Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 482, cr. P. C. (5)
  • section 409 i. P. C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 482, cr. P. C. (5)
  • section 409 i. P. C.
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Ramalingam J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed by two accused persons — K. P. Menon (chairman, Catholic Syrian Bank Ltd., Trichur) and B. K. Natarajan (manager, Catholic Syrian Bank Ltd., Vellore) — seeking quashing of process issued to them in C.C. 420 of 1984 on the file of the J.F.C.M. No. 1, Vellore (North Arcot District). The complaint in C.C. 420/1984 was lodged by N. Punithavathi Manian (the respondent), wife of Balasubramaniam.

The respondent alleged that she (and her husband) were partners in certain chit-fund firms which had credit facilities with the Catholic Syrian Bank, Vellore. The respondent stated that she had personal fixed/family-welfare deposits with the bank (deposit nos. 48/83, 11/84, 12/84 and 13/84) and complained that entries in her accounts showed the deposits had been closed on 27-4-1984 without her request for premature encashment (she had only requested premature encashment for three deposits via Bank of Baroda on 5-6-84). The respondent says she was not informed of any premature encashment and later received a letter from Bank of Baroda stating that Catholic Syrian Bank had exercised a lien over three of the deposits and had adjusted amounts against the account of Messrs. Sathyanarayana Chit Funds (of which she is a partner).

The respondent alleged falsification of accounts and wrongful gain by the bank and lodged the criminal complaint which led to cognizance under sections 409 and 477-A read with section 34, I.P.C. The petitioners contend that the bank exercised its right of lien to adjust firm liabilities, paid any balance to the respondent, and that the matter is civil in nature; further they assert that deposits with a bank give rise to a debtor-creditor relationship and do not constitute entrustment of specific trust money making section 409 inapplicable.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the allegations in the complaint attract the offences punishable under sections 409 and 477-A, I.P.C., so as to justify criminal process against the petitioners.
  2. Whether the relationship between the bank and the depositor (respondent) is fiduciary (trust) such that section 409, I.P.C. applies, or whether it is a debtor-creditor relationship (so that the dispute is essentially civil).
  3. Whether the bank validly exercised a lien over the respondent's deposits to adjust dues of the firms in which the respondent was a partner, and whether that exercise of lien converts the dispute into one of criminal misappropriation or into a civil claim.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Accused) Arguments

  • The relationship between the respondent and the petitioners (bank) is that of debtor and creditor (banker-customer), not trustee-beneficiary; deposits are lent to the banker and do not remain the customer's trust property.
  • Even accepting the respondent's complaint and her statement at face value, they do not disclose the essential ingredients of offences under sections 409 and 477-A, I.P.C.; the allegations raise civil disputes only.
  • The petitioners relied on authoritative banking law well-established in precedent (including Foley v. Hill and Privy Council observations in Attorney General of Canada v. Attorney General of the Province of Quebec) to show that monies deposited cease to be the depositor's specific trust money and the bank is a debtor obliged to repay an equivalent sum.
  • The petitioners assert they exercised a lawful right of lien over the respondent's deposits, adjusted firm dues, and paid any balance; the respondent (as partner of the firms) is jointly and severally liable for those firm dues.
  • Because the matter is purely civil in nature, the petitioners should not be made to face criminal process and the magistrate's process should be quashed under section 482, Cr.P.C.

