AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Acts
  • section 4(1) of the land acquisition act ('the act')
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Acts
  • section 4(1) of the land acquisition act ('the act')
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from L.A.O.P. No. 85 of 1999 before the Senior Civil Judge, Gudur. The appellants are the claimants whose land measuring 10 acres and 25 cents in survey Nos. 354/1A & 354/1B (Penubarthy Village, Rapur Mandal) with pomegranate trees was acquired for foreshore submersion of Kandaleru reservoir under the Telugu Ganga Project. Section 4(1) notification was issued on 25.07.1994, followed by declaration under Section 6 and an award by the Land Acquisition Officer dated 31.07.1996 fixing market values for land and trees. The reference Court enhanced the award, fixing specified market values for categories of land, trees and other items (including a per-tree value for pomegranate trees of Rs. 75 per tree per year with a multiplier of 3, and a total tree count of 1,053).

The appellants challenged the adequacy of compensation—principally the valuation of the pomegranate trees—and filed the present appeal. The appeal proceeded with oral evidence (claimants examined CW-1 to CW-3) and documentary exhibits (Exs. A-1 to A-20). The Government/Respondents defended the reference Court's findings. The appellate bench considered the evidence, earlier precedents, and documentary material and enhanced the compensation for pomegranate trees to Rs. 2,000 per tree with statutory additions and interest, while leaving other findings intact.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the compensation fixed by the reference Court for the fruit-bearing pomegranate trees was inadequate and required enhancement.
  2. Whether the capitalization/yield (multiplier) method should have been applied to value the pomegranate trees and, if so, what multiplier and valuation ought to apply.
  3. What statutory benefits and interest are payable on any enhanced compensation awarded.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • Government Order G.O.Ms. No. 338/63/1988 setting market values for fruit trees and its guidelines were ignored by the reference Court without basis.
  • The reference Court and the Land Acquisition Officer failed to apply the multiplier (capitalization) method despite numerous precedents from the Supreme Court and this Court.
  • Oral evidence (CW-1 to CW-3) and documents (Exs. A-1 to A-20) established that the appellants grew the Ganesh variety of pomegranate, a variety yielding more fruit, and that trees were about five years old (gestation period), making capitalization appropriate.
  • Based on documentary evidence and NABARD guidelines (100–150 fruits per tree; assumed fruit price Rs. 3; average yield 150 fruits), net lifetime income per tree supports valuation of each tree at Rs. 3,600 or more.
  • Relied on Verareddy Kumaraswamy Reddy v. State of A.P. (2006) for the principle that annual income should be multiplied by the life of the trees (capitalization method) and on decisions of this Court (Special Deputy Collector v. Peddireddy Madhava Reddy; Palempalli Sunil Manohar Reddy v. Special Deputy Collector) for support.

