Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a suo-motu civil contempt proceeding initiated on 15.7.2009 by A.H. Saikia, C.J., against three State officers: (i) Mr. C.L. Sharma, Special Secretary, Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms and Training, Government of Sikkim; (ii) Mr. R.K. Purkayastha, Legal Remembrancer-cum-Secretary, Law Department, Government of Sikkim; and (iii) Mr. Tashi Wangyal, then Superintendent of Police, Police Headquarters, Gangtok (later Senior Vigilance Officer, Energy and Power Department). The proceeding followed the court's perusal of affidavits filed by these officers after directions issued on 1.6.2009 and 23.6.2009 in W.P. (C) No. 10 of 2007.

Background facts: One Adup Tshering Bhutia, an Inspector of Police in the Sikkim Vigilance Department, challenged an inter-se seniority list of Police Inspectors notified on 14.11.2006 by filing W.P. (C) No. 10 of 2007. The Court, while admitting the writ, passed an interim order on 22.5.2007 restraining the respondents and their agents "from in any manner giving any effect to the said notification dated 14.11.2006 in so far as it describes the annexure thereof as a confirmed seniority list." The interim order nonetheless permitted the respondents to consider representations and to declare confirmation if done "in accordance with the rules and the recommendations of the Committees and the Board in operation in the field."

Despite the interim order, an Office Order dated 18.7.2008 (issued by respondent No.1, Mr. C.L. Sharma) promoted two Police Inspectors (Tilak Kumar Chettri and B.B. Subba) to the rank of Deputy Superintendent of Police on an officiating basis, with the promotion "subject to final decision of the Court in W.P No. 10 of 2007." The Court observed that no application had been made to modify or vacate the interim order before issuing that Office Order.

The Court directed explanations and affidavits from the officers involved. Mr. C.L. Sharma and Mr. Tashi Wangyal filed affidavits and appeared in person on 23.6.2009; Mr. R.K. Purkayastha later filed an affidavit and appeared. The affidavits revealed that the offending Office Order of 18.7.2008 had been issued on the basis of legal advice rendered by the Legal Remembrancer and by Hon'ble Mr. Justice R.K. Patra (Retd.), Chairman, Law Commission of Sikkim.

The Court examined whether the actions amounted to civil contempt under the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 and whether the disobedience was wilful. During proceedings the State withdrew the impugned Office Orders (including subsequent related promotions) and the impugned seniority list, and the officers tendered unconditional apologies. The Court accepted those apologies, relied on precedent regarding misinterpretation of orders, and ultimately dropped the contempt proceedings. The main writ petition was disposed of as the Government had withdrawn the impugned seniority list.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the officers named (Mr. C.L. Sharma, Mr. R.K. Purkayastha and Mr. Tashi Wangyal) committed civil contempt by issuing or facilitating an Office Order of 18.7.2008 that promoted officers on the basis of a challenged seniority list, despite the interim order of 22.5.2007 restraining the respondents from giving effect to that notification.
  2. Whether the disobedience (if any) was wilful within the meaning of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, such that contempt proceedings should continue.
  3. What legal effect a bona fide misinterpretation or legal opinion (here, advice from the Law Commission / R.K. Patra, J. (Retd.)) has on the question of wilful disobedience and the appropriateness of continuing contempt proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Tapan Kumar Mukherjee v. Shri Heromoni Mondial (1991 Cri LJ 390) Establishes that it must be proved beyond doubt that a contemner committed wilful contempt; for civil contempt, the disobedience must be wilful to attract punishment. The Court invoked this authority to emphasize that disobedience alone does not constitute contempt unless wilful disobedience is shown. This standard framed the Court's inquiry into whether the officers had acted with wilful default.
Ashok Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar Holds that misinterpretation of an order of the Court may mean the respondents did not wilfully or contemptuously flout the order, and therefore contempt proceedings may not be appropriate where misinterpretation is shown. The Court relied on this precedent to conclude that the officers' conduct was the result of a misinterpretation (via the Law Commission's opinion) rather than wilful disrespect, and therefore the contempt proceedings were not fit to continue; the Court found the present case to be squarely covered by Ashok Kumar Singh.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded methodically from fact-finding to legal conclusion:

