AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (John Mathew, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

Plaintiffs (appellants) sued for recovery of possession of a building (plaint A schedule) and arrears of rent. The plaintiffs alleged that on 8-10-1982 they entered into Ext. A1 with the defendant: a document described as an agreement by which the plaintiffs leased out the A schedule building to the defendant at Rs. 150 per month and agreed to purchase B schedule movables (furniture/utensils) from the defendant for Rs. 9,610. On the Ext. A1 date the defendant paid Rs. 9,000 as security/advance. Plaintiffs alleged that after expiry of the lease-term they were ready to repay the advance and purchase the movables on payment of the sale consideration, but the defendant refused to execute a sale deed and refused to surrender vacant possession. Rent was paid only up to 12-9-1985. Plaintiffs alleged damage to the building (loss of Rs. 2,000) and served Ext. A2 (lawyer's) notice dated 8-10-1985 terminating the tenancy; the suit followed (filed 21-11-1985).

The defendant's case included that his father had been tenant since 1957; the defendant and his brother ran the business for their father from 1982; Ext. A1 was executed under coercion after plaintiffs' supporters trespassed into the building; the defendant paid the Rs. 9,000 but no new tenancy arose; Ext. A1 was invalid/unenforceable; the lease rights devolved on all legal representatives of his deceased father; the suit suffered from non-joinder of necessary parties; he had paid rent up to 12-9-1985 and alleged plaintiffs later refused to receive rent. The parties produced various documents and witnesses at trial.

The trial court found Ext. A1 genuine, held the defendant alone was the tenant, refused specific performance for sale of movables, found rent in arrears from 13-9-1985, and decreed recovery of possession on repayment of Rs. 9,000 and arrears at Rs.150/month. On appeal the Additional District Judge held Ext. A1 inadmissible because unregistered, allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit. The defendant then filed a Second Appeal; by order dated 15-6-1992 the matter was referred to a Division Bench and is before the two-judge Bench.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Appellate Court's finding that Ext. A1 can be used only for proving the nature of the transaction and, because there is no pleading and evidence to prove the terms and commencement of the prior tenancy, the suit is liable to be dismissed, is correct.
  2. What order should be passed (i.e., the appropriate disposition of the appeals and decrees)?

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • Ext. A1 was an agreement arrived at pursuant to mediation and not a lease deed requiring registration; the document's nomenclature and clause 15 (referring to five copies prepared and mediators keeping copies) indicate a mediated settlement/agreement.
  • Evidence of P.W.2 (one mediator) supports that Ext. A1 was the product of mediation and that the document was read aloud and copies given to mediators and parties.
  • Because the document constituted a memorial of an earlier oral arrangement rather than a lease creating a registrable interest, it should not be treated as compulsorily registrable (though this contention was not raised below).

