AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The present application sought condonation of delay in filing an appeal challenging the order dated 04.08.06 passed by the Punjab State Electricity Regulatory Commission. At the time of filing the interlocutory application, the delay in instituting the appeal was 106 days. The Registry had returned the appeal for removal of certain defects; when the appeal was re-filed there was an additional delay of 117 days. The interlocutory application addressed only the initial 106-day delay.

The applicant initially attempted to obtain relief by filing a review petition, which was found not to be maintainable. The applicant attributed the 106-day delay to internal movement of the file within the appellant's department while preparing the review and thereafter in presenting the appeal. The re-filing delay was attributed to objections arising from changes introduced by a notification dated 22.01.07 under the APTEL (Forms, Verification and the Fee for Filing an Appeal) Rules 2004, and to drafts prepared by counsel getting lost in the post, necessitating re-sending. The applicant was based in Patiala while counsel responsible for filing was based in Delhi.

The respondent opposed the application, contending that sufficient grounds had not been made out, that the application was an abuse of the court's process, that the impugned order was justified, and that the appellant took an unduly long time to approach the Tribunal after the review petition was rejected.

The Tribunal heard the matter and pronounced its order on 08 May 2008.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal should condone the initial delay of 106 days in filing the appeal.
  2. Whether the delay in re-filing the appeal (attributed to registry objections and loss of drafts in the post) should be excused.
  3. Whether, if delay is condoned, it should be subject to any conditions such as payment of costs.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The 106-day delay resulted from internal movement of the file within the appellant's department while preparing a review and subsequently presenting the appeal.
  • An attempt was first made to obtain relief by filing a review petition, which was later found not maintainable.
  • The appeal was returned by the Registry because of objections arising from changes introduced by a notification dated 22.01.07 under the APTEL (Forms, Verification and the Fee for Filing an Appeal) Rules 2004.
  • Drafts prepared by counsel were lost in the post, and re-sending drafts caused further delay in re-filing; counsel responsible for filing was based in Delhi while the applicant was based in Patiala.
  • The affidavits filed by the appellant set out how the 106 days were spent across different sections of the applicant, explaining the delay.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contended that sufficient grounds for condoning the delay had not been shown and characterized the application as an abuse of the process of the court.
  • It was asserted that the impugned order was justified and that the appellant unduly delayed approaching the Tribunal after the review petition was rejected; therefore the delay should not be condoned.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Nagaland Vs. Lipok AO and Others 2005 (3) SCC 752 The Supreme Court stated that the State as an impersonal machinery working through its officers and servants cannot be put on the same footing as an individual; public interest is involved when matters are pursued by the State. The Tribunal relied on this line of authority to recognize that delays caused by State mechanisms and public-sector functioning may warrant sympathetic treatment and to accept that the appellant's departmental processes were a relevant factor in explaining delay.
Sainik Security Vs. Sheel Bhai & Others 2008 AIR SCW 1948 The Supreme Court, being satisfied that sufficient ground existed, condoned delay but imposed a cost as a condition precedent to condonation. The Tribunal followed this approach and conditioned condonation of the delay on payment of costs (Rs.5,000/-) to compensate the respondent for loss of time.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal analyzed the two components of delay separately.

On re-filing delay: The Tribunal accepted the appellant's account that the appeal had been returned because of objections linked to changes introduced by the notification dated 22.01.07 under the APTEL Rules 2004, and that drafts prepared by counsel were lost in the post, necessitating re-sending. The respondent's reply did not dispute the truth of the allegations in the affidavits. The Tribunal held that loss of drafts in the post could not be attributed to negligence of the appellant or counsel and therefore the delay in re-filing had to be excused.

On the initial 106-day delay: Although the respondent objected to condonation, it did not dispute the factual assertions in the appellant's affidavits explaining how the 106 days were spent. The Tribunal observed a broader concern about the need to improve functioning of public sector undertakings in pursuing litigation and referenced Supreme Court authorities addressing delays by State mechanisms. While noting that it would have preferred greater diligence by the appellant in approaching the Tribunal, the Tribunal concluded that the delay had been sufficiently explained and that the cause was sufficient to justify condonation.

