Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Raj Pal, a resident of Village Hassanpur, was found dead near a government tubewell on the morning of 12-1-2000. The previous night, his brother Raj Singh had seen the appellant, Sanjeev alias Gaja, running from the vicinity wearing blood-stained clothes. A First Information Report was lodged the same morning and the investigation revealed severe ante-mortem injuries on the deceased, allegedly inflicted with a brick. Sanjeev was medically examined at 1:30 a.m. on 12-1-2000, showing a recent incised wound on his forearm. After investigation, he was charged under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).

The Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track Court), Sonepat, convicted Sanjeev on 3-10-2002 and sentenced him to life imprisonment with a fine of ₹5,000. The Punjab and Haryana High Court dismissed his appeal on 24-5-2011. Sanjeev then filed the present appeal before the Supreme Court by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the circumstantial evidence established by the prosecution was sufficient to uphold the conviction of the appellant for murder under Section 302 IPC.
  2. Whether the facts brought on record bring the case within Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC, thereby reducing the offence to culpable homicide not amounting to murder punishable under Section 304 Part I IPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The prosecution case rests entirely on circumstantial evidence; no eyewitness saw the appellant commit the crime.
  • The alleged circumstances do not form a complete chain pointing unerringly to the appellant’s guilt.
  • No motive for the murder was established, casting further doubt on the conviction under Section 302 IPC.

State's (Respondent's) Position

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s specific arguments; it relies on the prosecution evidence accepted by the lower courts.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court evaluated five key circumstances proved by the prosecution:

  1. PW 9 Raj Singh saw the appellant fleeing with blood-stained clothes around 10 p.m. on 11-1-2000.
  2. PW 13 Dr C.P. Arora documented a fresh incised wound on the appellant’s forearm shortly after the estimated time of the offence.
  3. PW 12 Om Prakash testified to an extra-judicial confession in which the appellant admitted an altercation with the deceased after consuming liquor and assaulting him with a brick.
  4. PW 1 ASI Rajiv Kumar and PW 7 Inspector Ram Kala recovered the appellant’s blood-stained clothes on his disclosure.
  5. Forensic tests confirmed that the blood on the recovered clothes matched the deceased’s blood group ‘O’.

The Court held that these circumstances, taken together, identified the appellant as the assailant. However, it noted that the extra-judicial confession indicated a sudden quarrel after both men were intoxicated. Applying Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC, the Court concluded that the act was committed:

  • Without premeditation,
  • In a sudden fight upon a sudden quarrel, and
  • Without the appellant taking undue advantage or acting in a cruel or unusual manner (the weapon was an available brick).

Therefore, the offence constituted culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part I IPC rather than murder under Section 302 IPC.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The conviction under Section 302 IPC is set aside. The appellant is convicted under Section 304 Part I IPC and sentenced to ten years’ rigorous imprisonment with a fine of ₹5,000; in default, two months’ further imprisonment.

Implications: The appellant’s life sentence is reduced to a determinate ten-year term. The decision turns on the specific facts and the statutory Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC; the Court did not articulate a new legal principle, limiting broader precedential impact.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sanjeev v. State Of Haryana .

    Prafulla C. Pant, J.— This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 24-5-2011 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana in Sanjeev v. State of Haryana Sanjeev v. State of Haryana, 2011 SCC OnLine P&H 6575 whereby conviction and sentence recorded by the Additional Sessions Judge (FTC), Sonepat against the appellant under Section 302 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) has been affirmed.