Defendant's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • Ext. A1 was executed under coercion and therefore invalid; the defendant alleged he signed because plaintiffs' husband and supporters trespassed and put him in fear.
  • Ext. A1 is an unregistered document creating a lease exceeding one year and therefore inadmissible/invalid; no new tenancy was created by Ext. A1.
  • All legal representatives of the defendant's deceased father inherited the leasehold right, so the suit was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties.
  • Defendant contended rent was paid up to 12-9-1985 and that mediators negotiated an enhancement to Rs. 175 per month after service of Ext. A2, which explained the lack of reply to the termination notice.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kashinathsa v. Narsingsa, AIR 1961 S.C. 1077 This authority was cited by plaintiffs' counsel in argument (court notes it existed). The opinion states this case was relied on by plaintiffs' counsel but says it is not necessary to discuss it because the court rejected the late contention about non-registration; no specific application explained in the opinion.
Kare v. Dy. Director of Consolidation (1976) 3 SCC 119 : AIR 1976 S.C. 807 Cited by plaintiffs' counsel in support of their contentions about registration/agreements. The opinion records the citation but does not analyze or apply it because the court declined to entertain the late-raised registration contention.
Sultan Singh v. Ratan Singh, AIR 1983 Allahabad 66 Cited in argument (registration/related issues). Cited but not discussed in the opinion for reasons explained by the court (contention not raised earlier).
Ashok Kapur (HUF) v. I.T.O., New Delhi (1985) 18 T.L.R. 307 (Del. Trib.) Cited by plaintiffs' counsel on registration/contract principles. The opinion notes the citation but does not discuss its application.
Saraswatamma v. Paddayya, AIR 1923 Madras 297 Interpreting the word "affect" in Section 49 of the Registration Act; used to show breadth of "affect" regarding immovable property transactions. The court used this authority to explain that "affect" includes transactions that create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish rights in immovable property when considering Section 49.
Rana Vidya Bhushan Singh v. Rati Ram, (1969) 1 S.C.W.R. 341 Authority for the proposition that an unregistered agreement cannot create registrable rights but can be admitted as evidence of collateral facts (e.g., character of possession). The court cited it to support the proposition that unregistered documents may be received as evidence of collateral facts though not to create registrable interests.
Biswabani Pvt. Ltd. v. Santosh Kumar, (1980) 1 SCC 185 : AIR 1980 S.C. 226 Principle that where a purported lease is void for non-registration but the person in possession under it pays rent and the landlord accepts, an inference of tenancy (month-to-month) may follow; an unregistered lease may be deemed a monthly lease terminable by notice. The court relied on this dictum to hold that although Ext. A1 was void as a permanent lease (for non-registration), the defendant, having paid rent which was accepted, became a tenant by holding over under Section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act and thus a monthly tenant terminable by 15 days' notice.
Arif v. Jadunath, (1931) 58 Ind. App. 91 (PC) Holds that a lease compulsorily registrable under the Transfer of Property Act must be by registered instrument and if not so made is void. Quoted to show that a lease required to be registered but not so made is void; used to frame the problem of Ext. A1's non-registration.
M. Kesava Gounder v. D.C. Rajan, AIR 1976 Madras 102 Authority cited for the proposition that construction of a document is a question of law and can be raised in a second appeal. Court cited it to justify taking up the construction of Ext. A1 in the Second Appeal even though some points were not argued earlier.
K. Kanna Roddy v. K. Venkata Reddy, AIR 1965 A.P. 274 Cited regarding admissibility of evidence and collateral facts when an unregistered document exists. Used as a supporting authority for the proposition that the existence of a contract as fact is not prohibited even when terms reduced to a document are not admissible under Section 91.
N. Seetharamaih v. N. Raraakrishaih, AIR 1970 A.P. 407 Similar citation regarding admissibility of collateral evidence despite an unregistered document being inadmissible for terms. Referred to support the discussion on evidence where an unregistered document exists.
Venkatagiri Zamindar v. Raghava, I.L.R. (9) 1886 Madras 142 Cited in the context of collateral evidence and the consequences of unregistered instruments. Listed as authority supporting principles about evidentiary use of unregistered documents; no detailed application beyond citation.
Gangayya v. M.C. Samdaria, AIR 1973 Madras 262 Cited on similar lines regarding admission of collateral evidence with unregistered instruments. Referred as part of the authorities explaining evidentiary principles; not separately analyzed.
K.C. Itoop & Sons v. Antony, 1986 K.L.T. 567 Considered whether an unregistered rent deed can be relied upon; held evidence independent of unregistered document may justify inference of a month-to-month tenancy — a question of fact. The court stated this case does not assist the defendant and noted its holding that independent evidence may justify inference of tenancy from month-to-month.
Ram Kumar Das v. Jagadish Chandra Deb Dhabel Deb, AIR 1952 S.C. 23 : 1952 S.C.R. 269 Authority that acceptance of rent by landlord can give rise to an inference of tenancy even where formal lease is defective. Relied upon (along with Biswabani) to support inference that payment and acceptance of rent established a tenancy by holding over.
Hitkarini Sabha v. Jabalpur Municipality, (1972) 2 SCC 325 : AIR 1972 S.C. 2017 Cited among authorities addressing consequences of defective instruments and related principles. Referred to support the general legal discussion; no discrete application beyond citation in the opinion.
Calcutta Credit Corporation Ltd. v. Happy House (P.) Ltd., 1968 (2) S.C.R. 20 : AIR 1968 S.C. 471 Held that party serving a notice may be estopped from denying validity of a defective notice under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act where the recipient has accepted and acted upon it. The court relied on this principle to observe that the defendant acted upon Ext. A2 (notice) and therefore cannot successfully contend that the notice was invalid; it contributed to upholding validity of the notice.
Gur Prasad v. Hansraj, AIR (33) 1946 Oudh 144 Cited for the proposition that a lessee under an unregistered rent deed may be a tenant at will and that no notice may be necessary to determine such tenancy (contextual authority). Used to show that a lessee holding under unregistered instrument may be treated as tenant at will and to support the discussion on notice and termination.
Bundoo v. Akbar Ali, 1978 All. L.J. 215 Cited in relation to facts showing single person paying advance and rent and consequences for non-joinder. Referred by the court to support the trial court's finding that the suit was not bad for non-joinder because only the defendant had paid advance and rent.
Madhubala v. Budhiya, AIR 1980 Allahabad 266 Cited regarding non-joinder and inference from who paid rent/advance. Supported the court's conclusion that non-joinder of other heirs was not fatal where only the defendant had acted as tenant and paid the advance and rent.
Madhavan Vydiar v. Janaki, 1973 K.L.T. 490 & Niranjan Pal v. Chaitanyalal, AIR 1964 Patna 401 (F.B.) Cited by the defendant regarding the effect of defective notice and proof of commencement of lease. The court considered these citations but concluded Ext. A2 was valid in the circumstances (notice sent after expiry of the two-year term and giving more than 15 clear days). The opinion does not adopt these cases to overturn the notice's validity.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a stepwise legal analysis, constrained to the materials and arguments in the record:

  1. Genuineness of Ext. A1: The court accepted the trial court's finding (and noted it was not seriously challenged on appeal) that Ext. A1 is a genuine document. The defendant's signatures on all pages, his handwriting near signatures, payment of Rs. 9,000 on the Ext. A1 date, and P.W.2's evidence that Ext. A1 resulted from mediation and that mediators kept copies, led the court to hold Ext. A1 genuine.
  2. Registrability and admissibility: The court noted Ext. A1 contained terms of a lease for a period exceeding one year and therefore, under Section 17(d) read with Section 2(7) and Section 2(6) of the Registration Act, the lease portion was compulsorily registrable. The agreement to purchase movables did not require registration, but the lease portion did.
  3. Effect of non-registration (Section 49 of the Registration Act): The court examined Section 49 which prohibits unregistered documents required to be registered from affecting immovable property or being received as evidence of such transactions, subject to specified exceptions (e.g., part performance / specific performance / collateral transactions). The court quoted authorities construing "affect" and observed that while an unregistered document cannot create the registrarial rights, it may be admissible for collateral facts such as character of possession.
  4. Whether a tenancy arose despite non-registration: Relying on Biswabani and related authorities, the court reasoned that although Ext. A1 would be void as a permanent lease for non-registration, the defendant's continued possession coupled with payment of rent and the plaintiffs' acceptance up to 12-9-1985 justified an inference that a month-to-month tenancy by holding over under Section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act came into existence. The court treated this as a tenancy terminable by 15 days' notice.
  5. Validity of termination notice (Ext. A2): The court addressed the defendant's contention that the date of commencement of lease was not proved and therefore Ext. A2 was invalid. The court found that Ext. A1 indicated a lease beginning 8-10-1982 with a two-year term expiring 8-10-1984; Ext. A2 (served 8-10-1985) was therefore sent after expiry of the fixed term and provided more than 15 clear days for vacating. The court also relied on the principle (from Calcutta Credit Corporation and related commentary) that a party who acts on a notice cannot later repudiate it; the defendant had acted on Ext. A2 (per his written statement), which further undermined his challenge. The court confirmed Ext. A2 was a valid notice to quit.
  6. Non-joinder of other legal representatives: The court considered whether failure to implead other legal representatives of the defendant's deceased father was fatal. The court noted that Ext. A1 was executed during the father's lifetime and circumstances indicated the father had likely transferred the business/rights to the defendant; the advance of Rs. 9,000 and rent payments were made by the defendant alone; none of the other heirs were shown to have paid rent or otherwise asserted rights in the proceedings. On these facts and authority cited, the court affirmed the trial court's conclusion that the suit was not bad for non-joinder.
  7. Disposition on appeal points: The Appellate Court had treated Ext. A1 as inadmissible for creating the lease and dismissed the suit. The Division Bench held that although Ext. A1 was unregistered and therefore could not create a permanent lease, the factual matrix (possession and payment/acceptance of rent) gave rise to a month-to-month tenancy; the termination notice was valid; and non-joinder was not fatal. Consequently, the appellate court's judgment was set aside and the trial court's decree restored.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The appeal is allowed: the judgment and decree of the lower appellate court are set aside and the judgment and decree of the trial court are restored.

