Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Smart Summary

Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns classification of imported fabrics that were coated with coloured nylon flock and whether they fall under Customs Tariff Heading 59.07 or under Heading 43.04 as artificial fur lining. Test reports and expert opinions (from IIT Delhi, SASMIRA and NITRA) were obtained regarding the nature/length of the flock fibres, and an impugned order-in-original was passed in the wake of a CESTAT order dated 5.12.2002. The Revenue moved in appeal and the assessee also appealed. The tribunal examined the classification issue, the admissibility and effect of expert opinions and test reports, and whether samples tested from some consignments could be applied to other consignments. The tribunal set aside the impugned order-in-original and remanded the matter to the jurisdictional Commissioner of Customs for de novo consideration, directing that both sides be given opportunity to present their case and that a speaking, appealable order be passed. The opinion concludes by dismissing the assessee's appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the imported fabrics coated with nylon flock should be classified under Customs Tariff Heading 59.07 or under Heading 43.04 as artificial fur lining, having regard to the length of the flock fibres and the HSN Explanatory Notes.
  2. Whether expert opinions (from IIT Delhi, SASMIRA and NITRA) relied upon by the department can be relied upon where cross-examination of those experts was not permitted.
  3. Whether test reports based on samples taken from some bills of entry can be used to classify goods imported under other bills of entry from which no samples were drawn.
  4. Who bears the burden of proof for showing the correct classification when Revenue seeks to classify goods differently from the assessee's claim.
  5. Whether HSN Explanatory Notes for Chapters 56 and 59 (and related chapter notes) can be applied to determine classification of the impugned goods.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Classification was based on reports of IIT Delhi, SASMIRA and NITRA, but no opportunity was given to cross-examine those experts; therefore their opinions cannot be relied upon.
  • IIT Delhi initially gave an opinion in favour of the appellant and only changed its opinion after a detailed letter from the Revenue; that change undermines reliance on the opinion against the appellant.
  • Only samples for some bills of entry were tested; test reports for those samples cannot be applied to other bills of entry for which samples were not drawn.
  • The goods were described in sale as "artificial fur lining", indicating classification under artificial fur heading.
  • HSN Explanatory Notes for Chapter 56 of the Customs Tariff should not be used for classification of the impugned goods (appellant contested reliance on Chapter 56 notes).
  • The burden of proof that the goods are classifiable under 59.07 lies on Revenue and several judgments were cited to support this proposition.

Respondent's (Ld. DR's) Arguments

  • The Commissioner in the impugned order analysed classification and found that because the flock length ranged between 0.45 mm to 0.50 mm, the goods could not be classifiable under Heading 43.04 as artificial fur lining.
  • Reliance was placed on chapter headings 59.07, 56.01 and 43.04 and on the HSN Explanatory Notes to contend that the goods were correctly classifiable under 59.07.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CCE Vs. Ballarpur Industries Ltd., 2007 (215) ELT 489 (SC) Technical expert's opinion is only an opinion; its evidentiary value should be ascertained by permitting cross-examination. The court acknowledged this principle to evaluate the effect of expert opinions in the record and noted the general requirement that such opinions have evidentiary value only after cross-examination is permitted.
Dharampal Satyapal Ltd. Vs. CCE, 2015 (87) SCC 519 (SC) Even if there is violation of natural justice (e.g., no hearing/cross-examination), the order need not always be set aside if non-grant of hearing caused no prejudice; validity is to be tested on the touchstone of prejudice. The court applied this principle to consider whether lack of cross-examination of experts vitiated proceedings. It observed that where denial of cross-examination causes prejudice the expert opinion should be ignored for deciding the issue; but also recognised that in some cases lack of hearing may not change outcome.
Adani Wilmer Ltd., 2008 (231) ELT 545 (Tri.-Ahm.) Where more than one government laboratory test report gives different results, it is not permissible to accept only the report favorable to the Revenue. The appellant relied on this authority; the court considered the principle in context but ultimately relied on undisputed factual findings (flock length) and HSN notes rather than differing expert opinions.
Kanishk Steel Indus. Ltd. Vs. CCE, 2005 (191) ELT 231 (Tri.-Chennai) Similar principle that conflicting government lab reports cannot result in selective acceptance of the report favourable to Revenue. The court noted this precedent as supporting the appellant's contention about multiple reports but did not base classification solely on expert opinions; instead used undisputed factual material and explanatory notes.
Puma Ayurvedic Herbal Pvt. Ltd. Vs. CCE, 2006 (196) ELT 3 (SC) Burden of showing correct classification lies on Revenue; the chief chemist's role is to supply analytical data and expert opinion has limited relevance for classification. The court reiterated that classification should not be decided merely on experts' opinions. In the present case, the court held classification on the basis of undisputed fiber length and HSN Explanatory Notes; it found that Revenue had discharged its burden in that manner.
HPL Chemicals Ltd. Vs. CCE, Chandigarh, 2006 (197) ELT 324 (SC) If the department seeks to classify goods under a different heading than claimed by the assessee, the department must produce proper evidence and discharge the burden of proof. The court applied this principle to examine whether Revenue had discharged its burden. It concluded that Revenue had discharged the burden through undisputed factual findings (length of flock between 0.45-0.50 mm) together with HSN Explanatory Notes.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise manner:

  1. Consideration of admissibility and weight of expert opinions: The court recognised the Supreme Court authorities that expert opinions are merely opinions and ordinarily require cross-examination to determine their evidentiary value (CCE vs. Ballarpur). It also noted the Dharampal Satyapal principle that the consequence of denial of hearing/cross-examination depends on whether prejudice resulted; not every procedural lapse automatically voids the decision.
  2. Examination of the record and factual findings: The court reviewed the show cause notice and impugned order and observed that the show cause notice specifically stated the flock height averaged between 0.45 mm and 0.50 mm. The appellant, despite seeking cross-examination of the person who wrote the test report, never disputed that flock length range at any stage; indeed, in pleadings the appellant had asserted that minimum length of fur was not laid down and had at one point contended that length was irrelevant. Because the length was never contested earlier, the court applied the principle of non-traverse and treated that factual finding as not open to contest at that stage.
  3. Application of HSN Explanatory Notes: The court closely read the HSN explanatory notes for Chapter 59 and Chapter 56. It quoted the explanatory note that textile flock consists of textile fibres not exceeding 5 mm in length and that fabrics produced with longer textile fibres (5 mm and above) are excluded from heading 59.07 if they have the character of artificial fur of Heading 43.04. From a combined reading, the court concluded that fabrics coated with textile flock less than 5 mm in length are not excluded from 59.07 even if they have the character of artificial fur.
  4. Synthesis of facts and law for classification: Given the undisputed factual finding that nylon flocks measured between 0.45 mm and 0.50 mm (i.e., well below 5 mm), and the HSN notes indicating that only flocks of 5 mm or longer that have the character of artificial fur are excluded from 59.07, the court concluded that the impugned goods fall within the scope of heading 59.07.
  5. On sample representativeness: The court addressed the appellant's contention that test reports from some consignments could not be applied to others. It relied on the authorised representative's statement dated 23/11/1996 that all imports under various bills were of the same quality, character and technical specifications (except colour). Examination of samples from a number of consignments supported that statement. The court held there was no infirmity in using test results from examined consignments for other consignments where no samples were drawn, and indicated that insisting on sampling every consignment when the authorised representative had admitted sameness would constitute undue harassment.
  6. Burden of proof and role of expert opinions: The court acknowledged authorities stating that Revenue bears burden to show correct classification if it differs from the assessee's claim, and that expert opinions are only evidentiary. The court emphasised that in the present matter classification was not being determined solely on expert classification opinions; instead it rested on the undisputed factual measurement of flock length and the HSN Explanatory Notes, and therefore Revenue had discharged its burden.
  7. Procedural disposition: While the court found the factual and legal basis for classification, it nevertheless directed remand to the jurisdictional Commissioner of Customs for de novo consideration, instructing the Commissioner to provide opportunity to both sides and to pass a speaking, appealable order. The impugned order-in-original was set aside and the appeals of the Revenue were allowed by way of remand.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • The impugned order-in-original is set aside.
  • The appeals of the Revenue are allowed by way of remand to the jurisdictional Commissioner of Customs for de novo consideration.
  • The assessee's appeal is dismissed.

