Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 8 ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT 1996
  • Code of Civil Procedure itself. Section 94 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • V.K Jain, J.:IA No. 4272/2011 (u/S. 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act)1.
  • Section 8(1) of the 1996 Act
  • sub-section (1) of Section 8
  • Section 8 of the 1996 Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 8 ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT 1996
  • Code of Civil Procedure itself. Section 94 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • V.K Jain, J.:IA No. 4272/2011 (u/S. 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act)1.
  • Section 8(1) of the 1996 Act
  • sub-section (1) of Section 8
  • Section 8 of the 1996 Act,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion addresses an application filed under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, seeking to refer disputes raised by the plaintiff to arbitration pursuant to an arbitration agreement between the parties. The defendants appeared and filed their written statement on 25th January 2011, followed by the plaintiff’s replication on 14th February 2011. The application under Section 8 was filed on 22nd February 2011, after the written statement and replication had been submitted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an application under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act can be entertained if filed after submission of the first statement on the substance of the dispute (i.e., after filing the written statement).
  2. Whether merely pleading the existence of an arbitration agreement in the written statement, without filing an application under Section 8 within the prescribed time, is sufficient to refer the dispute to arbitration.
  3. The extent to which the timing and procedural requirements under Section 8 affect the jurisdiction of the Civil Court to entertain the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant/Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants contended that since they had pleaded the existence of an arbitration agreement in their written statement, the Civil Court had no jurisdiction to adjudicate the suit.
  • They argued that the application under Section 8 should be maintainable even though it was filed after the written statement, as they did not submit to the jurisdiction of the Civil Court by pleading arbitration.
  • The defendants relied on the Supreme Court decision in Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. v. Verma Transport Co. to support their contention that interlocutory proceedings do not amount to submission to jurisdiction.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff relied on the Supreme Court decision in Sukanya Holdings Pvt. Ltd. v. Jayesh H. Pandya to argue that since the defendants had already filed their written statement and had not filed an application under Section 8 before that, the matter was not required to be referred to arbitration.
  • The plaintiff emphasized the mandatory conditions under Section 8, including the requirement that the application must be filed before submitting the first statement on the substance of the dispute.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sukanya Holdings Pvt. Ltd. v. Jayesh H. Pandya, (2003) 5 SCC 531 Interpretation of Section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act: application must be filed before first statement on substance of dispute; absence of such application bars reference to arbitration. Supported the view that an application under Section 8 filed after the written statement is not maintainable.
K. Jayakumaran Nai v. Vertex Securities Ltd., AIR 2005 Ker. 294 Application under Section 8 must be filed before or along with written statement; raising arbitration clause in written statement without application is insufficient. Reinforced that filing written statement alone without Section 8 application does not refer dispute to arbitration.
West Bengal State Electricity Board v. Shanti Conductors Pvt. Ltd., AIR 2004 Gau 70 Application under Section 8 filed after written statement is not maintainable even if arbitration clause is admitted in plaint and written statement. Confirmed that the Court cannot refer matter to arbitration if application under Section 8 is filed late.
Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. v. Verma Transport Co., (2006) 7 SCC 275 Distinction between interlocutory proceedings and first statement on substance of dispute; application under Section 8 must be filed before first statement; filing interlocutory pleadings does not amount to submission on substance. Distinguished interlocutory proceedings from first statement; held that application under Section 8 after filing first statement is not maintainable.
Food Corporation of India v. Yadav Engineer & Contractor, (1982) 2 SC 499 Interlocutory proceedings are incidental and do not amount to main proceedings disclosure. Supported distinction between main and supplemental proceedings in context of Section 8 timing.
Hindustan Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. v. Pinkcity Midway Petroleums, (2003) 6 SCC 503 Application under Section 8 filed in reply to suit summons before filing written statement. Not applicable as in the present case application was filed after written statement.
Agri Gold Exims Ltd. v. Sri Lakshmi Knits & Wovens, (2007) 3 SCC 686 This case was cited but not applicable as it did not deal with application under Section 8 filed after written statement. Not applied to the facts of the present case.
Everest Electric Works v. Himachal Futuristics Communications Ltd., No. 4438/2003 in CS(OS) No. 2400/2001 This Court’s decision cited but not relevant as it did not consider Section 8 application filed post written statement. Not applicable to the present facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the conditions prescribed under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which require that an application for referring disputes to arbitration must be filed before the first statement on the substance of the dispute is submitted, accompanied by the arbitration agreement or its certified copy. In the present case, the application under Section 8 was filed after the defendants had already filed their written statement and after the plaintiff had filed replication, thus failing the timing requirement.

