Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary (Delivered by Thanikkachalam, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs (three persons related by marriage) filed O.S. No. 118 of 1983 seeking specific performance of a sale agreement dated 13-7-1980. Under that agreement the defendant (appellant) agreed to sell the A‑Schedule property for Rs. 2,35,000, and on execution of the agreement the plaintiffs paid Rs. 1,00,000 by way of advance. The first plaintiff agreed to purchase half the property and the second and third plaintiffs to purchase one quarter each. Possession was handed over to the plaintiffs in pursuance of the agreement.

Because a suit was pending (filed by one Mehaboob Bivi) and thereby the sale transaction could not be completed within the original one year term, the parties endorsed an extension of six months on 11-7-1981. The defendant also received a further Rs. 10,000 (endorsed on the agreement on 15-12-1981) to discharge a prior mortgage; another endorsement concerning Rs. 10,000 appears in the record. The sale agreement contained a clause that if the defendant could not execute the sale deed in respect of the A‑Schedule property, she would execute a sale deed in respect of the B‑Schedule property treating the advance of Rs. 1,00,000 as sale consideration.

The plaintiffs maintained they were ready and willing to perform their obligations but the defendant refused to execute the sale deed, alleging the pending suit and an interim order affected her ability to perform. The plaintiffs issued a notice dated 10-1-1982 and then instituted the present suit for specific performance.

At trial, plaintiffs produced seven documents and examined the first plaintiff as PW1. The defendant produced four documents and examined her husband (DW1) and one Govindasamy (DW2). The trial Court granted the suit as prayed (directing the defendant to execute the sale deed after receiving the balance of the sale consideration and directing the plaintiffs to deposit the balance within three months). The defendant appealed against that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendant could refuse specific performance on the ground that there was a cloud/encumbrance on the title of the A‑Schedule property due to the pending suit by Mehaboob Bivi (i.e., whether the pending suit/encumbrance prevented execution of the sale deed).
  2. Whether the sale agreement was a contingent contract such that, upon the contingency (inability to convey A‑Schedule free from encumbrance) occurring, the defendant could be compelled only to convey the B‑Schedule property instead.
  3. Whether the plaintiffs had abandoned the contract by delay (specifically by a nine‑month delay in sending a rejoinder to the defendant's reply) or by other conduct.
  4. Whether all three plaintiffs were required to testify at trial for the plaintiffs to be entitled to specific performance (i.e., whether the failure of two plaintiffs to give evidence defeats the suit).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Defendant's) Arguments

  • The defendant executed the sale agreement to raise money for her daughter's marriage and received advances; the plaintiffs were aware of the pending suit by Mehaboob Bivi when the agreement was made.
  • Possession was not handed over as plaintiffs alleged (defendant disputes plaintiffs' possession claim).
  • Because of the pending suit and an interim injunction obtained by Mehaboob Bivi restraining the defendant from interfering with possession, the defendant could not execute the sale deed free from encumbrance; therefore performance was impossible.
  • The sale agreement was contingent: the defendant could convey the B‑Schedule property if the A‑Schedule could not be conveyed free from encumbrance. The contingency has arisen, so the contract has fallen through.
  • Alternatively, the sums taken were loans and/or the B‑Schedule property was intended only as security, so specific performance should not be ordered.
  • The plaintiffs abandoned the contract—there was a nine‑month delay in sending a rejoinder after the defendant's reply notice—and two plaintiffs did not testify, which weakens the plaintiffs' claim.