Practical Consequences and Directions: The matter is remanded to the jurisdictional Commissioner of Customs who is directed to provide both sides an opportunity to present their cases and thereafter to pass a speaking, appealable order in accordance with law. The tribunal accepted on record the factual finding that the flock fibres measured between 0.45 mm and 0.50 mm and, applying HSN Explanatory Notes, indicated that such fabrics are not excluded from Heading 59.07 (exclusion applies to textile fibres of length 5 mm or above that have the character of artificial fur). The tribunal also held that test reports from sampled consignments could be applied to other consignments where the authorised representative had admitted sameness of quality and specification.

Precedential Effect: The opinion applies existing authorities concerning the evidentiary value of expert opinions, the principle of prejudice in cases of denial of hearing, and the burden on Revenue to prove classification. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new principle of law; its decision turns on the application of the HSN Explanatory Notes to the undisputed factual finding about flock length and procedural directions to the Commissioner for further proceedings.


Pronounced in Court on 1.3.2016. (Justice G. Raghuram) President (R.K. Singh) Member (Technical)

    Hpl Chemicals Ltd v. Cce

    We, therefore, consider that this matter needs to go back to the jurisdictional Commissioner of Customs for de novo consideration in the light of our above discussion. We, therefore, remand this matter to the jurisdictional Commissioner of Customs who will provide an opportunity to both the sides to present their respective case and will then pass speaking appealable order as per law. Thus, the impugned order-in-original is set aside and both the appeals of the Revenue are allowed by way of remand to the jurisdictional Commissioner of Customs, as above. The appeal is thus allowed by way of remand. In the wake of CESTAT order dated 5.12.2002 the impugned order was passed.

    4. The appellant has contended as under:

    (i) Classification has been determined on the basis of report of IIT, Delhi, SASMIRA and NITRA. No opportunity for cross examination of Shri P.K. Hari of IIT, Delhi, Dr. R. Sarkar of SASMIRA and Shri S.S. Satsangi of NITRA was afforded and therefore their opinion cannot be relied upon. It cited several judgements in support of the said proposition :

    (ii) Initially IIT, Delhi gave opinion in favour of the appellant and it was only when Revenue wrote a detailed letter to IIT that the opinion was changed and therefore such opinion cannot be relied upon against the appellant.

    (iii) Only samples in respect of some bills of entry were tested and therefore in respect of other bills of entry, the test reports cannot be applied.

    (iv) While selling these goods were described as artificial fur lining.

    (v) The HSN Explanatory Notes for Chapter 56 of Customs Tariff cannot be used for classification of the impugned goods.

    (vi) The burden of proof that the goods are classifiable under 59.07 is clearly on Revenue as has been held by several judgements which were cited.

    5. Ld. DR, on the other hand, stated that the Commissioner in the impugned order has analysed the issue of classification and has come to a clear finding that by virtue of the fact that the length of flock was ranging between 0.45 to 0.50 mm, such goods could not be classifiable under Heading 43.04 as artificial fur lining. He strenuously referred to the chapter headings 59.07, 56.01 and 43.04 and relied upon HSN Explanatory Notes to contend that the goods have been correctly held to be classifiable under 59.07.

