Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act.16. Article 97 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963
  • article 97 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act,
  • SECTION 22 HINDU SUCCESSION ACT 1956
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act.16. Article 97 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963
  • article 97 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act,
  • SECTION 22 HINDU SUCCESSION ACT 1956
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs appealed against the judgment and decree dated 30.6.2001 of the District Judge, Karimganj, which had dismissed their Title Appeal No. 2/1999 and upheld the trial court's judgment and decree dated 27.9.1999 in Title Suit No. 35/1984 by which the plaintiffs' suit was dismissed.

The plaintiffs originally sued for a declaration that certain land (settlement survey Dag Nos. 5247, 5248 and 5249, Taluk Nos. 14886/197 and 14779/90 in Karimganj) was joint family property of the plaintiffs; for declaration that three registered gift deeds dated 11.2.1983 (Ext. A), 11.2.1983 (Ext. B) and 15.6.1983 (Ext. C) executed by Ramesh Chandra Banik in favour of defendant Nos. 1–3 were fake, fraudulent and inoperative; for recovery of khas possession of a specified area; and for confirmation of the plaintiffs' 1/5th share in the remaining suit land.

The plaintiffs alleged that their father, Radha Ballav Banik, purchased the property by two sale deeds dated 11.11.1938 (Exts. 1 and 2). After his death in 1944 the property devolved on his five sons (the three plaintiffs, Ramesh Chandra Banik — husband of defendant No. 3 — and another brother who was pro forma defendant No. 7). Ramesh Chandra Banik, who acted as Karta, purportedly executed three gift deeds in 1983 transferring portions of the land in favour of the original defendants.

During trial the plaintiffs amended their plaint on 26.11.1987 to add a claim for preferential right to purchase under section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. The defendants filed a joint written statement admitting that the suit land belonged to Radha Ballav Banik but pleading that the land fell into the separate share of Ramesh Chandra Banik as a result of an amicable partition and that Ramesh had gifted his share by registered gift deeds (Exts. A, B and C).

The trial court framed issues (including whether the gift deeds were collusive/inoperative and whether the plaintiffs were entitled to the reliefs claimed). The trial court answered issues of cause of action and valuation in favour of the plaintiffs but decided the issues on the validity of the gift deeds and entitlement against the plaintiffs, resulting in dismissal of the suit. On appeal the District Judge affirmed the trial court's decision. The plaintiffs then filed the present second appeal, which was admitted on substantial questions of law.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether occupation of separate shop room by the coparceners raises a legally permissible presumption (as drawn by the courts below) that there was an amicable partition although the fact of partition delineating and specifying shares of coparceners was not otherwise proved?
  2. Whether the plaintiffs/appellants have a preferential right under section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, in the event it is found that the property left by Radha Ballav Banik was amicably partitioned and the portion covered by the gift deeds fell into the share of Ramesh Chandra Banik?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (Plaintiffs') Arguments

  • The written statement of the defendants admits that the suit property originally belonged to Radha Ballav Banik and devolved on his five sons, so in absence of proof of an amicable partition each heir (including the plaintiffs) would inherit a 1/5th share.
  • Ramesh Chandra Banik, as a coparcener and eldest son, could not validly transfer by gift the property that was undivided family property; the gift deeds executed by him (Exts. A, B and C) could not convey right, title or interest in the absence of a partition.
  • Even if there had been an amicable partition and the suit land fell into Ramesh's share, the plaintiffs would have a preferential right of purchase under section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act prior to transfer to outsiders (the original defendants).
  • The courts below wrongly relied on evidence of partition of family business rather than partition of the landed property.

Respondents' (Defendants' Heirs') Arguments

  • Both courts below recorded a concurrent finding of fact that the property left by Radha Ballav Banik was amicably partitioned among the five brothers, and there is no perversity in that concurrent finding so it should not be disturbed on second appeal.
  • PW1 (plaintiff No.1) admitted in cross-examination that all five brothers had been living separately for about ten years on their respective lands, had partitioned the family business and were doing business in different shop rooms, which supports the finding of amicable partition.
  • Evidence and the pleaded position show that Radha Ballav Banik had other lands (total 1 powa 1 jasti 5 pon = 32.25 rekh) besides the suit land; the small size of the suit land (about 8 rekh) and silence as to the remaining land support the defendants' case of division of property.
  • On the preferential right claim under section 22, the respondents contended that article 97 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act prescribes a one-year limitation period to enforce a right of pre-emption; possession by the donees immediately after the gift deeds and the plaintiffs' knowledge date (22.8.1984) mean the section 22 claim, introduced by amendment on 26.11.1987, is time-barred.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the pleadings, documentary and oral evidence considered by the courts below to determine whether there was perversity in the concurrent factual finding that the property was amicably partitioned among the five brothers.