Respondents' (Government) Arguments

  • The reference Court had been liberal in awarding compensation to fruit bearing trees and the amounts fixed are, in the Government's view, on the higher side; the Government chose not to disturb those findings to bring finality.
  • The appellants' claims were exaggerated and the claimants failed to discharge the burden of proving the actual number of trees, their ages and annual yield with cogent material.
  • On the record, there was no basis to come to any conclusion different from that arrived at by the reference Court; the reference Court's order is just and proper and does not call for interference.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Verareddy Kumaraswamy Reddy v. State of A.P. (2006) 2 SCC 670 Principle of capitalization: annual income should be multiplied by the lifetime of the trees. The appellants relied on this authority to argue for capitalization/yield-based valuation; the Court acknowledged the principle when considering whether multiplier should apply.
Sk. Imambi v. Spl. Deputy Collector Discussed appropriate multipliers for trees; affirmed that standard multiplier should be 10, with higher or lower multipliers only in special circumstances supported by evidence. The Court cited this decision's reasoning regarding multipliers (standard multiplier 10) as part of the legal backdrop for assessing whether a multiplier should be applied and what multiplier is appropriate.
Commr.-cum-Land Acquisition Officer v. S.T. Pompanna Setty (2005) 9 SCC 662 Where compensation is awarded on yield basis, multiplier '10' is proper and appropriate (as applied in similar contexts). Referenced by the Court and earlier Division Bench decisions as supporting the use of multiplier 10 when yield-based valuation is applied.
Land Acquisition Officer v. P. Veerabhadarappa (1984) 2 SCC 120 Authority cited for the proposition that the standard multiplier should be 10; courts may, on special evidence, adopt higher or lower multipliers. Used as one of the consistent authorities establishing the standard multiplier rule which the Court considered in choosing how to value the trees.
Land Acquisition Officer v. Madivalappa Basalingappa Melavanki (1995) 5 SCC 670 Support for the principle on standard multiplier for valuation of fruit trees. Cited among the Supreme Court decisions indicating when deviations from multiplier 10 may be justified; contributed to the Court's multiplier analysis.
Land Acquisition Officer v. Virupax Shankar Nadagouda (1996) 6 SCC 124 Further authority supporting the consistent approach to multipliers in valuation of fruit trees. Referred to in the Court's survey of Supreme Court jurisprudence on multipliers.
Revenue Divisional Officer v. M. Ramakrishna Reddy (2011) 11 SCC 648 Authority cited among cases reinforcing the standard multiplier approach and the framework for adjusting multipliers in special circumstances. Included in the line of authorities the Court relied on when deciding how to treat the multiplier issue for pomegranate trees.
Special Deputy Collector (Land Acquisition) v. Peddireddy Madhava Reddy and others (A.S. No. 1749 of 2004, disposed 01-03-2013) Division Bench held that where detailed evidence of yield exists, compensation should be determined on yield basis by applying appropriate multiplier; fixed specific market values per tree (and in that decision fixed certain rates e.g., Rs. 3,000/- for several species as a yardstick). This Court relied on that Division Bench's approach and the market value fixed per tree by that bench. The present Court adopted the market-value reasoning and used it as a primary basis for fixing pomegranate tree value at Rs. 2,000 per tree.
Asst. Commissioner-cum-Land Acquisition Officer v. S.T. Pompanna Setty (referenced again) Reiterated that multiplier 10 is appropriate when compensation is awarded on yield basis. Used in the Court's reasoning (via the Division Bench precedents) supporting the use of multiplier 10 as a benchmark in yield-based valuation.
Palempalli Sunil Manohar Reddy v. The Special Deputy Collector (A.S. No. 3798 of 2000, disposed Sept. 2013) Referenced as a recent decision of this Court relevant to valuation of fruit bearing trees (specific rule not described in detail in the opinion). The Court relied upon this decision together with others to support the approach of fixing tree values by reference to precedents and available evidence.
L.A.A.S. No. 427 of 2009 (this Bench) Referenced as a relevant precedent of this bench in matters of valuation of fruit trees (specific rule not elaborated in the opinion). The Court relied on the principles laid down in this bench decision among other authorities in concluding the appropriate valuation for pomegranate trees.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a structured manner, grounded in the record and applicable precedents:

  1. Record appraisal: The claimants examined CW-1 to CW-3 and produced Exs. A-1 to A-20; the Land Acquisition Officer (respondent) produced no exhibits besides his own testimony as R.W.1. The Court noted that the claimants did not heavily contest land value with contemporaneous sale registers or extensive oral evidence, and the reference Court had therefore fixed only a nominal land value while focusing on tree compensation.
  2. Reference Court finding reviewed: The reference Court fixed the per-tree value for pomegranate at Rs. 225 per tree (based on a report of the Director of Horticulture) and earlier award adopted a multiplier of 3 for Rs. 75 per tree per year—these calculations were found wanting on analysis.
  3. Assessment of appellants' evidence and submissions: The appellants had adduced documentary evidence (Exs. A.1–A.20) including sale proceeds, a Horticulture Department letter (Ex. A14), and judgments/awards in related matters. They asserted the use of the capitalization/yield method (annual net income multiplied by lifetime) and argued a per-tree valuation of Rs. 3,600 based on yield and NABARD guidance.
  4. Legal framework on multipliers: The Court surveyed Supreme Court authorities (Sk. Imambi and others) establishing that the standard multiplier is 10 for yield-based valuations, with deviations permissible only in specific circumstances supported by evidence. The Court also relied on Division Bench decisions of this Court (including Special Deputy Collector v. Peddireddy Madhava Reddy) which had applied yield-based valuation and fixed per-tree market values in comparable contexts.
  5. Evaluation of earlier award and arbitrariness: The Court found that the award dated 31.07.1996 did not undertake a proper exercise in fixing tree values and described that approach as arbitrary.
  6. Decision to follow precedents and market indicators: Rather than remanding, the Court decided to fix the compensation itself. It relied on (a) the market value assessed under Ex. A14 (Horticulture Department report), (b) the evidence of PW-1 to PW-3 (claimants' witnesses), and (c) precedents of the Supreme Court and this Court to arrive at an appropriate per-tree value.
  7. Final valuation and ancillary relief: The Court enhanced the market value of pomegranate trees to Rs. 2,000 per tree and granted statutory benefits (30% solatium and 12% additional market value) on the enhanced amount. It also directed interest on the enhanced market value at 9% from the date of taking possession up to one year, and thereafter 15% until the enhanced amount is paid or deposited in court. Other findings of the reference Court were left undisturbed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed insofar as the valuation of fruit-bearing pomegranate trees is concerned: the market value of each pomegranate tree is fixed at Rs. 2,000 per tree.

