Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2(a) of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act
  • FIR (First Information Report)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2(a) of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act
  • FIR (First Information Report)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal under Section 2(a) of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act. The appellants were convicted by the High Court (in an appeal by the State) after they had been acquitted by the Sessions Judge. The High Court convicted the appellants under Section 302 read with Section 149 (imprisonment for life), under Section 148 IPC (one year’s rigorous imprisonment), and under Section 324 read with Section 149 (two years’ rigorous imprisonment), with all sentences directed to run concurrently.

The Supreme Court considered both the High Court judgment and the Sessions Judge’s judgment and assessed the treatment of eyewitness evidence (PWs 1, 2, 5 and 14), including the fact that the occurrence took place in broad daylight and that three eyewitnesses were injured witnesses.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in reversing the Sessions Judge’s acquittal and convicting the appellants on the basis of the eyewitness testimony of PWs 1, 2, 5 and 14.
  2. Whether appellants who allegedly did not themselves assault the deceased could nonetheless be convicted with the aid of Section 149 IPC as members of an unlawful assembly.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • It was urged (by Mr Mehta) that except for Matadin and Dulare, the other appellants did not appear to have assaulted the deceased and therefore should be acquitted of the charge with the aid of Section 149 IPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court affirmed the High Court’s reliance on the testimony of four eyewitnesses (PWs 1, 2, 5 and 14), finding their evidence “consistent and cogent.” It noted the High Court’s conclusion that no material contradictions were shown, that the witnesses’ statements were corroborated by facts and circumstances, and that they were “natural and probable” witnesses without inherent defects or improbability. The Court also accepted the High Court’s emphasis on the occurrence having taken place in broad daylight and the presence of injured eyewitnesses, which supported their presence at the spot and their capacity to observe the incident.

In contrast, the Court held that the Sessions Judge had rejected the eyewitness evidence on “wrong, unconvincing and unsound” reasons, appearing to be unduly influenced by “insignificant omissions” in police statements. The Court clarified that police statements are intended to be brief and cannot substitute for evidence in court; only “vital” omissions merit serious consideration. Mere small omissions do not justify branding witnesses as liars. On this assessment, the Court characterized the Sessions Judge’s judgment as “manifestly wrong and perverse,” and therefore upheld the High Court’s reversal of the acquittal.

On the Section 149 argument, the Court rejected the attempt to distinguish between appellants based on whether they individually assaulted the deceased. It found that all appellants were members of the unlawful assembly and that their names appeared in the FIR. On these stated reasons, the Court saw no basis to differentiate their cases from those of Matadin and Dulare and overruled counsel’s submission.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

The High Court’s convictions and sentences (life imprisonment under Section 302 read with Section 149; one year RI under Section 148; and two years RI under Section 324 read with Section 149, to run concurrently) remained undisturbed. The appellants who were on bail were directed to surrender to serve the remaining portion of their sentences. The opinion, as provided, does not indicate that it set any new precedent beyond resolving the parties’ dispute on the evidentiary appreciation and application of Section 149 IPC.

    Matadin And Others v. State Of U.P .

    S. Murtaza Fazal Ali, J.— In this appeal under Section 2(a) of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act, the appellants have been convicted under Section 302 read with Section 149 and sentenced to imprisonment for life. They have also been convicted under Section 148 IPC and sentenced to one year's RI. They are further convicted under Section 324 read with Section 149 for which they have been sentenced to two years' RI. The sentences have been directed to run concurrently. All the appellants were acquitted by the learned Sessions Judge but the High Court on appeal by the State convicted them of the various charges mentioned above.

    2. We have gone through the judgment of the High Court and that of the Sessions Judge. We find ourselves in complete agreement with the judgment of the High Court. It appears that all the four eyewitnesses PWs 1, 2, 5 and 14 have given consistent and cogent evidence which has been accepted by the High Court after discussing their evidence. The High Court observed as follows:

    “Nothing was shown to us in the statements of the eyewitnesses by the learned counsel for the respondents on account of which their statements may be rejected. We have not come across any material contradiction on which their statements could be rejected. On the other hand we find that the statements of these witnesses are corroborated by facts and circumstances. In our opinion these witnesses are natural and probable witnesses and their statements do not suffer from any inherent defects or improbability. The occurrence took place in broad daylight and three of the eyewitnesses were injured witnesses. Their presence at the spot cannot be doubted. There was sufficient light and in this light these witnesses could see the occurrence.”

    3. The learned Sessions Judge, had rejected the evidence of the eyewitnesses on wrong, unconvincing and unsound reasons. The Sessions Judge appears to have been swayed by some insignificant omissions made by some of the witnesses in their statement before the police and on the basis of these omissions dubbed the witnesses as liars. The Sessions Judge did not realise that the statements given by the witnesses before the police are meant to be brief statements and could not take the place of evidence in the Court. Where the omissions are vital, they merit consideration, but mere small omissions will not justify a finding by a court that the witnesses concerned are self-contained liars. We have carefully perused the judgment of the Sessions Judge and we are unable to agree that the reasons that he has given for disbelieving the witnesses, are good or sound reasons. The High Court was, therefore, fully justified in reversing the judgment passed by the trial court. We are satisfied that this is a case where the judgment of the Sessions Judge was manifestly wrong and perverse, and was rightly set aside by the High Court. It was urged by Mr Mehta that as other appellants excepting Matadin and Dulare do not appear to have assaulted the deceased, so they should be acquitted of the charge under Section 149. We, however, find that all the appellants were members of the unlawful assembly. Their names find place in the FIR. For these reasons, we are unable to find any ground to distinguish the case of those appellants from that of Matadin and Dulare. The argument of the learned counsel is overruled. The result is that the appeal fails and accordingly dismissed. The appellants who are on bail, will now surrender to serve out the remaining portion of their sentence.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Matadin And Others v. State Of U.P .
    (Mar 6, 1979)