Key evidentiary points relied upon by the courts below and reviewed by this court included:

  • The written statement admitted the suit land belonged to Radha Ballav Banik but pleaded amicable partition resulting in a separate share for Ramesh Chandra Banik.
  • PW1's cross-examination admission that the five brothers were living separately on different lands by constructing houses thereon and had partitioned the family business and were conducting business separately in different shop rooms.
  • The plaintiffs' own pleadings and evidence that Radha Ballav Banik purchased, by Exts. 1 and 2 (sale deeds dated 11.11.1938), a total of 1 powa 1 jasti 5 pon (32.25 rekh) of land spread over four Taluks, whereas the suit land was only about 8 rekh — a small part of the total estate — and the plaintiffs were silent about the remaining land.

On these bases the court concluded there was adequate evidentiary foundation for the concurrent finding of amicable partition by the trial and first appellate courts. The court rejected the appellants' contention that the admissions about separate living might relate to lands other than the inherited property because there was no pleading that the plaintiffs had other self-acquired lands; moreover, PW1 had given evidence claiming they lived on the suit property jointly, and the plaintiffs had not disclosed the existence of alternative self-acquired lands.

Concerning the second substantial question (preferential right under section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act), the court analysed limitation law. It cited article 97 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963 (limitation for enforcement of right of pre-emption is one year from the date when the purchaser takes physical possession or, if physical possession is not possible, when the instrument is registered).

The court noted the admitted factual position that the original donees (defendant Nos. 1–3) were in possession of the property immediately after execution of the gift deeds (11.2.1983 and 15.6.1983), and that the plaintiffs pleaded they learned of the gifts on 22.8.1984. The plaintiffs, however, only introduced a claim under section 22 by amendment on 26.11.1987 — more than one year even from the date of knowledge. On this basis the court held the claim under section 22 (a species of pre-emption) was barred by limitation under article 97.

Having answered the first substantial question in favour of the respondents (upholding the finding of amicable partition) and the second substantial question by holding the section 22 claim time-barred, the court found no merit in the appeal.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

Holding (direct outcome):

  • The appeal by the plaintiffs is dismissed and the judgments and decrees of the trial court and the District Judge, Karimganj (which had dismissed the plaintiffs' suit and upheld the trial court) are affirmed.
  • The court answered the two substantial questions of law as follows: (1) the courts below rightly found an amicable partition of the property among the five brothers based on the evidence; (2) the plaintiffs' claim under section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act is barred by limitation (article 97 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act) because the section 22 claim was introduced by amendment after the one-year limitation period.
  • No costs were awarded; the Registry was directed to send down the records.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the plaintiffs' suit remains dismissed and the defendants (through their heirs) retain the rights established by the gift deeds as upheld by the courts below subject to the factual findings on partition.
  • The court did not set out or rely upon any new judicial precedent in this opinion; the decision rests on concurrent findings of fact and an application of the Limitation Act (article 97) to the plaintiffs' amended pre-emption claim under section 22. The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal principle beyond applying these facts to existing statutory provisions.

This summary is based exclusively on information contained in the provided opinion and does not include information beyond that text.

    Gourish Banik And Ors. v. Arati Banik And Ors.

    1. This appeal by the plaintiffs is directed against the judgment and decree dated 30.6.2001 passed by the learned District Judge, Karimganj in Title Appeal No. 2/1999, dismissing the appeal by upholding the judgment and decree dated 27.9.1999 passed in Title Suit No. 35/1984 by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Karimganj, whereby and whereunder the plaintiffs' suit was dismissed.

