Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 84 of the Penal Code read with S. 105 Illustration (a) of Evidence Act
  • S. 84.S. 106 of the Evidence Act
  • S. 105 of the Evidence Act
  • S. 106 of the Evidence Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 84 of the Penal Code read with S. 105 Illustration (a) of Evidence Act
  • S. 84.S. 106 of the Evidence Act
  • S. 105 of the Evidence Act
  • S. 106 of the Evidence Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from the conviction of Dharam Pal alias Dharmi alias Dharam Deo under Section 302 IPC and the life sentence imposed by the Sessions Judge, Moradabad on 31-3-1977, in respect of the death of Hira Lal Kahar of village Maulagarh, P.S. Chandausi, district Moradabad.

The factual narrative in the judgment records that on 9-12-1973 at about 7:00 a.m., Rameshwar (P.W.2) found the deceased tied to a hut pole and groaning. The deceased allegedly pointed to the accused as the person who had tied him. When Rameshwar tried to free the deceased the accused allegedly brandished a spear and later was seen running from the hut; villagers pursued and caught him about 100 paces away. The deceased later died of extensive burns. A written report was dictated by Rameshwar to Ram Chandra (P.W.4) and lodged at the police station. The investigation included a site inspection, seizure of a spear and samples of ashes and cloth, inquest and post-mortem by Dr. J.P. Chaturvedi (P.W.7), who opined death due to shock and burns (Ex. Ka.13). A charge-sheet was submitted and the accused pleaded not guilty, asserting that he was not in his senses (a plea of insanity).

At trial the Sessions Judge found that the appellant had failed to establish the plea of insanity and convicted him for murder under Section 302 IPC. On appeal, after hearing counsel, the Bench of B.C. Jauhari, J. reviewed the evidence and accepted the plea of insanity, allowed the appeal and acquitted the appellant under the exception provided by Section 84 IPC, subject to detention/conditions under Section 335 Cr.P.C.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant actually committed the act of murder (the factual question of culpability) — as framed by the evidence led by the prosecution and the appellant's statement.
  2. Whether the murder was committed when the appellant was of sound mind or during a state of insanity such that the exception in Section 84 IPC applies (the legal issue of insanity at the time of the offence).
  3. How the burden of proof with respect to insanity operates: what material is necessary to discharge or shift that burden, and whether the accused succeeded in establishing insanity under applicable principles and authorities.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant pleaded not guilty and asserted he was "not in senses" — i.e., he raised a plea of legal insanity.
  • Evidence supporting insanity included: an extract (Ex. kha.1) showing prior admission to a hospital for mental disease (13-12-1971 to 7-2-1972), testimony from his nephew (D.W.2) describing repeated mental derangements, prior hospital treatment (including electric shocks), episodes of tearing clothes and running away, and a recent episode of disturbance on 2-12-1973 culminating in confinement and an escape that preceded the incident.
  • The Chief Judicial Magistrate (C.J.M.) had obtained a medical report and, after examination on 21-10-1974, held that the accused was incapable of understanding court proceedings and required psychiatric treatment — material relied upon to establish incapacity.
  • Circumstantial facts relied on to support insanity included the strange manner of the killing (tying and burning), lack of motive, the accused being far from home, scant clothing in freezing weather, and incoherent speech observed by witnesses.

State / Prosecution's Arguments (as reflected in the trial finding)