Respondents' (Plaintiffs') Arguments

  • The defence of contingent contract was not pleaded in the written statement and was not raised at trial; it cannot be permitted at the appellate stage.
  • The sale agreement did not make conveyance of A‑Schedule conditional upon removal of encumbrances; the plaintiffs were willing to take the property even with the encumbrance.
  • PW1 admitted the defendant was willing to execute the sale deed along with the encumbrance; thus a pending suit by Mehaboob Bivi (which only restrained interference with possession) was not an impediment to executing the sale deed.
  • There was no pleading that the plaintiffs were unwilling to buy the A‑Schedule property; the additional Rs.10,000 received by defendant underscores plaintiffs' intention to purchase the A‑Schedule property.
  • The nine‑month lapse in sending a rejoinder does not, given the circumstances, constitute abandonment where plaintiffs had issued the primary notice and pursued their claim thereafter.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sriram Cotton Pressing Factory v. Narayanasamy, AIR 1965 Madras 352 Delay and laches by a purchaser (palpable delay) may amount to waiver or abandonment of the contract; long inaction can justify dismissal for abandonment. The court distinguished that case: there the first notice was itself sent after nine months, evidencing delay; in the present case plaintiffs had issued the initial notice timely and only the rejoinder was sent after nine months, so the earlier decision did not apply and did not establish abandonment here.
Dalisukh v. Guarantee Life & Employment Insurance Co. Ltd., AIR 1947 PC 182 A contingent contract which required the non‑occurrence or occurrence of a specified contingency (e.g., Court approval) may fail where the contingency does not take place. The court held this authority inapplicable: the contingent contract was not pleaded or argued at trial, and additionally the option to treat the A‑Schedule as unsellable rested with the plaintiffs (not the defendant), so the alleged contingency did not in law cause the contract to fail.
Rajendrakumar v. Poosammal, AIR 1975 Mad 379 Under S.20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, the exercise of discretion in granting or refusing specific performance should be judicious and not arbitrary or unreasonable. The court cited this principle to underscore that discretion must be exercised judicially; it was referred to in assessing whether trial Court's exercise of discretion was correct (the court upheld the trial Court's decision).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the sale agreement and the evidence before it and addressed the appellant's contentions in a step‑by‑step analysis:

  1. Interpretation of the contractual clause: The court read the relevant portion of the sale agreement and concluded that the option to "come to the conclusion" that the A‑Schedule sale could not be executed was vested in the purchasers (plaintiffs) and not in the defendant (para 8 of the opinion). Thus the defendant could not unilaterally treat the A‑Schedule as unsaleable and compel conveyance of the B‑Schedule property instead.
  2. Willingness of plaintiffs to perform: The plaintiffs (through PW1) were shown to be willing to purchase the A‑Schedule property even with the encumbrance. Given that willingness, the defendant could not refuse to execute the sale deed merely because the A‑Schedule was not free from encumbrance (para 9).
  3. Pleading and trial conduct: The alleged contingent contract defence was not pleaded in the written statement and had not been argued at trial. The court treated this omission as significant, concluding it was inappropriate for the appellant to raise that distinct contention for the first time on appeal (para 11 and para 14 reasoning).
  4. Effect of the Mehaboob Bivi suit: The court examined the injunction obtained in the Mehaboob Bivi suit and noted that the injunction only restrained the defendant from interfering with possession and enjoyment of the property; there was no injunction expressly restraining the defendant from executing the sale deed. Therefore, the pendency of Bivi's suit could not be treated as an absolute impediment to execution (para 11).
  5. Evidence of parties and burden to prove: The court rejected the appellant's submission that all plaintiffs needed to be examined. It observed that the suit was filed by all plaintiffs and only one plaintiff (PW1) gave evidence to prove the plaintiffs' case; this was sufficient. Likewise, the defendant had not personally given evidence (her husband and another witness gave evidence on her behalf) and thus the appellant's point on non‑testimony of two plaintiffs was not compelling (para 12).
  6. Delay and abandonment: The court considered the contention that a nine‑month delay in sending a rejoinder indicated abandonment. It contrasted the facts with the Sriram Cotton Pressing Factory case and found the circumstances different: here the plaintiffs had issued the original demand notice (forming the basis of the suit) and the rejoinder delay alone did not establish abandonment (para 13 and para 14 discussion).
  7. Application of precedents: The court analyzed the precedents relied upon by the appellant (Dalisukh and Sriram Cotton) and found them distinguishable on the facts and procedural posture. The court emphasized that the contingent‑contract argument was not previously pleaded and that the operative contractual option belonged to the plaintiffs; therefore the alleged contingency did not under the present facts invalidate plaintiffs' claim (para 14–15).

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: Appeal dismissed; the judgment and decree of the trial Court are confirmed.

Immediate consequences for the parties (as stated in the record):

  • The trial Court's decree in favor of the plaintiffs (ordering specific performance) stands and is confirmed by this Court.
  • The defendant's appeal is dismissed with costs.
  • Per the trial Court's directions (as reported in the record), the defendant was directed to execute the sale deed after receiving the balance of the sale consideration and the plaintiffs were directed to deposit the balance of sale consideration within three months of the trial Court judgment; the appellate court confirmed the trial Court's judgment and decree.

