Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302 read with Section 34, and/or Section 302 read with Section 149, Section 302 simpliciter and other sections of Indian Penal Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302 read with Section 34, and/or Section 302 read with Section 149, Section 302 simpliciter and other sections of Indian Penal Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 25 July 1978, communal violence in Villupuram, Tamil Nadu, led to the brutal killing of nine Harijans. Thirty-six non-Harijans were tried; the Sessions Judge acquitted five and convicted thirty-one—sentencing three (A-1, A-11 and A-19) to death and the others to life imprisonment for offences under Sections 302/34, 302/149 and related provisions of the Indian Penal Code. Upon appeal, the High Court:

  • Confirmed the death sentences of A-1, A-11 and A-19.
  • Confirmed life sentences of sixteen convicts.
  • Acquitted thirteen others.

The present Supreme Court judgment reviews those High Court decisions, focusing primarily on (i) the correctness of the convictions and (ii) whether the death sentences should stand.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the concurrent findings of the trial court and the High Court sustaining the convictions of the appellants were justified on the evidence.
  2. Whether the death sentences imposed on Accused 1 (Kannan), Accused 11 (Pachiappan) and Accused 19 (Amavasai @ Ramalingam) met the “rarest of rare” standard articulated in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab, thereby warranting confirmation, or should be commuted to life imprisonment.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The accused were falsely implicated because the victims’ bodies were discovered near their village; unknown assailants, not the appellants, were responsible.
  • The appreciation and assessment of evidence by the courts below contained infirmities warranting reversal of conviction.
  • Even if guilt were upheld, the case did not fall within the “rarest of rare” category; hence death sentences were unwarranted.

State's/Prosecution's Position

The opinion does not set out the prosecution’s arguments in detail, beyond the fact that it relied on corroborated eyewitness and approver testimony to support the convictions and sentences.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 684; AIR 1980 SC 898 Established that the death penalty should be awarded only in the “rarest of rare” cases. The Court applied this benchmark to conclude that the circumstances did not justify retaining the death penalty for A-1, A-11 and A-19 and therefore commuted their sentences to life imprisonment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

After a meticulous review of the trial and High Court records, the Supreme Court reached the following conclusions:

  1. Reliability of Evidence: Testimony from three injured eyewitnesses (PWs 30, 31, 32) was corroborated by medical findings. Four approvers (PWs 1–4) were accepted as credible; their accounts were independently corroborated. No material infirmity in evidence appreciation was demonstrated by defence counsel.
  2. Confirmation of Convictions: Given the consistency between eyewitness, approver and corroborative evidence, the Court upheld all convictions entered by the courts below.
  3. Re-examination of Death Sentences:
    • The Court reiterated that only “rarest of rare” situations justify the death penalty.
    • No overarching conspiracy was proved; all accused were acquitted of that charge.
    • For A-1, only one of the two alleged killings was supported by injured-witness testimony; the other rested chiefly on an approver’s statement.
    • For A-11, medical evidence showed death by strangulation, inconsistent with eyewitness accounts of assault with a casuarina stick, weakening the basis for a death sentence.
    • For A-19, approver testimony implicating him in one death lacked corroboration from injured eyewitnesses.
    Considering these factors, the Court found it disproportionate to retain the death sentences.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Convictions of all appellants are affirmed. The death sentences of Accused 1, Accused 11 and Accused 19 are commuted to imprisonment for life; all other sentences on remaining counts are confirmed.

Implications: The judgment reinforces the stringent “rarest of rare” threshold for capital punishment and demonstrates the Supreme Court’s willingness to scrutinise evidentiary nuances before upholding a death sentence. Practically, all appellants will now serve life imprisonment, and no new legal principle beyond the reaffirmation of Bachan Singh has been set.

    Kannan And Others v. State Of Tamil Nadu .

