DW 2) in their defence.

    7. The two parties are related by blood. Gurdial Singh and Mukhtiar Singh, are sons of one Miyan Singh. Mukhtiar Singh is the father of the deceased Jagsir Singh. The two brothers were owners in possession of 2/3 share of total land measuring 157 kanals and 19 marlas situated in the revenue estate of Village Ganga, Tehsil Dabwali, District Sirsa. The sons of Mukhtiar Singh i.e the complainant party, believed that their uncle Gurdial Singh and his sons i.e the accused party, had encroached upon their land. They had therefore moved an application for demarcation of the property. The accused were not in agreement with the course adopted by the complainants. Therefore, they cornered the deceased Jagsir Singh in front of their house when he was on his way to the village market. The acquitted accused, Gurdial Singh and his wife Surjit Kaur had exhorted their sons i.e Surjit and Gurjit, to commit the crime.

    8. It is significant that in defence, the accused admitted the occurrence. Their version, however, has differed from that of the prosecution. According to them, Gurdial Singh was digging in the street and was dumping mud along the wall of his house. Thereafter, Jagsir Singh (deceased) came there armed with a gandasi (sharp-edged weapon) and raised a khangura (a provocative sound made to incite another person). In response, Gurdial asked Jagsir Singh why he had made that sound since he had brought him up as a child. Jagsir Singh responded by demanding a certain piece of land from Gurdial Singh. Thereafter, Jagsir Singh struck Gurdial Singh with the gandasi on his head. It is further stated, that Gurdial Singh then rushed into his house with Jagsir Singh in pursuit. Thereafter, Jagsir Singh struck him again with the reverse side of the weapon. Meanwhile, Gurjit, Gurdial's son, picked up a kassi and tried to save his father from the hands of Jagsir Singh. In the process, Gurjit struck Jagsir Singh on the back of his head, causing him to fall on the sharp side of the kassi which had fallen from the hands of Gurdial Singh. The learned counsel for the appellants thus pleaded self-defence and sudden provocation before us.

    9. The doctor (PW 4), who conducted the autopsy on the dead body of Jagsir Singh, observed two incised wounds i.e one over the scalp extending 4 cm behind the left ear and the other extending from the nasal septum to 2 cm below the right external ear. In the opinion of the doctor, the cause of death was shock and haemorrhage as a result of injuries to vital organs, which were ante-mortem in nature.

    10. At this stage, it is apposite to notice that the injury is said to have been caused to Gurdial Singh by Jagsir Singh with a gandasi (sharp-edged weapon). As per the first information report, the incident took place at about 2.15 p.m At around 6.55 p.m in the evening, Gurdial Singh went to the Primary Health Centre at Odhan and got himself examined by the medical officer on duty there, namely, Dr Bhushan Garg (DW 2). The doctor found:

    1. An incised wound 4 cm × 1 cm on the right parietal area of head and it was 6 cm above the right ear. Fresh bleeding was present and margins were sharp. The doctor advised an x-ray for this injury.
    2. A contusion 3 cm × 1 cm on the left hand on the dorsal aspect at the base of left thumb and it was transversely placed. Severe tenderness was present.

    The doctor prepared a skiagram (an x-ray image) of the injuries and sent a ruqa to Police Station, Odhan. Further, although this witness ruled out the injury by a friendly hand or by self, he did not reject the possibility of the injuries being self-inflicted. Significantly, this witness admitted in his cross-examination that the injured i.e Gurdial Singh, did not offer himself for radiological examination and further, he did not disclose the history of the injuries to him.

    11. It is equally significant that the weapon, which is said to have been used to cause this injury to Gurdial Singh i.e the gandasi, was never recovered.

    12. The trial court accepted the defence version in its entirety. It came to the conclusion that Gurjit caused an injury on the head of Jagsir Singh (deceased) in self-defence i.e after Jagsir had attacked his uncle Gurdial Singh on the head with a gandasi. That thereupon, Jagsir Singh fell face down on the kassi which had allegedly fallen from the hands of Gurdial. The trial court completely acquitted the other accused Sukha alias Surjit Singh. The trial court concluded that Surjit had no role to play because Sukhwinder Kaur, Jagsir Singh's widow, stated in her deposition that Gurjit had struck Jagsir Singh on the head with the kassi. The second kassi-blow, however, was given on the right side of the face of Jagsir Singh. Because she had not mentioned the name of the person who had given the second blow on the face of the deceased, the trial court concluded, that the witness attributed the second blow also to Gurjit.

    13. The trial court seems to have attached no importance to the fact that the recovery of the weapon (the kassi) was made at the instance of the accused Surjit Singh. This was simply dismissed as highly improbable.

    14. The learned counsel for the appellants, Dr J.P Dhanda, placed reliance on Chandrappa v. State of Karnataka (2007) 4 SCC 415 , (2007) 2 SCC (Cri) 325, State of M.P v. Ramesh (2011) 4 SCC 786 , (2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 493 and Ranjitham v. Basavaraj (2012) 1 SCC 414 , (2012) 1 SCC (Cri) 454 to submit that in an appeal against acquittal, interference by the appellate court is not warranted in the absence of perversity in the judgment of the trial court. These judgments do not help the cause of the appellants because the High Court has given clear and cogent reasons to show that the judgment of the trial court was perverse and not based on the evidence on record. Further, Dr Dhanda relied on Arun Raj v. Union of India (2010) 6 SCC 457 , (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 155 and Kapildeo v. State of U.P 1983 SCC (Cri) 311 to show that the offence committed by the appellants fell within the scope of Section 304 Part II IPC and not under Section 302 IPC. It is pertinent to note that in Arun Raj (2010) 6 SCC 457 , (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 155 this Court had rejected the defence of grave and sudden provocation and convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC. Whereas in Kapildeo 1983 SCC (Cri) 311 this Court altered the conviction from Section 304 Part I to Section 304 Part II IPC. The circumstances in the above cases were entirely different from the present case.