Direct consequences for the parties (as reflected in restoration of the trial court decree):

  • The trial court decree in favor of the plaintiffs — which had decreed recovery of possession of the plaint A schedule building on repayment of Rs. 9,000 (the sum paid on Ext. A1 date) and recovery of arrears of rent at the rate of Rs. 150 per month — stands restored.
  • The court held that although Ext. A1 (being unregistered as to a lease exceeding one year) cannot create the registrable lease-rights, the facts established a month-to-month tenancy by holding over (defendant had paid rent and plaintiffs accepted it), terminable by 15 days' notice; Ext. A2 was validly served and effective.
  • Non-joinder of other legal representatives of the defendant's father did not invalidate the suit, because only the defendant had acted as tenant and paid advance/rent and no material assertion by other heirs was evidenced.

Broader implications: The opinion applies established principles about non-registration, admissibility of unregistered documents for collateral facts, and the legal effect of acceptance of rent in creating a month-to-month tenancy. The opinion did not purport to set a novel precedent beyond applying these principles to the facts; its primary effect is to restore the trial court's decree between these parties.

    Mohammed Kunju Isha Beevi And Others v. Elayakunju Shahul Hameed

    John Mathew, J.:— Plaintiffs are the appellants. The suit was for recovery of possession with arrears of rent. According to the plaintiffs plaint A schedule building belonging to them was leased out to the defendant on 8-10-1982 on a monthly rent of Rs. 150/- as per Ext. A1 agreement. Plaint B schedule movables belong to the defendant. As per Ext. A1 agreement plaintiffs Page: 315agreed to purchase B schedule movables for a consideration of Rs. 9,610/-. On Ext. A1 date the defendant paid Rs. 9,000/- to the plaintiffs as security for the rent arrangement. After the period of lease the plaintiffs were ready and willing to repay the advance and purchase B schedule movables on paying the sale consideration. The defendant did not agree to execute the sale deed in respect of plaint B schedule movables. He was also not willing to surrender vacant possession of A schedule building. Rent was paid only up to 12-9-1985. Due to the damages caused by the defendant to plaint A schedule building the plaintiffs have sustained a loss of Rs. 2,000/-. Plaintiffs caused to send Ext. A2 lawyer's notice dated 8-10-1985 terminating the tenancy. Subsequently the suit was filed.

    2. Defendant contended that his father Elayakunju had taken plaint A schedule building on rent from the original owner in 1957. He was conducting business in the building. B schedule movables were purchased by him for conducting tea-shop in the building. In 1982 when defendant's father was laid up defendant and his brother were conducting the business on his behalf. In October, 1982 plaintiffs demanded to enhance the rent and to pay a sum of Rs. 10,000/- as advance. They also compelled the defendant to execute a rent deed in their favour. Since the defendant was not amenable to this, plaintiffs' husband and their supporters trespassed into the building and finally they forced the defendant to sign Ext. A1 agreement. They have also received Rs. 9,000/- from the defendant. By Ext. A1 no new tenancy was created. Defendant did not agree to sell the plaint B schedule movables. Defendant was forced to execute Ext. A1 as he was put to fear. Defendant's father was in possession of the building till his death on 21-8-1984. He was paying the enhanced rent also. After the death of defendant's father his right in A & B schedule items devolved on all of his legal representatives including the defendant. Defendant and his brother have been conducting the business for and on behalf of themselves and the other legal representatives. Suit is bad for non-Joinder of necessary parties. Ext. A1 agreement is invalid and unenforceable. Defendant has paid rent up to 12th September 1985. Thereafter plaintiffs refused to receive the rent. After receiving the notice certain mediators intervened and the defendant and others agreed to enhance the rent to Rs. 175/- per month. Exts. A1 to A4 series were produced on behalf of the plaintiffs. Second plaintiff was examined as P.W 1. Another witness was examined as P.W 2. The defendant produced Exts. B1 to B15. Defendant was examined as P.W 1 Another witness was examined as D.W 2. The trial court held that Ext. A1 was a genuine document and that the defendant alone is the tenant of plaint A schedule building. The trial court further held that the plaintiffs are not entitled to the relief of specific performance regarding the sale Page: 316of plaint B schedule movables. The court further held that rent was in arrears from 13-9-1985 onwards. Recovery of arrears of rent on that basis was also allowed. Accordingly the suit was decreed in part and the plaintiffs were allowed to recover plaint A schedule building on repayment of Rs. 9,000/- paid to them as security. Plaintiffs were also allowed to recover arrears of rent at the rate of Rs. 150/- per month.