    M.P Thakkar, J.— Villupuram in Tamil Nadu was the scene of an occurrence which culminated in the killing of 9 Harijans and shocked the conscience of the country. In connection with this occurrence which took place ten years back on 25-7-1978, 36 non-Harijans were prosecuted. Five of them namely A-6, A-8, A-16, A-31 and A-35 were acquitted by the learned Sessions Judge. The remaining 31 were convicted for various offences under Section 302 read with Section 34, and/or Section 302 read with Section 149, Section 302 simpliciter and other sections of Indian Penal Code. Accused 1, Accused 11 and Accused 19 were sentenced to death by the learned Sessions Judge. The remaining accused were sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life. The convicts appealed to the High Court. There was also a reference for the confirmation of the death sentence in regard to A-1, A-11 and A-19. The High Court disposed of both these matters by an exhaustive and well considered judgment giving rise to the present appeal.

    2. The High Court confirmed the death sentence imposed on A-1, A-11 and A-19. The High Court confirmed the sentence of imprisonment for life imposed on 16 of the convicts. The High Court acquitted 13 of the convicts who had been convicted by the trial court. In this appeal we are mainly concerned with the death sentence imposed on A-1, A-11 and A-19 and the sentence of imprisonment for life imposed on the other accused who have appealed.

    3. It appears that in the first week of July a Harijan woman of Peria colony was molested while returning from a cinema show. Incited by this incident, PW 69 along with his companion is alleged to have assaulted PW 79, a member of the Association of Vegetable Vendors on 23-7-1978. PW 79 in his turn reported the matter to the Association and also lodged a complaint with the police which is Ex. P-70. On the next day i.e on 24-7-1978, the Association of the Vegetable Vendors observed a hartal at Villupuram. A great deal of tension prevailed in Villupuram. There were sporadic incidents of violence. It is alleged that Harijans set fire to the houses of non-Harijans. The non-Harijans in retaliation set fire to the houses of the Harijans of Peria Colony. This rioting continued on July 24 and 25, 1978.

    4. The version of the prosecution is that on the morning of 25-7-1978 rumours spread that the Harijans of Peria Colony set fire to the houses of non-Harijans. Incited by such rumours, PW 1 and some others assembled and resolved to catch hold of Harijans of Peria Colony and teach them a lesson. In the wake of this development a number of incidents occurred between 9.30 a.m and sunset. It is alleged that the victims were brought to Bharathiyar and Dharmaraja streets. They were tied to poles and were assaulted. In the result 9 of the Harijans from Peria Colony succumbed to the injuries inflicted on them.

    5. The version of the defence is that the accused have been falsely implicated, since all of them were residents of Maruthur village within the Municipal limits of Villupuram and as the dead bodies were found at Maruthur village and near about the said locality. According to them as the dead bodies of the 9 victims who had been done to death, were thrown by some unknown assailants who had killed them near the lane the police had implicated them on account of suspicion by reason of the fact that the dead bodies were found near Maruthur village. The trial court has accepted the evidence of 3 injured witnesses namely PW 30, PW 31 and PW 32 and several other witnesses including the evidence of PW 1, PW 2, PW 3 and PW 4 who have turned approvers. They were arrested on 13-11-1978 and made confessional statements on 24-11-1978. They have been granted pardon by the trial court. Relying on the testimony of the approvers, three injured eyewitnesses, and other witnesses who have supported the prosecution version the trial court has convicted the appellants and sentenced them in the manner indicated earlier. The High Court on a close and careful scrutiny of the entire evidence has confirmed the death sentence imposed on A-1, A-11 and A-19. The High Court has also confirmed the sentence of imprisonment for life imposed on A-2, A-5, A-7, A-9, A-10, A-13, A-14, A-15, A-20, A-21, A-22, A-23, A-24, A-28, A-29 and A-30. We are now concerned with the conviction of the aforesaid accused and the question as regards the propriety of the death sentence imposed on A-1, A-11 and A-19. We have been taken through the relevant parts of the judgment of the trial court and the High Court. We have also been taken through the evidence of the concerned witnesses. On an analysis of the evidence we consider it appropriate to set out in a tabular form the evidence which connects each of the accused persons and the evidence of the witnesses which connects the particular accused in the context of the injuries inflicted on the victims and the connected weapons used in the assault.