  1. Identification of the controlling interim order (22.5.2007): The Court reiterated that it had restrained respondents and their agents from giving any effect to the 14.11.2006 seniority notification insofar as it described the annexure as a confirmed seniority list, while also allowing the respondents to consider representations and confirm officers "in accordance with the rules."
  2. Examination of the offending action: The Office Order dated 18.7.2008 promoted two Inspectors to Dy. SP on officiating basis where their seniority was under challenge. Though the order stated that promotions were "subject to final decision" of the writ, the Court observed that the promotion was based on the challenged seniority list and thus ran counter to the interim order.
  3. Inquiry into wilfulness: The Court applied the legal standard from the Contempt of Courts Act (civil contempt requires wilful disobedience) and the precedent in Tapan Kumar Mukherjee to require a demonstrable wilful default before continuing contempt proceedings.
  4. Consideration of explanations and the source of the decision: The affidavits revealed that the officers responsible acted on a legal opinion furnished by the Legal Remembrancer and Hon'ble Mr. Justice R.K. Patra (Retd.), Chairman, Law Commission of Sikkim. The Court examined that opinion (extracted in the record) and found it to amount to a misinterpretation of the interim order: the Law Commission opinion suggested promotions could be made subject to the final decision of the Court.
  5. Assessment of conduct and remedial steps taken: The State withdrew the impugned Office Orders (and later the impugned seniority list), and the officers tendered unconditional apologies. The Court treated these steps as relevant to the question of whether the disobedience was wilful.
  6. Use of binding precedent on misinterpretation: Drawing on Ashok Kumar Singh, the Court noted that where actions stem from a misinterpretation of a Court's order, it cannot conclusively be said that there was wilful contempt; thus continuing proceedings may not be appropriate.
  7. Conclusion of legal analysis: On balance, the Court found the explanations unsatisfactory in substance but persuasive in the sense that the offending actions flowed from a misinterpretation and from reliance on legal advice; given the withdrawal of the orders and the unconditional apologies, the Court concluded that wilful disobedience was not established to the level required to sustain contempt sanctions.
  8. Separate assessment of the Superintendent of Police (Mr. Tashi Wangyal): Although the Court expressed reservations about his explanation and noted that his communication (dated 19.7.2007) was improper given that the representation had been addressed to the Director General of Police, the Court accepted his unconditional apology and, in the interest of justice, refrained from taking contempt action. The Court, however, issued a note of warning clarifying officers' responsibilities in complying with directions and disposing of representations.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The suo-motu civil contempt proceedings initiated on 15.7.2009 were dropped against the officers involved.

Specific outcomes and immediate consequences:

  • The Court accepted the unconditional apologies tendered by Mr. C.L. Sharma and Mr. R.K. Purkayastha and concluded that their actions were the result of a misinterpretation based on the Law Commission's opinion rather than wilful contempt. Accordingly, the contempt proceedings against them were dropped.
  • The Court also dropped the contempt proceeding against Mr. Tashi Wangyal, the then Superintendent of Police, while issuing a formal warning that officers entrusted with disposing of representations (or those delegated) must carry out such duties responsibly and with care.
  • The main writ petition (W.P. (C) No. 10 of 2007) was disposed of because the Government withdrew the impugned seniority list.

Broader implications:

  • The Court emphasized that officers of the State (within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution) must exercise power with utmost vigilance when interpreting or complying with Court orders, particularly where a matter is sub judice. Misinterpretation of judicial orders in such circumstances would be viewed seriously and could give rise to contempt proceedings in appropriate cases.
  • The opinion relied on existing Supreme Court authority (Ashok Kumar Singh) rather than laying down a new precedent; the decision applies the established principle that misinterpretation of a judicial order may negate the necessary element of wilfulness for civil contempt.

