Jawahar Lal Gupta, J.:— The petitioners in these 16 writ petitions are dealing in grinding of cotton-seeds and sale of cotton-seed oil. They were assessed for the payment of sales tax on the hypothesis that they were producing edible oil. These assessments were later on suo motu reopened by the Regional Authority under the Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948. Separate notices were issued in respect of different assessment years. C.W.P Nos. 264, 311—315, 1302, 6919, 1673, 2011, 2084 and 6769 of 1987, 2476,8407, 8408 and 8409 of 1988 are directed against the notices served on the respective petitioners. In C.W.P No. 6919 of 1987, the petitioner appeared before the Assistant Excise and Taxation Commissioner and pursued the remedies under the Act. In this petition, the orders at annexures P4 and P5 passed by the respective authorities have been challenged. It would be trite to notice the facts as stated in C.W.P No. 6919 of 1987.
2. The petitioner is a partnership firm at Mansa. It is engaged in grinding of cotton-seeds, etc. The cotton-seed oil is sold in the State of Punjab as well as in other States. It is registered as a dealer under the Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948 and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1948 and 1956 Acts”, respectively). Originally the sales tax was levied on inter-State sales at the rate of 4 per cent. However vide Notification dated January 11, 1979, issued under section 8(5) of the 1956 Act, the Government of Punjab fixed the rate of sales tax at 1 per cent. The petitioner was assessed for the years 1981-82, 1982-83, and 1983-84 and sales tax on inter-State sales was charged at the rate of 1 per cent. Thereafter, the petitioner received notices under section 21 of the 1948 Act calling upon it to show cause as to why tax be not assessed at the rate of 4 per cent. It was also called upon to show cause against the imposition of penalty and interest. The petitioner appeared before the authority, viz., respondent No. 3, who vide orders dated November 24, 1986, a copy of which has been placed on record as annexure P4, created an additional liability of tax for an amount of Rs. 62,913 besides an amount of Rs. 42,974 towards the interest. The petitioner filed three revision petitions before the Presiding Officer of the Sales Tax Tribunal which were dismissed vide orders dated August 5, 1987, a copy of this order is at annexure P5. Aggrieved by these orders, the petitioner has approached this Court through the present writ petition.
3. The motion Bench had initially directed the issue of notice of motion. Subsequently, after hearing the learned counsel for the parties, the writ petition was admitted.
4. In the written statement besides a preliminary objection that the petitioner had an effective alternative remedy under section 22(1) of the 1948 Act it has been, inter alia, averred that the case does not involve any question of law; and the writ court cannot interfere with the finding of facts recorded by the authorities under the Act it has been averred that the washing of the cotton-seed oil with caustic soda does not convert it into edible oil. Reference to the respective pleadings of the parties shall be made at the appropriate stage.
5. Arguments were addressed on behalf of the petitioners in these petitions by Messrs J.K Sibal, R.P Sawhney and D.S Brar. Mr. Rajiv Raina, Assistant Advocate-General, argued the matter on behalf of the respondents. A perusal of the order at annexure P4 passed by the Assistant Excise and Taxation Commissioner shows that the following findings have been recorded:
“(1) The cotton-seed oil as produced by the assessee is not edible because it is produced in crude or raw form without the removal of free fatty acids and impurities. It can become edible only when it is subjected to further refining and purifying processes;
(2) even, the people, who deal in the trade of cotton-seed oil will never deal in it as edible oil because it is not fit to be taken as food in the form and shape it is produced by the assessee;
(3) for the lone reason that cotton-seed oil is consumed by many people, it does not become edible unless it is made fit to be taken as food. Even palm-oil which is basically meant for manufacture of soaps is also consumed by a very large number of people for frying fish and pakoras. It is also used by the halwais in the preparation of sweets. Even palm-oil cannot be treated as edible;
(4) there are casual entries of purchase of caustic soda and sale of ‘gad’. Mere employment of caustic soda does not result in refining and purifying the cotton-seed oil;
(5) the fact that cotton-seed oil is permitted for use in the manufacture of edible, and vegetable oil products does not prove its worthiness to be declared as edible oil. There is no denying the fact that the Central Government has permitted the use of specified percentage of cotton-seed oil by mixing it with specified percentage of other refined oil for the manufacture of edible oil products;
(6) the dealer has a plant. In this plant, after crushing cotton-seeds, the crude oil is taken to a vessel. It is heated to a certain degree by passing steam in the pipes fitted in the vessel and the fans fitted therein start thrashing the oil. Caustic soda is poured in the vessel so as to wash the cotton-seed oil. By this process, certain impurities settle down which come out of the vessel as ‘gad’. The remaining oil lying on the surface of the vessel is taken out through pipes to a separate tank. At the most, we can say that the dealer sold washed cottonseed oil;
(7) the cottonseed oil to assume the character of edible oil has to be refined;
(8) a minimum refinery unit consisting of the three units, i.e, neutralising section, bleaching section and decolourising section has to be provided, before the oil can be termed as edible oil; and
(9) the assessee has supplied oil to M/s. D.C.M and General Mills, Delhi and United Vanaspati Works (P) Ltd., Solan. These mills are manufacturing vegetable ghee and the cotton-seed oil purchased from this dealer was further purified, refined and processed before using the same as a constituent of vegetable ghee.”
