AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges

    Tej Ram And Others (Auction-Purchasers) v. Harsukh (Judgment-Debtor).

    [103] It is not contended that an appeal lies to this Court from the order of the Judge, or that under the Code of Civil Procedure this Court has any power of interference. It is argued that the Court is authorized to exercise jurisdiction in the matter in virtue of the provisions of 24 and 25 Vic, c. 104, S. 15. These provisions have frequently been urged as justifying the interference of this Court with orders of a Subordinate Court, on the grounds that the orders of the Subordinate Court has proceeded on an error of fact or law, and that no further appeal is given by the Code, and so far as we are aware the Court has uniformly declined jurisdiction.

    The provisions of S. 9 of the Statute above-mentioned declare that High Courts established under the Act shall have and exercise all such civil, Ac, jurisdiction, &c., and all such powers and authority for, and in relation to, the administration of justice, etc., as Her Majesty may by Letters Patent grant and direct, and that save as by such Letters Patent may be otherwise directed, and subject and without prejudice to the legislative powers in relation to the matters aforesaid of the Governor-General of India in Council, the High Court to be established in each Presidency shall have and exercise all jurisdiction and every power and authority whatsoever in any manner vested in any of the Courts in the same Presidency abolished under the Act at the time of the abolition of such last-mentioned Court.

    By the Letters Patent of this Court Her Majesty was pleased to confer on it extraordinary original civil jurisdiction and appellate civil jurisdiction, but she conferred on it no powers of revision in civil suits or matters arising there out. In these matters the Court has no other power or authority than that enjoyed by the Sudder Dewany Adawlut of these Provinces at the time of its abolition unless such power is derived from the 15th section of the Statute. The Sudder Dewany Adawlut certainly had no power to exercise judicial functions in any case in which its rights of interference was not declared by the law of India, and no provision of any Indian Act is cited as conferring on the Sudder Dewany Adawlut authority to interfere on an application of the nature of that which is now preferred to the Court.

    The petitioners then can rely only on the provisions of 24 and 25 Vic, c. 105, S. 15, which declare that the High Courts established under the Act shall have “superintendence” over all Courts [104] which may be subject toits appellate jurisdiction, and consequently it is contended that the term superintendence confers jurisdiction to revise proceedings of the Subordinate Civil Courts.

    We cannot allow this contention. Whether we consider the ordinary significance of the term or construe it in connection with the context, it appears to us to confer on the High Court no revisional power, no power to interfere with or set aside the judicial proceedings of a Subordinate Court, but that it confers on the High Court administrative authority and not judicial powers; as we construe the term, it would be competent to the High Court in the exercise of its power of superintendence to direct a Subordinate Court to do its duty or to abstain from taking action in [105] matters of which it has not cognizance, but the High Court is not competent in the exercise of this authority to interfere and set right the orders of a subordinate Court on the ground that the order of the Subordinate Court had proceeded on an error of law or an error of fact. It is true that some cases may be found in the reported decisions of other High Courts, in which it appears that Judges have claimed in virtue of the right of superintendence given them by the Statute to exercise larger powers than we believe are conferred by the provisions of that law, but the practice of this Court has accorded with the views expressed by us, and on the construction we put on the Statute we are not at liberty to disturb it.

    The record will be returned to the Bench with this expression of our opinion.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tej Ram And Others (Auction-Purchasers) v. Harsukh (Judgment-Debtor).
    (Aug 10, 1875)