    3. In the appeal filed by the defendant the learned Additional District Judge held that Ext. A1 was not admissible in evidence since it was an unregistered document. Plaintiffs had not challenged the decree of the trial court refusing specific performance of the agreement for sale of plaint B schedule items. The Appellate Court allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit. The Second Appeal is directed against the said judgment and decree.

    4. Our learned brother Chettur Sankaran Nair, J. by his order dated 15th June, 1992 referred the Second Appeal to a Bench of two Judges. Accordingly the appeal is now before us.

    5. In the nature of the contentions the following points arise for consideration: (1) Whether the finding of the Appellate Court that Ext. A1 can be used only for proving the nature of the transaction and since there is no pleading and evidence to prove the terms and commencement of the prior tenancy the suit is liable to be dismissed, is correct. (2) What is the order to be passed?

    6. Point Nos. (1) & (2): Learned counsel for the plaintiffs - appellants submitted that a reading of Ext. A1 along with the evidence of P.W 2 will show that Ext. A1 was only an agreement pursuant to a settlement and not a lease deed. Learned counsel pointed out that the nomenclature of the document shows that it is only an agreement and not a lease deed. In clause 15 of Ext. A1 it is specifically stated that as per the agreement arrived at between the parties through the intervention of the modiators 5 copies of this agreement were prepared, out of which one copy was to be kept by the plaintiffs, one copy by the defendant and one copy each by the three mediators who have also signed in the document as mediators. P.W 2 is one of the alleged mediators. He gave evidence to the effect that he along with two others mediated in the dispute between the plaintiffs and the defendant, as a result of which Ext. A1 agreement was entered into. All the three mediators kept one copy each of Ext. A1. Before signing Ext. A1 the document was read aloud in the presence of plaintiffs and defendant. The contention that Ext. A1 is only an agreement arrived at by the mediation of P.W 2. Page: 317and others and not a lease deed requiring registration, was not urged in the trial court or in the first appeal. That may be because the defendant did not put forward any contention in his written statement or at the evidence stage that Ext. A1 was inadmissible in evidence due to its non-registration. That contention appears to have been urged only at the time of arguments before the trial court. According to the learned counsel for the plaintiffs that was the reason why this contention was not raised till now. Under the circumstances of this case, we are of the view that the plaintiffs cannot be permitted to urge this contention at this stage.

    7. The suit was for eviction from plaint A schedule property which consists of three shop rooms and a verandah. The arrangement between the parties is governed by the provisions in Ext. A1, according to the averments in the plaint. Plaintiffs' father was the original owner of this property. In 1950 he let it out to the defendant's father under an oral lease. After the plaintiffs' father's death the three plaintiffs became the owners of the property and they were collecting the rent. Defendant's father had two wives. The defendant is the only son through the first wife. As per Ext. A1 the monthly rent was Rs. 150/-. Defendant” father became an invalid in 1982 January and died on 21-8-1984. Plaintiffs case is that defendant's father orally assigned his right over the property to the defendant and even during defendant's father's life time the defendant was exclusively conducting the tea-shop business (Shini Hotel) in plaint A schedule property. According to the plaintiffs they wanted a record for this oral arrangement and they approached P.W 2 and two other mediators. On their mediation it was agreed that the defendant will continue as the tenant on a monthly rent of Rs. 150/-. As per the agreement the defendant paid Rs. 9,000/- as advance. A period of two years was fixed for the tenancy, after which on demand the defendant was to surrender the property. It was also agreed that the plaintiffs will purchase the furniture and other utensils in the building for Rs. 9,610/-. A list of the furniture and utensils was appended to Ext. A1. Ext. A1 dated 8-10-1982 was executed incorporating these terms. It may be observed that on Ext. A1 date defendant's father was alive. He died only in 1984. The defendant was paying the rent up to 12-9-1985 viz. for about three years after Ext. A1. The lease was terminated by Ext. A2 notice and the suit was filed on 21-11-1985.