Implications and consequences:

  • The appellants/claimants are entitled to statutory benefits on the enhanced amount: 30% solatium and 12% additional market value.
  • Interest on the enhanced market value is awarded at 9% from the date of taking possession up to one year, and at 15% thereafter until the enhanced amount is paid or deposited in Court.
  • All other findings of the reference Court were left undisturbed; the Court did not remand the matter but resolved the valuation issue itself to give finality.
  • The opinion relied on existing Supreme Court and Division Bench jurisprudence to reach its conclusion; the Court did not purport to lay down a new principle of law. No new precedent or novel legal rule beyond application of existing authorities was announced by this judgment.

As a sequel, any miscellaneous petition pending was directed to stand closed.

    Maddisetti Bharathi And Another v. Special Deputy Collector And Others

    Dama Seshadri Naidu, J.

    The appellants in this land acquisition appeal are the claimants in L.A.O.P. No. 85 of 1999 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge, Gudur. Impugning the Order, dt. 16.04.2007 passed by the reference court on the ground of inadequacy of compensation, the present appeal is preferred. Facts in brief are that an extent of Ac. 10-25 cents of land belonging to the claimants, comprised in survey Nos. 354/1A & 354/1B of Penubarthy Village of Rapur Mandal, with pomegranate trees standing thereon, was acquired for the purpose of foreshore submersion of Kandaleru reservoir under Telugu Ganga Project. Notification under section 4(1) of the land acquisition act ('the act') was issued on 25.07.1994; it was followed by declaration under Section 6 of the Act; and thereafter the Land Acquisition Officer passed an award on 31.07.1996, fixing the market value of the trees and lands therein and eventually the same was enhanced by the reference Court as follows:

    (a) The market value for the lands under category numbers I and II is fixed at `25,000/- per acre;

    (b) the market value for the lands under category III is fixed at Rs. 20,000/-;

    (c) The market value of each pomegranate tree is fixed at Rs. 75/- per tree per year, with a multiplier of 3, the total number of trees being 1053;

    (d) The market value of the motor shed is fixed at Rs. 22,311/-; and

    (e) the market value of 7 fig trees is fixed at Rs. 7,000/- [consolidated].

    2. Aggrieved by the order passed by the reference court, especially with regard to the value fixed for the pomegranate trees, the landowners have filed the present appeal.

    3. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants has contended that Government issued G.O.Ms. No. 338/63/1988 to fix the market value of different fruit bearing trees, but the guidelines given in the said GO have been ignored by the reference Court without any basis. It is contended that despite numerous precedents laid down by the Supreme Court as well as this Court, the primary authority and the reference Court have not taken into account the multiplier method to fix the value of the fruit bearing trees. The LAO and the reference Court have given a very summary treatment to all the claims made by the appellants.

