AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 149 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE 1908
  • Rule 986 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules, 1985.
  • Rule 986 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules, 1980. Rule 986
  • 4 11. Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC)
  • Rule 131 of the Bombay High Court (Original Side) Rules.
  • Rule 986 of Bombay High Court Original Side Rules.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 149 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE 1908
  • Rule 986 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules, 1985.
  • Rule 986 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules, 1980. Rule 986
  • 4 11. Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC)
  • Rule 131 of the Bombay High Court (Original Side) Rules.
  • Rule 986 of Bombay High Court Original Side Rules.
Smart Summary

Court Opinion Summary — High Court of Judicature at Bombay (S. J. Kathawalla, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff, Uday Singh Deshraj Rajput, filed Suit (L) No. 967 of 2013 on 11 November 2013 seeking a declaration that he was the owner of the script and screenplay of the film Krrish-3 and that the Defendants were not entitled to use that script or screenplay. At presentation of the plaint the Plaintiff had not paid the requisite court fees. The Plaintiff's advocate made an endorsement on the docket (dated 26 October 2013) explaining urgency because the Plaintiff resided in a remote village and the film's release was imminent.

The Prothonotary and Senior Master endorsed a grant of two weeks' time to pay court fees (endorsement dated 25 October 2013). On 29 October 2013 the Plaintiff moved an application for urgent ad-interim relief to restrain the release of Krrish-3 on 1 November 2013; that application was rejected by the Court on 29 October 2013.

On 7 March 2014, when the suit was called for directions, no one appeared for the Plaintiff and the suit was dismissed for want of prosecution. The Court later noticed that the plaintiff had not paid the required court fee and had pursued an urgent interim application before abandoning the suit.

On 24 June 2015 the Court ordered the Plaintiff's advocate, Ms. Rekha K. Mehta, to appear on 1 July 2015. She failed to appear and the matter was adjourned with directions for personal service. On 29 July 2015 Ms. Mehta appeared and undertook to collect and deposit a deficit court fee of Rs.2,50,000/- within two weeks. When the advocate could not secure the plaintiff's cooperation, a bailable warrant for Rs.15,000/- was issued against the Plaintiff returnable 31 August 2015.

The Plaintiff was produced in Court on 31 August 2015 and gave an undertaking to pay the outstanding Rs.2,50,000/- in five instalments of Rs.50,000/-, with specified dates (first instalment by 3.00 p.m. on that day, and the remaining on 30-09-2015, 31-10-2015, 30-11-2015 and 23-12-2015). The Plaintiff paid the first four instalments but failed to pay the fifth instalment due 23 December 2015 and did not seek further time. The Court ordered a fresh bailable warrant of Rs.15,000/- to be issued returnable 22 February 2016, and directed transmission of the warrant to the relevant police authorities.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the office of the Prothonotary and Senior Master can, in practice, grant time for payment of admitted court fees at the time of presentation of a plaint (i.e., whether the Prothonotary may exercise the power under Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908).
  2. Whether Rule 986 of the Bombay High Court (Original Side) Rules applies to non-payment of admitted court fees at the time of presentation, or whether non-payment of such admitted fees must be addressed exclusively by the Court under Section 149 CPC.
  3. Whether the routine practice by the Prothonotary & Senior Master of accepting undertakings to pay court fees later (without a judicial order) is lawful and should be continued.

Arguments of the Parties

Prothonotary & Senior Master's Position (as reported)

  • The Prothonotary informed the Court that he had been granting time to parties to pay court fees in the initial stage in exercise of his power under Rule 986 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules, 1980 (reproduced in the judgment).

Advocate / Plaintiff-related Statements

  • Ms. Rekha K. Mehta, Advocate for the Plaintiff, undertook in Court on 29 July 2015 to collect the deficit court fee of Rs.2,50,000/- from the Plaintiff and to deposit it with the Prothonotary and Senior Master within two weeks; the undertaking was accepted by the Court.
  • Ms. Mehta later informed the Court that the Plaintiff was avoiding her calls and was not cooperating to pay the requisite court fee.
  • The Plaintiff later undertook in Court on 31 August 2015 to pay the deficit in five instalments, and subsequently paid four instalments but not the fifth.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Buta Singh (Dead) by L.Rs vs. Union of India, (1 995) 5 SCC 284 Held that the discretion conferred on the Court by Section 149 CPC is a judicial discretion and that the aid of Section 149 is to be taken only when the party was unable to pay court fee in circumstances beyond his control; court should give due notice to affected parties when exercising discretion under Section 149. The Court relied on this authority to conclude that the power under Section 149 is judicial in nature and therefore cannot be exercised by the Prothonotary & Senior Master; only the Court/Judge concerned can exercise that discretion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in these steps, confined to the materials and reasoning contained in the opinion:

  1. Statutory text and scope: The Court reproduced Section 149 CPC which empowers "the Court" in its discretion to allow a person to make up deficiency of court-fees and give the document the same force as if the fee had been paid initially.
  2. Observed administrative practice: The Court described a commonplace practice where Advocates, immediately upon filing a plaint, approach the Prothonotary and Senior Master orally seeking extension of time to pay court fees, and the Prothonotary habitually grants time on an undertaking by the Advocate without inquiring into reasons for non-payment and without a system to follow up compliance.
  3. Identified abuse and consequences: The Court noted that dishonest plaintiffs exploit this practice by filing suits and seeking urgent interim reliefs; if those interim remedies fail or if plaintiffs change their minds, they simply allow suits to be dismissed for non-removal of office objections, thereby avoiding payment and bypassing the intended threshold requirement of paying admitted court fees at presentation.
  4. Meaning of "Court" under Section 149: The Court concluded the word "Court" in Section 149 does not include the Prothonotary and Senior Master. The matters that the Prothonotary may dispose of are prescribed by Rule 131 (Original Side Rules), and except where Chamber Judge powers are expressly delegated, the Prothonotary cannot exercise judicial powers that belong to the Court/Judge.
  5. Reliance on precedent: The Court cited the Supreme Court decision in Buta Singh to underline that the discretion under Section 149 is judicial and must be exercised by the Court after appropriate consideration, not by the Prothonotary as a routine administrative measure.
  6. Rule 986 and its proper application: The Court reproduced Rule 986 (relating to rejection of plaints and other documents for non-removal of office objections within 30 days) and examined the Prothonotary's assertion that he acted under Rule 986. The Court held that Rule 986 cannot be read as authorizing the Prothonotary to accept undertakings to pay admitted court fees later at the time of presentation. If a party pays fees according to schedule but an officer raises an additional objection, Rule 986 gives 30 days to remove that objection. However, where the party is unable to pay the admitted amount of court fees at presentation, Rule 986 is not applicable and the proper remedy is to approach the Court under Section 149.
  7. Conclusion on delegation and authority: The Court reasoned that the judicial power to grant time under Section 149 cannot be delegated to the Prothonotary without express rule-making authority; therefore the Prothonotary's routine practice of accepting undertakings for later payment is without authority of law.
  8. Case-specific enforcement actions: On the facts, because the plaintiff failed to comply with the undertaking (did not pay the final instalment), the Court ordered issuance of a bailable warrant for Rs.15,000/- returnable 22 February 2016 and directed the Prothonotary to forward the warrant to the relevant police authorities for execution and return.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that the power under Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 to make up deficiency of court-fees is a judicial power exercisable only by the Court/Judge concerned and cannot be exercised by the Prothonotary & Senior Master. The practice of the Prothonotary & Senior Master routinely granting time to pay admitted court fees on the basis of undertakings is without authority of law and must be discontinued.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on parties and court office: The Prothonotary & Senior Master shall stop the routine practice of accepting undertakings for later payment of admitted court fees; parties who are unable to pay admitted court fees at presentation must seek relief through the Court under Section 149 CPC.
  • Clarification of Rule 986: The Court clarified that Rule 986 applies to removal of office objections where an objection is raised by the office as to valuation or additional fees, giving 30 days to remove or challenge such objections; but Rule 986 does not apply to cases where a party simply does not pay the admitted court fee at the threshhold — in such circumstances Section 149 is the exclusive provision to be invoked.
  • Enforcement in the present case: The immediate consequence for the Plaintiff in this case is the issuance of a bailable warrant (Rs.15,000/-) returnable 22 February 2016, to be sent to police authorities for execution.
  • Precedential scope: The judgment construes the proper allocation of judicial power under Section 149 and directs administrative change in practice; the Court's decision corrects an unauthorized administrative practice but does not purport to create any rule beyond the legal conclusions expressly stated in the opinion.

