AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Tribunal Opinion (Appeal No. 213/06)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant, Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB), filed Appeal No. 213/06 challenging a suo moto order of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) dated 30 June 2006 in Petition No. 67 of 2003. The impugned CERC order brought the Kayamkulam Rajiv Gandhi Combined Cycle Power Project (RGCCPP), owned by National Thermal Power Corporation Limited (NTPC) and dedicated to supply power to KSEB, under the Availability Based Tariff (ABT) regime with effect from 1 July 2006.

RGCCPP is a naphtha-fuelled power plant located at Kayamkulam, Kerala, with an installed capacity of 359.58 MW. The entire output of the station is contracted to KSEB under a power purchase agreement. Following a sharp rise in naphtha prices the plant became economically unviable and largely unutilised; the Government of India temporarily allocated about 50% of the station's capacity to Tamil Nadu Electricity Board (TNEB), while purchasers (KSEB and TNEB) were compensated with cheaper power from other NTPC stations producing a composite tariff of Rs. 2.5/kWh. KSEB asserted it had paid about Rs. 1,190 crores towards fixed costs against an approved capital cost of Rs. 1,125.31 crores.

The Tribunal heard the appeal and the related submissions of parties and NTPC's operational data. The Tribunal rendered its decision on 12 February 2008.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Central Commission (CERC) had jurisdiction to introduce the ABT mechanism for a generating station supplying power solely within the State of Kerala (i.e., a "single-beneficiary" plant).
  2. Whether CERC erred procedurally by issuing earlier orders (notably the order dated 4 July 2005) implementing ABT for RGCCPP without giving beneficiaries, the generator or other stakeholders an opportunity to represent their views.
  3. Whether applying ABT to RGCCPP was inappropriate because the plant's operation on naphtha (with very high variable cost) would encourage gaming by the generator (under-generating relative to schedule to avoid higher variable cost), and whether the CERC failed to appreciate the station's unique economics.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (KSEB) Arguments

  • KSEB contended that CERC lacked jurisdiction to impose ABT on a generating station whose output is consumed exclusively within one State.
  • KSEB argued that CERC's earlier order dated 4 July 2005 (implementing ABT for RGCCPP from 1 December 2005) was passed without giving an opportunity of hearing to beneficiaries, the generator or other stakeholders.
  • KSEB asserted that RGCCPP's high variable cost of generation due to naphtha made the plant economically unviable; applying ABT (and the Merit Order Dispatch mechanism) would not schedule the station unless its variable cost was reduced, and because the variable cost could be higher than UI charges at certain frequencies, the generator would be tempted to under-generate (thereby promoting gaming). KSEB supplied operational data in support of its apprehensions.
  • KSEB was concerned that ABT might deprive it of lien/control over the plant and the potential future benefits if fuel economics improved (e.g., transition to LNG).

Respondent NTPC's Arguments and Submissions

  • NTPC furnished detailed daily schedule and actual generation data for Kayamkulam station from 1 July 2006 to 30 September 2007 demonstrating that any under-generation relative to schedule was marginal and insignificant.
  • NTPC asserted it had not engaged in gaming, and the Central Commission's impugned order reached a similar finding.

CERC / Regulatory Position (as recorded in the opinion)

  • CERC had earlier decided (in an order dated 4 January 2000) to implement ABT in a phased manner after hearings and consultations with stakeholders; the impugned order was a step implementing that earlier decision.
  • CERC had recorded NTPC's categorical assurance that the generating station would not generate below schedule except for technical limitations or if frequency exceeded 50 Hz; the Tribunal considered such assurances inadequate without deterrent measures in the scheme itself.
  • CERC (through the Terms and Conditions of Tariff (4th Amendment) Regulations, 2007) raised UI rates (to be effective 7 January 2008) up to Rs. 10 per kWh, which the Tribunal noted reduced or eliminated the asserted discrepancy between plant variable cost and UI charges that had motivated KSEB's gaming concern.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent / Authority Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Tribunal judgment in Appeal No. 152 of 2005 (Central Power Distribution Company & Ors. v. CERC & Anr.), decided 3 January 2006 Rejected the contention that CERC lacked jurisdiction to introduce ABT for a single-beneficiary generating station; addressed procedural challenge (lack of hearing) by reference to earlier consultations. The Tribunal relied on this prior Tribunal decision to reject KSEB's jurisdictional and procedural pleas, noting the similarity of issues and outcome.
Hon'ble Supreme Court, Civil Appeal No. 2104 of 2006 (challenge to the Tribunal's decision), judgment dated 17 August 2007 Affirmed the Tribunal's decision upholding availability of CERC's jurisdiction and the Tribunal's reasoning (i.e., dismissal of challenge). The Tribunal noted that the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, thereby upholding the Tribunal's earlier conclusion and reinforcing the view that CERC could implement ABT for single-beneficiary stations.
CERC order dated 4 January 2000 (petition No. 2/99, suo moto) and related phased implementation orders Established the decision and process (including hearings/consultations) to implement ABT nationwide in a phased manner; formed the basis for subsequent implementation steps. The Tribunal observed that the impugned order was an implementation step of the 2000 decision and that stakeholders had been given opportunity to be heard in the process that led to that earlier decision.
National Electricity Policy, notified 12 February 2005 (para 5.7.1(b)) Recognised the positive impact of ABT and advised State Electricity Regulatory Commissions to introduce ABT at the State level within one year. The Tribunal cited the National Electricity Policy as supportive material showing a policy-level endorsement of ABT's beneficial effects and as guidance relevant to CERC's implementation steps.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal proceeded by addressing each principal ground advanced by KSEB and applying the relevant factual record and prior authorities:

  1. Jurisdictional challenge: The Tribunal relied on its earlier decision in Appeal No. 152 of 2005 (Simhadri STPS case) which had rejected the argument that CERC lacked jurisdiction to introduce ABT for single-beneficiary plants. The Tribunal observed that the impugned order was a logical implementation of CERC's earlier comprehensive decision (order dated 4 January 2000) reached after hearings and consultations. Consequently, the Tribunal found no merit in the jurisdictional objection.
  2. Procedural fairness / opportunity of hearing: The Tribunal noted that the 2000 CERC decision (petition No. 2/99) had involved a transparent process of hearing and consultations with stakeholders and that the impugned order was an implementation of that prior decision. The Tribunal therefore concluded that the claim of denial of opportunity to be heard was unsustainable.
  3. Gaming and economic-uniqueness argument (naphtha cost and under-generation): The Tribunal examined the operational data produced by NTPC for the period 1 July 2006 to 30 September 2007 and noted that any under-generation relative to schedule was marginal and insignificant; CERC had recorded a similar finding. The Tribunal further observed that even in the absence of ABT the liability of KSEB to pay variable charges would not be altered by deviations; the potential savings to NTPC by being paid at UI rates were marginal in view of the plant's operation scale. Importantly, the Tribunal recorded that the alleged risk of gaming was mitigated by regulatory action: the CERC's 2007 amendment raised UI rates (effective 7 January 2008) up to Rs. 10 per kWh, ensuring that UI charges would no longer be lower than the plant's variable cost and thereby removing the incentive to under-generate.
  4. Ancillary operational concerns: The Tribunal addressed KSEB's apprehension about losing lien or scheduling control over the plant. It relied on the impugned order's assurance that KSEB would continue to have 100% lien over the generating station unless it itself chose to forego part of its allocation, and that scheduling remained with the State Load Dispatch Centre (SLDC) of Kerala (not the SRLDC). On this basis the Tribunal treated the concern as misplaced.

After evaluating the factual material, regulatory amendments, earlier judicial findings and policy documents, the Tribunal concluded that the grounds of the appeal lacked merit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Tribunal concluded that the appeal had no merit and therefore DISMISSED the appeal. The order was passed with no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • The CERC's decision to bring RGCCPP under the ABT regime (effective 1 July 2006) was upheld by the Tribunal.
  • The Tribunal relied on prior Tribunal and Supreme Court rulings and on CERC's earlier consultative decision, and therefore treated the impugned order as an implementation of established regulatory policy rather than a novel exercise of jurisdiction. The opinion does not state that it sets a new legal precedent independent of the cited authorities.
  • The specific operational concern that ABT would create an incentive for NTPC to under-generate (gaming) because UI charges were lower than plant variable cost was addressed by the regulatory increase in UI rates (Terms & Conditions of Tariff (4th Amendment) Regulations, 2007), which the Tribunal recorded as removing that incentive.
  • Direct effect on parties: KSEB's challenge was rejected and CERC's implementation of ABT for the RGCCPP remained in force; NTPC's provision of data and undertakings were accepted as part of the factual record supporting dismissal.