Respondent's (Complainant) Allegations and Contentions

  • The respondent alleged that her deposit accounts (family welfare deposits) were marked closed on 27-4-1984 without her advising or requesting premature encashment (she only requested premature encashment later, on 5-6-84, for some deposits via Bank of Baroda).
  • She stated that the bank's entries and actions (reopening and closing accounts, credit entries to the firm account on 9-6-84, and adjusting her deposits towards the firm's liabilities) amount to falsification of accounts and wrongful gain by the bank.
  • She alleged the bank improperly adjusted her deposits against the liabilities of Messrs. Sathyanarayana Chit Funds despite her contention that by certain dates those firms had no liabilities to the bank and had closed accounts.
  • The complaint led to criminal proceedings alleging offenses under sections 409 and 477-A, I.P.C., for criminal breach of trust and falsification of accounts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Attorney General of Canada and another v. Attorney General of the Province of Quebec and another (Privy Council) The opinion states the Privy Council observed that money deposited with a bank is not trust money; the banker is not a trustee but a debtor obliged to repay a like sum in like currency. The court relied on this principle to support the conclusion that banker-customer relationship is debtor-creditor and not fiduciary for the purposes of section 409, I.P.C.
Foley v. Hill Quoted for the proposition that money paid into a bank becomes the banker's money and the banker is bound only to repay an equivalent sum; the banker is not guilty of breach of trust in employing deposited money. The court used observations from Foley v. Hill to reinforce that a depositor lends money to the banker and that this makes the dispute civil rather than criminal under section 409.
Kesharichand Jaisuklal v. Shillong Banking Corporation The Supreme Court accepted the principle that a banker does not hold received money in a fiduciary capacity; monies are lent to the banker and the banker is liable to repay an equivalent amount. The court cited this Indian precedent as endorsing the relevant principle of banker-customer law and applied it to conclude that the complaint did not disclose offences under ss. 409 / 477-A.
K. Nazir au Barqa Zaidi and others v. State of U.P. The opinion cites this case but does not state in the text the specific rule or principle taken from it. The court listed this authority among those cited by learned counsel; the opinion does not elaborate further on its specific application.
Charley and Smarts (leading cases in the law of banking — reference) Referenced generally for observations about the banker-customer relationship (debtor-creditor). Used as part of the body of authorities to support the debtor-creditor characterization; the opinion does not set out a distinct application beyond that general support.
Sheldon's Practice of Law and Banking (10th edn.) Referenced for commentary on the banker-customer relationship (cited at page 186 in the work). Cited as secondary authority reinforcing the debtor-creditor nature of deposits; the court relied on these textual authorities to support its reasoning.
Dalmia v. Delhi Administration The opinion records that this authority was cited by the respondent but states it will not apply to the facts of the case; no specific rule is set out in the opinion. The court explicitly stated this authority would not apply to the facts; no further application described.
Shivnarayana Lakshminarayana Joshi v. State of Maharashtra Cited by the respondent but the opinion says it will not apply to the facts; the specific principle is not stated in the opinion. The court noted this authority would not apply to the facts presented; no elaboration provided.
Ambala Ex. St. Co. Op. Society v. State of Punjab Cited by the respondent; the opinion records it will not apply to the facts, without stating the rule. The court concluded this authority does not apply to the facts; no further use in reasoning is recorded.
Brahmayya and Co. v. Thangavelu Cited by the respondent; the opinion indicates it does not apply to the facts and does not specify the rule. The court stated it will not apply to the facts of the case; no further application described.
Kapur v. State of Punjab Cited by the respondent; the opinion states it will not apply to the facts and does not detail the principle. The court indicated non-applicability to the present facts; no additional application recorded.
Ernest John Dobbert v. State of Florida Cited by the respondent; the opinion records it will not apply to the facts and does not set out the principle. The court noted this authority as not applicable to the factual matrix; no further discussion in the opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining whether the allegations in the complaint disclose the essential ingredients of offences under sections 409 and 477-A, I.P.C., sufficient to continue criminal proceedings against the petitioners or whether the dispute is essentially civil and unfit for criminal adjudication.

Key steps in the court's analysis, strictly as set out in the opinion:

  • The court accepted and relied on established authorities (including the Privy Council in Attorney General of Canada v. Attorney General of the Province of Quebec, Foley v. Hill, and the Supreme Court in Kesharichand Jaisuklal v. Shillong Banking Corporation) for the legal proposition that money deposited with a bank ordinarily ceases to be the depositor's trust property and that the banker becomes a debtor obligated to repay an equivalent amount; thus the banker-customer relationship is one of debtor and creditor and not of trustee and beneficiary.
  • Applying that principle to the respondent's complaint and to her recorded statement (taken at face value), the court found that the allegations did not make out the essential ingredients of sections 409 (criminal breach of trust by a public servant or by a person in a position of trust) or 477-A (falsification of accounts) — at least not as against the petitioners in their capacities at the bank.
  • The court noted the petitioners did not deny receiving the amounts from the respondent nor the account entries; moreover, the petitioners had communicated to Bank of Baroda that they were exercising their lien over certain receipts in order to adjust dues owed by Messrs. Sathyanarayana Chit Funds, an account-holder/firm with liabilities to the bank.
  • Given that the bank asserted a lien and adjustment of amounts against the firm's liabilities (and that the respondent was a partner in the firm), the fundamental dispute raised — whether the bank had a lien and rightly adjusted the deposits — was characterized by the court as a matter of civil law (rights and liabilities between banker, depositor and firm), not criminal wrongdoing by the bank amounting to offences under the cited penal provisions.
  • The court also observed that authorities cited by the respondent (a list of cases including Dalmia v. Delhi Administration and others) were not applicable to the factual situation before it; the opinion does not elaborate further on those authorities beyond stating non-applicability.

On that basis, and without further detailed inquiry into the facts at trial, the court concluded that criminal process for the alleged offences was not appropriate in this case.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court allowed the petition and quashed the process issued by J.F.C.M. No. 1, Vellore in C.C. 420 of 1984 to the petitioners (the bank officials).

Implications:

  • The immediate effect is that criminal proceedings (process under the magistrate's court in C.C. 420/1984) against the petitioners were terminated by quashing the process.
  • The court treated the dispute over the deposits and the bank's exercise of lien as a civil matter concerning the rights of the depositor, the bank and the firm; accordingly, the opinion indicates the proper remedy is civil litigation rather than criminal prosecution for sections 409 or 477-A, I.P.C.
  • The opinion does not state that it set any new legal precedent; it rests its decision on application of established authorities and confines itself to the direct effect on the parties by quashing the criminal process.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not infer or add information beyond what is stated therein.