    2. The plaintiffs instituted the aforesaid suit prayed for declaration that the land covered by settlement survey Dag Nos. 5247, 5248 and 5249, Decennial Mahal Taluk Aladal Taluk No. 14886/197 and Afzal Taluk No. 14779/90 in Karimganj Town, in the District and PS-Karimganj, with the boundary given in the schedule to the plaint, as joint family properties of the plaintiffs; for declaration that three gift deeds dated 11.2.1983 (Ext. A), 11.2.1983 (Ext. B) and 15.6.1983 (Ext. C), executed by Ramesh Chandra Banik in favour of Sambhu Nath Banik, Sushil Kumar Banik and Renu Bala Banik, the defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3, respectively, are fake, fraudulent and inoperative and also for recovery of khas possession of the land measuring 21¼ cubits × 4 ¼ cubits as mentioned in the said schedule, upon eviction of the defendants and also for confirmation of possession in respect of the remaining land of their, being 1/5th share of the suit land. It was contended in the plaint that Radha Ballav Banik, the father of the plaintiffs and pro forma defendant No. 7 and father-in-law of the defendant No. 3, purchased the suit land by Exts. 1 and 2 sale deeds, both dated 11.11.1938, which property, after the death of their father in the year 1944 devolved on them and was looked after by the eldest son, namely, Ramesh Chandra Banik, husband of the defendant No. 3 being the Karta, who, however, before his death in the year 1983 executed the aforesaid three gift deeds (Exts. A, B and C in favour of the defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3, respectively), though the plaintiffs are entitled to their share over the suit land, the same being the ancestral property. In the plaint it has been contended that the plaintiffs could know about the execution of the said registered deeds of gift on 22.8.1984 During pendency of the suit the plaintiffs filed application seeking amendment of the pleadings in the plaint, which was allowed vide order dated 26.11.1987 By such amendment the prayer for the declaration that the plaintiffs have preferential right to purchase, as envisaged by section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the property which was transferred by way of the aforesaid gift deeds. The defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3 have filed their joint written statement. In the written statement, though they have denied the contention of the plaintiffs that the suit property was the self acquired property of Radha Ballav Banik, their predecessor-in-interest, in paragraph 13 the defendants, however, have admitted that the suit land belonged to Radha Ballav Banik, their predecessor-in-interest. The defendants further have pleaded that the suit land, however, fell in the share of Ramesh Chandra Banik, the eldest son of Radha Ballav Banik, by virtue of amicable partition and thereafter Ramesh Chandra Banik gifted the suit land in favour of the defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3 by executing the registered deeds of gift being Exts. A, B and C.

    3. On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned Civil Judge framed the following issues for determination:—

    (i) Has the plaintiff any cause of action for the suit?

    (ii) Is the suit property valued and stamped?

    (iii) Whether the three deeds of gift dated 11.2.1983 executed by Ramesh Chandra Banik in favour of defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3, are collusive, inoperative and void?

    (iv) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get a decree as claimed?

    Additional Issue

    (v) Whether the plaintiffs have preferential right under section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956?

    4. While the plaintiffs examined two witnesses and proved 16 documents, the defendants have also examined two witnesses and also proved certain documents. The trial court upon appreciation of the evidences on record answered the issue Nos. (i) and (ii) in favour of the plaintiffs but dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs as issue Nos. (iii) and (iv) were decided against them. During pendency of the suit, the defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3, namely, Sushil Kumar Banik, Sambhu Nath Banik and Renubala Banik died and their heirs were brought on record.

    5. Being aggrieved the plaintiffs preferred Title Appeal No. 2/1999 in the court of the learned District Judge at Karimganj, which has been dismissed vide judgment and decree dated 30.6.2001, affirming the judgment and decree passed by the trial court. Hence, the present appeal by the plaintiffs.

    6. This appeal was admitted for hearing vide order dated 7.12.2001 on the following substantial question of law:

    Whether occupation of separate shop room by the Coparceners raises a legally permissible presumption as drawn by the learned courts below that there was partition although factum of partition of the property delineating and specifying share of coparceners were not proved?

    During the course of hearing of the appeal on the aforesaid substantial question of law as formulated, based on the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the parties, this court yesterday, i.e, on 26.11.2012 framed the following substantial question of law:—

    Whether the plaintiffs/appellants have preferential right under section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, in case, it is found that the property left behind by Radha Ballav Banik was amicably partitioned and the same covered by Exhibits A, B and C gift deeds fell in the share of Ramesh Ch. Banik?

    The appeal, therefore, as agreed to by the learned counsel for the appearing parties, has been heard on the aforesaid two substantial questions of law.

    7. I have heard Mr. G.N Sahewalla, learned senior counsel for the appellants/plaintiffs and Mr. N. Choudhury, learned counsel appearing for the principal respondents, who are the heirs of original defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3.