6. These findings were challenged through the three revision petitions filed by the petitioner. The Presiding Officer of the Tribunal has observed as under:
“8. Shri Goyal further argued that in common parlance, cotton-seed oil is taken as edible oil and shown in the newspapers as such. In support of this he attached some newspaper cuttings, particularly, from the Tribune of May 6, 1987, where while quoting price of edible oils, cotton-seed oil (mill delivery) was also mentioned. The point at issue is, whether the washed cotton-seed oil, sold by the applicant-dealer in the particular years, is edible; and if so, what evidence is available in its support. The Assessing Authority, vide its orders of October 19, 1984, July 5, 1985 and October 18, 1985, accepted it as edible and charged the tax at the rate of one per cent. The orders of the Assessing Authority are very sketchy and do not refer to any material on the basis of which he accepted this oil as edible. Later, the revisional authority, vide his orders of November 24, 1986, declared the oil sold by the applicant-dealer as non-edible. These orders are detailed one and discuss all the points raised by Shri Goyal today in his oral arguments. These orders do discuss the point of common parlance, nomenclature, consumability and edibility, purchase of caustic soda for refining and cleaning of the oil and the machinery with the applicant-dealer for refining process so as to make this oil edible. As regards these orders, argument of Shri Goyal is that these were passed ex parte and full opportunity was not made available to the applicant-dealer. However, even in arguments today, no new point has been brought excepting an extract from the instructions of the Government of India in Schedule 12 regarding agmark grade designation and the definitions of quality for the cotton-seed oil. In support of his arguments, Shri Goyal cited rulings reported in [1985] 156 ITR 585 (SC); (1985) 4 SCC 590 : AIR 1986 SC 484 (Shree Sajjan Mills Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax), (1986) 2 SCC 512 : AIR 1986 SC 1162 (Satyanarayana v. State of Karnataka) and [1973] 31 STC 302 (SC) (Commissioner of Sales Tax v. S.N Brothers).
9. Shri Brar representing the State brought to my notice that the question of cotton-seed oil being edible or not, was discussed quite succinctly in Appeal No. 65 of 1985-86 decided by this Tribunal where various provisions of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955, were also discussed. This Tribunal, vide order of January 27, 1987, in Appeal Nos. 411,412 and 413 of 1985-86 held that the cotton-seed oil was not fit for direct human consumption and hence was liable to be taxed at the rate of four per cent.
10. In view of these facts and after giving careful consideration to the arguments of Shri Goyal, as well as rulings; cited by him and taking into account my order of January 27, 1987, I see no reason to upset the orders of the Assistant Excise and Taxation Commissioner dated November 24, 1986, and hence I dismiss these revision applications.”
7. The admitted position, therefore, is that the petitioner sold washed cotton-seed oil. Was this edible oil? This expression is not defined under the 1948 Act or the 1956 Act.