    6. We have considered the contentions of both sides and perused the records and the judgements cited. As regards the contention of the appellant that experts opinions should not be relied upon as their cross-examination was not permitted, we find that in the case of CCE Vs. Ballarpur Industries Ltd. - 2007 (215) ELT 489 (SC) the Honble Supreme Court inter alia observed that opinion of the technical expert is only an opinion and its evidentiary value has to be ascertained by permitting his cross-examination. In the case of Dharampal Sataypal Ltd. Vs. CCE - 2015 (87) SCC 519 (SC), Supreme Court has summed up to the issue essentially holding that there may be situations where it is felt that fair hearing would make no difference-meaning that a hearing would not change the ultimate conclusion reached by the decision-maker in such situations, fair procedures appear to serve no purpose since the right result can be secured without according hearing/cross-examination. (ii) It may not be necessary to strike down the action and refer the matter back to the authorities to take fresh decision after complying with the procedural requirement in those cases where non-grant of hearing has not caused any prejudice to the person against whom the action is taken. Therefore, every violation of a facet of natural justice may not lead to the conclusion that the order passed is always null and void. (iii) The validity of the order has to be decided on the touchstone of prejudice. The Honble Supreme Court in para 40 of the said judgement observed as under : 40. In this behalf, we need to notice one other exception which has been carved out to the aforesaid principle by the Courts. Even if it is found by the Court that there is a violation of principles of natural justice, the Courts have held that it may not be necessary to strike down the action and refer the matter back to the authorities to take fresh decision after complying with the procedural requirement in those cases where non-grant of hearing has not caused any prejudice to the person against whom the action is taken. Therefore, every violation of a facet of natural justice may not lead to the conclusion that order passed is always null and void. The validity of the order has to be decided on the touchstone of prejudice. The ultimate test is always the same, viz., the test of prejudice of the test of fair hearing. There is no doubt that there can be a situation whether denial of cross-examination of expert may not cause any prejudice and in such case not allowing cross-examination would not vitiate the proceedings. However, in the present case it is eminently arguable that not allowing cross examination of the experts has caused prejudice to the appellant as their opinion was relied upon to negate the appellants plea/contention and therefore the least that follows is that as the cross examination of the experts who gave their opinions was not permitted/held, their opinion is to be ignored for the purpose of deciding the issue at hand.

    7. We have perused the show cause notice and the impugned order. We find that it was categorically mentioned in the show cause notice that the impugned fabrics comprised a synthetic knitted base and were coated/covered with coloured nylon flocks with an average flock height ranging between 0.45 0.50 mm. Even though the appellant sought cross examination of the person who wrote the test report, at no sage during the proceedings it disputed that the average flock length was not ranging between 0.45 to 0.50 mm or claimed that it was more than 5 mm. As a matter of fact, in the reply to the show cause notice (in para 20) the appellant claimed that the minimum of length of fur is nowhere laid down in the chapter notes of Chapter 43 of Customs Tariff. Therefore the departments contention by cross reference to some length referred to in sub heading 56.01 has no relevance. Not only that, even in its appeal (in para 7 page 28 of the appeal) it has made an assertion that length of the fur is totally irrelevant for the reason that the purpose of fur is to safeguard the animal from external temperature/environment Thus the appellant never disputed the length of flock being 0.45 to 0.50 mm. Once it was not disputed at any stage earlier, by the principle of non traverse, this cannot be contested at this stage even if the appellant chose to attempt to do so.

    8. We have perused the HSN notes pertaining to 59.07; as per note (G) under that chapter it is stated as under: (G) Fabric, the surface of which is coated with glue (rubber glue or other) plastics, rubber or other materials and sprinkled with a fine layer of other material such as:- (1) Textile flock or dust to produce imitation suedes (fabrics produced in a similar manner with longer textile fibres are excluded if they have the character of artificial fur of heading 43.04). Fabrics covered with textile flock or dust to produce imitation pile (for example, corduroy) remain classified in this heading. (2) Powdered cork (e.g. for wall coverings) (3) Powder or small granules of glass (e.g. microspheres for cinematograph screens) (4) Powdered Mica. We find that as per HSN note be under 56 textile flock is described as under: Textile flock consists of textile fibres not exceeding 5 mm in length (silk, wool, cotton, man-made fibres etc.). It is obtained as waste during various finishing operations and, in particular, from the shearing of velvets. It is also produced by cutting textile tow or fibres. Textile dust is obtained as waste, or by grinding textile fibres to a powder. Textile flock and dust fall in this heading even if bleached or dyed or if the fibres having been artificially curled. These products are used for a wide variety of purposes (e.g. for blending with other fibres and spinning into yarns, for making imitation suedes, for coating or decorating wallpaper, as a basis for face powder or make up] . A combined reading of the above-quoted Explanatory Notes make it very clear that fabrics produced in a similar manner with textile fibres of length 5 mm and above are excluded from CTH 59.07 if they have the character of artificial fur of heading 43.04. The clear implication of this is that fabrics covered with textile flock of less than 5 mm length are not excluded out of the purview of 59.07 even if they have the character of artificial fur. We also find that the appellant have nowhere claimed that the impugned goods looked like fur of any particular animal. That however is not of any consequence because even if the impugned goods looked liked some fur, by virtue of the HSN notes cited earlier and the analysis above, because of the fact that nylon flocks had the length between 0.45 mm to 0.5 mm, the impugned goods do not get excluded from the scope of chapter heading 59.07. We may repeat that to exclude the goods from the scope of 59.07 (i) the flocks have to be of length 5 mm or longer and (ii) the goods should have the character of artificial fur.

