Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 120-B of the Code
  • IPC (Indian Penal Code)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 120-A of the Penal Code
  • The Penal Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 120-B of the Code
  • IPC (Indian Penal Code)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 120-A of the Penal Code
  • The Penal Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 11 October 1991, Head Constable Mukesh Kumar (PW 7) discovered an unconscious and bleeding man lying on Indore Road. The victim was transported to hospital where he was pronounced dead. Inspector S.S. Tomar (PW 14) registered an offence under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and investigated. Ultimately, two appellants—Baliya and Gopal—along with Manish (since deceased) and Chhotu (acquitted) were charge-sheeted for offences under Section 120-B read with Section 302 IPC.

The Special Sessions Judge, West Nimar, Mandaleshwar, tried the case, examining fourteen prosecution witnesses and numerous documents. During trial Manish died; Chhotu was acquitted; the appellants were convicted of conspiracy to murder (Section 120-B) and murder (Section 302) and sentenced to life imprisonment. The Madhya Pradesh High Court affirmed the convictions on 20 April 2007. The present Supreme Court appeals challenge that common judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved, beyond reasonable doubt, the existence of a criminal conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC among the appellants to murder the deceased Pradeep.
  2. Whether the circumstantial and testimonial evidence established the appellants’ guilt for the substantive offence of murder under Section 302 IPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The alleged public conversation between Dr. Sandhya Swami and accused Baliya—relied upon by the prosecution to prove conspiracy—was inherently improbable because it supposedly occurred in a busy market in loud tones, yet only two witnesses (PWs 8 & 11) claimed to have overheard it.
  • Eyewitness testimony was unreliable: PW 3 turned hostile and PW 4’s identification of accused was inconsistent with other key witnesses (PWs 1 & 5).
  • The “last-seen” circumstance and recovery of blood-stained clothes/weapon were isolated pieces of evidence that, even if accepted, did not complete a chain of circumstances pointing unerringly to guilt.

State's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent State’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
E.K. Chandrasenan v. State of Kerala (1995) 2 SCC 99 Principles governing proof of criminal conspiracy. Cited illustratively to reaffirm that conspiracy is usually proved by inference from established circumstances.
Kehar Singh v. State (Delhi Administration) (1988) 3 SCC 609 Nature of agreement and “meeting of minds” required for Section 120-B. Referenced to stress that proof of an overt act is unnecessary once unlawful agreement is proved.
Ajay Aggarwal v. Union of India (1993) 3 SCC 609 Evidentiary standards for inferring conspiracy from circumstantial evidence. Relied upon to outline the inferential method the court must employ.
Yash Pal Mittal v. State of Punjab (1977) 4 SCC 540 Need for cautious appraisal of circumstantial evidence in conspiracy cases. Used to reiterate that circumstances must exclude every hypothesis except guilt.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Assessment of Eyewitnesses: PW 3 was declared hostile. PW 4’s courtroom identification of Baliya conflicted with PWs 1 & 5, and she failed to identify the accused in police custody. The Court found her testimony unsafe to rely upon.

Conspiracy Charge: The prosecution proved (via PWs 8 & 11) that Dr. Sandhya Swami confronted Baliya about a defamatory pamphlet and that Baliya said he knew its author (the deceased) and told Manish and Gopal that “he should be killed.” However, the Court held that:

  • No evidence showed how Manish and Gopal responded, leaving the crucial element of “meeting of minds” unproved.
  • The subsequent murder could not itself serve as evidence of a prior conspiracy; the conspiracy must precede the act.

Applying the precedents, the Court concluded that the circumstantial chain did not exclude other rational hypotheses; thus, conspiracy was not established beyond reasonable doubt.

Murder Charge: With PW 4 discarded, only circumstantial evidence remained:

  • “Last-seen” evidence was inconsistent—PWs 1 & 5 differed on Gopal’s presence.
  • Recovery of Gopal’s blood-stained clothes and a knife from Manish were corroborated by FSL reports but, standing alone, were insufficient to prove guilt.