8. Mr. Sibal, learned counsel for the petitioner, contends that in the absence of a definition in the Act, the meaning given to the expression under various other statutory provisions should be adopted. He has referred to the provisions of the Pulses, Edible Oil Seeds and Edible Oils (Storage Control) Order, 1977, issued under section 3 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955. By a Notification of September 13, 1990, the Control Order was amended and edible oil was defined as under:
“2(g) ‘edible oil’ means oil used, directly or after processing, for human consumption and includes hydrogenated vegetable oil.”
9. He also referred to the instructions issued by the Government of India under the Agricultural Produce (Grading and Marking) Act, 1937. In these instructions of the Directorate of Marketing and Inspection, Ministry of Food and Agriculture, edible oil has been described as “refined edible oil” and “washed edible oil”. Under the heading of washed edible oil, the following description has been given:
“Cotton-seed oil shall be the oil obtained from the seed of plant cotton (gossypium Sp.) only. It shall be clear and free from admixture with any other oil or substance and from suspended matter or sediment. The oil shall be neutralised with alkali, washed and dried.”
10. A copy of these instructions has been appended as annexure P9 with C.W.P No. 264 of 1987. Relying on the above description of edible oil, the learned counsel has contended that the oil sold by the petitioner conformed to the above specifications. According to the learned counsel, it was oil, used after processing for human consumption and thus met with the requirements of the Control Order referred to above. He further submits that even under the provisions of the Agricultural Produce (Grading and Marking) Act, 1937, the Government of India had accepted two forms of cotton-seed oil, viz., the refined and the washed. Both these forms had been accepted to be “edible”. The product sold by the petitioner conformed to the description of washed edible oil. In this view of the matter, the action of the respondents in reopening the settled assessments was wholly illegal and arbitrary.
11. Mr. Raina, on the other hand, has contended that the edibility of the product has to be determined with reference to the provisions of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1954 Act”). He referred to standards of quality as specified in appendix “B” to the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955, wherein the following entry appears:
“A. 17.02—Cotton seed oil (Binole ka tel) means the oil extracted from clean, sound and decorticated cotton-seeds (genus gossypium), refined and dehydrated. It shall be clear, free from rancidity suspended or other foreign matter, separated water, added colouring or flavouring substances, or mineral oil.
It shall conform to the following standards:
(a) Butyro-refractometer reading at 40° C
55.6 to 60.2
(b) Saponification value
190 to 198
(c) Iodine value
98 to 112
(d) Unsaponifiable matter
Not more than 1.5%
(e) Free fatty acid as oleic acid
Not more than 1.0%
(f) There shall be no turbidity after keeping the filtered sample at 30°C for 24 hours.”
12. He has also relied upon the standard prescribed by the Indian Standards Institution at annexure R2. He also relied upon the decision of a Division Bench of the High Court of Hyderabad in Kishenlal Oil Mills v. Commissioner of Sales Tax, [1955] 6 STC 650, wherein the following observations appear:
“The second point, viz., whether cotton-seed oil is edible, is a question of fact. We have gone through the report of the Chemical Laboratories and find that at some stage or other if the cotton-seeds are subjected to a highly specialised process, it might be possible to extract oil which is edible. The National Chemical Laboratories have in their report stated as under:
‘Cotton-seed oil when pressed from cotton-seeds is dark and unappetising. On refining with alkali, bleaching with bleaching earths generally followed by deodorisation, colouring matters are removed and a light coloured oil is obtained. Most of this colour is due to a pigment called gossypol; on alkali treatment, the pigment is carried away leaving a light coloured oil.
Refined cotton-seed oil, provided it is of the quality usually expected of an ordinary refined vegetable oil like groundnut, sesame, till, etc., is completely harmless and edible. This has been proved in the laboratory by test on rats; while especially in America, where the major oil is refined cotton-seed oil, it has been eaten without ill-effects for over 30 years. It is also being consumed after refining in various parts of India. It can be used as food material as such or after hydrogenation: to vanaspati.
Refined cotton-seed oil of good quality is hence an edible oil just like any other edible vegetable oil.’
The report taken as a whole would show that cotton-seed oil at any rate for the present has not become edible in the hands of the dealer.”