  • The trial court (Sessions Judge) found that the prosecution had proved the murder beyond reasonable doubt based on eye-witness evidence (Rameshwar P.W.2, Ram Chandra P.W.4 and others) and that the accused was caught at the scene after the deceased was found tied and burned.
  • The Sessions Judge concluded that the appellant had not discharged the burden of proving legal insanity at the time of the offence and therefore was not entitled to the benefit of Section 84 IPC; consequently the appellant was convicted under Section 302 IPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ratan Lal v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (1970) 3 SCC 533; AIR 1971 SC 778 That the crucial time for proving unsoundness is when the crime was committed; burden of proof can be discharged from circumstances preceding, attending and following the crime; testimony of defence witnesses who are relations should not be disbelieved merely because of relationship. The court relied on this principle to consider the accused's past admissions, conduct around the crime and post-incident behaviour as material to determine mental condition at the time of the offence, and to accept testimony of relatives where probative.
Abdul Latif v. The State of Assam, 1981 Cri LJ 1205 That it is unjust to demand conclusive proof of sanity from a person recently recovered from mental derangement; insanity may be established by preponderance of probabilities from conduct that creates reasonable doubt regarding Section 84 conditions. The court invoked this approach to hold that the accused need not prove insanity beyond all doubt but could establish it on the preponderance of probabilities from surrounding circumstances and conduct, contributing to acceptance of insanity plea.
Unknown author (Kant), 1983 Cri LJ 619 Held that if an accused has a previous history of lunacy, the burden shifts to the prosecution to establish negatively that the accused was not of unsound mind when he committed the offence. The court used this authority to support its view that the accused's prior history of mental illness shifted the evidentiary burden and required the prosecution to negativate insanity, and that absence of such negative proof favoured the accused.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The appellate court proceeded in two analytical stages: fact (whether the appellant committed the murder) and law (whether the appellant was legally insane at the time of the act).

On the factual question, the court found no doubt that the appellant committed the murder. It relied on eyewitness testimony (Rameshwar P.W.2 and Ram Chandra P.W.4) establishing that the deceased was tied to a pole, that the accused warded off an attempt to free the deceased with a spear, that the accused fled and was caught soon after, and that the deceased then succumbed to burns. The court accepted that these facts established the appellant's act of setting fire to the deceased after tying him.

The sole legal question was whether the appellant acted with full faculties or during a fit of madness such that Section 84 IPC applied. The court recited the applicable legal principles and precedents: (a) the temporal focus for proof of unsoundness is the time of the offence; (b) the accused may discharge the burden by adducing circumstances before, during and after the offence; (c) testimony of relatives should not be discarded merely for relationship; (d) if a previous history of lunacy exists, the evidentiary burden shifts to the prosecution to show the accused was sane at the time.

The court examined the defence evidence: (i) an extract (Ex. kha.1) documenting a prior admission to a mental hospital (13-12-1971 to 7-2-1972); (ii) the nephew’s testimony (D.W.2) describing repeated mental derangements, prior hospital treatment (including electric shocks), a recent episode on 2-12-1973 when the accused tore his clothes and was confined before escaping the same night; and (iii) the C.J.M.'s medical enquiry and order of 21-10-1974 that the accused was incapable of understanding court proceedings and required psychiatric treatment.

The court further considered objective, circumstantial facts supportive of insanity: the extremely unusual mode of killing (tying then burning), absence of any motive (accused came from Rohtak to Moradabad and had no known reason to attack the deceased), lack of normal clothing in very cold weather, incoherent speech observed by Rameshwar, and the accused's distant location from his home. These factors, taken together with the medical/legal findings and prior admissions, led the court to conclude that the defence had established sufficient material to raise reasonable doubt as to the appellant's sanity at the time of the offence.

Invoking the cited precedents, the court held that once a previous history of mental illness and supporting circumstances exist, the onus effectively shifts and the prosecution must negate insanity; where that negative is not convincingly made and reasonable doubt exists, the accused is entitled to the benefit of the exception in Section 84 IPC. The appellate court thus accepted the plea of insanity.

Finally, although acquitting under Section 84 IPC, the court addressed public safety and statutory procedure under Section 335 Cr.P.C., ordering psychiatric examination, conditional release to relatives upon satisfactory sureties and reporting to the State Government, or detention in jail until certified mentally fit if sureties are not furnished.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was allowed and, applying the exception in Section 84 IPC, the court ACQUITTED the appellant on the ground of legal insanity.