The Court emphasized that a single incriminating circumstance cannot sustain a conviction unless it forms part of an unbroken chain leading exclusively to the accused. Such a chain was missing in this case.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Appeals Allowed; Convictions and Sentences Set Aside; Appellants Acquitted.

Consequently, Baliya and Gopal are to be released forthwith unless required in any other case.

Implications: The decision affects only the parties to this case. It does not establish new legal principles but reinforces existing standards for evaluating circumstantial evidence in conspiracy and murder prosecutions.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Baliya Alias Bal Kishan v. State Of Madhya Pradesh .

    Ranjan Gogoi, J.— Criminal Appeal No. 2001 of 2008 has been filed by accused, Baliya whereas Criminal Appeal No. 2002 of 2008 has been filed by co-accused, Gopal. Both the appellants are aggrieved by the common order dated 20-4-2007 Criminal Appeal No. 394 of 1998 passed by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh by which the conviction of the appellants under Section 120-B read with Section 302 IPC and the sentence imposed has been affirmed.

    2. The short case of the prosecution is that on 11-10-1991 Head Constable, Mukesh Kumar (PW 7), of Police Station Balwada, while returning from the court where he had gone to attend the hearing of a case, found a person lying unconscious on the roadside on Indore Road. As the person was profusely bleeding PW 7 sent information to Police Station Balwada, which was entered in the general diary of the police station. Thereafter, the victim was brought to the hospital where he was declared dead.

    3. As there were injuries on the person of the deceased, PW 14, S.S Tomar (Inspector of Police) registered an offence under Section 302 and took up investigation of the case. On completion of investigation, the two appellants along with co-accused, Manish (since dead) and Chhotu (acquitted) were charge-sheeted for the offences under Section 120-B read with Section 302 IPC. The offences being triable by the Court of Session, the case was committed to the Court of the learned Special Sessions Judge, West Nimar, Mandaleshwar (M.P). Charges under the aforesaid sections of the Penal Code were framed against all the accused to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

    4. In the course of the trial prosecution examined as many as 14 witnesses besides exhibiting a large number of documents. Accused Manish died in the course of the trial whereas the remaining accused including the two appellants contested the charges framed against them. At the conclusion of the trial, while accused Chhotu was exonerated of the charges levelled, the appellant-accused have been convicted as aforesaid and sentenced to undergo, inter alia, rigorous imprisonment for life. The said conviction and sentence has been maintained by the High Court in the two separate appeals filed by the appellants giving rise to the present appeals.

    5. We have heard Shri S.K Bhattacharya, learned counsel for the appellants and Shri C.D Singh, learned counsel on behalf of the respondent State. We have also considered the evidence of the key witnesses examined by the prosecution as well as the several documents exhibited in the course of the trial. We have also perused the orders of the learned trial court as well as of the High Court.

    6. The deposition of PWs 1, 4, 5, 6, 8 and 11 who are the key witnesses examined by the prosecution may now be noticed. According to PW 1, the first informant, on the day of the occurrence, in the late afternoon, he was returning from the factory along with two linemen of the M.P Electricity Board who had gone to the factory to carry out an inspection of a fault that had occurred in the electric connection. All the three were coming back from the factory on one scooter. According to PW 1, from the other side, accused Manish; deceased, Pradeep and accused, Gopal were coming on a red motorcycle belonging to the accused Manish. As deceased Pradeep had asked him to stop PW 1 stopped the scooter and on being asked by the deceased he informed him that they were coming from the factory after getting the electric fault inspected. According to PW 1, at that point of time accused Gopal went away in the direction of Gayatri Market and the deceased alighted from the motorcycle and after talking to PW 1, he drove away on the motorcycle with the other accused i.e Manish. According to PW 1, the scooter by which he had brought the linemen belonged to the deceased and he was going to return the same. However, the brother of the deceased, one Mukesh (PW 5), asked for the scooter and as the house of PW 1 was near Gayatri Market both of them i.e PW 1 and PW 5 Mukesh rode the scooter together up to a certain point. Thereafter, PW 1 went to his house and shortly thereafter he came to know from one Satya Vijaya that the deceased Pradeep had been stabbed by somebody with a knife.