    6. Insofar as the three accused i.e A-1, A-11 and A-19, who have been sentenced to death are concerned the aforesaid particulars may be gleaned from the following statement:

    “Accused Deceased Overt act as per witnesses Weapons used 1 D -1 PW 1 speaks of presence only Casuarina stick PW 32 says that A-1 beat D-1 with casuarina stick on the right side of the head near the bridge and tied D-1. D -7 PW 3 says that A-1 waylaid D-7 and beat him on the head. PW 4, PW 44, PW 45, PW 46 & PW 50 also speak the same Casuarina stick 11 D -6 PW 4 states that A-11 beat on his head twice. PWs 30, 31 and 32 also speak the same Casuarina stick D -8 PW 4 says that A-11 beat him on the right side chest. PWs 30, 31 and 32 also speak the same. Casuarina stick 19 D -5 PW 1 states that A-19 beat D-5 on the back side of his head near the lake Aruval D-7 PW3 Says that A-19 beat D-7 on the back side of the head with an iron rod (MOID) PWs 4, 44, 46 and 50 also speak” Iron rod

    7. With regard to the evidence connecting rest of the accused, who have been sentenced to imprisonment for life, the relevant material may be gathered from the following tabular statement:

    “Accused Deceased Overt act as per witnesses Weapons used (1) (2) (3) (4) A-2 D-8 PW 3 Cut D-8 on the back of his head with koduval Koduval PW 4 also supports A-5 D-8 PW 3 Cut D-8 on his right side forehead Aruval PW 4 also supports A-7 D-2 PW 47 Beat on right side of the neck of D-2 Casuarina stick A-9 PW 47 Hitting one of D-2 to D-4 on the lower jaw with the bent portion of koduval Koduval (according to charge-sheet casuarina stick) A-10 D-4 PW 1 Beat D-4 on his left side chest near the lake Iron pipe A-13 D-3 PW 1 Beat D-3 on backside of the head near lake Casuarina stick A-14 PW 1, PW 2 He was in the group taking D-5 PW 44, PW 45 & PW 46 He was one of the persons who dragged D-2, D-3, D-4 at 10.15 a.m Casuarina stick (according to charge) A-15 D-3 PW 45 Beat D-3 on the right side of frontal region (forehead) Casuarina stick PW 47 also speaks A-20 PW 1 speaks of his presence PW 47 attacked one of D-2 to D-4 with a casuarina stick on his right hand Casuarina stick A-21 D-2 PW 47 Beat on right side neck Casuarina stick A-22 D-2 PW 47 Beat D-2 with casuarina stick Casuarina stick
    (1) (2) (3) (4) A-23 D-2 PW 1 Beat D-2 on the head Casuarina stick A-24 PW 1 Beat D-5 on the back PWs 43, 44 and 47 Beat D-2 on the side of the neck Casuarina stick A-28 PWs 3, 4, 46 and 50 Beat D-7 on the back of the head Casuarina stick A-29 D-8 PWs 3 and 4 Beat on the left forehead Casuarina stick A-30 PW 3 Cut both the legs of D-7 PWs 4, 44, 46 and 50 also speak Aruval

    8. Having perused the evidence of the witnesses and having accorded our anxious consideration to the submissions made by the learned Counsel for the appellants, we are satisfied that the trial court and the High Court were perfectly justified in accepting the evidence of the three injured witnesses PW 30, PW 31 and PW 32. The medical evidence pertaining to the injuries sustained by them fully corroborates their version as regards their presence at the scene of the occurrence. The trial court and the High Court have recorded concurrent findings accepting the incriminating evidence insofar as the appellants are concerned. Counsel for the appellants has not been able to satisfy us that there exists any infirmity in the appreciation of evidence, or assessment of evidence, or in the approach of the courts below to the relevant evidence. There is thus no reason to upturn the concurrent finding of the said courts in this respect.

    9. We have also carefully considered the evidence of each of the 4 approvers namely, PW 1, PW 2. PW 3 and PW 4. By and large their evidence has been accepted by the trial court and the High Court and we see no reason to disturb the concurrent findings of facts recorded by the aforesaid courts insofar as their presence at the scene of occurrence and their participation in the offence is concerned. It is not shown that any of them had any personal animus, motive, or design to falsely implicate the appellants. Even so in regard to their evidence we have made an approach informed with caution with a view to seek independent corroboration. Both the trial court and the High Court have taken into account the other evidence which corroborates their testimony. And on appreciation of their evidence, and the evidence of the witnesses who have corroborated their testimony, recorded a finding of guilt against all of them. We are not shown any good reason, and we see no good reason, to differ from the assessment made by the trial court and the High Court in regard to the credibility of their testimony and with regard to the quantity, and quality of the evidence connecting the appellants to the crime. We therefore confirm the order of conviction as against each and all of the appellants.