Immediate consequences for the parties:

  • The appellant is acquitted of the charge under Section 302 IPC by reason of insanity as covered by Section 84 IPC.
  • Under Section 335 Cr.P.C., the court ordered that the appellant be taken into custody and examined by a doctor as to his fitness to live in society. The appellant may be delivered to a relative or friend upon satisfactory security to the C.J.M., ensuring proper care and prevention of harm to himself or others, and produced for inspection before any officer directed by the State Government. The C.J.M. is to report to the State Government the action taken. If no sureties are furnished, the appellant is to be detained in jail until certified mentally fit.

Broader legal implications: The opinion applies existing authorities on the burden of proof and proof of insanity and does not purport to lay down a new principle of law beyond the application of those precedents to the facts of this case.

    Dharam Pal v. State Of U.P .

    B.C Jauhari, J.:— Dharam Pal alias Dharmi alias Dharam Deo has filed this appeal against his conviction under S. 302 I.P.C and sentence of life imprisonment awarded to him by the judgment of the Sessions Judge, Moradabad dated 31-3-1977.

    2. The occurrences relates to the murder of Hira Lal Kahar resident of village Maulagarh, P.S Chandausi, district Moradabad in a most curious and strange fashion. It is said that the deceased Hira Lal had erected a hut on the outskirts of the village in order to keep a watch on his field. On 9-12-1973 at about 7.00 A.M Rameshwar, P.W 2, who belongs to the same village had gone to evacuate himself on the pond lying to the north of the hut. He heard the groaning of Hira Lal and went to his hut. There he found Hira Lal tied with the pole of the hut. On making inquiries from Hira Lal, Hira Lal pointed out towards the accused who was sitting near him as the person who had tied him. When Rameshwar wanted to untie the strings, the accused rushed towards him with spear and accordingly Rameshwar came back to the village and along with Dhandhari, Asharfi P.W 3 and Girdhari reached the hut. As they reached the hut, they found the appellant emerging from the hut and running away. He was given a chase and caught at a distance of about 100 paces and brought back to the hut. In the meantime Hira Lal succumbed to the extensive burn injuries sustained by him. Leaving the accused in the custody of the villagers, Rameshwar dictated his report to Ram Chandra P.W 4 and the report was taken to the Police Station Chandausi where it was lodged at 8.45 a.m On the basis of the written-report a formal FIR. was drawn up by the clerk constable Ram Ratan Singh P.W 1 who registered a case in the General Diary copy of which is Ex. Ka. 2. The investigation of the case was conducted by Sub-Inspector Qazal Bash who is now dead and whose writings have been proved by Deengar Singh P.W 6 who is acquainted with the hand-writings of the deceased Investigating Officer Sri Qazal Bash. The Investigating Officer visited the spot, took the accused in custody and held an inquest on the deadbody of Hira Lal in the presence of Mohan P.W 5 son of the deceased and other Panches. After sealing the corpse and preparing the usual formal letters it was sent for post-mortem examination through constable Deengar Singh. The spear and samples of ashes with pieces of Dhoti and strings with which the deceased was tied, were collected and sealed and memos prepared. The Investigating Officer inspected the locality and prepared a site-plan which is Ex. Ka. 11. The Investigating Officer also interrogated the witnesses. Dr. J.P Chaturvedi, P.W 7, Medical Officer, District Hospital, Moradabad conducted an autopsy on the dead-body of Hira Lal on 10-12-1973 at about 3 p.m The deceased was found to have extensive first and second degree burns extending from the top of the head to the tip of the toes involving the front and back of the body, head, neck and thorax, abdomen, penis, scrotum, thighs, legs, arms, hands and feet. The internal organs were found congested, the stomach was empty. In the opinion of the doctor the death was due to shock and burns, vide the post-mortem report Ex. Ka. 13. After completing the investigation a charge-sheet was submitted against the accused. The accused pleaded not guilty and in his statement in answer to a question whether he committed the murder, said that he was not in senses. Similarly he has feigned ignorance whether on an attempt of Rameshwar to release Hira Lal, he ran towards him with a spear. He again said that he did not know whether he ran from the hut on the arrival of the witnesses. Then he said that he did not know whether he was arrested after giving a beating. He also feigned ignorance whether the witnesses found Hira Lal tied, burnt and dead on the spot. In essence, therefore, the plea of the accused is one of insanity.

