Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • peace.6. Sections 110 and 111 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act No. 2 of 1974)
  • Section 489-A, Section 489-B, Section 489-C or Section 489-D of that Code, or(e)
  • Section 107, Section 108, Section 109 or Section 110,
  • provisions of Section 110, Cr. P.C
  • sections (Sections 107-110, Cr. P.C
  • provisions of section 111, Cr. P.C
  • Sections Page: 148107-109, Cr. P.C
  • Sections 107-110, Cr. P.C
  • Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C
  • Section 111, Cr. P.C Page:
  • section (107-110, Cr. P.C
  • section 111, Cr. P.C
  • Section 110, Cr. P.C
  • Section 482, Cr. P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • peace.6. Sections 110 and 111 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act No. 2 of 1974)
  • Section 489-A, Section 489-B, Section 489-C or Section 489-D of that Code, or(e)
  • Section 107, Section 108, Section 109 or Section 110,
  • provisions of Section 110, Cr. P.C
  • sections (Sections 107-110, Cr. P.C
  • provisions of section 111, Cr. P.C
  • Sections Page: 148107-109, Cr. P.C
  • Sections 107-110, Cr. P.C
  • Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C
  • Section 111, Cr. P.C Page:
  • section (107-110, Cr. P.C
  • section 111, Cr. P.C
  • Section 110, Cr. P.C
  • Section 482, Cr. P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged the entire proceedings of Case No. 124 of 2009 (State v. Rakesh Singh) under Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C, pending before the Court of Pargana Magistrate, Kaisarganj, Bahraich. The challenge was specifically against the notice dated 25.11.2009 issued under Section 111, Cr. P.C. The petitioner contended that the Magistrate issued the notice mechanically on a typed proforma without applying judicial mind and failed to set forth the substance of the information received, which is mandatory under Section 111, Cr. P.C. The proceedings were initiated based on a police report dated 23.11.2009.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the notice issued under Section 111, Cr. P.C without setting forth the substance of the information received is valid?
  2. Whether the Magistrate applied judicial mind before issuing the notice under Section 111, Cr. P.C?
  3. Whether non-compliance with the mandatory requirements of Section 111, Cr. P.C vitiates the entire proceedings under Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C?
  4. Whether the powers conferred under Section 110, Cr. P.C should be exercised with caution and judicial discretion?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The notice under Section 111, Cr. P.C was issued mechanically on a typed proforma with only minimal information filled in, lacking the substance of the information received.
  • The Magistrate failed to apply judicial mind before issuing the notice.
  • Non-compliance with Section 111, Cr. P.C, which mandates setting forth the substance of information, vitiates the entire proceedings.
  • Relied on various Supreme Court and High Court precedents emphasizing the necessity of detailed and judicially considered orders under Section 111, Cr. P.C.

Opposite Party's Arguments

  • The Additional Government Advocate contended that the proceedings under Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C were in accordance with law.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Madhu Limaye v. Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Monghyr (1970) 3 SCC 746 : AIR 1971 SC 2486 Requirement that the order under Section 111 must contain the substance of information to inform the person proceeded against of the grounds for apprehension. The Court held that the impugned notice lacked the substance of information and thus was void, relying on this precedent to emphasize the necessity of detailed notice.
Gopalanachari v. State of Kerala, 1980 Supp SCC 649 : AIR 1981 SC 674 Section 110 must be read narrowly respecting Article 21; powers under Section 110 are drastic and must be exercised with caution and judicial discretion. The Court reiterated the need for strict adherence to procedural safeguards and cautioned against misuse of Section 110 powers as an instrument of oppression.
Siya Nand Tyagi v. State of U.P, 1993 (30) ACC 146 : 1994 Cri LJ 1298 Support for procedural safeguards under Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C. Referenced to support the petitioner’s contentions regarding proper exercise of magistrate’s powers.
Ranjeet Kumar v. State of U.P, 2002 (43) ACC 627 Procedural requirements and judicial discretion under Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C. Used to reinforce the necessity of judicial mind and proper procedure.
Shiv Kant Tripathi v. State of U.P, 2005 (3) JIC 477 (All) Judicial scrutiny in proceedings under Sections 110/111. Supported the principle of careful judicial oversight in such cases.
Devendra Kumar v. State of U.P, 2006 (1) JIC 196 (All) Importance of procedural compliance in preventive orders. Referenced for adherence to statutory requirements.
Har Charan v. State Of U.P & Anr., 2008 (2) JIC 418 : 2008 (4) ALJ 122 Judicial discretion and procedural safeguards under Sections 110/111. Supported the petitioner’s argument for strict compliance with procedural mandates.
Lola @ Manish Dhar Dubey @ Babloo v. State of U.P, 2009 (1) JIC 629 (All) Judicial oversight in preventive proceedings. Used to emphasize the need for judicial mind and procedural correctness.
Mahesh Prasad Kannaujia v. State of U.P, 2009 (2) JIC 918 (All) : 2009 (6) ALJ 69 Procedural propriety in proceedings under Sections 110/111. Reinforced the necessity of compliance with statutory requirements.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the statutory scheme under Chapter VIII of the Cr.P.C, which empowers Magistrates to require security for good behaviour from habitual offenders to prevent breaches of public peace. Sections 110 and 111 Cr.P.C impose strict procedural requirements, including the issuance of a preliminary order under Section 111 that must set forth the substance of the information received, serving as a notice to the person proceeded against.