    K.P.Menon v. N.Punithavathi Manian

    Ramalingam.J.:- (1) This petition has been filed by the two accused, viz, k. P. Menon, chairman, catholic syrian bank ltd. , trichur, and b. K. Natarajan, manager. Catholic syrian bank ltd. , vellore to quash the process issued to them in c. C. 420 of 1984 on the file of the j. F. C. M. No. 1, vellore, north arcot dt. Which was taken cognizance for offences under ss. 409 and 477 - a read with 5. 34, i. P. C. On a complaint given by n. Punithavathi manian, the respondent herein wife of balasubramaniam in the following circumstances: - the respondent punithavathi manian is a partner of: sathya narayana chit funds, vellore. Her husband is also a partner in the same firm, apart from being a partner along with others in lakshmi narayana chit funds and lakshmi narayana chit corporation, sathya narayana chit funds, in which the respondent and her husband are partners along with others, has been enjoying certain credit facilities from the catholic syrian bank, vellore branch, hereinafter referred to as the bank and they owe money to the bank. The respondent in her personal capacity deposited the following amounts (2) The respondent had an account with the bank of baroda, vellore branch also. On 5 - 6 - 84, the respondent wrote through bank of baroda for premature encashment of the aforesaid deposits with the bank (catholic syrian bank) with regard to deposit nos. 48/83, 11/84 and 12/84. There was no request from the respondent for premature encashment of the deposit no. 13/84. By letter dated 7 - 6 - 1984, the bank of baroda wrote to the respondent that, in pursuance of the respondents request, they approached the bank for premature encashment of her three deposits and they were informed that the bank has referred the matter to their head office and they were asked to wait for a reply from the head office. According to the respondent, the information furnished by the bank to the bank of baroda is contrary to the endorsement found in the respondents accounts with reference to the deposits (family welfare deposits) wherein the bank has endorsed that all the accounts have been closed on 27 - 4 - 1984. The further case of the respondent is that she has not advised the bank for any premature payments of her deposits, on 27 - 4 - 1984. The entries made by s. No. Deposit no. Amount deposited. Maturity value 1. 48/83 5000 rs. 5975 2. 11/84 30000 35850 (3) 12/84 15000 17975 (4) 13/84 20000 23900 70000 83700 the bank with reference to her deposits being closed on 27 - 4 - 1984 amount to falsification of her accounts, since premature closure of her deposits was not intimated to her, nor to bank of baroda. Later on, the respondent received from the bank of baroda, a letter informing her that the bank has exercised its lien over the deposits bearing nos. 48/83, 11/84 and 12/84, for a sum of rs. 65,000 and have adjusted the amounts with the account of messrs. Sathyanarayana chit funds, wherein the respondent is a partner. According to the respondent, sathyanarayana chit funds and lakshminarayana chit corporations have closed their accounts on 27 - 1 - 1984 and lakshminarayana chit funds closed their account on 2 1 - 5 - 1984. The closure of the above three accounts have been completed and such closure has been accepted by the aforesaid three firms. By 21 - 5 - 1984, none of the firms mentioned above had any liability to the bank. By letter dated 31 - 5 - 1984, these three firms instructed the bank not to deal with their accounts except on authorisation in writing signed by all the partners. Contrary to the aforesaid, according to the respondent, credit entries have been falsely made in the accounts of sathyanarayana chit funds on 9 - 6 - 1984. On the very same date, the account of the respondent was reopened and once again it was closed. These acts on the part of the bank are nothing but a deliberate falsification of accounts and wrongful gain for the bank. It is under these circumstances, the respondent gave the complaint, which has been taken on file as c. C. 420 of 1984 on the file of j. F. C. M. I, vellore. It is to quash the process issued to the petitioners that this petition has been filed. The case of the petitioners is that the deposits of the respondents were adjusted by exercising the banks right of lien, when the respondent expressed her desire to close the deposit and get premature payment. The bank after adjusting the dues of the firms in which the respondent is a partner, paid the balance to her and she is jointly and severally liable in respect of dues of the firm in which she is a partner. The further case of the petitioners is that the deposits made by a person in a bank cannot be deemed to be an entrustment of money with the bank and that section 409 i. P. C. Has no application to a bank if any employee of the bank commits criminal breach of trust. The allegations made in the complaint and the statement of the respondent recorded in support of her complaint do not make out any case against the petitioners, much less offences under section 409 or 477 - a. I. P. C. The question that arises for consideration is whether the allegations contained in the complaint attract the provisions of sections 409 and 477, i. P. C. , so as to exercise the power vested in this court under section 482, cr. P. C.

    (5) Learned counsel for petitioners urged the following points: (1) the relationship between the respondent and petitioners is that of a debtor and a creditor. (2) the complaint made by the respondent as well as the statement recorded from the respondent in support of the complaint, even if taken at their face value make out absolutely no case against the petitioners and that the complaint does not disclose the essential ingredients of offences punishable under sections 409 and 477 - a, i. P. C. And as such the matter is purely of a civil nature and the petitioners should not be harassed to appear before court till all the witnesses are examined for the purpose of framing a charge, and then argue the case before the trial court, that the matters are of civil nature and the magistrate has no jurisdiction to proceed with the enquiry.

