AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

These four consolidated appeals challenge four different orders of the learned Deputy Registrar dated 05.02.2008, 17.04.2009, 27.04.2009 and 13.08.2007. The applications in dispute concern multiple trade mark applications by the respondents for marks in Kannada and English, described in the opinion as:

  • “NANDHINI DELUXE” (Kannada) — application No. 982284 in class 30 and application No. 982286 in class 06 (subject matter of OA 12 & 13/2009.TM/CH);
  • “NANDHINI DELUXE WITH LOGO” (Kannada) — application No. 982285 in class 29 (subject matter of OA 41/2009.TM/CH);
  • “NANDHINI DELUXE” — application No. 982281 in class 31 (subject matter of OA 85/2009.TM/CH);
  • “NANDHINI” word per se — application No. 817305 in class 30 (subject matter of OA 53/2009/TM/CH).

The appellants opposed registration of these marks. The Deputy Registrar disallowed the oppositions, reasoning that the opponents could not claim monopoly over the trade mark NANDINI, that there was no deception or confusion because parties dealt in different descriptions of goods, and that the artistic designs and lettering of the applicant's marks differed from those of the opponents. The Registrar found the balance of convenience in favour of the applicants, but directed deletion of “milk and milk products” from the class 29 registration by filing TM 16. Aggrieved, the opponents filed these appeals and the matters were consolidated because the facts and issues were identical.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent-applicants can be permitted to register and use marks incorporating the word “Nandhini”/“Nandini” (including “NANDHINI DELUXE” and variants) for goods in classes 29 and 30, in view of the appellants' prior and long-standing use of the mark “NANDINI” for milk and milk products.
  2. Whether the addition of the letter “H” in the English representation (NANDHINI v. NANDINI), or the addition of the word “Deluxe”, or differences in devices or artistic presentation, are sufficient to avoid confusion or deception among the average consumer.
  3. Whether evidence of long prior use and acquired distinctiveness by the appellants supports disallowing registration of the respondents' marks for goods akin to the appellants'.
  4. Whether the appellants' alleged long acquiescence (18 years) to the respondents' use of their mark in connection with hotel/restaurant services is relevant to opposition to registration for goods in classes 29 and 30.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant is a Federation of milk producers and owns the trade mark NANDINI, used since 1983 on milk and milk products (curd, butter, cheese, ghee, milk powder, flavoured milk, paneer, khoa, ice-cream, milk-based sweets) sold in bottles, sachets, tetrapacks, polythene containers, etc.
  • The appellant uses a device of a standing cow on grass with a rising sun in the background and has used the mark for about two-and-a-half decades; it is a well-known trade mark and household name in Karnataka.
  • The adoption by the respondent of “NANDHINI” is dishonest; the channels of trade and class of customers overlap, so consumers will not distinguish differences in devices or artwork and will focus on the word NANDHINI/NANDINI.
  • The addition of the letter ‘H’ does not change pronunciation and the Kannada script for the marks is identical; hence there will be confusion.
  • The appellant produced evidence of sales turnover, advertising and promotional expenditure (figures from 1996-97 to 2005-06), prior registrations in classes 29–32 and copyright registrations from 1984–1985 to support distinctiveness and prior use.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent argued that the appellant had acquiesced in the continuance of the respondent's mark for 18 years and thus cannot now object to registration.
  • The respondent contended the mark is not confusing and asserted that the word “Nandini” is a deity's name and cannot be appropriated exclusively by the appellant.
  • Respondents relied primarily on documentary advertisements showing they operated restaurants (e.g., “Nandhini Andhra Speciality Restaurants”, “Nandhini - The Restaurant”), suggesting use in the hospitality trade rather than the specified goods classes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
2003 (27) PTC 352 (Mad) — Woodlands Travels and Agencies v. K. Vasudevan Rao Where there is evidence that a mark (W-WOODYS) had been used on products, in the shop/restaurant, on boxes and cartons, the objection based on confusion was rejected. The court quoted this case to illustrate that factual proof of use on the relevant goods and trade channels is decisive; it contrasted that case with the present facts where respondents produced only restaurant advertisements and no evidence of trade in the contested goods.
AIR 1963 SCC 449 — Amritdhara Pharmacy v. Satya Gupta The opinion lists this authority among cited precedents (as cited in the record). The court included it among authorities considered; the opinion does not specify the precise rule from this decision applied to the facts of these appeals beyond its inclusion in the list of authorities.
2004 (29) PTC 376 (IPAB) — (as cited regarding Kraft Jacobs Sucharc Ltd. and others) Example where interim injunction was not granted because the plaintiff failed to establish secondary meaning in the word “grand” and was not the first user in connection with hotel business. The court used this precedent to demonstrate that lack of secondary meaning and prior user can defeat injunctions; it observed that each case depends on its facts and used this as comparative guidance.
2004 (28) PTC 404 — Bharat Hotels Limited v. Unison Hotels Limited Listed among authorities in the record (cited contextually with other PTC authorities). The opinion lists this decision as one of the comparative authorities; the court did not elaborate a detailed application beyond citing it as part of the jurisprudence considered.
(2001) 5 SCC 73 — Cadila Health Care Ltd. v. Cadila Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Cited by the appellant (case relied upon by the appellant in submissions). The court acknowledged the appellant's reliance on Cadila; the opinion does not set out a direct, detailed rule from Cadila but considers general principles of confusion and distinctiveness in the context of prior use.
2004 (29) PTC — (case concerning MILKA and PIONEERS MILKA) An example where competing marks MILKA and PIONEERS MILKA were at issue (used to illustrate factual distinctions between marks). Referenced to show that stylization and surrounding words can be relevant, but that decisions depend on factual contexts; used to underscore that identicality and actual use matter.
2007 34 PTC — (case concerning CITIZEN) Example where registration of the impugned mark (CITIZEN) had continued for seven years with no evidence of confusion. Used as a comparative illustration that long continued registration/use without confusion may sustain a mark, but the court emphasized that each case turns on its facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the record and submissions and proceeded through a fact-focused analysis:

  1. The court observed that in OA/41/200/TM/CH there was a certificate (at Page 41 of the paper-book) which deleted “milk and milk products” from the registration even before TM 16 was filed; this factual detail was noted as part of the record.
  2. The Deputy Registrar's impugned orders referred to some evidence produced by the applicants (respondents) asserting proprietorship; however, the only documentary material the respondents produced in the record were advertisements showing operation of restaurants (e.g., “Nandhini Andhra Speciality Restaurants”, “Nandhini - The Restaurant”, pictorial depictions and dated advertisements offering food and catering).
  3. The court held that such advertisement material only established use in the hospitality trade (class 42) and did not demonstrate that the respondents were trading in the contested goods for classes 29 and 30. Consequently, the respondents had not shown trade in the goods for which registration was sought.
  4. The argument that the appellant had acquiesced for 18 years to the respondents' mark for hotel services was held to be irrelevant to the question of registration for goods in classes 29 and 30. Any issue concerning class 42 (hotel services) would have to be dealt with separately when that registration is specifically contested.
  5. The court accepted the appellants' evidence of long prior use of the word mark Nandini since the mid-1980s, noting a Copyright Certificate dated 25.02.1992 and other documentary entries from Kannada weeklies (e.g., Sudha and Tharanga) indicating public association of the word with the appellant's products. The respondents themselves did not deny that the appellants had been in the business for more than two decades.
  6. Applying the principle that the average consumer would likely assume goods in classes 29 and 30 bearing the mark belonged to the appellant (specifically naming the Karnataka Cooperative Milk Producer's Federation in the opinion), the court held that the word NANDINI had acquired distinctiveness through long use.
  7. The court analysed differences relied upon by the Deputy Registrar — such as the respondents' device, artistic work, the addition of the letter “H” and the word “Deluxe” — and found them insufficient to avoid confusion. The court emphasized that the addition of the letter ‘H’ does not alter pronunciation and that in Kannada there was no difference in spelling between the appellant's and respondent's trademarks.
  8. Given the appellants' established priority in use and acquired distinctiveness, and the lack of evidence by respondents of use of the disputed marks on the goods in classes 29 and 30, the court found that registration and use by the respondents in respect of those goods would likely cause confusion and mislead the public.
  9. The court concluded that the Deputy Registrar's finding that there was no likelihood of confusion could not be sustained on the facts; the balance of convenience favored the appellants.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The court allowed the appeals and set aside the Deputy Registrar's orders.

Implications and direct effects (as stated or clearly implied in the opinion):

  • The Registrar's orders disallowing opposition to registration (in respect of the contested applications for classes 29 and 30) do not stand and have been set aside by this court.
  • The court's findings emphasize that the appellants' prior and continuous use of the mark Nandini had resulted in acquired distinctiveness for the appellants in relation to milk and milk products, and that registration or use by the respondents for the goods in classes 29 and 30 would cause confusion among consumers.
  • Miscellaneous petitions connected with these appeals were disposed of. The court made no order as to costs.
  • No broader/precedential rule beyond the application of established principles to these facts is announced; the court reiterated that each case must be decided on its own facts.