Decision rendered by: A. A. Khan, Technical Member; Manju Goel, Judicial Member. Dated: 12 February 2008.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Central Power Distribution Company And Ors v. Cers And Anr

    Per Honble Mr. Anwar Ahmad Khan, Technical Member The Appellant, Kerala State Electricity Board (hereinafter referred to as KSEB) in this appeal has challenged the suo moto order passed by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (hereinafter referred to as the Central

    1 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 Commission/CERC) on 30 Jun 06 in Petition NO. 67 of 2003 (Suo moto) whereby the Kayamkulam Rajiv Gandhi Combined Cycle Power Project (for brevity hereinafter referred to as RGCCPP) owned by National Thermal Power Corporation Limited (hereinafter referred to as the NTPC), a Central Power Sector Undertaking dedicated to supply power to the Appellant is brought under the purview of Availability Based Tariff (ABT) with effect from 01 Jul 06.

    2. The Appellant has challenged the impugned order primarily on the following grounds: (a) The Central Commission has no jurisdiction to introduce ABT mechanism for generating stations supplying within the state of Kerala. (b) The Central Commission has issued order dated 04 Jul 05 in Suo moto petition 67 of 2003 directing NTPC and KSEB to implement ABT regime in RGCCPP with effect from 01.12.2005 without giving opportunity to the beneficiaries, generator or other stakeholders to represent their views/concerns. (c) Uniqueness of RGCCPPs operation on an economically unviable fuel of Naphtha has not been appreciated by CERC as its order dated

    04 Jul 05 for implementing ABT mechanism was extended to it

    2 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 alongwith lower fuel cost of coal and gas-based stations without any discrimination. Higher viable cost of energy generated by RGCCP compared to UI-charges at frequency lower than 50 Hz will tempt the generator to adopt operation strategy such that it will opt for payment of charges at UI- rates and will avoid paying higher variable cost of generation by under generating below the schedule, and will promote gaming by the generator. The Appellant has butteressed this claim by furnishing operation data in its additional grounds. Facts of the Case

    3. The KSEB, constituted by the Government Kerala under the Electricity (supply) Act 1948 is an integrated board dealing with the business of generation, transmission and distribution of electricity in the State of Kerala.

    4. RGCCPP is a project established in Kayamkulam in the State of Kerala and owned by NTPC which is administered by Ministry of Power, Government of India. The Plant is based on Naphtha fuel with an installed capacity of 359.58 MW. The entire power from this station is dedicated for use within the State of

    3 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 Kerala and KSEB has been having PPA with NTPC for availing the entire power from this station.

    5. In view of the unprecedented hike in price of Naphtha fuel the energy from this plant has become economically unviable and KSEB could not schedule the power from this project due to very high variable cost of generation. Consequently the capacity of the station remained unutilized for a long period, Government of India, thereafter, for utilization of the assets, stepped in and temporarily allocated nearly 50% of the station to Tamil Nadu Electricity Board (TNEB) and compensated the high energy charges of the plant by the purchasers (i.e. KSEB and TNEB) with cheaper power from the Stations in other regions owned by NTPC resulting into composite tariff of Rs. 2.5/Kwhr. Balance 50% of the capacity charge is payable by KSEB. The arrangement is stated to be still continuing. The appellant claims that it has already paid about Rs. 1190 crores towards fixed costs of this plant against the capital cost of Rs. 1125.31 crores approved by the Central Commission.

    6. Realizing that full fixed cost of the plant having been recovered from KSEB (alongwith a part of fixed cost revenue from TNEB due to temporary allocation to it) and imminent Possibility of LNG being made available for plant

    4 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 operation which would further reduce the operating cost making the generation from the station more economic, KSEB does not want to give up the benefits it is entitled to receive. The averment of the appellant is that it has right to utilize the full capacity of this plant and it can choose to sell power to other consumers on terms and conditions agreed between it and KSEB. The Appellant apprehends that application of ABT mechanism to RGCCPP will deprive its lien/control over it and make it loose the emerging benefits in future. This apprehension of KSEB is misplaced as CERCs order dated 04 Apr. 06 in para (i) clearly assures that KSEB shall continue to have 100% lien over the generating station unless it itself decides to forego a part of its (and only in such a case a part of the capacity maybe allocated to some other beneficiary). Extension of ABT to the generating station, therefore, would not deprive KEB of any benefit in any manner. The scheduling of the generating station shall continue to be carried out by SLDC of Kerala (not by SRLDC), and KSEBs apprehensions of being by passed is not necessarily valid. ABT and Unschedule Interchange (UI Charge)

    7. In order to better appreciate the implication of introduction of ABT in the instant case we need to understand the mechanism of ABT. The rationale of ABT mechanism is to enforce grid discipline to normalize frequency ideally at 50 Hz so that serious damages both at generation and load ends caused due to wide

    5 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 fluctuations in frequency could be prevented. During peak load hours the frequency goes down to 48.0 48.5 Hz, while during off-peak hours it goes up to 50.5 to 51 Hz with rapid change of 1 Hz in 5 to 10 minutes for many hours everyday. It causes frequent grid disturbances, tripping of generating stations, grid collapses, leading to interruption of supply and black out in wide area of electricity consumption and disintegration of regional grids. These problems could be remedied by : (a) During Peak Load Hours: Maximizing generation and load shedding equal to deficit in generation (b) During Non-peak Hours: Backing down of generation to match load reduction on the basis of merit order generation.