    3. The learned Sessions Judge after examining the evidence came to the conclusion that the appellant had failed to establish his plea of insanity and therefore, he was not entitled to be acquitted or to the benefit of S. 84 IPC. being extended to him.

    4. We have heard the learned counsel for the appellant and the learned State counsel at great length and come to the conclusion that the plea of insanity must be accepted in this case and the accused-appellant be acquitted of the offence under S. 302 IPC.

    5. As far as the factum of murder is concerned, there is absolutely no doubt in our mind that the murder was committed by the appellant. The evidence of Rameshwar P.W 2 coupled with the statement of Ram Chandra P.W 4 abundantly establishes that the deceased had been tied to a pole and when Rameshwar P.W 2 tried to get him released, he was warded off by showing a spear and thereafter, he came with Dhandhari, Asharfi P.W 3 and Girdhari and found the accused running away and the accused was then caught on the spot. Consequently, from the statements of the witnesses it is established beyond any shadow of reasonable doubt that the accused must have set fire to the deceased after tying him to a pole and was arrested on the spot. The statement of the accused quoted above also points in that direction. Consequently, the only point to determine is whether the murder was committed by the accused when he was possessed of his full faculties or that it was committed during a fit of madness and the case is covered by the exception provided in S. 84 of the Penal Code.

    6. The accused in this case examined two defence witnesses. Tara Chand D.W 1 is a clerk of the hospital for mental diseases at Shahadara, Delhi who has filed an extract Ex. kha. 1 about the admission of the accused in hospital for mental disease on 13-12-1971 and his discharge on 7-2-1972. Chaman Lal D.W 2 is the nephew of the accused. He has said that the accused used to suffer from disorders of the mind and about seven years before he had also suffered from such a mental dearrangement. The accused used to tear his clothes and dance and run away from the house for 2 or 3 days. He was admitted for treatment and electric shocks were given to him in the hospital. Thereafter, he became alright. Then he again suffered from mental illness after a period of two years and was admitted to Sahadara Hospital under the orders of the Magistrate. On Sunday i.e 2-12-1973 the accused again suffered from a fit of insanity and started tearing his clothes and beating the children. The witness went to Patel Nagar and lodged a report and two constables arrived. His aunt then intervened and the police left with a warning that he should behave or else the accused would be confined in jail and directed him to hospitalise the accused. He was kept in confinement till 11 p.m When he was released and then he escaped in the night and was not available despite a search. Relations were informed and later on it was learnt that he was implicated in a murder case in Chandauisi. We have consequently to determine in this case as to how far this plea of insanity of the accused can be accepted. The learned Sessions Judge held that since the accused had failed to prove that he was insane at the time of the occurrence and the burden fay on him, his plea of insanity should be repelled and it should be held to be a case of homicide.

    7. The question of burden of proof of insanity in a criminal prosecution has been the matter of consideration in several cases decided by the highest Court The learned Sessions Judge has referred to them in his judgment S. 84 of the Penal Code read with S. 105 Illustration (a) of Evidence Act lays down that the burden of proof of the general exception is upon the accused and the Court shall presume the absence of such circumstance. There is also another principle that in criminal cases it is the duty of the prosecution to prove beyond all reasonable doubt the guilt of the accused. S. 105 of the Evidence Act which lays the onus of proof of general exception on the defence does not mean that such exception can be proved only from the evidence adduced by the prosecution (defence?) itself. Burden can be discharged by leading evidence or by relying on the prosecution evidence itself. In the case of Ratan Lal v. State Of Madhya Pradesh., (1970) 3 SCC 533 : AIR 1971 SC 778 it was held by Hon'ble the Supreme Court that the crucial point of time at which unsoundness of mind has to be proved is the time when the crime was actually committed. The burden of proving this can be discharged by the accused from the circumstances which preceded, attended and followed the crime. In para 14 of the judgment it was held that the testimony of the defence witnesses as to unsoundness of mind of accused should not be disbelieved merely because they are relations of the accused. In the case of Abdul Latif… v. The State Of Assam…., 1981 Cri LJ 1205 it was held that” it is not justice to demand proof of insanity from a person just recovered from mental derangement and to demand of him to establish his mental faculties at the time of the offence. The insanity may be established only by preponderance of probabilities on the basis of some features fleaning from the conduct of the accused which point to a reasonable doubt that he had acted under circumstances set forth in S. 84.”