The Court noted the importance of judicial discretion and cautioned against mechanical issuance of notices without application of mind, emphasizing that Section 110 powers are drastic and must be exercised with care to protect personal liberty. The Court relied heavily on the Supreme Court’s observations in Gopalanachari and Madhu Limaye, which require specificity and judicial reasoning in such orders.

Upon reviewing the impugned notice, the Court found it was issued on a pre-printed form with only minimal details filled and lacked the substance of the information received. This indicated non-application of judicial mind and rendered the notice vague and ambiguous. Consequently, the notice and ensuing proceedings were held to be void and without jurisdiction, constituting an abuse of the court’s process.

Therefore, the Court concluded that failure to comply with the mandatory provisions of Section 111 vitiates the preliminary order and the entire proceedings under Sections 110/111, Cr.P.C.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the petition under Section 482, Cr. P.C and quashed the entire proceedings relating to Case No. 124 of 2009 (State v. Rakesh Singh) including the notice dated 25.11.2009 issued under Section 111, Cr. P.C.

The Court clarified that the learned Magistrate is at liberty to initiate fresh proceedings in accordance with the law and after due application of judicial mind. The decision directly affects the parties by setting aside the impugned notice and proceedings but does not establish any new precedent beyond reaffirming existing principles of procedural fairness and judicial discretion under Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C.

    Rakesh Singh v. State Of U.P

    1. Heard Sri S.M Royekwar, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Rajendra Kumar Dwivedi, learned AGA for the opposite party and perused the relevant documents on record.

    2. The instant petition is being preferred under Section 482, Cr. P.C challenging the entire proceedings relating to Case No. 124 of 2009 (State v. Rakesh Singh) under Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C, including the notice dated 25.11.2009 issued under section 111, Cr. P.C, pending in the Court of Pargana Magistrate, Kaisarganj, Bahraich. It is submitted that the learned Pargana Magistrate, Kaiserganj, Bahraich proceeded to issue impugned notice under section 111, Cr. P.C on the basis of the police report dated 23.11.2009 without application of judicial mind. The impugned notice has been issued on a typed format in a cyclo styled manner. In the said typed format only the name, date and police station has been filled in the gaps. It is further submitted that in violation of section 111, Cr. P.C, the Pargana Magistrate did not set forth the substance of the information received by him in the impugned notice, which is mandatory in nature and non-compliance thereof vitiates the entire proceedings.

    3. Learned Additional Government Advocate strongly contended the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioner and submitted that the impugned proceedings under Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C are in accordance with the provisions of law.