The Court referred to the Supreme Court’s decision in Sukanya Holdings which explicitly states that if no application under Section 8 is filed before the first statement, the matter need not be referred to arbitration. The Court rejected the defendants’ contention that merely pleading the arbitration agreement in the written statement, without filing an application under Section 8 within the prescribed time, amounts to non-submission to the jurisdiction of the Civil Court. It held that allowing an application after filing the written statement would defeat the purpose of the statutory provision and could lead to abuse by delaying arbitration until late stages of trial.

Further, the Court distinguished interlocutory proceedings from the first statement on the substance of the dispute relying on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. The Court found that the defendants had submitted their full statement on the dispute by filing the written statement, thereby waiving their right to invoke arbitration at a later stage without timely application under Section 8.

Consequently, the Court held that an application under Section 8 filed after the written statement is not maintainable, even if the arbitration agreement is pleaded in the written statement without a specific prayer for arbitration referral.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED the application under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act filed after the written statement.

The direct effect of this decision is that parties must file an application under Section 8 before submitting their first statement on the substance of the dispute to invoke arbitration. Failure to do so results in the Civil Court retaining jurisdiction to try the suit. This ruling reinforces the strict procedural compliance required under Section 8 and prevents parties from delaying arbitration by waiting until after filing their written statement. No new precedent was set beyond the application of existing Supreme Court principles to the facts at hand.

    Arti Jethani v. Daehsan Trading (India) Pvt. Ltd.

    V.K Jain, J.:—

    IA No. 4272/2011 (u/S. 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act)

    1. This is a petition under Section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) for referring the disputes raised by the plaintiff for arbitration, in terms of the arbitration agreement between the parties.

    2. A perusal of the record would show that on suit summons being served on them, the defendants appeared through counsel on 04th January, 2011 and it was directed that the written statement be filed within the prescribed period. The matter was adjourned to 02nd May, 2011. The written statement was filed on 25th January, 2011. Replication to the written statement was filed on 14th February, 2011. In replication, the plaintiff relying upon the decision of Supreme Court in Sukanya Holdings Pvt. Ltd. v. Jayesh H. Pandya (2003) 5 SCC 531 : AIR 2003 SC 2252, stated that the defendants having already filed Written Statement and no application under Section 8 of the Act having been filed, the matter was not required to be referred to the arbitral tribunal. The application under consideration came to be filed on 22nd February, 2011.

    3. A careful analysis of Section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 would show that the following conditions are required to be fulfilled before the Court can refer the matter to arbitration;

    (a) the dispute between the parties should be subject matter of an arbitration agreement;

    (b) one of the parties to the suit should apply for referring the parties to arbitration;

    (c) the application should be filed on or before submitting first statement on the substance of the dispute and;

    (d) the application should be accompanied by the original arbitration agreement or its certified copy.

    4. In the case before this Court, the application under consideration having not been filed on or before filing of written statement, but having been filed about four weeks after the written statement had been filed and after 8 days of filing of replication, one of the pre-requisite conditions for referring the parties to arbitration under Section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act does not stand fulfilled in this case.

    5. In Sukanya Holdings (supra), Supreme Court, while interpreting Section 8 of the Act, inter alia, observed as under:

    “Further, the matter is not required to be referred to the arbitral Tribunal, if-(1) the parties to the arbitration agreement have no filed any such application for referring the dispute to the arbitrator; (2) in a pending suit, such application is not filed before submitting first statement on the substance of the dispute; or (3) such application is not accompanied by the original arbitration agreement or duly certified copy thereof.”

    It is true that in the above-referred case, the application under Section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act appears to have been filed before the written statement was filed and, therefore, the question as to whether such an application can be filed after the written statement has already been filed, did not directly come up for consideration in this case, but, the above-referred observations made by the Court do support the view that such an application cannot be filed after the first statement on the substance of the dispute has been filed by the applicant.

    6. The contention of the learned counsel for the applicant is that since the defendant had already pleaded in the written statement that there is an arbitration agreement between the parties and, therefore, this Court has no jurisdiction to adjudicate the instant suit, it is evident that the applicants did not submit to the jurisdiction of the Civil Court and, therefore, the application is maintainable even after filing of the written statement.