This summary is based exclusively on the language and materials contained in the provided opinion and does not add information from external sources.

    Karnataka Cooperative Milk Producers Federation Limited v. N. Anand

    Hon'ble Justice Prabha Sridevan, Chairman:— These four appeals were disposed of by four different orders, dated 05.02.2008, 17-04-2009, 27-04-2009 and 13.08.2007 They are in respect of the marks “NANDHINI DELUXE” (Kannada) under application No. 982284 in class 30 and “NANDHINI DELUXE” (Kannada) under application No. 982286 in class 06 is the subject matter of OA 12 & 13/2009.TM/CH; NANDHINI DELUXE WITH LOGO (Kannada) under application No. 982285 in class 29 is the subject matter of OA 41/2009.TM/CH. The application No. 982281 in class 31 which relates to the mark “NANDHINI DELUXE” which is the subject matter of OA 85/2009.TM/CH and “NANDHINI” word per se application No. 817305 in 30 is the subject matter of OA/53/2009/TM/CH. Since the facts are the same and issues involved are identical in all these matters, they are being disposed of by this common order.

    2. The appellants opposed the registration. The learned Deputy Registrar disallowed the opposition. The reasons for rejection of the opposition in both the orders are almost identical. The learned Deputy Registrar held that the opponents cannot claim monopoly over the trade mark NANDINI and that though the opponents are the prior user, there is no deception or confusion since parties are dealing in different description of goods. The artistic work design and letters of the applicant's marks are totally different from that of the opponent's and the balance of convenience is in favour of the applicant. However, with regard to the registration in class 29 the applicants were directed to delete the items “milk and milk products” by filing TM 16. Aggrieved by the orders, the opponents have filed this appeal.

    3. The grounds of appeal are almost the same. The appellant is a Federation of milk producers and the trade mark NANDINI belongs to the appellant. The goods sold are milk and milk products such as curd, butter, cheese, ghee, milk powder, flavoured milk, pannier, khoa, ice-cream and milk based sweets. They are sold in bottles, sachets, tetrapacks, polythene containers etc, since the year 1983. The device of a standing cow on a grass land in the background of rising sun is also used by the appellant. It is a well known trade mark and a household name in the State of Karnataka. For two-and-half decades, this mark has been used by the appellant and no one else. The appellant has given statistics of the sales turnover and the advertisement and sales promotional expenditure for the last 10 years from 1996-97 Rs. 39.80 lakhs to 2005-2006 Rs. 1048.89 lakhs. The appellant has obtained several registrations in respect of the trade mark “NANDINI” and label forms in classes 29, 30, 31 and 32. The appellant has also secured copyright registration as early as 1984 and 1985. While that is so, the appellant came across the advertisement of the respondent with an identical mark and therefore filed this opposition.

    4. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that it is the household name and the adoption of “NANDHINI” is dishonest and the channel of trade of the appellant's goods and the respondent's goods are the same, the class of customers who purchase cannot be expected to look at the difference in the device which is relied on by the learned Deputy Registrar. The only thing that the common man would refer to is the word NANDHINI and whether it is NANDHINI MILK, KHOA or NANDHINI SPICE and the addition of the letter ‘H’ in the English representation cannot make the difference because the pronunciation is the same and the Kannada script they are identical.

    5. The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the appellant having acquiesced in the continuance of the mark of respondent for 18 years cannot now oppose the registration. The learned counsel submitted that the mark is not confusing, and that the word “Nandini” which belongs to a deity cannot be appropriated by the appellant.

    6. The appellant filed many documents to support his case and the respondent also relied on certain documents. The respondents relied 2003(27) PTC 352 (Mad) Woodlands Travels and Agencies v. K. Vasudevan Rao, AIR 1963 SCC 449 (V 50 C63) Amritdhara Pharmacy v. Satya Gupta, 2004 (29) PTC 376 (IPAB) Kraft Jacobs Sucharc Ltd. v. Government of India by Secretary Ministry of Commerce and Industry, 2004 (28) PTC 404 (Bharat Hotels Limited…Plaintiff; v. Unison Hotels Limited…Defendant.. The appellant relied on (2001) 5 SCC 73 Cadila Health Care Ltd. v. Cadila Pharmaceuticals Ltd.. Ltd..

