Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Deep Jot Singh Anand v. Union Of India Others

    Swatanter Kumar, J.

    1. The Petitioner is the owner of the agricultural land measuring about 25.15 Bighas in Khasra No. 65/ 5/2 (0-12), 6/1 (2-8), 66/1/1 (0-2), 1/2 (2-7), 1/2/2 (2-7), 66/2 (4-16), 3 (4-16), 4 (4-16), 5 Min. (1-10), 10/1 (2-8) in the Revenue Estate of Village Tikri Kalan, Nangloi, New Delhi. The land was acquired by the appropriate Government by invoking the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act (hereinafter referred to as the 'Act'). The Award was made and thereafter notice under Section 12 (2) of the Act read with Section 31(1) of the Delhi Reforms Act on 29.10.1998 informing the Petitioner that vide Award No. 3/DCW/98-99 the Award had been published on 10.9.1997 and the Petitioner being an interested person he should receive the compensation payable to him in terms of the Award. After receiving the said letter the Petitioner claims to have sent his acceptance vide letter dated 9.11.1998. Thereafter, the Petitioner has been visiting the office of the Respondents on different occasions and claims to have met SDM (PB) on 27.10.1998 for removal of material at the site as well as for payment of compensation. It is also stated by the Petitioner that he had furnished requisite documents to the Respondents and again met the SDM Respondent No.3 on 25.5.1999 and requested for disbursement of payment to the Petitioner. Having failed to receive the entire compensation even payable in terms of the Award the Petitioner has approached this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India with a prayer that the compensation of Rs.72,51,223.77 in terms of the notice given by the Respondents dated 23.10.1998 besides interest solatium and compensation for trees, tube wells etc. should be ordered to be paid to the Petitioner immediately.

    2. Upon notice the Respondents filed the counter affidavit wherein it has been stated that the Department has never denied payment to the Petitioner and the Petitioner has not come forward to receive the compensation and the Petitioner can receive compensation legitimately due to him by contacting the office of the Land Acquisition Collector. It is not disputed that the compensation of Rs.72,51,223.77 is due to the Petitioner and the Petitioner is entitled to solatium additional amount @ 12% p.a. and interest @ 9% p.a. which has been allowed to the Petitioner and it is further stated that the Petitioner is not entitled to another further interest or compensation on account of trees, tube wells as claimed.

    3.It is clear that no payment had been made to the Petitioner for all this period. The Petitioner has placed on record copies of the various letters written by him to the Respondents. In one of the letters written by the Petitioner which also bears the receipt of the Department dated 31.10.2001 the Petitioner has specifically stated that he has already furnished requisite documents to the Respondent Department. Some of these letters are admitted to have been received by the Respondents but the stand of the Respondents before the Court on the basis of the record is that the Petitioner furnished the documents to the Department only recently and during the pendency of the petition payments have been made to the Petitioner.

    4.This writ petition was filed in this Court and notice to show cause why rule nisi be not issued was passed on 9.9.1999. Even after then no effort has been made on the part of the Respondents to make the payment to the Petitioner. It was only after the Court passed an order on 9.1.2002 directing the Respondents to bring the admitted amount to the Court and pay to the Petitioner. It was only different orders passed by this Court which resulted in payment of the part of their amount determined on account of compensation payable to the Petitioner for acquisition of his land.

    5. Still there was a difference of Rs.1, 27, 537.67 which was given to the Petitioner after number of hearings on 16.2.2005. While the admitted balance of Rs.2,88,748.65 was paid by the Respondents again on the previous date.

    6. It is certainly a matter of regret that a citizen whose land has been acquired by the appropriate Government in exercise of the authority vested in it under the provisions of the Act without payment of proper compensation. Least that is expected of the authorities which on the number of eminent domain can comparisely acquire the land to ensure that the payment of compensation as determined under the terms of the Award must be without delay. The explanation given by the Respondents that the Petitioner was not coming forward to receive his compensation does not find support even from the record of the Respondents themselves. We do not consider it proper to go into the greater details of this aspect of the case as admittedly reference under Section 1 has already been made to the Court of the learned District Judge. These questions can be effectively determined in those proceedings as it would be necessary for the purpose to lead proper evidence in support of their respective claim. According to the Respondents, as they had offered payment on 28.10.1998 they are not liable to pay interest. While according to the Petitioner, the Respondents are liable to pay the interest for all this period as they failed to make the payment despite best efforts of the part of the Petitioner. According to the Petitioner and to some extent rightly that even during the pendency of the petition even the admitted payment was not disbursed at one time and it was paid in installments this depriving the Petitioner of utility of the entire amount. As already noticed, the sum of Rs.2,88,748.65 was paid on one date while another difference of Rs.1,27,537.67 was paid on 16.2.2005. Once the proceedings under the special Act that is the Land Acquisition Act have been initited for determination of amount and/or enhancement and other ancilliary amount due to the Petitioner in regard to the acquisition of his land, it will not be proper for this Court to exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction in determining such disputes in that regard particularly when it would require documentary and/or oral evidence to be led to the parties.

    7. Learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner relied upon the judgment of this Court in Sunder Vs. Union of India, (2001) 7 SCC 211 to contend that he is entitled to receive interest on the whole amount including the solatium and he is further entitled to compensation because of inaction on the part of the Respondents. We have already noticed that determination of the final amount payable to the Petitioner along with the interest for the period 23.10.1998 to 19.2.2002 would be determined by the Court of competent jurisdiction in accordance with law.

    8. In view of our above discussion we dispose of this writ petition while granting liberty to the Petitioner to raise all these issues before the Court of competent jurisdiction. We further direct that the Respondents shall pay costs of the present petition of Rs.10,000/- as they have compelled the Petitioner to come to this Court even for the payment of admitted amount which has been paid on different dates for no fault of the Petitioner.

    9. We are of the considered opinion that the liability of costs should not be imposed ultimately upon an income tax payer and should not be permitted to be paid by the public exchequer. The costs at the first instance would be paid by the Respondents and then shall be recovered from the salary of the officers/officials responsible for this undue delay. The recovery shall be made in accordance with law and after granting them an opportunity within 3 months from the date the certified copy of this orders brought to the notice of the concerned authorities. The compliance report shall be submitted to the Registrar of this Court within one week from the expiry of the stipulated period of 3 months.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Deep Jot Singh Anand v. Union Of India Others
    (May 5, 2005)