    10. Insofar as the appellants excepting original Accused 1, 11 and 19 are concerned the sentence of imprisonment for life and the other sentences on the other counts must be confirmed. Insofar as the three appellants on whom death sentence has been imposed are concerned namely Accused 1 (Kannan), Accused 11 (Pachiappan) and Accused 19 (Amavasai alias Ramalingam), we have carefully considered the facts and circumstances of the case and have reached the conclusion that the ends of justice will be met if the sentence of death imposed on them is converted into the sentence of imprisonment for life. We have formed this opinion inter alia on the ground that if the case of the rest of the appellants is not considered as “rarest of the rare” case within the parameters of the decision of this Court in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 684, AIR 1980 SC 898 the case of Accused 1, 11 and 19 cannot be brought under the category of ‘rarest of rare’ case particularly having regard to the facts of the case. A charge of conspiracy was framed against all the appellants, but all the appellants have been exonerated of the charge of conspiracy. One of the reasons which has weighed with the High Court in confirming the death sentence on Accused 1, 11 and 19 is that each of them was responsible for causing death of two victims by assaulting them. On an examination of the evidence on record and the judgment under appeal, we find that Accused 1 has been found guilty of causing death of two victims namely D-1 (Sellamuthu) and D-7 (Manikundu). Now so far as the evidence connecting Accused 1 with the death of Deceased 1 is concerned, the evidence of PW 32 (one of the injured witnesses) corroborates the evidence of the approver who has implicated him namely PW 1. But so far as the evidence implicating the said accused with the death of the D-7 is concerned the conviction is essentially structured on the evidence of PW 3 (an approver) and other witnesses who are not injured witnesses. None of the three injured witnesses namely PWs 30, 31 and 32 implicates him. Under the circumstances we consider it appropriate to impose a sentence of imprisonment for life instead of death sentence.

    11. Turning now to the case of Accused 11, he has been implicated in connection with the death of two victims namely D-6 (Rangaswamy) and D-9 (an unidentified person). But so far as the evidence of D-6 is concerned the medical evidence shows that his death was caused by strangulation whereas the evidence of the witnesses including the three injured eyewitnesses (PW 30, PW 31 and PW 32) is to the effect that he was assaulted by casuarina stick. We consider it a circumstance which can reasonably be taken to account for converting the death sentence into one of imprisonment for life. Accused 19 has been implicated for the assault on D-5 (Arumugham) and D-7 (Manikundu) resulting in the death of the aforesaid two victims. In regard to evidence implicating Accused 19 with the death of D-5 is concerned, there is the evidence of PW 1 (one of the approvers) and other witnesses. But the evidence of the approver is not corroborated by the evidence of any one of the three injured eyewitnesses namely PW 30, PW 31 and PW 32. Under the circumstances in his case also, in our opinion, the appropriate sentence to impose would be the sentence of imprisonment for life. We accordingly convert the sentence of death into a sentence of life imprisonment.

    12. In the result the conviction of all the appellants is confirmed. Insofar as the sentence of death imposed on three of the original accused i.e Accused 1 (Kannan), Accused 11 (Pachiappan) and Accused 19 (Amavasai alias Ramalingam) is concerned the sentence of death is converted into a sentence of imprisonment for life. All the appellants will, therefore, suffer imprisonment for life. The sentence imposed on all the appellants on the other counts stands confirmed. The appeal of original Accused 1, 11 and 19 namely Kannan, Pachiappan and Amavasai alias Ramalingam partly succeeds on the question of sentence to the limited extent that the sentence of death imposed on them is converted into sentence of imprisonment for life. So far as the other appellants are concerned, the appeal fails and is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kannan And Others v. State Of Tamil Nadu .
    (Oct 31, 1988)