Direct effect on the parties: Contempt proceedings were dropped; the impugned promotion(s) and the challenged seniority list were withdrawn; officers' apologies were accepted; and a warning was issued to responsible officials regarding cautious compliance with court directions. No new legal precedent was announced; the Court applied existing authorities.

    C.L. Sharma, In Re

    A.H Saikia, C.J:— This Suo-Motu civil contempt proceeding has been initiated on 15.7.2009 against (i) Mr. C.L Sharma, Special Secretary to the Government of Sikkim, Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms and Training, (ii) Mr. R.K Purkayastha, Legal Remembrancer-cum-Secretary to the Government of Sikkim, Law Department and (iii) Mr. Tashi Wangyal, the then Superintendent of Police, Police Headquarters, Gangtok now Senior Vigilance Officer, Energy and Power Department, Government of Sikkim, Gangtok, having found a sprima facie case against them on perusal of the respective affidavits filed by all those 3 (three) officers abovenamed as directed by this Court on 1.6.2009 and 23.6.2009 in W.P (C) No. 10 of 2007 for alleged violation of the interim order passed by this Court on 22.5.2007 in W.P (C) No. 10 of 2007.

    2. We have heard Dr. (Ms.) Doma T. Bhutia, the learned Counsel for the petitioner in W.P (C) No. 10/2007 as well as Mr. J.B Pradhan, the learned Additional Advocate General, Sikkim (for short, ‘the AAG’) appearing on behalf of the alleged contemnors.

    3. The facts of the case which led to the initiation of the present suo-motu contempt proceedings may briefly be stated as follows:—

    One Adup Tshering Bhutia presently working as Inspector of Police in the Sikkim Vigilance Department within the Police Department, Government of Sikkim initiated a writ proceeding being W.P (C) No. 10 of 2007 wherein he, alleging non-consideration of his seniority, assailed the inter-se-seniority list of the Police Inspectors in the Police Department notified on 14.11.2006 In the writ petition he sought the following reliefs:

    “(a) A writ in the nature of mandamus or any other writ, order or direction for quashing or cancelling the Impugned Notification 01.PHQ dated the 14.11.2006, along with the Annexures of inter-se-seniority list of the promotees, thereby issuing another fresh rectified notification correctly placing the petitioner in confirmed capacity of Police Inspector in seniority list as per the due process of law.

    (b) A writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order or direction in the nature thereof directing the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 to issue fresh notification and prepare a fresh list of seniority for the promotees thereby duly incorporating the name of the petitioner in confirmed capacity of Police Inspector and to place in senior position according to the established rules.

    (c) Issue a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order or direction in the nature thereof directing the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 to establish a transparent and fair system while maintaining fresh confirmed seniority list of Police Inspectors according to the procedure established by law.

    (d) and pass such other order or orders as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the fact and circumstances of the case.”

    4. While admitting the said writ petition, this Court vide order dated 22.5.2007 passed an interim order in the following terms:

    “In view of the above submission and in view of the peculiar nature of the notification describing almost everybody as officiating in a so called confirmed seniority list, there will be an interim order restraining the respondents, their servants, officers, employees and agents from in any manner giving any effect to the said notification dated 14.11.2006 in so far as it describes the annexure thereof as a confirmed seniority list.”

    5. The interim order also provided as follows:

    “The writ petitioner is free to make a representation and the respondents to pass their decision thereon notwithstanding the pendency of the writ petition. All steps taken during the pendency of this writ petition will be subject to the final decision of the Court. The respondents are not prevented in any manner from declaring the writ petitioner or any others in the above said list as confirmed, if it Appears to them to be the right course to take in accordance with the rules and the recommendations of the Committees and the Board in operation in the field.”