    4. Summarizing his submissions, the learned counsel for the appellant-land owners has stated that the oral evidence of CW-1 to CW-3 and Exs. A-1 to A-20 clearly show that the appellants have raised Ganesh variety, which yields more fruits than other pomegranate varieties, that the value of each pomegranate tree ought to have been taken as Rs. 3,600, and that by the time of notification the age of trees was 5 years. It has further been contended that as per the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Verareddy Kumaraswamy Reddy vs. State of A.P. (1) (2006) 2 SCC 670, the principle of capitalization method is that the annual income should be multiplied with the life time of the trees. The reference court, however, has not followed the capitalization method. Even as per the NABARD guidelines, each pomegranate tree yields 100 to 150 fruits, that if the price of each fruit is taken at Rs. 3/-, and that if average yield of each tree is taken at 150 fruits, the yield of each tree must come to Rs. 450/-. By deducting the agricultural expenses, the net income per tree in its life time must be more than Rs. 3,600/- per tree.

    5. It is further contended that the evidence of CW-1 to CW-3 and Exs. A1 to A14 clearly establish the number of trees, yield per tree, etc. Finally, the learned counsel has relied on the decision of this court in The Special Deputy Collector (Land Acquisition), Somasila Project v. Peddireddy Madhava Reddy and 114 others (AS. No. 1749 of 2004, decided on 01-03-2013) and Palempalli Sunil Manohar Reddy and another v. The Special Deputy Collector (Land Acquisition) and another (A.S. No. 3798 of 2000, decided in September, 2013).

    6. The learned Government Pleader, on the other hand, has strenuously defended the award, as modified by the reference Court. He has contended that the reference Court has already been liberal in granting compensation to the fruit bearing trees, at the rate specified above, which, in the opinion of the Government, is on the higher side. Despite the same, the Government has not chosen to disturb the said findings, so that a quietus could be given to the issue. It is contended that the claim on the part of the appellants is highly exaggerated. Though the burden lay on the claimants to establish the actual number of trees, their age and the annual yield, the claimants could not place before the reference Court any cogent material to come to any other conclusion than what has been arrived at by the reference Court. In sum and substance, the learned Government pleader has submitted that the order of the reference Court is just and proper and does not call for any interference.

    7. Heard the learned counsel for the appellants and the learned Government Pleader for the respondents, apart from perusing the record.

    8. A perusal of the record shows that during the course of trial, the claimants have examined CWs. 1 to 3 and marked Exs. A. 1 to A. 20. On the part of respondent Land Acquisition Officer, apart from examining himself as R.W. 1, he has not marked any exhibits.

    9. It is evident that the claimants have not laid much stress on the value of the land, as they have not chosen to file any registration extracts of contemporaneous sales to prove the existing market value of the lands; nor have they led much oral evidence in that regard. It is, as observed from the record, felt by the reference Court that since a comprehensive value is fixed for the fruit bearing trees, a nominal value could be fixed for the land in question.

    10. Dealing with the aspect of the value of fruit bearing trees, it has come on record that by the date of draft notification, the age of the Pomegranate trees is about five years, which is also the gestation period. Basing on the report of the Director of the Horticulture, the reference Court has fixed the value of each pomegranate tree at Rs. 225/-.

    11. From a perusal of the record and the submissions made by the learned counsel for the appellants, it is evident that, leaving aside the market Value of the land, the appellants have laid a lot of stress on what is stated to be the omission of the L.A.O. to consider the value of the trees, despite the abundant oral evidence and documentary proof produced by the appellants.

    12. Insofar as the documentary evidence produced by the appellants is concerned, Exs. A. 1 to Ex. A13 relate to the sale proceeds of the produce marketed by the appellants; Ex. A14 is the letter, dated 23.11.1989 issued by the Horticulture Department; Ex. A15 is the copy of the award No. 6/2004-05, dated 25.10.2004; Ex. A16 is the copy of the judgment in LAOP No. 58 of 1990; Ex. A17 is a copy of judgment in LAOP 72/2000; Ex. A18 is a copy of common judgment in LAOPs 113/91 & others; Ex. A19 is a copy of the judgment in LAOP 16/1994; and Ex. A20 is a copy of Government order, dated 20.09.1986.

    13. It may be relevant to recall to the mind that the Hon'ble Supreme Court has recently reviewed the law on awarding compensation to the fruit bearing trees in Sk. Imambi v. Spl. Deputy Collector, wherein it was held:

    6. The Land Acquisition Officer had adopted a multiplier of 14 in regard to the annual income of Rs. 80 per lime tree. That has not been disturbed by the High Court. The High Court, however, was of the view that in regard to the increase in income adopted by it, the multiplier should be only 10, relying upon the decision in Commr.-cum-Land Acquisition Officer v. S.T. Pompanna Setty. (2005) 9 SCC 662 : 2005 (1) ALT 44.1 (DN SC).