    8. Prior to introduction of ABT, fixed charges for generation was based on the Actual generation proportionately shared by the purchasers. The liability of the fixed charges based on the actual drawl of energy allowed the purchasers to draw electricity from the grid at their whims and pleasure causing the grid frequency to fluctuate from 48.5 Hz to 51.5 Hz endangering the grid collapse and damages to generator and load ends. The second component of tariff i.e. rate of energy share is for the consumption of units of energy and is the same in both tariff systems i.e.

    6 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 the one san ABT and the other with ABT. In the existing regime even when ABT is not applied on a generating station the recovery of full cost is related to availability to be determined by CERC. In ABT scheme or otherwise the fixed charge is based on the declared generation capacity (with full fixed charge recovered at determined Target availability) proportionately shared by purchasers in ratio of the capacities allocated to them. The progressive reduction of fixed cost because of repayment of loan will continue to be available to the beneficiaries.

    9. The Only differentiating feature in ABT regime which is not a part of tariff but is a commercial mechanism to maintain grid discipline, is the third charge namely Unschedule Interchange (UI) of power exchange. It provides incentive and disincentive to generators and beneficiaries for generation and drawls above/below given schedule respectively. The UI charges are levied at the occurrence of the following : The UI charges are payable when (a) Beneficiary draws excess power than scheduled that results into drop in frequency.

    7 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 (b) Generator generates less than the scheduled capacity which causes shortage of equivalent quantity of power in the grid and consequent drop in the frequency. The UI charges are receivable when (a) Beneficiary drawn less than the scheduled quantity of power and such an under drawl benefits in increasing the grid frequency. (b) Generator generates more than the scheduled capacity that contributes to strengthening of the grid by increasing frequency.

    10. The appellant in its submission of additional grounds for the appeal has stated that prohibitive high variable cost and long duration required for shut down and start-up compels it not to schedule, RGCCPP. In the Merit Order Dispatch (MOD) mechanism, RGCCPP will not be scheduled unless its variable cost is sweetened by the supply of Compensating cheaper energy to the purchasers or by operating the station on some cheaper fuel like LNG. It argues that since Merit Order Dispatch mechanism is specified to be followed in ABT, and scheduling of RGCCPP in MOD scheme is not feasible, the ABT regime cannot be introduced

    8 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 in this specific station. The Appellant has stated that the variable cost of generation from RGCCPP being much higher than the UI charges at relevant frequency, the generation will have the temptation to under generate to save cost.

    11. Respondent No. 3, NTPC in its submission has furnished the data of schedule and actual generation from Kayuamkulam station of each day of operation from 01 Jul. 06 to 30 Sep. 07. NTPC with the help of the data furnished by it has stated that in any event if the plant has ever under-generated than what was scheduled, it was marginal and insignificant and they have not been indulging in any gaming. This is also the finding of the Central Commission in its impugned order.

    12. It may be observed that even if the station is not operating under ABT the liability of KSEB to pay at the rate of variable charges under any situation will not be impacted. It is another matter that by paying at UI rate the NTPC will be saving some cost which considering size of the operation is quite marginal and insignificant. It may thus be seen that KSEB would be financially immune on account of deviation of generating station from the given schedule and sharing of capacity with TNEB also does not change this status. The KSEBs liability being

    9 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 dependant on the schedules given will remain unchanged regardless of generation as per Schedule or under-generation.

    13. We have also observed that in the impugned order dated 30 Jun 06 the Central Commission has recorded that in response to our query the representative of NTPC gave categorical assertion that the generating stations would not generate below given schedule unless the frequency goes above 50 Hz and except due to technical limitation under exceptional circumstances. We opine that such kind of assurances in the commercial transactions is meaningless unless the scheme has built-in deterrence. We have now been informed by the Respondent No. 3, NTPC that this deterrence has been introduced by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) (4th Amendment) Regulations, 2007, to be brought into effect from 07 Jan. 08 whereby the UI rate have been upwardly revised up to Rs. 10/- per Kwhr. and thus the variable cost of the plant will no longer be higher than the UI charges. This disposes of the issue raised by the Appellant as mentioned in para 2(c) above.