    15. We might state at this stage itself that upon reading of the evidence of Mander Singh (PW 14), it cannot be said that Sukhwinder Kaur (PW 13) stated that the second kassi-blow was given on the right side of the face of Jagsir Singh to mean that the second blow was also caused by Gurjit Singh alias Gora. The trial court also seems to have missed the defence version, according to which Jagsir Singh received the second injury from the kassi because he fell on the ground where the kassi was lying, and not because Gurjit Singh caused it, vide the deposition of Kuldeep Kaur (DW 1), wife of Surjit Singh.

    16. As stated above, the trial court acquitted Surjit Singh completely and also Gurjit Singh of the charge under Section 302 IPC, accepting the defence version that Gurjit attacked deceased Jagsir Singh only to save the life of his father, Gurdial Singh, who had allegedly been injured by Jagsir Singh. The trial court convicted Gurjit Singh under Part II of Section 304 IPC.

    17. In appeal, the High Court reassessed the entire evidence and came to the conclusion that it cannot be said to be the duty of the prosecution in the circumstances to explain injuries on the person of the accused, Gurdial Singh, particularly, since Gurdial neither offered himself for radiological examination nor had he disclosed the history of his injuries to the doctor. The High Court opined that the non-explanation of injuries is insufficient to discard the case of the prosecution, if it otherwise inspires confidence and is worthy of credence. The High Court disagreed with the trial court and held that there is no reason to disbelieve the statement of Mander Singh, the brother of the deceased and Sukhwinder Kaur, the widow, only because they were near relations of the deceased. It is settled law, that the statement of a relative of the deceased cannot be discarded merely on the ground that he or she is an interested party. In Anwar Ali v. State of U.P (2011) 15 SCC 360 this Court rightly observed that once the prosecution has been able to prove its case by leading admissible and cogent evidence with reference to statements of the witnesses, the same cannot be brushed aside merely on the ground that the witnesses are relatives of the deceased. In Kartik Malhar v. State of Bihar (1996) 1 SCC 614 , 1996 SCC (Cri) 188 , 1995 Supp (5) SCR 239, this Court held that even

    “a close relative who is a natural witness cannot be regarded as an interested witness. The term ‘interested’ postulates that the witness must have some direct interest in having the accused somehow or the other convicted for some animus or for some other reason”.

    More recently, this principle was upheld in Ashok Rai v. State of U.P (2014) 5 SCC 713 , (2014) 2 SCC (Cri) 681 whereby this Court clearly stated that the evidence of interested witnesses is not infirm. The High Court has also disagreed with the trial court that the fight took place at the spur of the moment and the accused had not conspired with each other to commit the crime, since there was no evidence to that effect.

    18. Having considered the entire matter, we are of the view that the circumstances of the case point out to the commission of the crime under Section 302 IPC, as observed earlier.

    19. There is no doubt about the occurrence having taken place, in which Jagsir Singh was killed by the accused and that his injuries were caused by kassis. There is clear evidence that the accused party comprised of Gurdial Singh, his wife Surjit Kaur along with their sons Gurjit Singh and Surjit Singh. Gurjit and Surjit were armed with kassis. There are two injuries made by the kassis; on the back of the head and the other on the face of the deceased, Jagsir Singh. The eyewitnesses' accounts of Mander Singh (PW 13) and Sukhwinder Kaur (PW 14), who were undoubtedly present, in no uncertain terms reveals that Jagsir Singh was attacked by the accused party i.e Gurjit Singh and Surjit Singh. Sukhwinder Kaur has stated that the accused Gurjit gave a kassi-blow on the back of the head of Jagsir Singh, as a result of which he fell. Further, that the second kassi-blow was given on the right side of the face of Jagsir Singh. The inference drawn by the trial court that Sukhwinder Kaur intended to name Gurjit Singh, as the person who also caused the second blow is unwarranted. The acquittal of Surjit Singh on that ground is also not sustainable. Some element of confusion was sought to be created in the defence version by alleging, vide Kuldeep Kaur's (DW 1) deposition that Jagsir Singh received the second blow because he fell after receiving the first blow on a kassi lying beside Gurdial Singh, which cut his face on the right side.

    20. The trial court has come up with an inference, which is different even from the defence version. We consider it appropriate to accept the judgment of the High Court, which, after reading the entire evidence on this point, came to the correct conclusion that the two blows were caused by Gurjit Singh and Surjit Singh, who were both armed with kassis and who had been exhorted to kill Jagsir Singh by their parents, Gurdial Singh and Sukhwinder Kaur.

    21. We also agree with the judgment of the High Court that the injury on Gurdial Singh is self-inflicted, in all likelihood. Gurdial Singh was said to have gone to Primary Health Centre, Odhan at around 6.55 p.m, even though the incident had taken place at around 2.15 p.m The inordinate delay in seeking medical attention raises many questions. In addition, he also refused to undergo radiological examination of the injuries and did not tell the doctor as to how and why he got the injuries. Gurdial Singh's conduct appears to be wholly unnatural and it is not possible to accept the defence version that Gurjit Singh attacked Jagsir Singh (deceased) because Jagsir attacked his father with a gandasi. As observed earlier, the failure to corroborate the existence of the gandasi, has not been explained.

    22. For the aforesaid reasons, the appeal is dismissed. The order of conviction and sentence as recorded by the High Court is upheld and the order of acquittal passed by the trial court is set aside.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gurjit Singh Alias Gora And Another v. State Of Haryana .
    (Mar 10, 2015)