    7. In my view, if the Court accepts the contention that an application under Section 8 of the Act can be filed even after the first statement on substance of the dispute between the parties has already been filed, this would not only be contrary to the express provisions of law but, would also defeat the very purpose behind stipulating that such an application needs to be filed not later than submitting the first statement on the substance of the dispute. If such an application is entertained after filing of the first statement, it would be possible for a party to the suit to first allow the trial to proceed by not filing the application by the stage stipulated in the Act and then come to the Court at a much later stage when the trial is substantially complete and seek reference of the dispute to arbitration. It is true that in the case before this Court the trial has not commenced as yet, but if the interpretation sought to be given by the learned Counsel for the applicants/defendants is accepted, it would be open to a party to the suit to file such an application even after the trial has commenced.

    8. The question as to whether a defendant who pleads arbitration agreement in the Written Statement, but does not file an application under Section 8 of the Act, on or before filing of the Written Statement has come up before other High Courts in some cases. In K. Jayakumaran Nai v. Vertex Securities Ltd. AIR 2005 Ker. 294, the defendant filed Written Statement raising a contention that there was an arbitration agreement between the parties. After framing of issues he filed an application seeking reference of the dispute for arbitration. The High Court noted that Section 8 of the Act clearly provides that the application had to be made not later than submitting the first statement whereas the application before it had been filed after the issues were framed. The Court expressly rejected the contention that since the matter had been raised in the Written Statement that was enough. While doing so the Court noted that the Written Statement contained no prayer for referring the matter for arbitration.

    In West Bengal State Electricity Board v. Shanti Conductors Private Ltd. AIR 2004 Gau 70, the defendants filed Written Statement indicating that the dispute which had arisen between the parties and led to institution of the suit, was covered by arbitration clause. After submitting the Written Statement on 22.9.2000 the defendants filed an application under Section 8 of the Act on 7.11.2000 seeking reference of the dispute to the arbitration. The trial Court having rejected the application the matter was agitated by the defendant before the High Court and it was contended that in the plaint itself the plaintiff had admitted the existence of the arbitration clause and the Written Statement also indicated about its existence and therefore the Court below had taken a misconceived view of law as to its jurisdiction. Rejecting the contention, the High Court interalia held as under:

    In the case at hand, the application under Section 8 was made by the defendants after the written statement stood submitted. Hence, this application was not maintainable. The fact that the existence of the arbitration clause was admitted in the plaint or asserted in the written statement is immaterial inasmuch as the Court, under Section 8, can refer for arbitration a dispute pending in a civil suit only when the party or parties concerned make application for getting the dispute referred to arbitration. If despite existence of arbitration clause, the parties choose to contest the suit, the powers under Section 8 cannot be invoked.

    9. The learned Counsel for the defendants has relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. v. Verma Transport Co. (2006) 7 SCC 275. In the case before Supreme Court, a suit seeking permanent injunction against blacklisting the defendant or terminating the contract was filed. The trial Court directed the parties to maintain status quo. The appellants/defendants sought time to file Written Statement. They also filed a rejoinder to the counter affidavit of the application for injunction, wherein they took a specific plea that the subject matter of the suit, being covered by arbitration agreement, it was not maintainable. On 7.6.2002 they filed an application under Section 8 of the Act which was rejected by the trial Court on the ground that the process of the suit had already begun and the defendants had already entered into a defence of the suit and had thereby subjected themselves to the jurisdiction of this Court. A revision application filed by the defendants having been rejected by the High Court, the matter was taken to Supreme Court. The Supreme Court noted that under Section 8 of the Act, the power to refer the dispute for arbitration has to be exercised, if a party so applies not later than when submitting his first statement on the substance of the dispute. The Court referred to its decision in Food Corporation of India v. Yadav Engineer & Contractor (1982) 2 SC 499 where it had opined that interlocutory proceedings are only incidental proceedings to the main proceedings and therefore any step taken in interlocutory proceedings does not come within the purview of the main proceedings. The Court then interalia observed as under:

    36. The expression “first statement on the substance of the dispute” contained in Section 8(1) of the 1996 Act must be contra distinguished with the expression “written statement”. It employs submission of the party to the jurisdiction of the judicial authority. What is therefore needed is a finding on the part of the judicial authority that the party has waived its right to invoke the arbitration clause. If an application is filed before actually filing the first statement on the substance of the dispute, in our opinion, the party cannot be said to have waived its right or acquiesced itself to the jurisdiction of the court. What is, therefore, material is as to whether the petitioner has filed his first statement on the substance of the dispute or not, if not, his application under Section 8 of the 1996 Act, may not be held wholly unmaintainable.