    7. PW 3, Asha, examined as an eyewitness was declared hostile. PW 4, Gangabai who was examined as another eyewitness of the occurrence had deposed that on the day of the occurrence she along with PW 3 were returning from the factory after the day's work. This was at about 5 p.m When they had reached Chor Bavadi she saw three persons quarrelling and one person being stabbed. PW 4 also deposed that there was a red-coloured motorcycle on which the persons were seated. The deposition of PW 4 further indicates that though she could not identify any of the alleged assailants in police custody, she had identified accused Baliya and Gopal in the court.

    8. PW 5 Mukesh is the brother of the deceased. According to this witness, after the deceased Pradeep and PW 1 had completed their conversation, the deceased had left towards Indore Road along with accused Gopal and Manish. This part of the evidence of PW 5 is discrepant with the evidence of PW 1 who had stated that at this point of time accused Gopal had parted company and had gone in the direction of Gayatri Market, while the deceased had gone away on the motorcycle with accused Manish. Furthermore, according to PW 5, after PW 1 had dropped the linemen and along with PW 5 had come to Gayatri Market accused Gopal had again appeared and had taken away the scooter. Shortly thereafter he was informed about the incident.

    9. PW 6, Shantilal is a witness to the recovery and seizure of the wearing apparels of accused Gopal from the house of co-accused Chhotu (since acquitted). He is also a witness to the recovery of a knife at the instance of the accused Manish.

    10. PW 8, Kamlesh Kumar Sharma, is another brother of the deceased. According to this witness at about noontime on the day of the occurrence while he was going home for his meal, he had seen one Dr Sandhya Swami with the two appellant-accused and accused Manish. PW 8 has deposed that Dr Sandhya Swami, in a loud voice, was blaming accused Baliya that her reputation has been smeared because of him and that a pamphlet has been published with regard to her relationship with the accused Baliya. This witness has also deposed that the accused Baliya had stated that he knew the identity of the author of the pamphlet and had told accused Gopal and Manish that the said person should be done away with.

    11. Similar is the deposition of PW 11, Mansoor Khan. According to PW 11, when he was going to the market he found Dr Sandhya Swami and accused Baliya talking in the course of which Dr Sandhya Swami was telling Baliya that she has suffered in reputation on account of him and that a pamphlet has been published against her and others. According to PW 1, he had heard accused Baliya telling accused Manish and Gopal that Pradeep should not be spared and that he should be killed.

    12. A consideration of the evidence adduced by the prosecution witnesses, the core of which has been noticed above, would go to show that though the two alleged eyewitnesses were examined by the prosecution not much reliance can be placed on the testimony of either. PW 3 Asha had been declared hostile by the prosecution whereas the evidence of PW 4 Gangabai suffers from material discrepancies if read with the evidence of PWs 1 and 5, particularly, in respect of the role of the accused Baliya. While PWs 1 and 5 do not mention about the presence of accused Baliya at the place of occurrence, PW 4 had identified the said accused in the court as being one of the assailants. The said witness, however, could not identify any of the accused while they were in police custody. In such circumstances, it will not be safe and prudent to place any reliance on the evidence of PW 4.

    13. In the absence of any credible ocular evidence, the prosecution in order to succeed has to establish circumstances adverse to the accused from which an inference of guilt can reasonably follow. A scrutiny of the prosecution evidence, noticed above, would go to show that insofar as the charge of criminal conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC is concerned, the prosecution has sought to establish that a pamphlet authored/published by the deceased was in circulation casting doubt on the character of Dr Sandhya Swami and her relationship with the accused Baliya. The said pamphlet though seized in the course of investigation was not exhibited in the trial. From the evidence of PW 8 and PW 11 it transpires that in the afternoon of the day of the occurrence they had overheard a conversation between Dr Sandhya Swami and Baliya with regard to the pamphlet being distributed in the course of which the accused Baliya had stated that he knew who is the author of the pamphlet. From the evidence of the aforesaid two witnesses i.e PWs 8 and 11, it further transpires that Baliya had informed accused Manish and Gopal that it is Pradeep who was responsible for the pamphlet and that he should be killed. Shortly thereafter, the dead body of Pradeep was found lying on the road. From the evidence of PWs 1 and 5 the prosecution has sought to establish that a little while before his death the deceased was seen in the company of accused Manish and Gopal and that the deceased was seen by PWs 1 and 5 riding on a red motorcycle belonging to accused Manish. Over and above the aforesaid circumstances, from the evidence of PW 6, the prosecution has tried to establish that bloodstained clothes of accused Gopal were recovered at the instance of the said accused whereas a knife was recovered at the instance of accused Manish. The aforesaid bloodstains, according to the prosecution, stood proved by the FSL report which was duly exhibited in the trial.