    “S. 106 of the Evidence Act seems to be somewhat harsh in so far as proof of insanity is concerned. But S. 6 of the Penal Code must be treated as a Proviso to S. 106 of the Evidence Act. It imposes arr obligation on the Court as well to consider the cases of exceptions on its own in so far as it relates to burden of proving legal insanity. “Special Knowledge” envisaged in S. 106 of the Evidence Act is always impaired due to mental derangement.”

    8. In this case the Supreme Court case referred to above has been noticed. In 1983 Cri LJ 619 (Kant) it was held that if the accused has a previous history of lunacy the burden shifts on the prosecution to establish negatively that the accused was not of unsound mind when he committed the offence. Lastly it may be observed that it has been held that even if the plea of the accused has not been affirmatively established and a reasonable doubt is created in the mind of the Courts then too the accused is entitled to be acquitted.

    9. Applying the principles of law laid down above, we find that in this case there is the evidence of the nephew of the accused that the accused was admitted to the mental hospital earlier. Even in this case a medical report was called from the doctor about the mental condition of the accused by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Moradabad on 3-5-1974 and thereafter the Chief Judicial Magistrate examined the doctor and the accused and passed a detailed order on 21-10-1974. The C.J.M held that the accused was incapable of understanding the Court proceedings and the doctor was of the opinion that he requires psychiatric treatment. He was, therefore, released for treatment on the sureties undertaking to intimate about the condition of the patient.

    10. Apart from what has been stated above there are certain facts which speak for themselves and do not require any further comment. The first is that the murder was committed in very strange circumstances viz. by burning the deceased after tying him to a pole. The accused is a resident of district Rohtak and this murder was committed in the district of Moradabad far far away from the house of the accused-appellant. The accused had absolutely no motive whatsoever to commit this murder in this strange manner. According to the statement of Rameshwar he was not seen in the village prior to the date of occurrence. Though it was the coldest period of the winter as admitted by the witnesses, yet the accused was wearing an Angocha and had tied a Loongi on his ears and was not wearing anything else. According to Rameshwar he was talking incoherently.

    11. From what has been stated above it is clear that the accused had a previous history of mental illness. He committed this murder in strange circumstances and in a strange fashion. He had no motive to murder the deceased and had come a long way away from his house. He was ill clad and scanitly dressed in the coldest winter Season. Then even the C.J.M found him to be incapable of understanding the nature of the Court's proceedings and released him as such. Under these circumstances the facts speak out for themselves and the plea of insanity must be accepted. In view of what has been said above we would pass the following orders in this appeal:

    12. In the result the appeal is allowed. The accused is hereby given the benefit of exception of S. 84 I.P.C and his plea of insanity is accepted and he is acquitted accordingly. Under S. 335 CR. P.C however, we cannot release him without any strings attached to it. He shall, therefore, be taken into custody and examined by the doctor regarding his fitness to live in society. He may, however, be delivered to any relative or friend giving security to the satisfaction of C.J.M Moradabad that the appellant shall be properly taken care of and prevented from doing injuries to himself or others and be produced for inspection before such officer as the State Government may direct. The C.J.M shall report to the State Government the action taken by him. In case, however, the sureties are not furnished, he shall be kept detained. In jail until certified to be mentally fit.

    13. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dharam Pal v. State Of U.P .
    (Sep 11, 1984)