The opinion does not purport to lay down a new rule of general application; it applies established principles (including the reliance on cited authorities) to the facts of this case and confirms the trial Court's exercise of discretion in granting specific performance.

    R. Velammal v. R. Daivasigamani And Others

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Thanikkachalam, J.:— The defendant is the appellant herein. The first plaintiff is the brother-in-law of the second plaintiff. The third plaintiff is the co-brother of the first plaintiff. The plaintiffs filed O.S 118 of 1983 for specific performance of the sale agreement dated 13-7-1980. The case of the plaintiffs is as under:— The defendant agreed to sell her property to the plaintiffs under a sale agreement dated 13-7-1980 for a sum of Rs. 2,35,000/-. On the date of the execution of the sale agreement a sum of Rs. 1 lakh was paid by way of advance by the plaintiffs to the defendant. Among the plaintiffs the first plaintiff agreed to purchase half of the suit property and plaintiffs 2 and 3 agreed to purchase ¼th share each in the suit property. In pursuance of the above said agreement possession of the property was handed over to the plaintiffs. According to the sale agreement dated 13-7-1980 the sale transaction should be completed within one year from the date of the agreement. Since a suit filed by one Mehaboob Bivi against the defendant was pending, the sale transaction could not be completed within the period stipulated in the agreement. Hence, the parties agreed to extend the period by another six months for completing the transaction. An endorsement was made to that effect on 11-7-1981, on the sale agreement. The defendant also received another sum of Rs. 10,000/- for the purpose of discharging a prior mortgage. An endorsement was made in the sale agreement on 15-12-1981 to the effect that the defendant received Rs. 10,000/- from the plaintiffs. In the sale agreement dated 13-7-1980 there is a clause stating that if the defendant was unable to execute the sale deed with regard to the A-Schedule property, she agreed to execute the sale deed with regard to the B-Schedule property by treating the advance amount of Rs. 1 lakh as sale consideration. The plaintiffs were ready and willing to perform their part of the contract, but the defendant refused to execute the sale deed on the ground that the suit filed by the said Mahaboob Bivi is still pending. Thereafter, the plaintiffs sent a notice dated 10-1-1982 calling upon the defendant to execute the sale deed after receiving the balance of sale consideration, since the defendant refused to execute the sale deed, the plaintiffs came forward with this suit.

    2. The case of the defendant is as under:—

    The defendant executed the sale agreement in favour of the plaintiffs for the purpose of obtaining money to perform the marriage of her daughter. The fact that Mehaboob Bivi filed the suit O.S No. 20 of 1981 against the defendant was already known to the plaintiffs. The possession was not handed over to the plaintiffs as alleged. Since the said Mehaboob Bivi filed the above suit with regard to the A-Schedule property, the defendant was not in a position to execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiffs. The said Mehaboob Bivi filed an appeal before the High Court and obtained an order of interim injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with her possession and enjoyment of the suit property. Therefore, according to the defendant she was unable to perform her part of the contract. There was a Panchayat in which the plaintiffs agreed to take back their advance amount paid to the defendant. The B-Schedule property was not agreed to be sold to the plaintiffs. It was shown only as security for the advance amount received by the defendant. The defendant obtained the amount from the plaintiff only as a loan and the amount was not received as advance for the sale of the suit properties. Since the defendant was unable to execute the sale deed without encumbrance, the sale agreement has become infructuous. Therefore, the suit is liable to be dismissed.

