AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Acts
  • u/s.19 of Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • Rule 16 read with Rule 2 (c) of DRT (Procedure) Rules, 1993.
  • 03.08.2007 u/s.13(2) of SARFAESI Act.
  • section 19(20) of RDDB&FI Act.
  • u/s.13(4) of SARFAESI Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Acts
  • u/s.19 of Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • Rule 16 read with Rule 2 (c) of DRT (Procedure) Rules, 1993.
  • 03.08.2007 u/s.13(2) of SARFAESI Act.
  • section 19(20) of RDDB&FI Act.
  • u/s.13(4) of SARFAESI Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant bank filed an application on 24.11.2008 under Section 19 of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993, seeking recovery of Rs.1,78,49,451.32 along with future interest and penal interest from the defendants. The first defendant (D1), a limited company, approached the bank in September 2005 for credit facilities, which were sanctioned on 05.12.2005, including a Packing Credit facility and Letter of Credit. D1 executed loan documents including an agreement of hypothecation and created an equitable mortgage over the property described in the application. Defendants D2 to D4 provided guarantees. Due to irregular operation, D1's account became non-performing. The bank issued a recall notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act on 03.08.2007 and a possession notice under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act on 22.12.2007. The present application was filed following these events.

The defendants contested the application, filing a written statement denying liability, disputing the validity of the loan documents, challenging the mortgage, and raising issues including exorbitant interest charges, limitation, and the bank's simultaneous proceedings under different statutes. An interim stay was granted in a related proceeding (SA No.79/2008) on 25.02.2008, during which the defendants made a partial payment of Rs.10 lakhs. The application proceeded to adjudication thereafter.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the applicant bank is entitled to a recovery certificate for the claim amount stated in the application?
  2. Whether the applicant bank is entitled to the contractual rate of interest after filing the application as prayed for?

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant Bank's Arguments

  • The applicant bank sanctioned financial facilities to D1, who executed loan and security documents including hypothecation and equitable mortgage agreements.
  • The loan account became irregular and non-performing, prompting issuance of recall and possession notices under SARFAESI Act provisions.
  • The bank sought recovery of outstanding dues supported by evidence including loan documents, mortgage agreements, guarantee agreements, notices, and statements of account.
  • The bank contended the defendants failed to repay despite notices and the claim amount was properly calculated.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants alleged non-cooperation by the applicant bank and other lenders led to standstill of manufacturing operations, making repayment impossible.
  • They denied availing the loan and execution of the loan documents, claiming them to be fabricated.
  • They disputed the existence of mortgage over the scheduled property and denied depositing title deeds.
  • They challenged the charging of exorbitant and compound interest, including capitalisation of penal interest, contrary to Supreme Court precedent.
  • They argued the application was barred by limitation and that the bank could not proceed simultaneously under the DRT Act and SARFAESI Act under the doctrine of election.
  • The defendants contended they were not jointly and severally liable for the dues.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Central Bank of India Vs. Ravindra and others Prohibition on charging compound interest on penal interest The court noted the defendants' contention regarding compound interest on penal interest and directed the bank to file a fresh statement of account without capitalizing penal interest, which upon review was found to comply with loan terms and RBI guidelines.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the evidence presented by the applicant bank, including testimony and 19 documentary exhibits evidencing sanction of credit facilities, execution of loan and guarantee agreements, creation of equitable mortgage, issuance of recall and possession notices under SARFAESI Act, and statements of account.

The court found that the financial assistance was availed on 05.12.2005 and the mortgage created on 06.12.2005, with the application filed on 24.11.2008, thus within the period of limitation. The defendants' claim of limitation was rejected.

Regarding interest, the court observed that the initial statement of account showed capitalisation of penal interest, which was impermissible. The bank was directed to submit a revised statement excluding capitalisation. The revised statement demonstrated that the interest charged conformed to contractual terms and RBI guidelines, negating claims of excess interest.

The court also concluded that the defendants had created an equitable mortgage over the scheduled property, rejecting the defendants' denial of mortgage and title deed deposit.

On the quantum of claim, the court found the bank had proved entitlement to Rs.1,45,66,307.32, less than the claimed Rs.1,78,49,451.32, and limited recovery to the proven amount.

Considering the defendants' inability to pay due to unavoidable circumstances, the court exercised discretion under Section 19(20) of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act to reduce the contractual interest rate from 14% to 12% per annum simple interest from the date of application till realization, balancing justice and equity.

Holding and Implications

The application is partly allowed.