    In paras 38 & 39 of the judgment, the Supreme Court interalia observed as under:

    38. xxx

    In view of the changes brought about by the 1996 Act, we are of the opinion that what is necessary is disclosure of the entire substance in the main proceeding itself and not taking part in the supplemental proceeding.

    39. By opposing the prayer for interim injunction, the restriction contained in sub-section (1) of Section 8 was not attracted. Disclosure of a defence for the purpose of opposing a prayer for injunction would not necessarily mean that substance of the dispute has already been disclosed in the main proceeding. Supplemental and incidental proceedings are not part of the main proceeding. They are dealt with separately in the Code of Civil Procedure itself. Section 94 of the Code of Civil Procedure deals with supplemental proceedings. Incidental proceedings are those which arose out of the main proceedings. In view of the decision of this Court in Food Corporation of India, the distinction between the main proceeding and supplemental proceeding must be borne in mind.

    In para 42 of the judgment, the Court interalia observed as under:

    42. Waiver of right on the part of a defendant to the lis must be gathered from the fact situation obtaining in each case. In the instant case, the court had already passed an ad interim ex parte injunction. The appellants were bound to respond to the notice issued by the Court. While doing so, they raised a specific plea of bar of the suit in view of the existence of an arbitration agreement. Having regard to the provisions of the Act, they had thus, shown their unequivocal intention to question the maintainability of the suit on the aforementioned ground.

    The facts of this case however, are altogether different. In this case, the defendants have already filed their Written Statement and have thereby disclosed their entire defence and that has been done in the main proceedings itself, not in the supplemental proceedings. Of course, the application under Section 8 of the Act would be maintainable if the applicant has not filed his first statement on the substance of the dispute, but when the Written Statement is filed, it can hardly be disputed that the applicant has submitted not only the first but whole of his statement on the dispute between the parties. To hold such an application to be maintainable, even after filing of the Written Statement would be contrary to the provisions contained in Section 8 of the Act. Mere disclosure of arbitration agreement in the Written Statement and claiming that Civil Court has no jurisdiction to try the suit would be of no consequences unless the Written Statement itself contains a prayer for referring the dispute for arbitration. In the case before this Court, though the defendants claimed that there is arbitration agreement between the parties and Civil Court has no jurisdiction in the matter, no prayer was made in the Written Statement to refer the disputes between the parties for arbitration.

    10. The learned Counsel for the applicants/defendants has also referred to Hindustan Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. v. Pinkcity Midway Petroleums. (2003) 6 SCC 503. It appears from para 8 of the judgment that in this case, the application under Section 8 of the Act along with a copy of the arbitration agreement, was filed by the appellant/defendant in reply to the suit summons. There is nothing in the judgment to indicate that Written Statement had been filed before filing the application under Section 8 of the Act. Therefore, this judgment is of no help to the defendants before this Court.

    11. No one can dispute that a Civil Court has no jurisdiction to entertain the suit after application under Section 8 of the Act is filed but this would be subject to the application otherwise being in conformity with the requirements of the said Section. The jurisdiction of the Civil Court is not ousted on account of an arbitration agreement between the parties. It is ousted because of an application filed under Section 8 of the Act provided it otherwise confirms to the requirements laid down in the Section.

    12. The learned Counsel for the defendants/applicants also relied upon Agri Gold Exims Ltd. v. Sri Lakshmi Knits & Wovens (2007) 3 SCC 686 and decision of this Court in Everest Electric Works…Plaintiff v. Himachal Futuristics Communications Ltd.… No. 4438/2003 in CS(OS) No. 2400/2001 decided on 11.8.2004 Neither of these judgments applies to the facts of the case before this Court. In neither of the cases, the Court was called upon to deal with a situation where application under Section 8 of the Act is filed after filing of the Written Statement.

    For the reasons given in the preceding paragraphs the application is hereby dismissed.

    CS(OS) No. 1296/2010

    The matter be listed before the Joint Registrar on 30th May, 2011 for admission/denial of the documents and before this Court on 16th November, 2011 for framing of issues.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Arti Jethani v. Daehsan Trading (India) Pvt. Ltd.
    (May 16, 2011)