(S. J. KATHAWALLA, J.)

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Uday Singh Deshraj Rajput v. Film Craft Production (India) Pvt. Ltd.

    KPPNAIR 1 / 10 SL-967-2013

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION

    SUIT (L) NO. 967 OF 2013

    Uday Singh Deshraj Rajput … Plaintiff Versus

    Film Craft Production (India) Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. … Defendants None for the parties.

    CORAM : S. J. KATHAWALLA, J.

    DATED : 27TH JANUARY, 2016

    ORAL JUDGMENT:

    1. The above Suit was filed by the Plaintiff on 11thNovember, 2013 through his Advocate Ms. Rekha K. Mehta for a declaration that he is the owner of the script and screen play of the film Krrish-3 and that the Defendants are not entitled to use the said script and the screen play for their film Krrish-3 or for any other film.

    2. At the time of the filing of the above Suit, the Plaintiff had not paid the requisite Court fees. Instead the Advocate for the Plaintiff on 26thOctober, 2013 made an endorsement on the docket of the Plaint that "The Plaintiff is residing in remote village in Madhya Pradesh. The Plaintiff is urgently required to file the Suit otherwise his claim would be prejudiced. The film would be released in few days."

    1

    In response, the Prothonotary and Senior Master endorsed : "without prejudice granted two weeks time to the Plaintiff to pay the Court fee." Interestingly, the endorsement of the Prothonotary and Senior Master is dated 25thOctober, 2013 . Again why the Prothonotary used the words "without prejudice ... ... " is difficult to comprehend.

    3. Thereafter on 29thOctober, 2013 the Plaintiff through his Advocate moved an Application before this Court seeking urgent ad-interim relief restraining the Defendants from releasing the film Krrish-3 on 1stNovember, 2013. By its reasoned Order dated 29thOctober, 2013, this Court rejected the Plaintiff's Application to restrain the release of the film Krrish-3.

    4. On 7thMarch, 2014 when the Suit was called out for directions, none appeared for the Plaintiff in Suit (L) No. 967 of 2013. In view thereof, the Suit was dismissed for want of prosecution.

    5. After almost a year, my attention was drawn by one of the diligent staff members to the fact that the Plaintiff has, without paying Court fee moved this Court for urgent ad-interim reliefs, and being unsuccessful in obtaining the same, has allowed the Suit to get dismissed and has not paid the requisite Court fee till date. Therefore, on 24thJune, 2015, this Court passed the following order:

    "Ms. Rekha K. Mehta, Advocate for the Plaintiff having her office at B/4, Bhujbal Niwas, Opposite Bharat Cooperative Bank, J.N.

    2

    Road, Mulund (West), Mumbai - 400080 is directed to remain present before this Court on 1stJuly, 2015 at 11.00 a.m. Office to serve a copy of this order on Ms. Mehta by hand delivery."

    6. Though the Notice was received by the representative of Ms. Rekha K. Mehta, Advocate, she failed to appear before this Court on 1 stJuly, 2015. The matter was therefore adjourned to 28thJuly, 2015 with a direction to serve a copy of the order dated 1stJuly, 2015 on Ms. Rekha K. Mehta, Advocate personally through the Senior Inspector of Police of the concerned local police station.

    7. On 29thJuly, 2015, Ms. Rekha K. Mehta, Advocate for the Plaintiff appeared before this Court, when the following order was passed :

    "The learned Advocate for the Plaintiff undertakes that she will collect the deficit court fee of Rs.2,50,000/- from the Plaintiff and deposit the same with the Prothonotary and Senior Master of this Court within a period of two weeks from today. The undertaking is accepted. Stand over to 12thAugust, 2015."

    8. Ms. Rekha K. Mehta, Advocate for the Plaintiff, thereafter repeatedly sought time to contact the Plaintiff as well as the Advocate at whose instance she had accepted the brief of the Plaintiff. Ms. Mehta ultimately informed the Court that the Plaintiff is avoiding her calls and not coming forward to pay the requisite Court fee. In view thereof, a bailable warrant in the sum of Rs.15,000/- was issued against the

    3

    Plaintiff. The said warrant was made returnable on 31stAugust, 2015.