13. It is no doubt true that their Lordships in the above-noted case, have adopted a fairly stringent test for determining the edibility of the cottonseed oil. It is also correct that under the 1954 Act, certain standards, which the cotton-seed oil has to meet, have been prescribed. However, the fact remains that the petitioner is not facing a case for violation of the 1954 Act and the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955. It is nobody's case that the oil sold by the petitioner did not conform to these standards. In fact, even the authorities under the Act have not recorded any such finding. In such a situation, I am of the view that the provisions of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act and the Rules framed thereunder cannot be invoked. As far the test laid down by the Division Bench in Kishenlal Oil Mills' case, [1955] 6 STC 650 (Hyd.), it must be remembered that the decision was rendered in the year 1954. Thereafter, as far back as the year 1963, the Directorate of Marketing and Inspection! had itself described washed cotton-seed oil as edible. Further, as recently as September, 1990, the Central Government has defined “edible oil” to mean any oil used for human consumption after processing. The oil produced by the petitioner conformed to these standards. It was processed. It is admittedly used for human consumption. There is nothing to show that it did not conform to the instructions issued by the Government in the year 1963 (vide annexure P9 in C.W.P No. 264 of 1987).
14. In fact, a perusal of the impugned order would show that respondent No. 3 has found as a fact that cotton-seed oil is consumed by many people like the palm-oil and that the petitioner “sold washed cotton-seed oil”. Even the Presiding Officer of the Sales Tax Tribunal has found that the petitioner had sold washed cotton-seed oil. Even the specification issued by the Indian Standards Institution, inter alia, provides as under:
“2.12 Washed cotton-seed oil—cotton-seed oil obtained by the process of expression which has been neutralised with alkali and subsequently washed and dried.”
15. In this view of the matter, the conclusion of the authorities that the cotton-seed oil has to be subjected to a further process of refining by installing a plant for that purpose consisting of neutralising, bleaching and decolouring sections is wholly unwarranted. No such requirement has been laid down as a condition precedent. The insistence on the existence of a refining plant is, therefore, wholly unwarranted.
16. There is another aspect of the matter. Clause (1) of section 21 of the 1948 Act provides as under:
“The Commissioner may of his own motion call for the record of any proceedings which are pending before, or have been disposed of by any authority subordinate of him, for the purpose of satisfying himself as to the legality or propriety of such proceedings or order made therein and may pass such order in relation thereto as he may think fit.”
17. The authority can call for record of any proceedings which are pending or have been disposed of for the purpose of satisfying itself as to the “legality or propriety” of such proceedings or order made therein. In the present case, the Assessing Authority had upheld the claim of the petitioner. It had levied sales tax on the basis that the petitioner had sold edible oil. In this process, the authority had not violated any provision of law. The conclusion was not an impossible one. The authority had taken a positive view. In such a situation, no occasion for invoking the provisions of section 21 and issue of suo motu notices had been made out. In this context it is noteworthy that the petitioner had not concealed or withheld any information. If on the basis of the evidence available with, the Assessing Authority it had accepted the claim of the petitioner, it could not be said to have acted illegally or improperly. I am, therefore, of the opinion that no case for invoking the provisions of section 21 had been made out. Let it not be forgotten that the assessment orders had been passed many years prior to matter being reopened. It is not unlikely that the petitioner would have lost a fair amount of relevant evidence. Evidently even the material sold will not be traceable. In such a situation, it would be unfair to the petitioner to reopen the matter especially when no apparent illegality or impropriety has been shown to exist in the orders of assessment. Mr. Raina also contended that the petitioners had effective alternative remedy under the Act. The writ petitions have been filed by most of the petitioners against the notices only. It is no doubt correct that most of the petitioners had approached this Court against the notices. However, the view of the authorities is apparent from the orders produced by the petitioner in C.W.P No. 6919 of 1987. In that view of the matter, no useful purpose would have been served by their submitting to the jurisdiction of the departmental authorities. As such, the objections raised on behalf of the respondents cannot be sustained. In view of the above conclusion, I have not considered it necessary to go into the various other submissions made by the learned counsel for the petitioners regarding the limitation, etc.
18. The writ petitions are accordingly allowed. The impugned orders at annexures P4 and P5 in C.W.P No. 6919 of 1987 and the notices in the other cases are quashed. In the circumstances of the case, the parties are left to bear their own costs.
19. Writ petitions allowed.