    6. In the course of hearing of the above writ petition on 1.6.2009, it was brought to our notice through the rejoinder filed on behalf of the petitioner on 2.9.2008 that despite the interim order dated 22.5.2007, as quoted above, being in force, the respondent No. 1 Mr. C.L Sharma, Special Secretary to the Government of Sikkim, Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms and Training issued the offending Officer Order dated 18.7.2008 (Annexure R-3 to the rejoinder) thereby promoting two Police Inspectors namely, Tilak Kumar Chettri and B.B Subba whose names appeared at serial Nos. 1 and 2 of the impugned inter-se-seniority list dated 14.11.2006, to the post of Deputy Superintendent of Police on officiating capacity. The offending order dated 18.7.2008 reads as under:

    “GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM

    DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL A.R & TRAINING, PUBLIC GRIEVANCES, CAREER OPTION, EMPLOYMENT SKILL DEVELOPMENT AND CHIEF MINISTER'S SELF-EMPLOYMENT SCHEME, GANGTOK

    No. 704.G/DOPDated 18.7.2008

    OFFICE ORDER

    The Governor is pleased to promote the following Police Inspectors to the rank of Deputy Superintendent of Police in the scale of Rs. 7500-250-12000 on officiating capacity with immediate effect subject to final decision of the Court in W.P No. 10 of 2007.

    1. Shri Tilak Kumar Chettri, PI, Sub-Jail, Namchi

    2. Shri B.B Subba, PI/OC, Rangpoo.

    Their promotion on officiating capacity shall be subject to the following conditions:

    1. The officiating promotion shall not confer any right for regular promotion and shall not be counted for seniority.

    2. The regular promotion shall be made on the recommendation of the Sikkim Police Service Commission.

    BY ORDER

    (C.L SHARMA)

    SPECIAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM, DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL A.R & TRAINING, PUBLIC GRIEVANCES, CAREER OPTION, EMPLOYMENT SKILL DEVELOPMENT AND CHIEF MINISTER'S SELF-EMPLOYMENT SCHEME, GANGTOK”

    7. Evidently the above offending Office Order makes a reference to the writ petition i.e W.P (C) No. 10 of 2007 saying that the promotion shall be subject to final decision of the Court in the said W.P (C) No. 10 of 2007. This goes to show that the officer concerned responsible for issuing the Office Order dated 18.7.2008 was fully aware of the interim order passed on 22.5.2007 to the effect “restraining the respondents, their servants, officers, employees and agents from in any manner giving any effect to the said notification dated 14.11.2006…….”

    8. When the matter was subjudice, admittedly, no application whatsoever was moved before this Court for modification, alteration or cancellation of the interim order passed on 22.5.2007 as abovementioned before issuing offending Office Order dated 18.7.2008 by the respondents.

    9. Since the interim order as indicated above was thus in operation, at the time of passing the Office Order dated 18.7.2008, the Officer concerned was asked by this Court on 1.6.2009 to explain and clarify the necessity for issuance of such Officer Order by filing a detailed affidavit and also to appear in person on 23.6.2009 before this Court as the Court felt it appropriate to hear the officer also.

    10. Further our attention was also drawn to the fact that even the direction given in the penultimate paragraph of the interim order dated 22.5.2007, as already quoted above, whereby the writ petitioner was given the liberty to make a representation to the concerned authority and on such representation the respondents were required to pass their decisions notwithstanding the pendency of this writ petition, was also violated and the same is evident from the perusal of the affidavit, particularly Annexure R-14 appended to the said affidavit filed by one Kuber Sharma, Additional Secretary in the Sikkim Police Department, Government of Sikkim verified on 19.3.2008 on behalf of the respondent No. 1, the Chief Secretary to the Government of Sikkim, respondent No. 2, the Director General of Police, respondent No. 3, the Additional Secretary, Sikkim Police and respondent No. 4, the Secretary, Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms and Training, Government of Sikkim. This annexure clearly indicates that the petitioner had filed a representation dated 3.7.2007 pursuant to the order/direction recorded in the penultimate paragraph of the order dated 22.5.2007 of this Court passed in W.P (C) No. 10 of 2007, as indicated above, addressing the same to the Director General of Police, Police Headquarters, Government of Sikkim, Gangtok. Significantly Annexure R-14 annexed to the same affidavit goes to show that it was not the Director General of Police before whom the representation was submitted, but the Superintendent of Police, Police Headquarters, Gangtok who informed the petitioner on 19.7.2007 that his representation dated 3.7.2007 was being examined by the Police Headquarters and the outcome would be communicated to him in due course of time. The communication dated 19.7.2007 as mentioned above reads as follows:

    “No. 377.SP/HQ/07Dated 19.7.2007

    Please refer to your representation dated 3rd July, 2007 submitted by you to the DGP/SKM. The matter is being examined by the PHQ and the outcome will be communicated to you in due course of time.

    Superintendent of Police

    Police Headquarters,

    Gangtok.

    PI/Adup Tshering Bhutia

    Vigilance

    Gangtok”

    11. Be it noted that by order dated 22.5.2007 it was clearly provided that the petitioner was free to make a representation and then the respondents might pass their decisions on the representation notwithstanding the pendency of the writ petition. Surprisingly this did not happen in this case. In the premises above, the Court also felt it necessary to ask the said officer i.e the Superintendent of Police, Police Headquarters, Gangtok to explain under what authority he issued such communication when the representation was addressed to the Director General of Police, Police Headquarters, Government of Sikkim, Gangtok as one of the respondent i.e respondent No. 2 to file an affidavit and to explain as to why the direction of the Court was not complied in letter and spirit by filing an affidavit. On 1.6.2009 it was ordered accordingly. The Superintendent of Police, Police Headquarters, Gangtok was further directed to appear in person on 23.6.2009

    12. On 23.6.2009, Mr. C.L Sharma, Special Secretary to the Government of Sikkim, Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms and Training, Mr. Tashi Wangyal, Senior Vigilance Officer, Energy and Power Department, Government of Sikkim the then Superintendent of Police, Police Headquarters, Gangtok along with Mr. D.B Thapa, the present Superintendent of Police, Police Headquarters, Gangtok appeared in person in compliance of the order dated 1.6.2009 and both the officers namely, Mr. C.L Sharma and Mr. Tashi Wangyal filed their respective affidavits.

    13. The affidavits dated 17.6.2009 and 22.6.2009 filed by Mr. C.L Sharma and Mr. Tashi Wangyal respectively were also placed on record.

    14. On meticulous scrutiny and careful perusal of the averments made and the explanation submitted in those affidavits, particularly the affidavit filed by Mr. C.L Sharma, the concerned officer, the Court noticed that the concerned officer passed the offending Office Order dated 18.7.2008 on the basis of the legal advise rendered by the Legal Remembrancer-cum-Secretary, Law, Government of Sikkim as well as Hon'ble Mr. Justice R.K Patra (Retd.), Chairman, Law Commission of Sikkim.

    15. Therefore, having given due consideration to the entire facts and circumstances of the case and also taking note of the averments and explanations as set out in the affidavits, the Court considered it appropriate to summon the Legal Remembrancer-cum-Secretary, Law Department, Government of Sikkim to appear in person on 15.7.2009 and to explain the circumstances and the necessity for rendering such advise as quoted in the affidavit dated 17.6.2009 itself when the entire matter was subjudice with the interim order in question being in operation. The Legal Remembrancer-cum-Secretary, Law was also directed to place on record a detailed affidavit in this regard.

    16. Pursuant to such direction, Mr. R.K Purkayastha, Legal Remembrancer-cum-Secretary, Law also filed his affidavit.

    17. On 15.7.2009 all the officers namely Mr. C.L Sharma, Mr. Tashi Wangyal and Mr. R.K Purkayastha appeared in person. On close scrutiny and scanning of averments and statements made in those affidavits as well as upon hearing the learned Counsel for the parties, this Court was of the view that the explanations were not satisfactory and accordingly, the Court came to the conclusion that there was a prima facie case to initiate the contempt proceedings against the concerned officers.