    14. Having considered the evidence adduced by the prosecution witnesses we find that insofar as the publication of the pamphlet; the conversation between Dr Sandhya Swami and the accused Baliya and the statements attributed to accused Baliya along with the instructions to accused Manish and Gopal that Pradeep should be killed had been proved by the prosecution. Though the prosecution has also sought to prove that the deceased was seen in the company of accused Manish and Gopal shortly before his death there is some amount of discrepancy in the evidence of PWs 1 and 5, in this regard, as already noticed. That the accused Manish owned a red-coloured motorcycle and the use of such a motorcycle by the accused and the deceased shortly before the death had occurred have also been proved by the prosecution. There is also no doubt with regard to the recovery of bloodstained clothes of the accused Gopal at the instance of the said accused and also the recovery of a knife at the instance of the accused Manish. What has fallen for our determination is whether on the aforesaid proved circumstances, the appellants are liable for the offences alleged against them?

    15. The offence of “criminal conspiracy” is defined in Section 120-A of the Penal Code whereas Section 120-B of the Code provides for punishment for the said offence. The foundation of the offence of criminal conspiracy is an agreement between two or more persons to cooperate for the accomplishment/performance of an illegal act or an act which is not illegal by itself, through illegal means. Such agreement or meeting of minds create the offence of criminal conspiracy and regardless of proof or otherwise of the main offence to commit which the conspiracy may have been hatched, once the unlawful combination of minds is complete, the offence of criminal conspiracy stands committed. More often than not direct evidence of the offence of criminal conspiracy will not be forthcoming and proof of such an offence has to be determined by a process of inference from the established circumstances of a given case.

    16. The essential ingredients of the said offence, the permissible manner of proof of commission thereof and the approach of the courts in this regard has been exhaustively considered by this Court in several pronouncements of which, illustratively, reference may be made to E.K Chandrasenan v. State of Kerala (1995) 2 SCC 99, Kehar Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.) (1988) 3 SCC 609, Ajay Aggarwal v. Union of India (1993) 3 SCC 609 and Yash Pal Mittal v. State of Punjab (1977) 4 SCC 540. The propositions of law which emanate from the above cases are, in no way, fundamentally different from what has been stated by us hereinabove.

    17. The offence of criminal conspiracy has its foundation in an agreement to commit an offence or to achieve a lawful object through unlawful means. Such a conspiracy would rarely be hatched in the open and, therefore, direct evidence to establish the same may not be always forthcoming. Proof or otherwise of such conspiracy is a matter of inference and the court in drawing such an inference must consider whether the basic facts i.e circumstances from which the inference is to be drawn have been proved beyond all reasonable doubt, and thereafter, whether from such proved and established circumstances no other conclusion except that the accused had agreed to commit an offence can be drawn. Naturally, in evaluating the proved circumstances for the purposes of drawing any inference adverse to the accused, the benefit of any doubt that may creep in must go to the accused.