    8. The defendant contended that Ext. A1 agreement was executed by exerting force on the defendant. Defendant has signed on all pages of Ext. A1. He has also written his name before signing on the first page and last but one page, Defendant had paid Rs. 9,000/- to the plaintiffs a advance on Ext. A1 date, Defendant admits that the rate of rent Page: 318mentioned in Ext. A1 is correct. These circumstances show that the defendant voluntarily executed Ext. A1. Over and above this the evidence of P.W 2 that Ext. A1 was signed under the mediation of himself and two others and that he and other mediators were given a copy each of Ext. A1 support this view. The trial court held that Ext. A1 is a genuine document. It would appear that in the appeal the genuineness of Ext. A1 was not challenged. In the nature of the evidence adduced in this case, we hold that Ext. A1 is a genuine document.

    9. Then the question is whether the document was compulsorily registrable. Learned counsel for the plaintiffs-submitted that Ext. A1 only spells out an earlier oral arrangement of lease and therefore, it is not compulsorily registrable. Since this contention was not raised before the trial court or in appeal, we are of the view that the plaintiffs are not entitled to raise such a ground in this Second Appeal. In that view it is not necessary to discuss the following authorities relied on by the learned counsel for the plaintiffs. Kashinathsa v. Narsingsa AIR 1961 S.C 1077, Kare v. Dy. Director of Consolidation - (1976) 3 SCC 119 : AIR 1976 S.C 807, Sultan Singh v. Ratan Singh - AIR 1983 Allahabad 66 & Ashok Kapur (HUF) v. I.T.O, New Delhi - (1985) 18 T.L.R 307 (Del. Trib).

    10. Under Section 17(d) of the Registration Act Ext. A1 is compulsorily registrable since it is a lease agreement for a period exceeding one year. A lease agreement is also included in the definition of lease contained in Section 2(7) of the Registration Act. Under Section 2(6) land and building are also included in the definition of immovable property. No doubt, Ext. A1 contains two parts viz. a lease agreement as well as an agreement to purchase the furniture and utensils in the plaint schedule room. The agreement to purchase the movables does not require registration. However, the lease agreement in respect of immovable property for a period exceeding one year was compulsorily registrable.

    11. Therefore, the effect of non-registration of Ext. A1 requires to be considered. Section 49 of the Registration Act is as follows:

    “49. No document required by section 17 or by any provision of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, to be registered shall—

    (a) affect any immoveable property comprised therein, or

    (b) confer any power to adopt, or

    (c) be received as evidence of any transaction affecting such property or conferring such power,

    unless it has been registered:

    Provided that an unregistered document affecting immoveable property and required by this Act or the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, to be registered may be received as evidence of a suit for specific performance under Chapter II of the Specific Relief Act, 1877, or as evidence of part performance of a contract for the purposes of section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act 1882, or as evidence of any collateral transaction not required to be effected by registered instrument.”

    12. Under Clause (a) of Section 49 a document which is required to be registered shall not affect any immoveable property comprised therein, unless it has been registered. The word ‘affect’ takes in all transactions which may produce an effect upon or produce a material influence upon immoveable property. See in this connection Saraswatamma v. Paddayya AIR 1923 Madras 297. Reading Section 17 of the Registration Act and section 91 of the evidence Act along with Section 49 of the Registration Act the word ‘affect’ will have to be taken as expressing the meaning ‘purporting or operating to create, declare, assign, limit or (extinguish, whether in present or in future, any right, title or interest vested or contingent’. It is well settled that even though an agreement could not create any such right for the reason that the agreement was unregistered, it can be admitted and taken as evidence of collateral facts or purposes like character of possession. (See Rana Vidya Bhushan Singh v. Rati Ram - (1969) 1 S.C.W.R 341).

    13. According to the learned counsel for the plaintiffs since the defendant paid rent after the execution of Ext. A1, a relationship of landlord and tenant came into existence and the lease from month to month has to be inferred. This contention seems to be correct in view of the following dictum of the Supreme Court in Biswabani Pvt. Ltd. v. Santosh Kumar - (1980) 1 SCC 185 : AIR 1980 S.C 226, para 14:

    14. The Privy Council in Arif v. Jadunath, (1931) 58 Ind. App. 91 (PC) in terms held that if an indenture of lease is compulsorily registrable under Section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act, such a lease can only be made by a registered instrument and if not so made, is void altogether. However, if from, such a person in possession under a void lease the landlord accepts rent as held in Ram Kumar Das's case, an inference of tenancy would follow. Mulla in ‘Transfer of Property Act, 6th Edn., at p. 680 has observed that an oral agreement accompanied by delivery of possession, if for more than one year is valid, by delivery of possession, for the first year, and thereafter the lessee continuing in possession with the assent of the lessor becomes a tenant by holding Page: 320over under Section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act. Such a lease being created by operation of law is binding even though the provisions of Section 107 have not been complied with. It is also noted at P. 681 that though an unregistered lease is void as a permanent lease, it can be deemed to be a monthly lease terminable by 15 days' notice.”