    18. Accordingly, the instant suo-motu case has been initiated.

    19. Be it further mentioned herein that both the affidavits filed by the officers namely Mr. C.L Sharma, Special Secretary to the Government of Sikkim, Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms and Training and Mr. R.K Purkayastha, Legal Remembrancer-cum-Secretary, Law respectively, categorically register that while issuing the offending order they have acted upon the legal opinion of Hon'ble Mr. Justice R.K Patra (Retd.), Chairman, Law Commission of Sikkim to whom Mr. R.K Purkayastha had forwarded the file for his valuable opinion.

    20. Mr. R.K Purkayastha, Legal Remembrancer-cum-Secretary, Law, before whom the file was placed for his comments, on 14.5.2008 gave the following opinion:

    “Ref. Above and pre-page

    The observation at above have been perused. The view expressed at NSP-2X when viewed against the back drop of the order of the Hon'ble High Court reveals two sides of the matter.

    On the face of the order of the High Court it is clearly seen that the “respondents are not prevented in any manner from declaring the writ petitioner or any other in the above list as confirmed.”

    If this is the issue and the opportunity and liberty given by the High Court could be considered.

    However Hon'ble Chairman may give his valuable opinion please…….

    L.R-cum-Secretary

    Law Deptt.”

    21. The legal opinion given by Hon'ble Mr. Justice R.K Patra as reflected from the affidavits filed by those two officers is extracted here under:—

    “Pendency of the writ petition (C) No. 10 of 2007 in the High Court of Sikkim is no bar to take the promotion matter of P. Is to the post of Deputy Superintendent of Police. The High Court has not prohibited or injuncted from promoting the P.Is On the other hand the High Court vide order No. 3 dated 22.5.2007 has given liberty to the State to confirm the writ petitioner or any other officer according to law. This means that promotions can be made in accordance with the relevant rules but such confirmation or promotion shall abide by the final decision of the Court.

    It is not known when the Writ petition will be finally disposed of by the High Court. Therefore promotion of P.Is to the post to Deputy Superintendent of Police can be made according to the rules and procedures but such promotion shall be subject to the final decision of the High Court.

    I may say that if any officer is now promoted, it may be clearly mentioned in the order itself that the promotion shall be subject to final decision of the Court in writ petition No. 10 of 2007.”

    22. A close perusal of the above legal opinion shows that it was opined that there was no bar to take up the promotion matter of the Police Inspectors to the post of Deputy Superintendent of Police as the High Court had not prohibited or injuncted the Department from promoting the Police Inspectors when the direction in the interim order dated 22.5.2007 was very clear to the effect that the respondents, their servants, officers, employees and agents should not give any effect to the confirmed seniority list notified vide notification dated 14.11.2006 Thus the opinion, to say the least, is not in conformity with the specific direction contained in the order dated 22.5.2008

    23. The question is as to whether in the circumstances of the case as narrated hereinabove, the contemners have committed any act of contempt of Court as envisaged under the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 (for short, ‘the Act’) and if so whether any action is called for.

    24. As per the definition given in section 2 Clause (b) of the Act, a civil contempt means “wilful disobedience to any judgment, decree, direction or writ or other process of a Court, or wilful breach of any undertaking given to a Court”. Thus, according to this definition, a disobedience, if it is to be punishable as a contempt, must be wilful. In other words, a disobedience without wilful default would not amount to contempt and as such, it does not attract the provision of the contempt law. No one will, therefore, be proceeded against for disobedience of an order of a Court except for a “wilful violation” of the order.

    25. A direct authority on the point is the decision rendered by the Apex Court in Tapan Kumar Mukherjee v. Shri Heromoni Mondial . 1991 Cri LJ 390. wherein it was been held that it must be proved beyond doubt that there is wilful contempt committed by the contemner. It is thus well-settled that in case of civil contempt unless it is wilful, the contemner cannot be held guilty of Contempt of Court.