    3. The plaintiffs filed seven documents. The defendant filed four documents. The first plaintiff examined himself as PW 1. The husband of the defendant examined himself as DW 1. One Govindasamy was examined as DW 2. Considering the facts arising in this case, the trial Court decreed the suit as prayed for with costs, directing the defendants to execute the sale deed after receiving the balance of sale consideration. The plaintiffs were directed to deposit the balance of sale consideration within three months from the date of the judgment. It is against this judgment and decree, the present appeal has been preferred by the defendant. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant/defendant submitted as under:— As per the sale agreement dated 13-7-1980, the defendant agreed to sell the A-Schedule property to the plaintiffs for a sum of Rs. 2,35,000/-. A sum of Rs. 1 lakh was received by way of advance, on the date of execution of the sale agreement. One Mehaboob Bivi filed a suit against the defendant with regard to the A-Schedule property. She also obtained an interim order against the defendant restraining her from interfering with the possession and enjoyment of the A-Schedule property. Hence, the sale transaction could not be completed within the time stipulated in the sale agreement and time was extended by six months to complete the sale transaction. The extension of time was endorsed in the sale agreement on 11-7-1981. Again on 15-12-1981 the defendant received a further advance of Rs. 10,000/- to discharge a prior mortgage. That was endorsed on the sale agreement on 15-12-1981. Since there is a cloud on the title over the A-Schedule property, the defendant was unable to execute the sale deed free from encumbrance. Therefore, she was unable to perform her part of the contract. According to the sale agreement, the defendant agreed to execute the sale deed only after the cloud over the title is removed. Therefore, it is a contingent contract. Since the suit is pending, the cloud over the title to the A-Schedule property is not yet cleared. Therefore since the contingency as stipulated in the sale agreement has not taken place, the contract fell threw. The defendant is always ready to execute the sale deed, conveying the title to the plaintiff over the B-Schedule properties, but the plaintiffs are not willing to accept the same. The defendant sent a reply notice to the plaintiffs on 15-1-1982, but the plaintiffs sent a rejoinder after a lapse of 9 months. Therefore, the plaintiffs abandoned the contract. According to the sale agreement three persons agreed to purchase the A-Schedule property. But except one person, other two persons did not come to the box to prove their case. It was therefore submitted that the trial Court was not correct in decreeing the suit as prayed for.

    4. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents/plaintiffs submitted as under:— All these arguments now advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant with regard to the contingent contract was not pleaded in the written statement. There is also no mention about the alleged contingent contract in the sale agreement. The plaintiffs are willing to purchase the A-Schedule property along with the encumbrance. Even PW 1 in the witness box admitted that the defendant did not refuse to execute the sale deed along with the encumbrance. There is no alternative contract to purchase the B-Schedule properties as alleged by the plaintiffs. The contract is to sell the A-Schedule (property) for a sum of Rs. 2,35,000/- and a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- was paid by way of advance. The defendant also received another sum of Rs. 10,000/- towards advance. Thus, in all the defendant received a sum of Rs. 1,10,000/- towards the advance. In the sale agreement, it is stated that if the purchasers come to the conclusion that the A-Schedule property could not be sold, then the defendant agreed to execute the sale deed in respect of B-Schedule property, treating the advancement of the Rs. 1 lakh as sale consideration. The fact that the defendant received by way of advance more than Rs. 1 lakh would go to show that the intention of the purchasers is to purchase the A-Schedule property. In the suit filed by Mehaboob Bivi, there was no order of injunction restraining the defendant from alienating the A-Schedule property to the plaintiffs. Therefore, the said suit cannot be considered as an impediment in the matter of executing the sale deed. In the written statement, there was no pleading to the effect that the plaintiffs are not willing to purchase the A-Schedule property. It was therefore pleaded that the trial Court was correct in decreeing the suit as prayed for.

    5. We have heard the rival submissions.

    6. The fact remains that the sale agreement dated 13-7-1980 was executed between the plaintiffs and the defendant. According to the sale agreement, the defendant agreed to sell the A-Schedule property to the plaintiffs for a consideration of Rs. 2,35,000/-. On the date of execution of the said agreement, the defendant received Rs. 1 lakh by way of advance. The defendant also agreed to convey the A-Schedule property free from encumbrance. The defendant agreed to sell the A-Schedule property to plaintiffs either by way of separate sale deeds or by a consolidated sale deed in favour of all the plaintiffs' Since there was a suit pending filed by one Mehaboob Bivi, one year time was originally granted and then the time was extended by another six months. Endorsement was made to that effect on the sale agreement on 11-7-1981. In order to discharge a prior mortgage, the defendant also received a further advance of Rs. 10,000/- on 21-9-1984. Endorsement to that effect was also made on the sale agreement on 21-9-1984. Thus the defendant in all received a sum of Rs. 1,10,000/- by way of advance. In the sale agreement it is further stated that even though the defendant and the plaintiffs are ready to complete the sale transaction, if due to some unforeseen event and in accordance with the result filed by Mehaboob Bivi, when the purchasers come to the conclusion that the sale deed cannot be executed, with regard to the A-Schedule property then the defendant agreed to execute the sale deed conveying the B-Schedule property in favour of the plaintiffs by treating the advance of Rs. 1 lakh already paid by the plaintiffs as sale consideration. The relevant portion in Exhibit A-2 dated 13-7-1980 on this aspect runs as under:—

    (Vernacular matter is omitted — Ed.)