    14. Although such a contention was not specifically taken in the lower, courts, since the construction of a document is a pure question of law, it can be taken in this Second Appeal. See M. Kesava Gounder v. D.C Rajan - AIR 1976 Madras 102.

    15. An unregistered document will not avail to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish any right, title or interest in or to the immoveable property comprised in the document, Therefore, under Section 49(c) of the Registration Act such a document will be ineffectual to achieve the purpose for which it was brought into being, Section 49(c) prohibits the reception of such a document as evidence of any transaction affecting the immovable property comprised in it. However, Section 49(c) does not prohibit the reception of any other evidence of the transaction. Under section 91 of the evidence Act no evidence shall be given in proof of the terms of such a contract when the terms of the contract have been reduced to the form of a document, except the document itself or secondary evidence is admissible under the provisions of the Evidence Act. Thus if the Unregistered document is not to be relied upon and if the terms of the disposition of property embodied in the document are not sought to be proved by other evidence, the bar of Section 49(c) of the Registration Act and section 91 of the evidence Act will not apply. Only oral evidence in proof of the terms of the contract, is prohibited under section 91 of the evidence Act. The existence as a fact of the contract is not prohibited. See in this connection K. Kanna Roddy v. K. Venkata Reddy - AIR 1965 A.P 274 F.B & N. Seetharamaih v. N. Raraakrishaih - AIR 1970 A.P 407. Here without reference to Ext. A1 all the terms of the agreement are clear. See also Venkatagiri Zamindar v. Raghava - I.L.R (9) 1886 Madras 142 & Gangayya v. M.C Samdaria - AIR 1973 Madras 262.

    16. In the written statement the defendant has admitted the payment of Rs. 9,000/- to the plaintiffs. It is also admitted that the rate of rent was Rs. 150/- per month. The only contention was that Ext. A1 was executed by threatening the defendant and that all the legal representatives of deceased Elayakunju inherited his leasehold right. It is also admitted that the defendant paid rent to the plaintiffs at the rate of Rs. 150/- up to 12-9-1985. As D.W 1 the defendant admitted the rate Page: 321of rent as well as the payment of rent up to 12-9-1985. Therefore, the date from which the rent was defaulted is also not in dispute.

    17. In K.C Itoop & Sons v. Antony - 1986 K.L.T 567 the question that was considered was whether an unregistered rent deed can be relied on to establish the relationship existing between the parties. In that case this Court held that no lease can come into existence on the strength of that unregistered lease deed. However, it was further held that independent of that unregistered document the person in possession can lead evidence which may justify an inference of tenancy from month to month and that it is a question of fact to be decided on the materials available. We do not think that the said judgment will be of any assistance to the defendant. See also Ram Kumar Das v. Jagadish Chandra Deb Dhabel Deb - AIR 1952 S.C 23 - 1952 S.C.R 269, Hitkarini Sabha v. Jabalpur Municipality - (1972) 2 SCC 325 : AIR 1972 S.C 2017 & Biswabani Pvt. Ltd. v. Santosh Kumar - (1980) 1 SCC 185 : AIR 1980 S.C 226.

    18. Thus as held in Biswabani's case ((1980) 1 SCC 185 : AIR 1980 S.C 226) even though Ext. A1 is a void lease, the defendant who is in possession under that void lease paid rent and the landlords accepted the rent upto 12-9-1985. On the reasoning in the said case we hold that the defendant became a tenant by holding over under Section 116 of the Transfer of Property Act even though the provisions of Section 107 of the T.P Act have not been complied with and that it can be deemed to be a monthly lease terminable by 15 days notice.

    19. The further contention on behalf of the defendant is that there is no valid termination of the lease. According to the learned counsel the date of commencement of the lease is not proved and therefore, Ext. A2 notice will not amount to a valid termination of the lease. In this connection reliance was placed on Madhavan Vydiar v. Janaki 1973 K.L.T 490 & Niranjan Pal v. Chaitanyalal - AIR 1964 Patna 401 F.B We have already held that Ext. A1 will not create a lease and no rights will flow from that document. However, we have held that a month to month tenancy has to be deemed to have come into existence.