    4. Learned counsel for the petitioner placed reliance on the law laid down by Hon'ble Apex Court in the cases of Madhu Limaye v. Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Monghyr, reported in (1970) 3 SCC 746 : (AIR 1971 SC 2486) Gopalanachari v. State Of Kerala., reported in 1980 Supp SCC 649 : AIR 1981 SC 674 : 1980 Supp SCC 649 SC and also in support of his arguments cited law laid down by this Court in the cases of, Siya Nand Tyagi v. State of U.P, reported in 1993 (30) ACC page 146 : (1994 Cri LJ 1298), Ranjeet Kumar v. State of U.P, reported in 2002 (43) ACC Page 627, Shiv Kant Tripathi v. State of U.P, reported in 2005 (3) JIC 477 (All), Devendra Kumar v. State of U.P, reported in 2006 (1) JIC page 196 (All), Har Charan v. State Of U.P & Anr., reported in 2008 (2) JIC page 418 : (2008 (4) ALJ 122), Lola @ Manish Dhar Dubey @ Babloo v. State of U.P reported in 2009 (1) JIC 629 (All) and Mahesh Prasad Kannaujia v. State of U.P, reported in 2009 (2) JIC 918 (All) : (2009 (6) ALJ 69).

    5. Chapter VIII of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 under the heading “security for keeping peace and for good behaviour” authorizes the Magistrate to take appropriate steps for preventing a person from committing breach of public peace.

    6. Sections 110 and 111 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Act No. 2 of 1974) are reproduced as under:—

    110. Security for good behaviour from habitual offenders.— When (an Executive Magistrate) receives information that there is within his local jurisdiction a person who—

    (a) is by habit a robber, house-breaker, thief, or forger, or

    (b) is by habit a receiver of stolen property knowing the same to have been stolen, or

    (c) habitually protects or harbours thieves, or aids in the concealment or disposal of stolen property, or

    (d) habitually commits, or attempts to commit, or abets the commission of, the offence of kidnapping, abduction, extortion, cheating or mischief, or any offence punishable under Chapter II of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), or under Section 489-A, Section 489-B, Section 489-C or Section 489-D of that Code, or

    (e) habitually commits, or attempts to commit, or abets the commission of, offences, involving a breach of the peace, or

    (f) habitually commits, or attempts to commit, or abets the commission of (I) any offence under one or more of the following Page: 146Acts, namely:—

    (a) the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 (23 of 1940);

    (b) the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 (46 of 1973);

    (c) the Employees' Provident Fund (and Family Pension Fund) Act, 1952 (19 of 1952)

    (d) the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 (37 of 1954);

    (e) the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 (10 of 1955);

    (f) the Untouchability (Offences) Act, 1955 (22 of 1955);

    (g) the Customs Act, 1962 (52 of 1962);

    (h) the Foreigners Act, 1946 (3 of 1946); or

    (i) any offence punishable under any other law providing for the prevention of hoarding or profiteering or of adulteration of food or drugs or of corruption, or

    (g) is so desperate and dangerous as to render his being at large without security hazardous to the community,

    Such Magistrate may, in the manner hereinafter provided, require such person to show cause why he should not be ordered to execute a bond, with sureties, for his good behaviour for such period, not exceeding three years, as the Magistrate thinks fit.

    111. Order to be made.— When a Magistrate acting under Section 107, Section 108, Section 109 or Section 110, deems it necessary to require any person to show cause under such section, he shall make an order in writing, setting forth the substance of the information received, the amount of the bond to be executed, the term for which it is to be in force, and the number, character and class of sureties (if any) required.

    7. A bare perusal of provisions of Section 110, Cr. P.C would reveal that the proceedings under Section 110 are taken to prevent committing such acts, a person as mentioned therein. The object of Section 110 is to afford protection to the public against a repetition of crimes against their person or property; not a punishment of the offender for his past offences but securing good bahaviour for the future. The passing of preliminary order under section 111, Cr. P.C is a condition precedent for taking further steps, no final order in proceeding can be passed without giving an opportunity to such person to show cause.

    8. In the case of Gopalanachari, (1980 Supp SCC 649 : AIR 1981 SC 674) (supra), it was observed by Hon'ble the Apex Court “Law is what the law does, even as freedom is what freedom does. Going by that test, Section 110 cannot be permitted in our free Republic to pick up the homeless and the have-nots as it did when under British subjection because today to be poor is not a crime in this country. George Bernard Shaw, though ignorant of Section 110, did sardonically comment that “the greatest of evils and the worst of crimes is poverty.”

    9. Since Section 110, Cr. P.C confers drastic powers, bind down suspected persons, but not proved to have committed any of the offences specified in various clauses, the power should be used with extreme caution and judicial discretion and strictly according to procedure laid down, so that it may not be used as an engine of oppressions, black-mail or private vengeance and the Magistrate should not be influenced by vague rumour or gossip.