    9. On 31stAugust, 2015 the Plaintiff was produced before this Court by the police officials from Madhya Pradesh. On that day, the following order was passed :

    "1. Pursuant to the bailable warrant issued against the Plaintiff, he is today present in Court. The Plaintiff undertakes to pay the balance court fees of Rs.2,50,000/- as follows :

    Rs.50,000/- By 3.00 p.m. today

    Rs.50,000/- on or before 30-09-2015

    Rs.50,000/- on or before 31-10-2015

    Rs.50,000/- on or before 30-11-2015

    Rs.50,000/- on or before 23-12-2015

    The undertaking is accepted.

    2. ... ... ... ... "

    10. The Plaintiff thereafter paid the first four installments but failed and neglected to pay the 5thinstallment. The Plaintiff has not bothered to appear before the Court and seek further time / extension to comply with the undertaking given by him and accepted by this Court. In view thereof, a bailable warrant in the sum of Rs. 15,000/- be issued against the Plaintiff - Uday Singh Deshraj Rajput made returnable on 22nd February, 2016 at 3.00 p.m. The Prothonotary and Senior Master shall forward the said bailable warrant to the concerned Commissioner of Police / Superintendent of Police, Madhya Pradesh, by speed post with a direction to the said authority to execute the said bailable warrant and return the executed warrant to this Court, before the returnable date.

    4

    11. Section 149 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) empowers the Court in its discretion to allow a person to make up deficiency of court fees as decided by the Court. Section 149 of the CPC is reproduced hereunder:

    "149. Power to make up deficiency of Court-fees.— Where the whole or any part of any fee prescribed for any document by the law for the time being in force relating to Court- fees has not been paid, the Court may, in its discretion, at any stage, allow the person, by whom such fee is payable, to pay the whole or part, as the case may be, of such Court-fee; and upon such payment the document, in respect of which such fee is payable, shall have the same force and effect as if such fee had been paid in the first instance."

    12. Lately, this Court has observed that very often Advocates on record immediately upon filing suits approach the Prothonotary and Senior Master and orally request for extension of time to pay the Court fees. The Prothonotary and Senior Master in each and every case, i.e. without any exception, when first such oral request is made, unconditionally grants time to pay the court fees on an undertaking from the Advocate to pay the same at a later date, without even ascertaining as to why the Court fees are not paid upon presentment of the Plaint. Again after accepting the undertaking and granting time to a party to pay the court fees at a later date, the office of the Prothonotary and Senior Master has not evolved any system to follow up whether the undertaking given is complied with or not. It is only when the suit appears on the Board of the Prothonotary and Senior Master in

    5

    normal course for rejection on the ground of non-removal of objections that the Prothonotary and Senior Master realises that the undertaking accepted by him has been breached and in fact a substantial period has lapsed thereafter. Interestingly, the Prothonotary and Senior Master once again grants time (this time without an undertaking) to remove office objections within a stipulated period (including objection as regards non-payment of court fees) failing which the suit is to stand automatically dismissed. The suit thereafter would stand dismissed for non-removal of office objections.

    13. In view thereof, as has happened in the present case, many dishonest Plaintiffs in the meantime apply for urgent ad-interim reliefs and upon the same being refused, abandon the suits and allow them to be dismissed for non-removal of office objections including objections concerning non-payment of court fees.

    14. In my view, the word "Court" used in Section 149 of the CPC would not include the Prothonotary and Senior Master. The matters which are permitted to be disposed of by the Prothonotary and Senior Master are provided for by Rule 131 of the Bombay High Court (Original Side) Rules. Except these matters, where there is a delegation of the Chamber Judge's powers to the Prothonotary and Senior Master, the Prothonotary and Senior Master cannot exercise powers of the Court / Chamber Judge / Judge concerned. The order to be passed by the Court under Section 149 is a judicial order, to be passed after exercise of a judicial discretion. The Hon'ble

    6

    Supreme Court in the case of Buta Singh (Dead) by L.Rs vs. Union of India1 considered the power of the Court under Section 149 and held that "the discretion conferred on the Court by Section 149 is a judicial discretion" and observed further as follows:

    "The aid of Section 149 could be taken only when the party was not able to pay court fee in circumstances beyond his control or under unavoidable circumstances and the court would be justified in an appropriate case to exercise the discretionary power under s. 149, after giving due notice to the affected party."

    There is, thus, no question of the Prothonotary & Senior Master passing any order under Section 149.