    8. It has been contended by Mr. Sahewalla, learned senior counsel for the appellants that it is evident from the pleadings in the written statement filed by the defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3 that they have admitted the plaintiffs' case that the suit property originally belonged to their predecessor-in-interest, namely, Radha Ballav Banik and, hence-after the death of Radha Ballav Banik the property devolved on three plaintiffs, apart from the husband of the defendant No. 3 and the pro forma defendant No. 7, they being all brothers. The learned Sr. counsel, therefore, submits that in the absence of any proof relating to the amicable partition of the property amongst the brothers, as pleaded by the defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3 in the written statement, each of the brothers would inherit 1/5th share of the suit property. The learned Sr. counsel submits that Ramesh Chandra Banik, the eldest brother, who is the husband of defendant No. 3, during his lifetime and just before his death has transferred 360 cubits of land, which is equivalent to 1 jasti 4 rekh (approx.), which is again equivalent to 8 rekh, in favour of the defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3 by executing three gift deeds being Exts. A, B and C, which Ramesh could not have done there being no partition of the joint family property, as each of the heirs would have the right, title and interest in every inch of the undivided property. The learned Sr. counsel, therefore, submits that the gift deeds executed by Ramesh Ch. Banik cannot confer any right, title and interest on the predecessor-in-interest of the principal respondents, namely, the original defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3, the inherited land having not been partitioned. Mr. Sahewalla further submits that even if there was an amicable partition of the land originally belonged to Radha Ballav Banik, the predecessor-in-interest of the plaintiffs and the defendant No. 3 and pro forma defendant No. 7, the plaintiffs being the heirs, in view of section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, they have the preferential right of purchase, before Ramesh Ch. Banik transferred the right over the property in favour of an outsider, namely, the original defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3. The learned Sr. counsel, therefore, submits that the substantial questions of law may accordingly be answered by setting aside the judgments and decrees passed by the courts below, which according to the learned Sr. counsel was passed based on the evidence relating to the partition of the family business, not the landed property left behind by Radha Ballav Banik.

    9. Mr. Choudhury, learned counsel appearing for the principal respondents, on the other hand, supporting the judgments and decrees passed by the courts below, has submitted that both the courts below have recorded the concurrent finding of fact relating to the amicable partition of the property left behind by Radha Ballav Banik, amongst the five brothers and there being no perversity in recording such finding, the same may not be disturbed in second appeal. Referring to the deposition of PW 1, during cross-examination, which has been noticed by both the courts below, while recording the finding relating to the' amicable partition, Mr. Choudhury submits that the PW 1, who is the plaintiff No. 1, has deposed that all the five brothers are living separately for about ten years over their respective lands by constructing their dwelling houses, apart from the separation of family business amongst all the five brothers. The learned counsel further submits that it is evident from the pleaded case of the plaintiffs as well as the evidence adduced by them that vide Exts. 1 and 2 sale deeds, Radha Ballav Banik, predecessor-in-interest of the plaintiffs, defendant No. 3 and pro forma defendant No. 7 purchased altogether 1 powa 1 jasti 5 pon of land, which is equivalent to 32.25 rekh comprised in four different Taluks, namely, 14886, 14779, 14780 and 14842, but the plaintiffs have instituted the suit in respect of the land comprised in Taluk Nos. 14886 and 14779 only leaving aside the other land comprised in Taluk Nos. 14780 and 14842. Mr. Choudhury, therefore, submits that it is evident therefrom that Radha Ballav Banik had other land apart from the suit land. It has also been submitted that the aforesaid admission by the plaintiff No. 1 during cross-examination, that all brothers are living separately for about ten years over the respective land and also the fact that Radha Ballav Banik had more land than the suit land, gives credence to the defendants' pleaded case of amicable partition of the property left behind by Radha Ballav Banik, amongst the 5(five) brothers. The learned counsel, therefore, submits that there is no perversity in recording the finding by the courts below about the amicable partition of land left behind by Radha Ballav Banik.

    10. Relating to the second substantial question of law i.e the claim of the plaintiffs under section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, it has been submitted by the learned counsel that in the original plaint filed by the plaintiffs, though they have admitted that they came to know about the existence of the gift deeds being Exts. A, B and C on 22.8.1984, they never claim the preferential right under section 22 of the said Act, which prayer was introduced by way of amendment, which was allowed on 26.11.1987 Referring to article 97 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, it has been submitted by Mr. Choudhury that since the period of limitation for claiming such preferential right is one year from the date of execution of the deed, the suit of the plaintiffs insofar as it relates to the claim under section 22 of the aforesaid Act is barred by time, even if the date of knowledge, i.e, on 22.8.1984 is taken as the date of commencement of the period of limitation.