    14. Reverting to the larger issue of applicability of ABT in single beneficiary state, it may be worthwhile to mention that Respondent No. 3, NTPC, in its submission has submitted the judgment by this Tribunal in Appeal No. 152 of

    10 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 2005 passed on 03 Jan 06 in the case of Central Power Distribution Company and Ors. Vs. CERS and Anr. which like in the instant case also deals with a single beneficiary State with the similar issues raised in case of Simhadri Super Thermal Power Station (STPC) of NTPC established in Andhra Pradesh.

    15. In the aforesaid case also the Simhadri STPS was brought under the purview of ABT by the order of CERC passed on 04 Jul 06 arising out of the same petition as in the instant case i.e. petition no. 67 of 2003 (Suo Moto). This Tribunal while rejecting the plea of the appellant about lack of jurisdiction of the Central Commission to introduce ABT in a Single beneficiary Plant and not finding any merits dismissed the appeal by its aforesaid judgment and order. The appellants grievance of violation of principles of natural justice by the Central commission for not providing opportunity of being heard is also rejected by the Tribunal. The aforesaid judgment in para 7 reads thus:

    7. In view of the aforesaid discussion, we have no hesitation in rejecting the plea of the appellant that the CERC lacked the jurisdiction to introduce ABT for Simhadri thermal station.

    11 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06

    16. The aforesaid judgment further records thus:

    8. As regards the second submission of the appellant that no opportunity of hearing was provided to it before the CERC passed the impugned order is of no avail to the appellant. The impugned order specifically point out that the CERC in its earlier order dated January 4, 2000 in petition No.2/99 (suo moto) after going through a transparent process of hearing and consultations with all concerned had resolved to implement the ABT regime in all the regions of the country in a phased manner. Therefore, it is clear that at the time of the earlier decision the concerned agencies were heard. The decision to implement the ABT scheme was taken as far back as January 4, 2000. The impugned order is a logical step towards the implementation of the earlier order. Earlier the scheme of ABT was implemented in a phased manner in the case of generating stations supplying electricity to more than one State as per the following details: a. Western Region 1.7.2003 b. Northern Region 1.12.2002 c. Southern Region 1.1.2003 d. Eastern Region 1.4.2003 e. North-Eastern Region 1.11.2003

    9. It has also been noted in the impugned order that ABT has been applicable in all the regions of the country for sufficient time and the results point to its beneficial effect. As per the Commission,

    12 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06 the beneficial results of ABT are evident in the scheduling and despatch of generating capacity and maintenance of grid frequency within the optimum frequency band. The appellant has not placed any material on record to controvert the opinion of the Commission or to show any baneful effect of the ABT.

    10. The Central Government on February 12, 2005 has notified National Electricity Policy. Para 5.7.1 (b) of the Policy needs to be taken note of. The said para reads as follows: The ABT regime introduced by CERC at the national level has had a positive impact. It has also enabled a credible settlement mechanism for intra-day power transfers from licenses with surpluses to Licenses experiencing deficits. SERCs are advised to introduce the ABT regime at the State level within one year. Thus, the National Electricity Policy, which is required under sub-Section 4 of Section 79 of the Act to guide the CERC in discharge of its functions, also recognizes the positive impact of the ABT regime.

    17. It is pertinent to note that the aforesaid judgment of the Tribunal was challenged in the Honble Supreme Court by Civil Appeal No. 2104 of 2006. The Honble Supreme Court in its detailed Judgment dated 17 Aug. 07 has dismissed the appeal and upheld the judgment of this Tribunal.

    13 of 14 Appeal No. 213/06

    18. It may be pointed out that the Central commission in its order dated 04 Jun 2000 after going through the transparent process of hearing and consultation with all stake holders had resolved to implement ABT regime in all the 5 power regions of the country in phased manner and Southern Region of which the Appellant is a constituent the ABT was to come into effect from 01 Jan 03. The impugned order in this Appeal is based on the Central Commissions Order dated 04 Jan 2000. It, therefore, cannot be said that the stake holders were not given opportunities to put forward their views on the purpose and plan of introducing ABT regime. The impugned order is merely an order reflecting the implementation of the decision arrived at by due process of consultation in the earlier order of the Central Commission.

    19. In view of the above, we find no merit in this Appeal and dismiss it accordingly, with no order as to costs. (A. A. Khan) Technical Member (Manju Goel) Judicial Member Dated : 12th February, 2008.

    14 of 14

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Central Power Distribution Company And Ors v. Cers And Anr
    (Feb 12, 2008)