    10. In the case of Gopalanachari, (1980 Supp SCC 649 : AIR 1981 SC 674) (supra), Hon'ble the Apex Court observed in para-6 of the judgment as under:—

    “The constitutional survival of Section 110 certainly depends on its obedience to Article 21, as this Court has expounded. Words of wide import, vague amplitude and far too generalised to be safe in the hands of the police cannot be constitutionalised in the context of Article 21 unless read down to be as a fair and reasonable legislation with reverence for human rights. A glance at Section 110 shows that only a narrow signification can be attached to the words in clauses (a) to (g), “by habit a robber……”, “by habit a receiver of stolen property……”, “habitually protects or harbours thieves……”, “habitually commits or attempts to commit or abets the commission of……” “is so desperate and dangerous as to render his being at large without security hazardous to the community”. These expressions, when they become part of the Page: 147preventive chapter with potential for deprivation of a man's personal freedom up to a period of three years, must be scrutinized by the court closely and anxiously. The poor are picked up or brought up, habitual witnesses swear away their freedom and courts ritualistically commit them to prison and Article 21 is for them a freedom under total eclipse in practice. Courts are guardians of human rights. The common man looks upon the trial Court as the protector. The poor and the illiterate, who have hardly the capability to defend themselves, are nevertheless not ‘non-persons’, the trial Judges must remember. This Court in Hoskot case has laid down the law that a person in prison shall be given legal aid at the expense of the State by the court assigning counsel. In cases under Section 110 of the Code, the exercise is often an idle ritual deprived of reality although a man's liberty is at stake. We direct the Trial Magistrates to discharge their duties, when trying cases under Section 110, with great responsibility and whenever the counter-petitioner is a prisoner give him the facility of being defended by counsel now that Article 21 has been reinforced by Article 39-A. Otherwise the order to bind over will be bad and void. We have not the slightest doubt that expressions like ‘by habit’, ‘habitual’, ‘desperate’, ‘dangerous’, ‘hazardous’ cannot be flung in the face of a man with laxity of semantics. The court must insist on specificity of facts and be satisfied that one swallow does not make a summer and a consistent course of conduct convincing enough to draw the rigorous inference that by confirmed habit, which is second nature, the counter-petitioner is sure to commit the offences mentioned if he is not kept captive. Preventive sections privative of freedom, if incautiously proved by indolent judicial processes, may do deeper injury. They will have the effect of detention of one who has not been held guilty of a crime and carry with it the judicial imprimatur, to boot. To call a man dangerous is itself dangerous; to call a man desperate is to affix a desperate adjective to stigmatize a person as hazardous to the community is itself a judicial hazard unless compulsive testimony carrying credence is abundantly available. A sociologist may pardonably take the view that it is the poor man, the man without political clout, the person without economic stamina, who in practice gets caught in the coils of Section 110 of the Code, although, we as court, cannot subscribe to any such proposition on mere assertion without copious substantiation. Even so, the court cannot be unmindful of social realities and be careful to require strict proof when personal liberty may possibly be the causality. After all, the judicial process must not fail functionally as the protector of personal liberty.”

    11. The powers under Section 110, Cr. P.C must be exercised after observing all the formalities required under the law. The Magistrate can apply his power only on convincing testimony that the person is clear and present danger to the society. It is for the prevention, not the punishment of the crime. The Magistrate has to exercise his discretion in judicious manner.