    20. Admittedly the defendant received Ext. A2 notice. In Calcutta Credit Corporation Ltd. v. Happy House (P.) Ltd. (1968 (2) S.C.R 20 AIR 1968 S.C 471) the Supreme Court held that the party serving the notice will be estopped from denying the validity of a defective notice under Section 106 of the T.P Act. In Mulla's T.P Act, 7th Edition, page 671 the learned author after referring to the Calcutta Credit Corporation case, observed as follows:

    “It is submitted that the same principle would apply if the recipient of the notice having accepted and acted upon a defective notice seeks to contend that it is invalid provided, of course, that the party serving the notice can show that he has acted upon such notice and materially altered his position to his prejudice.”

    21. In para 13 of the written statement the defendant contended that on receipt of the notice certain mediators intervened and on their mediation rent was increased to Rs. 175/- per month. It was for that reason that no reply was sent to Ext. A2 notice.

    22. Even from the statements in the written statement it is clear that the defendant took some action pursuant to Ext. A2 notice which means that the defendant acted upon the notice. See in this connection Gur Prasad v. Hansraj - AIR (33) 1946 Oudh 144, where it was held that a lessee holding under unregistered rent deed is merely a tenant at will and no notice is necessary to determine, tenancy.

    23. It may also be observed that the plaintiffs' case is that the plaint schedule building was leased out to the defendant on a monthly rental of Rs. 150/- on 8-10-1982 and that the period of tenancy was 2 years. It was also alleged that there was an agreement between the plaintiffs and the defendant that the defendant shall surrender vacant possession of the building within one year after the expiry of the aforesaid term of two years. Ext. A2 notice was sent on 8-10-1985 terminating tenancy on 8-11-1985. We have already found that the defendant was a monthly tenant under the plaintiffs. The term of two years expired on 8-10-1984. That being so, the notice evidenced by Ext. A2 cannot be said to be invalid, as it was sent after the expiry of the term of the tenancy. So also the notice is not invalid since the tenancy was terminated by the end of the month of tenancy providing more than 15 clear days for vacating the plaint schedule building as envisaged under Section 106 of the T.P Act. Therefore, even on merits the contention that the notice is invalid has to be rejected.

    24. We confirm the finding of the trial court that the notice to quit is valid.

    25. Then the only remaining question is whether all the legal representatives of the defendant's father ought to have been impleaded in the suit. Although Ext. A1 is inadmissible in proving the creation of a lease arrangement between the plaintiffs and the defendant, it can be considered to prove the jural relationship Page: 323between the plaintiffs and the defendant. Ext. A1 was executed during the lifetime of defendant's father. From this circumstance it is highly probable that defendant's father had transferred his rights in the business and in the building to the defendant. The circumstance that profession tax and licence fee for the business were continued to be paid in the name of defendant's father, will only show that the defendant did not take steps to effect change of the names in the registers of the local authority and continued to pay the tax in the name of his father. We have already found that Ext. A1 is not bad on account of threat or coercion alleged to have been exerted by the plaintiffs on the defendant. Ext. A2 notice sent on behalf of the plaintiffs to the defendant was not replied by him. In case he had a case that the leasehold right vested in all the legal representatives of his deceased father, it was only probable that he would have informed the plaintiffs about that by sending a reply. The names of the other legal heirs would also have been informed to the plaintiffs. Even in the written statement their names are not mentioned. None of them have paid any rent. It was under these circumstances that the trial court held that there was an implied surrender of tenancy to other heirs, even if the contention of the defendant that the lease devolved on all the legal representatives is accepted. The advance amount of Rs. 9,000/- was admittedly paid by the defendant alone. The rent was also being paid by the defendant alone. See in this connection Bundoo v. Akbar Ali - 1978 All. L.J 215 & Madhubala v. Budhiya AIR 1980 Allahabad 266. Therefore, we confirm the finding of the trial court that the suit is not bad for non - joinder of parties. The learned District Judge only considered the question of non registration of Ext. A1 and the other points raised by the parties.

    26. In the result the judgment and decree of the lower appellate court are set aside and the judgment and decree of the trial court are restored, The appeal is allowed as above with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohammed Kunju Isha Beevi And Others v. Elayakunju Shahul Hameed
    (Apr 5, 1993)