    7. According to the learned counsellor the appellant the option to come to the conclusion viz., that the sale deed could not be executed with regard to the A-Schedule property is left to all the parties including the defendant. According to the learned counsel for the appellant, because of the pendency of the suit filed by Mehaboob Bivi, the sale deed with regard to the A-Schedule property could not be executed free from encumbrance. Hence, the contingency as stated in the sale agreement could not take place. Therefore it is not possible to execute the sale deed in respect of A-Schedule property. In such circumstances, the defendant is ready to execute the sale deed in respect of the B-Schedule property. But the plaintiffs abandoned the contract.

    8. A plain reading of the above portion in the sale agreement Exhibit A-2 would go to show that the option to come to the conclusion that the sale deed cannot be executed with regard to the A-Schedule property is given to the plaintiffs only and not to the defendant.

    9. In fact, the plaintiffs are ready and willing to purchase the A-Schedule property along with the encumbrance. PW 1 in his deposition has stated that the defendant is willing to execute the sale deed along with the encumbrance. Therefore when the plaintiffs are willing to purchase the A-Schedule property even along with encumbrance, the defendant cannot say that she is not in a position to execute the sale deed, since the A-Schedule property is not free from encumbrance. In the written statement, there is no pleadings with regard to the contingent contract as argued by the learned counsel for the appellant before this court. In the suit filed by the said Mehaboob Bivi, the injunction was only for restraining the defendant from interfering with her possession and enjoyment of the suit property. In fact, there is no injunction restraining the defendant from executing the sale deed in respect of the A-Schedule property. There is no clause in the sale agreement Exhibit A-32 to the effect that if there is any encumbrance, A-Schedule property cannot be conveyed. Both the plaintiffs and the defendant knew that the suit filed by the said Mehaboob Bivi was pending during the time when the sale agreement was executed. When the plaintiffs are willing to purchase the A-Schedule property with encumbrance, it is not open to the defendant to say that she cannot sell the A-Schedule property with encumbrance. The B-Schedule property was agreed to be sold if the purchasers came to the conclusion that ‘A’ Schedule property could not be sold on account of some unforeseen result of the suit filed by the said Mehaboob Bivi. Now it is seen that the pendency of the suit filed by Mehaboob Bivi cannot be an impediment in selling the A-Schedule property. Further the plaintiffs are willing to purchase the A-Schedule property along with encumbrance. Hence the defendant cannot refuse to sell the A-Schedule property.

    10. The learned counsel appearing for the defendant/appellant, submitted that according to the sale agreement, the property is to be sold to the three plaintiffs, but only the first plaintiff came to the witness box to prove his case and the other two plaintiffs did not come to the witness box to establish their case. Therefore, the other two plaintiffs are not entitled to a decree for specific performance of the contract. The suit was filed by all the plaintiffs and one of the plaintiffs got into the box, to establish the case put forward by the plaintiffs. It is not necessary that all the plaintiffs should come to the witness box to establish their case. In the sale agreement the defendant agreed to execute the sale deeds either separated or cumulatively in favour of the plaintiffs or their nominees. Therefore, it is not open to the defendant to say that the other two plaintiffs did not come to the witness box. But in so far as the defendant is concerned, she did not also come to the witness box but only her husband was examined. In such circumstances, this line of argument advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant cannot be accepted.

    11. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the rejoinder was sent by the plaintiffs, nine months after the reply notice was sent by the defendant. Therefore, according to the learned counsel, the plaintiffs abandoned the contract. In fact, the plaintiffs originally sent their notice demanding the defendant to perform her part of the contract. Therefore, a claim was already made by the plaintiffs against the defendant. The fact that the rejoinder was sent after nine months would not by itself go to show that the contract was abandoned. The defendant after having received Rs. 1,10,000/- from the plaintiffs for the purpose of celebrating the marriage of her daughter and for the purpose of clearing the prior mortgage cannot now say that she cannot sell the A-Schedule property to the plaintiffs and the plaintiffs abandoned their contract.