    11. I have considered the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and also perused the judgments and decrees passed by the courts below. To satisfy myself as to whether there is any perversity in recording the finding about amicable partition of the property left behind by Radha Ballav Banik, I have gone through the evidences adduced by the parties, both oral and documentary.

    12. Both the courts below have recorded concurrent finding of fact of the amicable partition of the property amongst the five brothers, namely, the three plaintiffs, husband of the defendant No. 3 and the pro forma defendant No. 7, on the basis of the evidences adduced by the parties. Both the courts below have also noticed the deposition of PW 1 (plaintiff No. 1), during cross-examination, to the effect that all the brothers arc living separately on different lands by constructing dwelling houses thereon for about ten years and the original family business has also been partitioned and they are doing their business in different shop rooms. As noticed above, to satisfy myself about the perversity, if any, in recording such finding, I have gone through the evidences adduced.

    13. It is evident from the evidences adduced that the PW 1 during the cross-examination has admitted that all the brothers are living separately on different lands by constructing dwelling houses and their family business has also been partitioned and all the brothers are doing business separately.

    14. Mr. Sahewalla, learned senior counsel submits that such deposition of PW 1 during cross-examination would not prove the amicable partition as pleaded by the defendants in the written statement, as that land may not be the part of the inherited property, which originally belonged to Radha Ballav Banik. Such contention of the plaintiffs cannot be accepted as there is absolutely no pleading in the plaint that the plaintiffs have other self acquired property over which they constructed their respective houses. On the other hand PW 1 in his evidence claimed that they are living on the suit property jointly. The plaintiffs have suppressed the fact of living separately on different lands by all the brothers by constructing dwelling houses. That apart, according to the plaintiffs themselves Radha Ballav Banik purchased total 1 powa 1 jasti 5 pon which is equal to 32.25 rekh of land vide two sale deeds both dated 11.11.1938 (Exts.-1 and 2). The said land, comprised in four Taluks, namely, 14886, 14779, 14780 and 14842. The suit land as described in the schedule to the plaint is measuring only about 8 rekh, which is equal to 1 jasti 4 rekh, which is almost ¼th of the total property purchased by Radha Ballav Banik during his lifetime and inherited by all the five brothers. The plaintiffs are silent about the remaining land, i.e, about 24.25 rekh, which was purchased by their father Radha Ballav Banik vide Exts. 1 and 2.3 Having regard to the aforesaid position and also the evidence of the PW 1 during cross-examination, it, therefore, appears that the courts below have rightly recorded the finding relating to the amicable partition of the property amongst the five brothers, which gives the credence to the defendants' pleaded case of amicable partition. The first substantial question of law is accordingly answered.

    15. This leads to the consideration of the second substantial question of law formulated on 26.11.2012, relating to the claim of preferential right under section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act.

    16. article 97 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963 provides that the limitation to enforce the right of pre-emption, whether the right is founded on law or general usage or on special contract, is one year from the date when the purchaser takes under the sale sought to be impeached, physical possession of the whole or part of the property sold, or, where the subject-matter of the sale does not admit of physical possession of the whole or part of the property, when the instrument of sale is registered. In the instant case it is an admitted position of fact, which is also evident from the prayer for recovery of khas possession made in the plaint, that the original defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 3 were in possession of the property immediately after execution of the aforesaid gift deeds dated 11.2.1983 and 15.6.1983 (Exts. A, B and C). The plaintiffs have also pleaded in the plaint that they came to know about the said gift on 22.8.1984 The plaintiffs for the first time introduced the claim of preferential right under section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, which is in the nature of pre-emption, by way of amendment, which was allowed on 26.11.1987, i.e, after one year even from the date of knowledge. Hence, the suit relating to the claim of preferential right under section 22 is barred by time. The second substantial question of law is also accordingly answered., In view of the aforesaid discussion, I do not find any merit in the appeal and, hence, the same is dismissed. No costs.

    17. The Registry is directed to send down the records.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gourish Banik And Ors. v. Arati Banik And Ors.
    (Nov 27, 2012)