    (6) In support of his contention, he cited the following decisions (1) attorney general of canada and another v. Attorney general of the province of quebec and another. (2) k. Nazir au barqa zaidi and others v. State of u. P. (3) kesharichand jaisukial v. Shillong banking corporation. Learned counsel relied on charley and smarts leading cases in the law of banking; 1977 edn. Page 1, wherein some observations in the judgment in foley v. Hill are extracted. This decision holds that the relationship between banker and customer is that of a debtor and creditor. He also relied on sheldons practice of law and banking, 10th edn. At page 186, which deals with the relationship of banker and customer. The leading case on that point is the one reported in attorney general of canada and another v. Attorney general of the province of quebec and another (supra) wherein their lordships of the privy council have observed, that money deposited with the bank is not trust money which the trustee must preserve and not use, but it is lent for use and the banker is not a trustee but a debtor to the depositor and that the difference between property and possession of deposits docs not come in question, the only obligation under which a bank lies is to repay a like sum in the like currency. In foley v. Hill (supra) , lord cottenham, l. C. In the course of his judgment, observed as follows money, when paid into bank, ceases altogether to be the money of the principal; it is then the money of the banker, who is bound to return an equivalent by paying a similar sum to that deposited with him when he is asked for it. The money paid into the bankers is money known by the principal to be placed there, for the purpose of being under the control of the banker, it is then the banker's money he is known to deal with it as his own, he makes what profit of it he can which profit he retains to himself, paying back only the principal according to the custom of bankers: in some places, or the principal and a small rate of interest, according to the custom of bankers in other places. The money placed in the custody of a banker is, to all intents and purposes the money of the banker to do with it as he pleases; he is guilty of no breach of trust in employing it; he is not answerable to the principal if he puts it into jeopardy, if he engage, in a hazardous speculation; he is not bound to keep it, or deal with it, as the property of his principal but he is of course answerable for the amount, because he has contracted, having received that money, to repay to the principal, when demanded a sum equivalent to that paid into his hands. That has been subject of discussion in various case. That being established to be the relative situations of banker and customer, the banker is not an agent, or factor but he is a debtor. Tlord brougham said this trade of a banker is to receive money, and use as if it were his own, he becoming debtor to the person who has lent or deposited with him the money to use as his own (7) That was accepted as the correct law, laying down the principle with reference to the relationship between a banker and a customer, by our supreme court in kesharichand jaisuklal v. Shillong banking corporation (supra). The banker when he receives money from a customer does not hold the money in a fiduciary capacity. What really happens is that money is not deposited with, when moneys were received by the banker either under a savings account or current account or fixed deposit account, but lent to the banker. All that the banker acknowledges to do is to discharge the debt by paying over an equal amount when called upon to payor at the time of maturity. Applying the above said principle to the facts of this case, a perusal of the complaint made by the respondent as well as the statement recorded from the respondent in support of the petition, even if taken at their face value, make out absolutely no case against the petitioners and the complaint does not disclose the essential ingredients of the offences punishable under ss. 409 and 477 a, i. P. C. , and as such the matter is purely of a civil nature. My reasons are as follows - (8) The petitioners have not denied the receipt of the amount from the respondent, under the family welfare deposit accounts nor have they denied the entries made by them in the accounts of the respondent.

    (9) The petitioners have informed the respondents bank, viz. Bank of baroda in the following terms:we wish to inform you that the holder of the family welfare deposits account nos. 060070/12/84, 060089/11/84, 060055/48/83 for an aggregate amount of rs. 50000 is a partner in messrs. Sathianarayana chit funds, which is an account bolder in our bank owes us more than the amounts covered by the receipts. As per advice of our head office, we are writing to inform you that we are exercising our lien over the receipts and for adjustment of the dues as aforesaid. In this ti therefore, it cannot be said that the accounts have been altered with a view to misappropriate the money belonging to the respondent and it is being alleged that the bank is withholding the money in exercise of the lien over the deposits made by respondent for adjusting the amounts due to messrs. Satyanarayana chit funds in which the respondent is a partner. Hence, the question that arises for consideration on the facts presented is whether the petitioner's bank has got a lien over the deposits made by the respondent so as to withhold the payment due to the respondent, in connection with the dues of the firm, in which the respondent is a partner. This question as posed involves determination of a dispute purely of a civil nature.

    (10) The following authorities cited by the learned counsel for the respondent will not apply to the facts of this case - (i) dalmia v. Delhi administration. (ii) shivnarayana lakshminarayana joshi v. State of maharashtra, (iii) ambala ex. St. Co. Op. Society v. State of punjab (iv) brahmayya and co. V. Thangavelu (v) kapur v. State of punjab: (vi) ernest john dobbert v. State of florida.

    (11) In the circumstances, i find the process issued by the j. F. C. M. No. 1 vellore, north arcot district to the petitioners accused in cc 420 of 1984 is liable to be quashed. In the result the petition is allowed. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.P.Menon v. N.Punithavathi Manian
    (Dec 12, 1986)