    12. The passing of preliminary order under section 111, Cr. P.C is obligatory. An order under section 111, Cr. P.C is a condition precedent for taking further steps in any proceedings under Sections 107-110, Cr. P.C The first thing that the Magistrate must do after receipt of the information referred to in Sections 107-110, Cr. P.C is to apply his mind to such information and, if he is satisfied that there is ground for proceeding under this chapter, to pass an order in writing under section 111, Cr. P.C The order under section 111, Cr. P.C must be in a writing and broadly contain the elements (i) Substance of the information received under Sections 107-110, Cr. P.C (as the case may be), (ii) Upon a consideration of such information he has formed the opinion that there is a likelihood of a breach of the peace and that it is necessary to proceed under the relevant sections (Sections 107-110, Cr. P.C as the case may be). He is not bound to draw up an order under section 111, Cr. P.C, merely because he has received a Police Report or other information, (iii) the amount of the bond to be executed, (iv) the term for which the bond is to remain in force, (v) The number, character and class of sureties required, in cases under Section 110, Cr. P.C, and, if so required, under Sections Page: 148107-109, Cr. P.C On the other hand, the order under section 111, Cr. P.C need not give (i) the source of the information received, or supply a copy of the Police report (ii) the list of witnesses in support of the information or the order, (iii) the definite acts which the person intends to commit where the substance of the information is communicated, (iv) a reference to section 111, Cr. P.C itself, if the substantive section (107-110, Cr. P.C as the case may be) is mentioned in the order, (v) the period of imprisonment to be suffered in default of execution of the bond, (vi) any extraneous matter.

    13. In the case of Madhu Limaye (supra), Hon'ble the Apex Court observed “Since the person to be proceeded against has to show cause, it is but natural that he must know the grounds for apprehending a breach of the peace or disturbance of the public tranquility at his hands. Although the section speaks of the ‘substance’ of the information it does not mean that the order should not be full. It may not repeat the information bodily but it must give proper notice of what has moved the Magistrate to take the action. This order is the foundation of the jurisdiction and the word ‘substance 1 means the essence of the most important parts of the information.”

    14. From the perusal of the record, it transpires that the impugned notice under section 111, Cr. P.C has been issued on a typed format in a cyclo styled manner and in the said typed format only the name, date and police station has been filled in the gaps and also the Pargana Magistrate did not set forth the substance of the information received by him in the impugned notice.

    15. In the case of Madhu Limaye, ((1970) 3 SCC 746 : AIR 1971 SC 2486) (supra) it was held by Hon'ble the Apex Court that the person proceeded against show cause notice must be informed of the allegations made against him, by giving him the substance of the information so that he may meet such allegations.

    16. The preliminary order contemplated under section 111, Cr. P.C is a judicial order and has to be prepared and drawn up cautiously and carefully in compliance with the provisions of section 111, Cr. P.C and the order must contain reasons of the Magistrate satisfaction. The substance of the information is the matter upon which he has to show cause. If substance of information is not given in the order under section 111, Cr. P.C the person against whom the order has been made will remain in confusion. The extent of information which must be set forth depends in each case upon the circumstances of that case. The basic object of preliminary order being to give the person proceeded against an opportunity to meet the allegation made against him as well as nature of the order proposed.

    17. In the instant case, the impugned order on the printed proforma without recording reasons show non-application of judicial mind. Use of printed/cyclo styled proforma with some insertions here or there in passing such order is not proper rather on the face it is nothing short of a farce. Notice under section 111, Cr. P.C containing vague apprehensions and allegations on printed/cyclo styled proforma indicate pre-conceived notions.

    18. The impugned notice under challenge is void and proceedings against the petitioner are nullity and without jurisdiction as substance of information received as required is incomplete and ambiguous. Notice without substance of information vitiate the proceedings. The impugned notice issued under section 111, Cr. P.C and proceedings drawn on the basis of such vague notice are apparently abuse of process of court. Failure to comply with the mandatory requirements of section 111, Cr. P.C vitiate the preliminary order and consequently the proceedings. The procedure followed by the learned Magistrate is not in consonance with the provisions of law.

    19. Considering the facts and circum stances of this case and the law propounded by Hon'ble Apex Court in above mentioned cases, it is a fit case where the inherent power of this Court under Section 482, Cr. P.C is required to be invoked for the purpose of se curing the ends of justice.

    20. Consequently, the petition under Section 482, Cr. P.C is allowed and the entire proceedings relating to Case No. 124 of 2009 (State v. Rakesh Singh) under Sections 110/111, Cr. P.C including the notice dated 25.11.2009 issued under section 111, Cr. P.C Page: 149pending in the Court of Pargana Magistrate, Kaisarganj, Bahracih, are hereby quashed. However, learned Magistrate is at liberty to draw a fresh proceedings against the petitioner, in accordance with the provisions of law, as discussed above.

    21. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rakesh Singh v. State Of U.P
    (Feb 15, 2010)