    26. Bearing the above principle of law in mind, we now propose to consider as to whether the disobedience in the case at hand is wilful and if so, whether the contempt law is attracted. From the facts situation that we have narrated in the preceding part of this judgment, it would be clear that the specific direction to the respondents/contemners herein was to the effect that no effect should be given to the impugned seniority list, what was left open to the respondents was only declaring the petitioner or any member of the service as confirmed according to rules on the recommendation of the Committee and the Board in operation in the field. It is despite such direction that the contemner No. 1 proceeded to issue the promotion order of one Tilak Kumar Chettri and B.B Subba both Pis whose seniority was under challenge, to the post of Dy. SPs. No doubt, the promotion was conditional in the sense that it was to be subject to the final order that may be passed in the writ petition. However, it is obvious that the said promotion order, though conditional, is based on the seniority list under challenge. Therefore, the promotion order, i.e, the offending order, without doubt, runs counter to the order of the Court dated 22.5.2009 It is thus hardly necessary to say that the violation of the order of this Court is clear and distinct. But as already noted above, violation or disobedience of an order alone is not enough to constitute the wrong of civil contempt as envisaged in the Act. In order to make such disobedience amounting to Civil Contempts, the other condition that must accompany to such disobedience is wilful default. Therefore, the question that now needs consideration is whether such disobedience is wilful in the case at hand.

    27. It is worth mentioning herein that during the pendency of this contempt issue it was informed by Mr. Pradhan, the learned AAG that both the Office Order dated 18.7.2008 by which Mr. Tilak Kumar Chettri and Mr. B.B Subba were promoted to the post of Deputy Superintendent of Police on officiating capacity and Office Order dated 19.2.2009 by which Mr. Tulsi Prasad Chettri and Mr. Nema Chedhar Bhutia were also promoted to the post of Deputy Superintendent of Police on officiating basis, were withdrawn vide Office Orders dated 9.7.2009 In support of his submission, Mr. Pradhan relied on the affidavit dated 10.7.2009 filed by Mr. C.L Sharma, Special Secretary to the Government of Sikkim, Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms and Training, wherein both the Office Orders dated 9.7.2009 as indicated above were annexed as Annexure A-1 and A-2 respectively. It is also stated by Mr. Pradhan that the impugned seniority list has also been withdrawn and the Government is proposing to issue a fresh list.

    28. Now as regards “wilful default”, the alleged contemners namely Mr. C.L Sharma and Mr. R.K Purkayastha have taken shelter in the legal opinion sought for and given by the Chairman, State Law Commission and they have also made it clear in their affidavit that they had issued the offending order entirely on the basis of the legal opinion given by the Law Commission. In order to demonstrate that the contemners had no intention to flout the order of the Court, the offending order has now been withdrawn and to add to that the contemner have tendered an unconditional apology. It is felt that the interpretation recorded by the Law Commission upon the order of the Court ought to have been avoided since the issue in question is being subjudice.

    29. Nevertheless we still wonder what makes Mr. R.K Purkayastha, Legal Remembrancer-cum-Secretary, Law, being the responsible law officer of the State Government, who is fully aware of the operation of the interim order, to send the connected file pertaining to the offending issue of promotion of those officers, being solely an administrative matter to the Chairman, Law Commission for his valuable opinion when the power of the Law Commission has specifically outlined in the terms and conditions vide Notification dated 6.8.1976

    30. Amongst of these terms and conditions, Clause (9) only gives the power to the Chairman to give opinion in question of law. We are of the firm view that the present offending action was an administrative matter regarding promotion of Police Inspectors to Deputy Superintendent of Police without involving any question of law of importance and for that purpose the authority simply ought to have approached the Court itself either for vacation/alteration/modification of the interim order or for seeking permission for such promotion in the interest of administrative exigencies which was not done in the instant case for the reasons best known to them. The order of this Court was never meant to say that it was open for the department to issue promotion order but the same shall be subject to the outcome of the writ. In such premises, the Law Secretary, in sending the related file to the Chairman, Law Commission, it appears, acted with total non-application judicial mind and in a manner of shifting the responsibility to the Law Commission.