    12. The counsel for the appellant submitted that there is a delay of nine months in sending the rejoinder by the plaintiffs to the reply notice sent by the defendant. Therefore, according to the learned counsel, the plaintiffs abandoned the contract. In support of this contention, reliance was placed upon a decision of this court rendered in Sriram Cotton Pressing Factory v. Narayanasamy, AIR 1965 Madras 352. According to the facts arising in that case, the plaintiff entered into an agreement on 26-1-1957 to purchase the suit land for constructing a factory. Though originally a period of two months was fixed for performance of the contract, the time was extended from time to time till 15-7-1958, to enable the parties to get the area declared as an industrial area. The Government finally refused to approve the suggestion made by the Panchayat to declare the suit land as an industrial area in December, 1957. Nevertheless, the defendant carried on correspondence with the authorities to grant permission to install an 100 HP Motor to run a factory, in the suit plot and the sanction was granted on 13-9-1958. The plaintiff kept quiet for a period of 9 months from 15-7-1958 and it was only on 26-4-1959, he gave notice to the defendant calling upon him to complete the transaction according to the agreement. It is on these facts, this court held that there was palpable delay on the part of the plaintiff to perform its part of the contract and from the considerable delay and laches on its part, it could easily be inferred that there was a waiver or abandonment of the contract. But according to the facts arising in the present case, a notice was sent by the plaintiffs calling upon the defendant to perform her part of the contract. The defendant sent a reply. Thereafter the plaintiffs sent their rejoinder. In the above said circumstances, the first notice itself would constitute the basis for the suit. In the above cited decision, the first notice itself was sent after nine months. Therefore, this decision will not be applicable to the facts of the present case and there is no abandonment of the contract by the plaintiffs. Yet another argument advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant was that the contract is a contingent contract. The contingency being that if all the four parties including the defendant came to the conclusion that the sale deed cannot be executed with regard to the A-Schedule property, then the defendant should sell the B-Schedule property by treating the advance Rs. 1 lakh as sale consideration. According to the learned counsel, because of the suit filed by the said Mehaboob Bivi is still pending, the defendant came to the conclusion that the sale deed with regard to the ‘A’ Schedule property cannot be executed without encumbrance. Therefore the contingency took place and hence the contract fell threw. In support of this line of argument, reliance was placed upon a decision reported in Dalisukh v. Guarantee Life & Employment Insurance Company Ltd., AIR 1947 PC 182. According to the facts arising in that case, one of the terms of the contract as proposed by the plaintiff was that earnest money was to be paid to the persons to be named by the attaching Court at the time of its giving approval to the transaction and to be paid inside the Court. The Court refused to grant such approval. Therefore, it was held that the contingency did not take place and hence the contract fell threw. But according to the facts arising in the present case, the contingent contract was not pleaded by the defendant in the written statement. This point was also not argued before the trial Court. Therefore, it is not now open to the appellant to plead this contingent contract before this Court. Further, the option to come to the conclusion that the sale deed with regard to the A-Schedule property cannot be executed was left to the discretion of the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs did not exercise this option. They are willing to purchase the A-Schedule property along with encumbrance and therefore the contingency as alleged by the defendant did not take place in this case. Accordingly, the above said decision will not render any assistance to the defendant to put forward her case.

    13. Yet another decision relied upon by the learned counsel appearing for the defendant was that reported in Rajendrakumar v. Poosammal, AIR 1975 Mad 379. In that case, this Court pointed out that in view of S. 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 the exercise of discretion either in the matter of grant or refusal of decrees for specific performance ought to be made judiciously and judicially, ought not to be arbitrary or unreasonable exercise.

    14. Thus, on a careful consideration of the facts arising in this case, in the light of the Judicial pronouncements cited supra, we hold that the trial Court was correct in dismissing the suit.

    15. Hence we are not inclined to interfere with the same.

    16. In the result, the judgment and decree of the trial Court are confirmed and the appeal is dismissed with costs.

    17. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    R. Velammal v. R. Daivasigamani And Others
    (Apr 21, 1992)