    7. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that the multiplier should not be less than 14 adopted by the Land Acquisition Officer. We cannot accept the contention of the appellant. Having regard to the consistent view taken by this Court, we are of the view that the High Court was right in holding that the multiplier should be 10.

    This Court has repeatedly held that the standard multiplier should be 10; and that in special circumstances based upon specific evidence regarding the nature, standard, condition of the orchard, the Court may apply a higher multiplier of 12 or 13 or a lower multiplier of 8. (See Land Acquisition Officer v. P. Veerabhadarappa (1984) 2 SCC 120; Land Acquisition Officer v. Madivalappa Basalingappa Melavanki (1995) 5 SCC 670; Land Acquisition Officer v. Virupax Shankar Nadagouda (1996) 6 SCC 124, Revenue Divl. Officer v. M. Ramakrishna Reddy (2011) 11 SCC 648.) But no such special circumstances are made out.

    7. On the facts and circumstances, we are of the view that the finding of the High Court that the multiplier should be 10 does not call for interference.

    14. Recently, following the above ratio, a Division Bench of this Court has held in the Special Deputy Collector (Land Acquisition) v. Peddireddy Madhava Reddy and others (A.S. No. 1749 of 2004), a Division Bench of this Court through its Order, dt. 1-3-2013, has answered the issue as follows:

    Having regard to such a detailed evidence available with regard to the yield from the fruit bearing trees, it appears to us that the compensation should have been determined on yield basis by applying the appropriate multiplier.

    In identical circumstances, Asst. Commissioner-cum-Land Acquisition Officer v. S.T. Pompanna Setty as reported in (2005) 9 SCC 662), it was held that where compensation is awarded on yield basis multiplier '10' is considered to be proper and appropriate. While relying upon the principles laid down in the said decision, the learned counsel for the respondents/Cross-objectors submitted that the compensation for trees may be awarded by applying multiplier '10'. However, the learned Government Pleader vehemently contended that the said issue requires consideration by the Reference Court and therefore the matter may be remanded for fixing the compensation on yield basis by adopting the multiplier system.

    ...

    Accordingly, instead of remanding the matter, we deem it appropriate to give a quietus to the controversy by fixing the compensation for the fruit bearing trees as under:

    For Mango, Acid Lime, Coconut, Guava, jack-fruit and Sapota (Sapodilla), the claimants-respondents/cross-objectors shall be entitled to compensation at the rate of Rs. 3,000/- per each tree....

    15. A perusal of the award, dated 31-07-1996 would show that no proper exercise has been undertaken in fixing the value of the trees. Such an approach as this, needless to say, is arbitrary.

    16. Without further discussion, in the light of the ratio laid down in A.S. No. 1749 of 2004, disposed on 01.03.2013 and A.S. No. 3798 of 2000, disposed of in the month of September, 2013, as well as the decision rendered by this very bench in L.A.A.S. No. 427 of 2009, the value of the fruit bearing trees is hereby fixed.

    17. In the light of the principles laid down by this Court in the above cases, we propose to rely on the market value fixed per tree by the earlier Division Bench of this in Court in Special Deputy Collector (Land Acquisition) v. Peddireddy Madhava Reddy and others. Thus, having regard to the evidence of PW-1 to PW-3, as well as the market value assessed under Ex. A14, and after appreciating the same in the light of the above precedents of the Apex Court and this Court, we feel that it will sub-serve the ends of justice if the market value of the pomegranate trees is fixed at Rs. 2,000/- per tree, without disturbing any other findings of the reference Court. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed by enhancing the value of fruit bearing tree, namely Pomegranate to Rs. 2,000/- per tree. The appellants-claimants are also entitled to statutory benefits like 30% solatium and 12% additional market value on the enhanced amount. They are further entitled to the interest on the enhanced market value at 9% from the date of taking possession up to one year and thereafter 15% till the enhanced amount is paid or deposited in the court.

    As a sequel thereto, Miscellaneous Petition, if any, pending shall stand closed.

    _____________

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Maddisetti Bharathi And Another v. Special Deputy Collector And Others
    (Nov 20, 2013)