    31. Be that as it may, the question we are now confronted with and to resolve is whether a person should be held guilty of contempt if his offending action is based on such misinterpretation of the direction or orders of the Court. As per the law laid down by the Supreme Court in Ashok Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar if there is a misinterpretation of the directions or orders of the Court, it cannot conclusively be said that the contemners have wilfully, deliberately or contemptuously flouted or disobeyed the order of the Court. Taking due note of the fact that there was misinterpretation of the related orders and direction, the Apex Court in para 11 of the judgment observed as follows:

    “From the material on record and after hearing learned Counsel for the parties, we are not satisfied that it is a case in which it can conclusively be said that the respondents have wilfully or deliberately or contemptuously flouted or disobeyed the order of this Court dated 7.2.1991 It appears to us to be a case of misinterpretation of the executive directions and order of this Court dated 7.2.1991 and is, therefore, not a fit case in which contempt proceedings need to proceed any further.”

    (emphasis added)

    32. The foregoing discussion would make it sufficiently clear that had there been no legal opinion by the Commission based on misinterpretation of the Court's order on a subjudice matter, the offending order would not have been issued in all probability. Such an inference is justified inasmuch as the impugned seniority list as well as the offending order have been withdrawn immediately as averred in the affidavit filed by the alleged contemners. Such a course in all probability would not have been adopted if there was an intention to flout the order of the. Court.

    33. That apart, both the contemners responsible for issuing such offending Office Order have tendered their unconditional apology. Since the respondents have tendered their unconditional apology, we accept the same. Acceptance of apology also can be said to be a magnanimous act on the part of the Court.

    34. Given facts and circumstances in its totality, we consider it legitimate to infer that had there been no misinterpretation of the relevant order at the level of the Chairman, Law Commission, there would have been no occasion to issue the offending order. Such being the circumstance under which the offending order came to be issued, we have no hesitation to hold that the present case is squarely covered by Ashok Kumar Singh's case (supra).

    35. Consequently, having regard to the judicial precedent as mentioned above and keeping in view the acceptance of the unconditional apology tendered by the contemners, we are of the view that it is not a fit case in which the present contempt proceedings needs to proceed any further against those two officers. Hence this suo-motu civil contempt proceeding stands dropped.

    36. Now coming to the case of other contemner Mr. Tashi Wangyal, the then Superintendent of Police, Police Headquarters, Government of Sikkim, it is seen that although the representation dated 3.7.2007 submitted by the petitioner before the respondent No. 2, the Director General of Police pursuant to this Court's order dated 22.5.2007 it was this officer to whom no direction was issued by this Court, being entrusted by superior officer like Director General of Police who ought to have disposed to dispose of the representation, made the above communication dated 19.7.2007 We have carefully gone through the explanation set out by him in his defence accompanied by unconditional apology so rendered by him. Though we are not fully satisfied with the explanation, in the interest of justice and also taking into account the unconditional apology, we refrain from taking any action under the law of contempt.

    37. Accordingly, we drop this contempt proceeding against him with a note of warning that the officer concerned to whom any direction has been given for consideration of the representation, it would be the duty and responsibility of the said officer for disposal of such representation, or any other responsible officer who may be duly delegated to carry out such direction. Before parting with this contempt matter, we would like to put on record that the officers working under the State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India should exercise their power with utmost vigilance in interpreting or compliance of the Courts' orders, particularly where the matter is subjudice. In a pending case, they must act with diligent, care and caution in dealing with any order of the Court including the interpretation of such orders. Be it noted that any such misinterpretation of the judicial Order while the matter is subjudice would be viewed seriously and the Contempt of Court would be the only recourse.

    38. Be it also mention herein that meanwhile the main writ petition has also been disposed of as the Government has already withdrawn the impugned seniority list.

    39. Writ Petition Disposed Of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    C.L. Sharma, In Re
    (Dec 8, 2009)