The applicant bank is entitled to recover Rs.1,45,66,307.32 together with interest at 12% per annum simple from the date of filing the application till realization, along with costs, jointly and severally from the defendants. The recovery is to be effected by sale of the mortgaged property described in the application. The bank is directed to file a costs memo within two weeks. A recovery certificate is to be issued accordingly, and copies of the order communicated to parties as per procedural rules.

No broader precedent was established beyond the application of existing statutory provisions and principles to the facts of this case.

    Central Bank Of India v. Ravindra And Others

    1. This application is filed by applicant bank u/s.19 of Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) on 24.11.2008 for recovery of an amount of Rs.1,78,49,451.32 together with future interest @ 14% p.a. with quarterly interest with penal interest @ 2% p.a. over and above the nominal interest on the interest overdue from the date of OA till the date of realisation together with costs from the defendants jointly and severally and by sale of property described in the schedule to the OA. Brief of Application :-

    2. The 1 defendant approached the applicant bank during September, 2005 for credit facilities and the applicant bank sanctioned Packing Credit facility of Rs.1 crore and Letter of Credit of Rs.4 crores on 05.12.2005. D1 has executed necessary loan documents on 05.12.2005 including agreement of hypothecation. D2 to D4 guaranteed due repayment of said facility and executed Agreement for Guarantee dt.05.12.2005 and 26.12.2005 in favour of applicant. D1 agreed to create equitable mortgage in respect of the property described in the schedule to the OA. However, the same was offered as collateral security. Since D1 has not operated the account properly the account of D1 has become non performing account. The efforts taken by bank by calling upon D1 to regularize the accounts through various correspondences proved futile. Hence, the applicant bank issued recall notice on 03.08.2007 u/s.13(2) of SARFAESI Act. Thereafter, the applicant bank issued possession notice u/s.13(4) of SARFAESI Act on 22.12.2007 in respect of mortgaged property. Hence the present OA is filed. Brief of written statement of defendants :

    3. The D4, the Director of D1 filed written statement for his behalf and on behalf of D1 to D3. The applicant bank refused to release the required working capital within the sanctioned limit. Hence, the manufacturing process of D1 company standstill and made it impossible to run the unit. The defendants made efforts for one time settlement. Instead, the applicant bank issued demand notice, possession notice and sale notice. Hence, D1 filed SA No.79/2008 and this Tribunal granted interim stay on 25.02.2008. In compliance of same the defendants remitted Rs.10 lakhs. The said SA was pending. In the circumstance the present OA is filed. The applicant bank had charged exorbitant interest and hidden charges which were not agreed by these defendants. Under Doctrine of Law of Election, the applicant bank cannot simultaneously proceed under DRT Act and SARFAESI Act. The OA is barred by limitation. The defendants denied availing of loan and execution of loan documents. The said documents are cooked up and fabricated for filing this OA. The defendant neither mortgaged nor deposited the title deeds relating to the said schedule mentioned properties. There is no mortgage as claimed by applicant bank. The applicant bank produced various statements of accounts. The particulars of initial entry on 15.03.2008 for Rs.1,36,52,124.32 was not furnished by applicant. The balance outstanding does not tally with the suit amount. The applicant bank failed to furnish rates of interest charged during each period. The compound interest is charged for penal interest also which has been prohibited under the order passed by Honble Supreme Court in Central Bank of India Vs. Ravindra and others case. The applicant bank claimed interest at quarterly rests whereas the applicant bank had already debited interest at monthly rests. The applicant bank may be directed to furnish statement of account from the commencement of the transactions with full details regarding rate of interest etc. The defendants are not jointly and severally liable to pay the dues. Hence, the defendants prayed for dismissing the OA. Point for consideration :-

    4. (i) Whether the applicant is entitled for recovery certificate for the claim amount in the OA?

    (ii) Whether the applicant bank is entitled for contractual rate of interest after filing the OA as prayed for? Points No.1 & 2 :-

    5. The applicant bank filed this application to recover a sum of Rs.1,78,49,451.32 from the defendants. The case of the applicant bank is that D1 is a Ltd., company and D2 is the Managing Director of D1 company. They approached the applicant bank for financial facilities and availed the same. The D1 has executed hypothecation agreement and mortgaged the schedule mentioned properties for the same. But the loan account of D1 was irregular. Therefore, the account was classified as NPA and issued demand notice to the defendants. In spite of this, they have not repaid the amount. Hence, this OA.