    18. Applying the above tests we find that in the present case the prosecution had proved, through the evidence of PWs 8 and 11, the conversation between Dr Sandhya Swami and the accused Baliya to the effect that the reputation of Dr Sandhya Swami had suffered because of accused Baliya and further that a pamphlet in this regard has been published. The prosecution has also succeeded in proving that the accused Baliya had stated that he knew who was the author of the pamphlet and that Baliya had told accused Manish and Gopal that the author of the pamphlet (deceased Pradeep) should not be spared. While this happened in the afternoon of the day of the occurrence, in the early part of the evening hours the deceased Pradeep was found lying injured on the road and on being brought to the hospital, was declared dead. Whether on this evidence the conclusion that the appellant-accused had hatched a conspiracy to commit the murder of Pradeep can be drawn to the exclusion of all other possible conclusions is the question that requires our answer.

    19. We have already held that in the present case, from the evidence of PWs 8 and 11, the prosecution has succeeded in establishing the conversation between the accused persons and Dr Sandhya Swami details of which need not be repeated. In coming to the above conclusion, we had considered the arguments advanced on behalf of the accused that the said fact is inherently improbable as such a conversation is alleged to have occurred in a busy market place and the exchanges are reported to have been in a loud voice within the hearing of the people in the immediate vicinity, like PWs 8 and 11. Balancing the totality of the facts and keeping in mind the strata of society to which the accused persons belong/belonged it will be difficult to disbelieve what has been stated by the prosecution witnesses in a clear and cogent manner merely on the assertion that such an event is impossible. However, even accepting the prosecution version what reasonably follows therefrom is that Dr Sandhya Swami had complained to accused Baliya that her reputation has been smeared because of the pamphlet; that accused Baliya had stated that he knew who was the author of the pamphlet and further that he had stated to accused Manish and Gopal that the author of the pamphlet (deceased Pradeep) should be killed. But what is conspicuous by its absence is the essential meeting of minds between accused Baliya, Manish and Gopal to commit the murder of the deceased. No evidence is forthcoming as to what was the response of accused Manish and Gopal to the statement made by Baliya to the effect that the author of the pamphlet must be done away with. In the absence of any material to establish the said fact the vital chain or link to enable us to satisfy ourselves with regard to an agreement or meeting of minds amongst the accused to commit the murder of deceased Pradeep is lacking. The alleged participation of the accused in the commission of the actual act of murder cannot be evidence of the conspiracy inasmuch as the commission of murder must be the result of the conspiracy already hatched. The alleged acts attributed to the accused insofar as the offence of murder is concerned, naturally, have to be considered separately in order to determine the liability of the accused for the said offence.

    20. The above would now require the Court to consider whether either of the appellants can be held to be liable for the offence under Section 302 IPC.

    21. We have already indicated that we do not find the evidence of PW 4 to be credible or reliable insofar as identification of accused Baliya at the place of occurrence is concerned. If the evidence of the alleged eyewitnesses (PW 4) is to be excluded, as it has to be, the accused Baliya has not been implicated, in any manner whatsoever, by the circumstances that the prosecution has sought to establish by examining PWs 1 and 5. The aforesaid witnesses have nowhere mentioned that the accused Baliya was present at any point of time or at the place when the occurrence took place. The said witnesses have, at best, implicated accused Gopal as being seen with the deceased Pradeep along with the accused Manish shortly before the incident. However, as already indicated, there is a serious discrepancy in the evidence of PWs 1 and 5 with regard to the presence of the accused Gopal in the company of the deceased immediately before the crime. The prosecution version of last seen together even if it is hypothetically accepted in its entirety, at the highest, would establish only a solitary incriminating circumstance against the accused, which in our considered view cannot give rise to the conclusion that the accused Gopal must be held liable for the murder of the deceased Pradeep. Recovery of the bloodstained clothes of the accused Gopal at his instance, by itself, again will not be sufficient.

    22. In view of the foregoing discussions we are of the view that the conviction of the appellant-accused under Section 120-B read with Section 302 IPC is not legally sustainable. We, therefore, allow appeals, set aside the judgment and order dated 20-4-2007 passed by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in Baliya v. State of M.P Criminal Appeal No. 394 of 1998 and acquit both the appellant-accused of the offences for which they were charged. The appellant-accused be set at liberty forthwith unless their custody is required in connection with any other case.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Baliya Alias Bal Kishan v. State Of Madhya Pradesh .
    (Oct 5, 2012)