    9. The appellant referred to the judgement in the case of Adani Wilmer Ltd. 2008 (231) ELT 545 (Tri.-Ahm.) to assert that where more than one test report of government laboratory was available showing different results, it is not possible to accept only one of them which is in favour of Revenue. The judgement in the case of Kanishk Steel Indus. Ltd. Vs. CCE 2005 (191) ELT 231 (Tri.-Chennai) is also to the same effect. The judgement in the case of Puma Ayurvedic Herbal Pvt. Ltd. Vs. CCE 2006 (196) ELT 3 (SC) was cited to support the proposition that the burden of showing correct classification lies on Revenue and the experts opinion has no relevance for determining classification of products as the role of chief chemist is only to supply analytical data. In the case of HPL Chemicals Ltd. Vs. CCE, Chandigarh 2006 (197) ELT 324 (SC), Supreme Court reiterated that if department needs to classify goods under a particular heading or subheading different from claimed by assessee, department needs to produce proper evidence and discharge burden of proof. In the present case the various experts reports did not change the findings of facts, only the opinion about classification was changed and no reliance has been placed on that opinion in the foregoing analysis. Further the classification is not being determined in the present case on the basis of the opinion given by the experts regarding classification. As stated earlier, the classification has been determined on the basis of the length of the flock fibres being between 0.45 limited to 0.5 mm which was never contested and on the basis of the HSN Explanatory Notes on classification which are standard and internationally accepted for the purpose of determining the classification of goods. Thus, Revenue has discharged its burden of proof while determining the classification.

    10. As regard the contention of the appellant that when the samples have not been drawn from the goods covered under various bills of entry, the test reports relating to goods which were covered under some other bills of entry of the appellant cannot be used for the purpose of classifying goods imported under bills of entry from where no samples were drawn, we note that the authorised representative of the appellant in his statement dated 23/11/1996 categorically stated that the appellant had imported artificial fur lining of the same quality, character and technical specifications (except colour) under all the bills of entry. Further the examination of samples drawn from a number of consignments imported under various bills of entry supported the said statement of the authorised representative. Therefore we do not find any infirmity in using the result of the test reports certifying the length of fibre to be between 0.45 mm to 0.5 mm for the goods imported under the bills of entry from where no samples were drawn. Indeed insisting on drawing samples from all the consignments when the authorised representative categorically accepted that the goods were of the same quality characteristic and technical specifications as the ones from which samples had been drawn would/could have invited the allegation of undue harassment. Samples are drawn when there is a dispute. When there were no dispute that the goods imported under other bills of entry were the same in quality characteristics and technical specifications, there was no requirement of drawing the samples from each and every consignment imported under each and every bill of entry. Thus this contention of the appellant is clearly unsustainable.

    11. In the light of the foregoing analysis, we do not find merit in the assessees appeal and therefore dismiss the same. (Pronounced in Court on 1.3.2016) (Justice G. Raghuram) President (R.K. Singh) Member (Technical)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hpl Chemicals Ltd v. Cce
    (Mar 1, 2016)