    7. We have considered the submissions and the materials on record. We find that in OA/41/200/TM/CH at Page 41 of the paper-book, even before TM 16 has been filed the certificate has been issued deleting the items “milk and milk products.” The order impugned refers to evidence produced by the applicants to show that they are the proprietors of the mark. The only documents that are produced by the respondents are advertisements which show the existence of a hotel, these are:

    a) one refers to “Nandhini Andhra Speciality Restaurants”

    b) is an advertisement in the Deccan Herald which refers to the “Nandhini - The Restaurant”

    c) refers to the pictoral depiction of the Restaurant Nandhini

    d) an advertisement dated 12.01.2000 “For the tastiest Andhra food in town”, dated 9.8.2002 “Home Delivery and Outdoor Catering” and so on.

    8. This evidence only shows that the respondents are running a restaurant which would come under class 42. We are not concerned with that. We must be shown that the respondents are dealing in goods in respect of which the trademarks have been registered. Therefore, the fact that the appellant did not raise any objection to their mark for 18 years has no relevance in this case. That will be dealt with as and when the registration in class 42 is taken up as the issue of controversy.

    9. Now we are concerned with whether the respondent can use the trademark for goods in classes 29 and 30. ‘Nandini’ may be a common name or even a Goddess’ name. But the word ‘Nandini’ and the mark ‘Nandini’ have been associated with the appellant from 1985 which is evidenced from the Copyright Certificate dated 25.02.1992 In fact the respondents themselves do not deny that the appellant has been in the business for more than two decades. It is the case of the respondenst that they also have their name in the business. But the respondent's business is running a hotel and there is not a scrap of evidence to show that they are trading in the goods in question. There is no doubt that if the goods under class 29 and 30 bearing the respondent's trade mark come out in the market the average consumer would conclude that it belongs to the Karnataka Cooperative Milk Producer's Federation. The word NANDINI has acquired distinctiveness. In fact even in the impugned order the finding is that the appellants are using the trade mark prior to respondent/applicant. When the appellants are using the trade mark prior to respondent in the same class of goods we do not understand how the registration of the respondent's mark can be permitted.

    10. In 2003(27) PTC 352 there was evidence to show that the mark W- WOODYS had been used on its products in the shop restaurant, on boxes and cartons and therefore the objection of woodlands Travels and Agencies was rejected.

    11. In 2004 (29) 376 PTC interim injunction was not granted since the plaintiff had failed to establish secondary meaning in respect of the word grand and there was material to show that the plaintiff was not the first user of the word grand in connection with their hotel business.

    12. In 2004 29 PTC the word was MILKA. There the competing marks were MILKA and PIONEERS MILKA written in a typical style.

    13. In 2007 34 PTC the registration of the impugned mark CITIZEN had continued for seven years and there was no evidence of confusion.

    14. So each case has to be decided on the basis of the facts on hand. With regard to the appellant's mark we find that one of the documents which is the Kannada Weekly Sudha where it is stated that “I am using NANDINI. You?” In Tharanga Kannada Weekly, “Nandini Ghee has a role in every moment of life Celebration” (translated from Kannada). These are pieces of evidence to show that the word Nandini itself has become associated with the appellant's products and therefore, though it might be a Hindu name, or even a deity's name, it has come to be recognized as a distinctive mark of the appellant by the appellant's use of the same for nearly two decades. The conclusion of the Registrar that it is not likely to confuse cannot be sustained. The word is identical. The addition of a letter H by the respondent cannot make a difference. Whether it is Nandini or Nandhini, it is pronounced identically. And in Kannada there is no difference in the spelling of the trademark of the appellant and that of the respondent.

    15. We have referred to the advertisement which says “I am using nandini”. It is clear that the consumer and the general public who are the source of the goods when the word nandini is used. When that is so, we cannot permit the respondent to use the identical mark in relation to goods which are akin to the appellants.

    16. The addition of the word Deluxe cannot improve the case of the respondent since the word NANDHINI is identical and it definitely will cause confusion in the minds of the consumers.

    17. The priority in use is indisputably the appellants. It has been so regularly and consistently used that the marks have become entrenched in the minds of the consumer. It will definitely not being in the interest of the public to allow the respondent to use the mark in connection with the goods in question. The balance of convenience is not in favour of the respondent.

    18. The Registrar's order does not stand the test of reasonableness and deserves to be set aside. Accordingly, the above appeals are allowed. The miscellaneous petitions stand disposed of. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Karnataka Cooperative Milk Producers Federation Limited v. N. Anand
    (Oct 4, 2011)