    15. Even otherwise, without ascertaining the reason/s for non payment of court fees along with the presentation of plaint, the Plaintiff could not as a matter of course be granted time to pay court fees at a later date. The Prothonotary appears to be passing such orders almost as a matter of routine. It is because of such a practice being followed by the Prothonotary and Senior Master, and in the absence of any follow up mechanism, that dishonest Plaintiffs take full advantage of the situation, and after unsuccessfully applying for urgent ad-interim reliefs, or after a change of mind qua pursuing the Suit, abandon the suit and allow the same to be dismissed.

    16. On being questioned by this Court as to under which provision of law the

    1 (1 995) 5 SCC 284

    7

    Prothonotary and Senior Master, immediately upon filing of a Suit, without any written application and without ascertaining the reason for non-payment of admitted Court fee at the time of presentation of a Suit, grants time to the Plaintiffs / Petitioners to pay Court fees at a later date, the Prothonotary has informed me that he is doing so in exercise of his power under Rule 986 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules, 1980. Rule 986 is reproduced hereunder :

    "R.986. Rejection of plaint, memo of appeal, execution application and applications and petit ion of original nature for non-removal of office objections .—Every plaint, memo of appeal, application for execution and all other applications and petitions of the original nature, including the petition by an indigent person, in which the

    Plaintiff/Appellant/Applicant/Petitioner does not remove the office objections within 30 days from the date of lodging the said documents, shall be placed before the Prothonotary and Senior Master for directions, who may reject such documents for non- removal of office objections. Rule 133 of these rules will apply to such rejection."

    If this explanation is correct, there is no apparent reason why the Prothonotary is taking an undertaking from the Plaintiff and / or his / her Advocate to pay the Court fees within two weeks when the parties and / or their Advocates approach him immediately upon filing of the Suit, seeking extension of time to pay the Court fees. If Rule 986 is applicable to the case of non-payment of Court fees admittedly payable, every Plaintiff would be at liberty not to pay the Court fees at the time of presentment of the Plaint, allow the office to raise an objection qua non payment of

    8

    the admitted Court fees and thus automatically get 30 days' time to 'remove the said objection', i.e., to pay the admitted Court fees. That would be an absurdity. Office objections referred to in Rule 986 do not include an objection pertaining to non- payment of admitted Court fees which are required to be paid at the threshhold, i.e., at the time of presentation of the Plaint, and that in case of non-payment of such admitted Court fees the only provision which can be invoked is Section 149 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908, reproduced hereinabove, which empowers the Court in its discretion to extend time for payment of unpaid Court fees.

    17. It is also necessary to clarify that if a party or its Advocate values the Suit by following the prescribed schedule of fees and pays Court fees accordingly, but the officer of the Court, who scrutinizes the Plaint, is of the view that the Suit is valued on an incorrect provision, and an additional sum is found to be payable towards Court fees, then the party and / or his Advocate would have 30 days' time to remove or challenge such objection failing which the Plaint may be rejected under Rule 986 of Bombay High Court Original Side Rules. However, at the cost of repetition, it is made clear that when a party and/or his/her Advocate for any reason is unable to pay the admitted amount of Court fees payable along with the Plaint, Rule 986 will have no application in such circumstances, and the only remedy for such party and/or his/her Advocate is to approach the Court under Section 149 of the Code for appropriate orders.

    18. The power under Section 149 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 to make

    9

    up deficiency of Court fees cannot be exercised by the Prothonotary and Senior Master. The Prothonotary also has no power to allow parties and/or their Advocates to pay the admitted Court fees or any part thereof at a later date under Rule 986 of the Bombay High Court Original Side Rules, 1985. The power to use discretion and granting time under Section 149 of the CPC can only be exercised by the Court/Judge concerned. The order under Section 149 is, as the words "in its discretion" make clear, a judicial power, i.e., a power vested in Court. As already held, the expression "Court" does not include the office of the Prothonotary. Such a power cannot be delegated without an express Rule framed in accordance with law. This power cannot simply be assumed by the Prothonotary.

    19. The practice, therefore, of the Prothonotary & Senior Master granting time to the Plaintiffs and their Advocates to present suits on an undertaking that they shall pay admitted court fees subsequently is without the authority of law and shall therefore immediately be discontinued.

    ( S. J. KATHAWALLA, J. )

    10

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Uday Singh Deshraj Rajput v. Film Craft Production (India) Pvt. Ltd.
    (Jan 27, 2016)