    2. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    3. The prosecution story, in brief, is that PW 9 Raj Singh, resident of Village Hassanpur, had three brothers. Raj Pal alias Pale (deceased) was younger to him. All the four brothers used to live separately. On 11-1-2000, Raj Singh had gone to Sonepat with his brother Raj Pal for some personal work. Raj Singh got held up in Sonepat, and Raj Pal left for the village. Later, he (Raj Singh) also proceeded from Sonepat. At about 10.00 p.m, when Raj Singh on his way to Village Hassanpur, alighted from three-wheeler, at G.T Road crossing, he noticed Sanjeev alias Gaja (appellant) with bloodstained clothes fleeing from the side of government tubewell towards Murthal Bus-stand. He (Raj Singh) could identify Sanjeev in the headlights of the vehicles, but did not have an idea that his brother (Raj Pal) had been murdered. After meals he went to bed. In the next morning, Shakuntala (wife of Raj Pal) came to him and told that Raj Pal had not reached home. On this, a search was made by Raj Singh and his another brother Ram Kumar regarding their missing brother. At about 9.00 a.m, they reached near water supply tubewell and noticed a man lying only with trousers. They went near to see the person and realised that their brother Raj Pal has been killed who was lying in the pool of blood. There were wounds on the forehead, nose and eyebrows of the body. Shirt, sweater, slippers, etc. were lying at some distance. Suspecting that Sanjeev alias Gaja might have killed or helped someone killing Raj Pal, he went to the police post and gave first information report (Ext. PG-1) on 12-1-2000 at 10.40 a.m

    4. PW 6, ASI Jagat Singh recorded the above first information report relating to the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC at Police Post Sadar, Sonepat. Police team headed by PW 14, SI Yashpal Singh with PW 8, HC Mahinder Singh and Constable Rajeev Singh, along with the informant, proceeded towards the place where the dead body was lying. The body of the deceased was taken into possession and sealed. The inquest report (Ext. PE-2) was prepared. Shirt, sweater, slippers, etc. and a bloodstained brick were also taken into possession by the police and a memorandum was prepared. Sealed dead body of Raj Pal was handed over to PW 8 HC Mahinder Singh, and sent for post-mortem examination through Constables Ramesh Kumar and Rajbir. PW 11 SI Ram Chander took up the investigation.

    5. PW 3, Dr Purnima Ahuja of Government Hospital, conducted post-mortem examination on the very day i.e 12-1-2000, on the dead body of Raj Pal, with her colleague Dr R.N Tehlan. Following ante-mortem injuries were recorded by the team of medical officers who prepared autopsy report (Ext. PA-1/2000):

    “1. Multiple contusion of varying sizes 5 × 1 cm, 4 × 3 cm, 2 × 1 cm, 3 × 1 cm, 3 × 1 cm and 1 × 1 cm, present on whole of back about 10 to 12 in number. On cut sections blood was found on the subcutaneous tissue.
    2. Defused swelling was present on the front and left side of chest of size 20 × 10 cm. On examination crepitus was found. On exploration, there was massive presence of blood in the subcutaneous tissue deep to the chest wall and pericardium and pleura. Numbers 3rd to 9th ribs were found fractured at multiple paces. Left thoracic cavity was full of blood (about 2 litres). Left lung was badly lacerated on right side. The 3rd and 6th ribs were fractured medially and thoracic cavity was full of blood. The lung was lacerated.
    3. Lacerated wounds 5 × 2 cm present on the middle of the forehead vertically placed. Underlying bone was fractured. CV was present.
    4. Lacerated wound 3 × 2 cm present on the right side just above the right eye. CV was present.
    5. Defused swelling were present on the left cheek 6 × 5 cm.
    6. Defused swelling on the left eye.
    7. Contusion 6 × 5 cm present on the back of the left shoulder.”

    It was opined by the two doctors, who conducted the post-mortem examination, that the abovementioned ante-mortem injuries were sufficient to cause death.

    6. Meanwhile, accused Sanjeev who had gone to Government Hospital in the intervening night of 11-1-2000 and 12-1-2000, was also medically examined by PW 13, Dr C.P Arora of General Hospital, Sonepat, at about 1.30 a.m (12-1-2000), and following injury was found on his person:

    “22 × 0.2 × 2 to 0.5 cm incised wound on the posterior surface of the left forearm. It was superficial in depth and skin-deep only. There was a corresponding cut on the shirt.”