As to conditions, the Tribunal referred to the Supreme Court's practice (as in Sainik Security) of imposing costs when condoning delay. Applying that principle, and to compensate the respondent for loss of time, the Tribunal decided to condone the delay on payment of a specified cost.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The application for condonation of delay is allowed; the delay is condoned. This condonation is subject to the applicant depositing a cost of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees Five Thousand Only) before the next date of hearing.

Implications and immediate effects:

  • The applicant must deposit Rs.5,000/- before the next date of hearing as a condition precedent to condonation.
  • Once the cost is deposited, the appeal will be numbered.
  • The appeal was listed for hearing on July 28, 2008.
  • The decision affects the parties directly by permitting the appeal to proceed subject to the cost condition; the opinion does not purport to establish a new legal precedent beyond its application of existing Supreme Court authorities.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Punjab State Electricity Board v. Punjab State Electricity Regulatory Commission

    The present application seeks condonation of delay in filing an appeal to challenge the order dated 04.08.06 passed by the Punjab State Electricity Regulatory Commission. The delay till the date of filing is of 106 days. The appeal was returned by the Registry for removing certain defects. The appeal thereafter was re-filed and in re-filing there is a delay of 117 days. The interlocutory application which does not take care of the delay in re-filing deals with delay of

    106 days. It is stated that the delay was caused as the file was being moved within the appellants department for preparation of review and subsequently in presenting the appeal. It may be stated here that the appellant/applicant had first attempted to obtain the intended relief by filing a review petition but did not succeed as the same was found to be not maintainable.

    2) Coming to the re-filing it is stated that the appeal was returned on account of the objections which has been raised keeping in view the changes introduced by a notification dated 22.01.07 under the APTEL (Forms, Verification and the Fee for Filing an Appeal) Rules 2004, that fresh drafts prepared by the IA No. 156 of 2007 counsel got lost in post and thereafter another copy of the draft had to be sent by the counsel which caused the delay. Another affidavit has been filed by the appellant stating therein as to how the 106 days were spent by different sections of the applicant and attempted to explain the delay. It may be mentioned here further that much of the delay is attributed to the fact that the applicant is based in Patiala whereas the counsel responsible for filing the appeal is based in Delhi.

    3) The application is opposed by the respondent who says that sufficient ground has not been made out and the application is an abuse of the process of the court. In the reply it is contended that the impugned order is justified and that despite rejection of the review petition the appellant has taken a long time to come to this Tribunal and therefore the delay should not be condoned.

    4) So far as re-filing is concerned, the loss of draft in post cannot be attributed to the negligence of the appellant or the counsel. Although the reply has been filed the truth of the allegations in the two affidavits has not been disputed. Therefore, so far as re-filing is concerned the delay has to be excused.

    5) So far as the filing is concerned the delay is of 106 days. Although the respondent objected to condonation of delay, it does not dispute the facts alleged in the affidavit.It cannot be denied that IA No. 156 of 2007 there is a need to improve the functioning of public sector undertakings in the matter of pursuing litigations. The Supreme Court in several judgments have talked about the delay made by the State mechanisms. In the case of State of Nagaland Vs. Lipok AO and Others 2005 (3) SCC 752 the Supreme Court stated that the State as an impersonal machinery working through its officers and servants cannot be put on the same footing as an individual. Further the Supreme Court advised that the public interest is also involved when matters are pursued by the State. Although we would have been happier if the appellant/applicant had shown more diligence in approaching this Tribunal. We cannot say that the delay has not been explained or that the cause is not sufficient.

    6) In a recent case, in the case of Sainik Security Vs. Sheel Bhai & Others 2008 AIR SCW 1948, the Supreme Court on being satisfied that there was sufficient ground condoned the delay but imposed a cost as a condition precedents for condoning the delay. In view of the facts in the present case as explained above we think it will be appropriate to condone the delay but subject to some cost in order to compensate the respondent for the loss of time. Accordingly, we allow the application for condonation of delay subject to a cost of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees Five Thousand Only) which should be deposited before the next date of hearing. IA No. 156 of 2007

    7) The appeal be listed for hearing on July 28, 2008. Meanwhile, the appeal will be numbered after the cost is deposited.

    8) Pronounced in open court on this 08th day of May, 2008. ( Justice Manju Goel ) ( H. L. Bajaj ) Judicial Member Technical Member The End

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Punjab State Electricity Board v. Punjab State Electricity Regulatory Commission
    (May 8, 2008)