    6. To prove its claim, the applicant bank examined its Assistant General Manager, Mr.R.Rangarajan and filed proof affidavit along with 19 documents and they were marked as Exhs.A1 to A19. Exh.A1 - Possession Certificate dt.10.05.2004. Exh.A2 - Agreement for sale of land dt.10.05.2004. Exh.A3 - Deed of Sale dt.12.08.2005. Exh.A4 - Encumbrance Certificate dt.05.11.2005. Exh.A5 - Sanction of Credit facility dt.07.11.2005. Exh.A6 - Sanction letter dt.08.11.2005. Exh.A7 - Agreement of Hypothecation of assets dt.05.12.2005. Exh.A8 - Agreement of Guarantee dt.05.12.2005. Exh.A9 - Agreement of Guarantee dt.05.12.2005. Exh.A10 - Common Agreement dt.05.12.2005. Exh.A11 - Mortgage letter dt.06.12.2005. Exh.A12 - Agreement of Guarantee dt.26.12.2005. Exh.A13 ] Form 8 for the charge created with the Registrar of ] Companies dt.03.01.2006. Exh.A14 ] Form 13 for the charge created with the Registrar of ] Companies dt.03.01.2006. Exh.A15 - Recall notice u/s.13(2) of the Act dt.30.08.2007. Exh.A16 - Show Cause notice dt.13.09.2007. Exh.A17 - Possession notice dt.22.12.2007. Exh.A18 - Statement of accounts dt.10.11.2008. Exh.A19 - Statement of accounts (filed during the pendency of OA).

    7. The main contention of the defendants is that the non-cooperative attitude of applicant bank and also other lender banks, the manufacturing process came to stand still and it made impossible to run the prestigious unit. Therefore, they were not able to repay the due amount. Further stated D1 has not mortgaged the schedule mentioned property. The penal interest has been capitalized by applicant bank. The rate of interest was also not given properly by applicant bank. The OA is barred by limitation. Hence, the defendants prayed for dismissing the OA.

    8. The financial assistance was availed by D1 on 05.12.2005 and D1 mortgaged the property on 06.12.2005. OA was filed on 24.11.2008 on mortgage. Hence, this OA is within the period of limitation and it is not barred by limitation.

    9. On perusal of statement of account, Exh.A18 it shows that penal interest was capitalized. Therefore, the Tribunal directed the applicant bank to file fresh statement of account without capitalizing the penal interest. In obedience of this Tribunals order, the applicant bank filed fresh statement of account and it was marked as Exh.A19. On perusal of Exh.A19 it clearly proves that it has charged rate of interest as per the terms and conditions of loan agreement and as per RBI guidelines and not excess rate of interest. There is no violation and the claim amount is proper.

    10. On seeing the deposit of title deeds and the mortgage agreement, it clearly shows that D1 has created an equitable mortgage in respect of schedule mentioned property. Therefore, the objections raised by the defendants are not acceptable.

    11. On going through the evidence of applicant bank and the clinching documents Exhs.A1 to A19, it reveals that the applicant bank has proved its claim against the defendants for Rs.1,45,66,307.32 only. But it has failed to prove the claim amount of Rs.1,78,49,451.32. Hence, the defendants are liable only to pay Rs.1,45,66,307.32 to applicant bank.

    12. The applicant bank has prayed for interest @ 14% p.a. with quarterly rests with penal interest @ 2% p.a. over and above the nominal interest on the interest over due for the claim amount. The defendants are unable to pay the loan amount due to unavoidable circumstances. In such circumstance, awarding contractual rate of interest will not meet the ends of justice. Therefore, in the interest of justice I am inclined to pass an order reducing the rate of interest as per section 19(20) of rddb&fi act.

    13. In the result, application is partly allowed as under :- (a) The applicant bank is entitled to recover a sum of Rs.1,45,66,307.32 (Rupees one crore forty five lakhs sixty six thousand three hundred and seven and paise thirty two only) together with interest @ 12% p.a. (simple) from the date of OA till the date of realisation together with costs from the defendants jointly and severally and by sale of property described in the schedule to the OA. (b) The applicant is directed to file costs memo within two weeks of the receipt of this order. (c) Issue recovery certificate in favour of the applicant bank in terms of this final order. (d) Communicate a copy of the order to the parties concerned in terms of Rule 16 read with Rule 2 (c) of DRT (Procedure) Rules, 1993. (Dictated to Stenographer, transcribed by him, corrected, signed and pronounced by me in the Open Court, this 30th day of November, 2015) Sd./- (R. RAVINDRA BOSE) PRESIDING OFFICER

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Central Bank Of India v. Ravindra And Others
    (Nov 30, 2015)