    7. After examination of the witnesses and on completion of the investigation, the investigating officer submitted charge-sheet against accused Sanjeev (appellant) for his trial in respect of the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC. The forensic report regarding blood group of the bloodstains found on the clothes of the accused and that of the deceased was also obtained. The case was committed by the Magistrate to the Court of Session and necessary copies were provided to the accused as required under Section 207 of the Criminal Procedure Code. After hearing on charge, the Sessions Judge framed charge of offence punishable under Section 302 IPC against accused Sanjeev on 23-5-2000 to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

    8. Thereafter, the prosecution got examined fifteen witnesses, namely, PW 1, ASI Rajiv Kumar (witness of disclosure as to the recovery of bloodstained clothes of the accused), PW 2, Constable Mahesh Chander (in whose presence bloodstained clothes of the deceased were taken into possession and recovery memo, Ext. PB prepared), PW 3, Dr Purnima Ahuja (who conducted post-mortem examination), PW 4, Jaipal (who took photographs of dead body of Raj Pal before the body was sealed), PW 5, Rampal Patwari (who prepared site plan, Ext. PF), PW 6, ASI Jagat Singh (who recorded the first information report, Ext. PG-1), PW 7, Inspector Ram Kala (who arrested the accused), PW 8, HC Mahinder Singh (to whom the dead body was handed over after the same was sealed), PW 9, Raj Singh (informant and brother of the deceased), PW 10, Balwan Singh (another brother of the deceased), PW 11, SI Ram Chander (who sent a letter, Ext. PO-1 requesting the government hospital for post-mortem examination), PW 12, Om Prakash (witness of extra-judicial confession), PW 13, Dr C.P Arora (who examined the injury on person of the accused), PW 14, SI Yashpal Singh (who went to the place of incident along with other police officials and the informant, after the first information report was registered, and prepared the inquest report), and PW 15, Azad Singh (another witness of extrajudicial confession).

    9. The oral and documentary evidence was put to the accused under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code on 16-1-2000 by the learned Sessions Judge, in response to which the accused pleaded that the same was incorrect, and stated that he was falsely implicated.

    10. The Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court, Sonepat, after hearing the parties, found accused Sanjeev guilty of charge of offence punishable under Section 302 IPC and convicted him accordingly on 3-10-2002. The parties were heard on sentence on 5-10-2002 and the convict (Sanjeev) was sentenced to imprisonment for life and directed to pay a fine of Rs 5000, in default of payment of fine he was directed to undergo further imprisonment for a period of two months.

    11. Aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 3-10-2002/5-10-2002, the convict preferred appeal before the High Court of Punjab and Haryana, which was registered as Criminal Appeal No. 827-DB of 2002. The High Court, after hearing the parties, concurred with the view taken by the trial court and dismissed the appeal. Hence, this appeal by way of special leave.

    12. The learned counsel for the appellant argued before us that it is a case of circumstantial evidence and no one has seen the appellant committing the crime. It is further argued that the circumstances shown by the prosecution in the present case do not complete the chain, and the courts below have erred in law in holding the appellant guilty of the charge of murder.

    13. To appreciate the above argument, we have to see the circumstances which are brought on record against the appellant. The prosecution has established following facts in this case against the accused:

    (i) PW 9, Raj Singh, informant, saw the accused running away on 11-1-2000 at about 10.00 p.m and his clothes were stained with blood.
    (ii) On 12-1-2000, when PW 13, Dr C.P Arora medically examined the accused Sanjeev in the wee hours, it was found that the accused had suffered incised wound measuring 22 × 0.2 × 2 to 0.5 cm on the posterior surface of left forearm, and there was cut in the shirt. This witness (PW 13) sent ruka (memorandum) Ext. PP-1 to the In-charge, Police Post, General Hospital (even before FIR was lodged).
    (iii) PW 12, Om Prakash, has stated that accused Sanjeev disclosed to him on 14-1-2000, that on 11-1-2000, he (accused) had altercation with Raj Pal after consuming liquor whereafter he assaulted the deceased with the brick.
    (iv) PW 1, ASI Rajiv Kumar and PW 7, Inspector Ram Kala, have adduced the evidence that on 15-1-2000 on disclosure (Ext. PA) from the accused Sanjeev, his bloodstained clothes which were concealed by him in a wooden box in his house, were recovered.
    (v) From the forensic laboratory report, it is established that same blood group was found in the bloodstained clothes recovered i.e Blood Group ‘O’.

    14. The above circumstances, read together, make us believe that it is only the appellant who could have caused death of Raj Pal in the intervening night of 11-1-2000 and 12-1-2000. When the prosecution has successfully proved that accused Sanjeev suffered the injury, as mentioned above, almost at the same time when the deceased had suffered the injuries, there should have been some explanation on the record from the side of the defence as to how he (accused) received the injury and went to the government hospital where his injury was recorded by PW 13, Dr C.P Arora, before giving him medical treatment. In absence thereof, the courts below had no reason to disbelieve the evidence relating to above chain of circumstances and they rightly recorded the finding that it was accused Sanjeev only who could have caused death with the knowledge that the act committed by him is likely to result in death of the person assaulted.

    15. On behalf of the appellant it is submitted that there was no motive on the part of the appellant to commit murder of Raj Pal, as such, in absence of motive, it cannot be said that it was only the appellant who could have committed the crime.

    16. It is settled principle of law that, to establish commission of murder by an accused, motive is not required to be proved. Motive is something which prompts a man to form an intention. The intention can be formed even at the place of incident at the time of commission of crime. It is only either intention or knowledge on the part of the accused which is required to be seen in respect of the offence of culpable homicide. In order to read either intention or knowledge, the courts have to examine the circumstances, as there cannot be any direct evidence as to the state of mind of the accused.

    17. In the present case, from the evidence of PW 12 Om Prakash, it reflects that while making extra-judicial confession, the appellant narrated that after both he and Raj Pal got drunk, they engaged into an altercation whereafter scuffle took place, and the appellant caused injuries on the forehead and chest of the deceased. This fact gets corroborated from the statement of PW 13, Dr C.P Arora, who recorded wound measuring 22 × 0.2 × 2 to 0.5 cm in the medical report soon after the time of the incident, on the person of the appellant.

    18. exception 4 to section 300 ipc provides that culpable homicide is not murder if it is committed without premeditation in a sudden fight in the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel and without the offender having taken undue advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner. The Explanation to Exception 4 to the section further provides that it is immaterial in such cases which party offers provocation or commits the first assault.

    19. In our opinion, when the prosecution evidence relating to extra-judicial confession made before PW 12 Om Prakash, is believed by the courts below to examine as to whether the act committed by the accused constitutes culpable homicide amounting to murder or not, they should have read the statement as a whole, and the circumstances, in which the injuries were caused by the appellant to the deceased, should not have been ignored. Having gone through the evidence on record and considering the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties, we are of the view that the act committed by the appellant in the present case is covered by exception 4 to section 300 ipc i.e culpable homicide not amounting to murder, as such the same is, punishable under section 304 part i ipc.

    20. For the reasons, as discussed above, we are inclined to partly interfere with the impugned orders. The conviction and sentence recorded by the trial court and affirmed by the High Court in respect of the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC against the appellant, is set aside. Instead, the appellant is convicted under section 304 part i ipc and sentenced to undergo imprisonment for a period of ten years and to pay a fine of Rs 5000, in default of which the appellant shall undergo imprisonment for a further period of two months. The amount of fine if deposited in compliance with the orders of the courts below shall be treated to have been deposited in compliance with the direction of this Court as above. The appellant is said to be in jail and he shall complete the sentence as awarded by this Court.

    21. The appeal, accordingly, stands disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sanjeev v. State Of Haryana .
    (Feb 19, 2015)