Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 8(20) of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1979
  • Rule 8(2)) of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1979
  • Rule 3 of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline), Rules, 1976.
  • Rule 8(20) of the said Rules, 1979
  • Rule 8(20) of Rules 1979
  • sub-rule(20) of Rule 8,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 8(20) of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1979
  • Rule 8(2)) of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1979
  • Rule 3 of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline), Rules, 1976.
  • Rule 8(20) of the said Rules, 1979
  • Rule 8(20) of Rules 1979
  • sub-rule(20) of Rule 8,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was employed as Head Accountant with respondent No.1 and was removed from service by an order dated 31/07/1996 passed by the Executive Director of respondent No.1. Departmental proceedings had been initiated on 27/03/1995; a charge-sheet named the petitioner, Shri P.S. Udawant and Shri N.L. Kundalikar. The specific allegation against the petitioner was dereliction of duty for not verifying the character and honesty of Shri Kundalikar and an intentional breach of Rule 3 of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline) Rules, 1976. Shri Kundalikar was separately accused of misappropriating Rs. 5,86,016.37 and later accepted guilt and deposited the amount. An Inquiry Officer (Shri S.G. Muglikar) conducted the inquiry, submitted a report, and the Board of Directors accepted the findings. Show-cause notices were issued; following replies, the Board removed the petitioner and Shri Kundalikar from service and permanently withheld four annual increments of Shri P.S. Udawant. The petitioner challenged the removal order before this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the departmental inquiry violated principles of natural justice by not allowing the petitioner assistance of a senior officer or by not supplying relevant documents (i.e., adequacy of opportunity and access to documents).
  2. Whether Rule 8(20) of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1979 was mandatory in the circumstances (specifically when the delinquent did not examine himself), and whether non-compliance vitiated the inquiry.
  3. Whether the punishment of removal was disproportionate to the proven charge against the petitioner and whether there was discriminatory treatment compared to other delinquents (notably Shri P.S. Udawant).
  4. Whether the Court should interfere with departmental findings and punishment on grounds of procedural impropriety or proportionality.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Shri M.D. Joshi)

  • The petitioner was not allowed assistance of Shri Modak or any other person during the departmental proceedings and was not supplied with relevant documents; this amounted to violation of natural justice and rendered the inquiry bad in law.
  • Non-compliance with Rule 8(2) (the opinion text also refers to Rule 8(20) of Rules, 1979) vitiated the inquiry and the order of removal; reliance was placed on the Division Bench decision in Masuood Alam Khan-Pathan Vs. State of Maharashtra and others (2009 (5) Mh.L.J. 68).
  • The petitioner faced only allegations of negligence (failure to verify character/integrity of Kundalikar) and not misappropriation; Kundalikar accepted guilt and repaid the amount. Since Shri P.S. Udawant faced the same charge but received a minor punishment (withholding of four increments), the petitioner's removal was discriminatory.
  • The punishment of removal was grossly disproportionate to the charge.

Respondent No.1's Arguments (as advanced by Shri R.P. Powar)

  • Compliance with Rule 8(20) of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1979 was not mandatory in the facts of the present case; non-compliance caused no prejudice to the petitioner.
  • The principles of natural justice were followed and the petitioner was given a proper opportunity; documents were made available for inspection.
  • The charges against the petitioner were proved and his conduct was not befitting the responsible post; the punishment imposed was appropriate.
  • The Court should not sit in appeal over departmental proceedings and findings, and ought not to interfere with the inquiry outcomes.
  • The employer had lost faith in the petitioner and there was evidence that the petitioner had connived with Shri Kundalikar, warranting dismissal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Masuood Alam Khan-Pathan Vs. State of Maharashtra & others (2009 (5) Mh.L.J. 68) That sub-rule (20) of Rule 8 is pregnant with the rule of audi alteram partem; departure from it would constitute violation of natural justice. The court relied on this Division Bench decision to support the conclusion that non-observance of Rule 8(20) amounted to denial of opportunity to explain and thus vitiated the inquiry.
State of M.P. & Ors. Vs. Hazarilal, AIR 2003 SC 1300 Recognition that the Wednesbury principle has been replaced by the doctrine of proportionality in judicial review. The court invoked Hazarilal to apply the doctrine of proportionality in assessing whether the punishment was disproportionate to the proven charge.
Indian Airlines Ltd. Vs. Prabha D. Kumari ((2006) 1 SCC 67) Listed among authorities illustrating the application or discussion of proportionality in administrative/judicial review. Referenced via the Hazarilal quotation to show supporting authorities for the shift to proportionality; used to contextualize the proportionality analysis.
State of U.P. Vs. Sheo Shankar Lal Srivastava ((2006) 3 SCC 276) Another authority referenced in the context of proportionality in judicial review. Appears in the Hazarilal passage quoted by the court to demonstrate the jurisprudential shift to proportionality.
M.P. Gangadharan & another Vs. State of Kerala and others (AIR 2006 SC 2360) Authority cited in the discussion of proportionality replacing Wednesbury unreasonableness. Included in the Hazarilal excerpt relied upon by the court when applying the proportionality doctrine to the punishment imposed.
Seal (FC) (Appellant) Vs. Chief Constable of South Wales Police (Respondent) ((2007) 4 All ER 177) Example from the United Kingdom showing application of the doctrine of proportionality. Quoted in the Hazarilal passage reproduced by the court to illustrate comparative jurisprudence on proportionality; used to support heightened scrutiny in proportionality analysis.
Haung (FC) (Respondent) v. Secretary of State for the Home Department (Appellant) ((2007) 4 All ER 15) UK authority cited among cases illustrating proportionality's application. Referenced via the Hazarilal quotation to support the court's adoption of proportionality principles in reviewing punishment.
Tweed (Appellant) vs. Parades Commission for Northern Ireland (Respondents) ((2007) 2 All ER 273) UK case discussing proportionality and intensity of review. Quoted in the Hazarilal excerpt and used to explain that proportionality may require assessment of the balance struck by decision-maker, informing the court's proportionality review.
Belfast City Council (Appellants) Vs. Miss Behavin' Limited (Respondents) ((2007) 3 All ER 1007) Another UK authority cited alongside other proportionality cases. Referred to through the Hazarilal quotation as part of the jurisprudential background on proportionality considered by the court.
R (on the application of Countryside Alliance and others) vs. Her Majesty's Attorney General and another ((2007) 3 WLR 922) UK decision cited among examples of the doctrine of proportionality in practice. Included in the Hazarilal passage; used by the court to demonstrate comparative authority for applying proportionality in review of administrative decisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court addressed the petitioner's grievances in a sequential manner and on the legal materials presented:

  1. On the contention of denial of assistance and documents: the court examined the record and concluded that the presenting officer was not a lawyer but whenever the petitioner requested documents he was provided inspection of the same. The court accepted respondent's submission and prior orders of the Inquiry Officer showing access to documents, and held the objection to be without substance.
  2. On the issue of Rule 8(20) of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1979: the court reproduced the sub-rule and undertook a textual interpretation of its language. It observed that the rule uses 'may' in one part and 'shall' in another; where the delinquent has not examined himself the word 'shall' makes it obligatory for the inquiring authority to question him on circumstances appearing against him in the evidence so as to enable explanation. Because it was undisputed that the delinquent did not examine himself, the court concluded the Inquiry Officer was obliged to question the petitioner; this mandatory provision was not complied with, and therefore the inquiry was vitiated. The court relied on the Division Bench decision in Masuood Alam Khan-Pathan to reinforce that sub-rule (20) embodies audi alteram partem and non-observance violates natural justice.
  3. On proportionality and comparative punishment: the court observed that the doctrine of proportionality has replaced the Wednesbury principle in judicial review, citing State of M.P. Vs. Hazarilal (and the authorities referenced therein). The court compared punishments: Udawant (charged similarly) received withholding of four increments, whereas the petitioner was removed—an outcome comparable to Kundalikar who had actually misappropriated funds. The court found no reason given by respondent No.1 for this differential treatment and concluded that removal was disproportionate to the proven charge of negligence for not verifying character/integrity. Applying the proportionality doctrine, the court held the punishment did not satisfy the proportionality test and thus was liable to be set aside on this ground as well.
  4. Remedy analysis: although the court quashed the termination order, it declined to order reinstatement or back wages. The reasons given were: the principle of 'no work no pay'; absence of pleading or proof that the petitioner was not gainfully employed during the relevant period; and the factual position that respondent No.1's establishment had ceased to function and employees had been given the benefit of a Voluntary Retirement Scheme (VRS). In view of these facts, the court directed that the petitioner be given the benefit of the VRS on par with an equally circumstanced employee, treating him as in employment on the date the VRS was made applicable.

Holding and Implications

The order of termination is quashed and set aside.

Direct consequences and implications for the parties:

  • The termination/removal order dated 31/07/1996 is quashed and set aside.
  • The court declined to order reinstatement or back wages to the petitioner (citing "no work no pay", lack of proof regarding employment status, and the fact that respondent No.1's establishment had ceased functioning and had implemented a Voluntary Retirement Scheme).
  • The petitioner is directed to be given the benefit of the Voluntary Retirement Scheme on par with an equally circumstanced employee, treating him as in employment on the date the VRS was made applicable by respondent No.1.
  • The rule is made absolute in the terms stated by the court, and there is no order as to costs.

The opinion does not assert that a new legal precedent was created; it applies existing principles (audi alteram partem under Rule 8(20) and the doctrine of proportionality) to quash the removal and to formulate a remedy tailored to the factual context (VRS benefit, no reinstatement/back wages).

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Vijay S/O Shamrao Bhale v. Godavari Garments Ltd. Another

    S.V. Gangapurwala, J.

    The petitioner takes exception to the order of his removal dated 31/07/1996 passed by the Executive Director of the respondent No.1, thereby removing the petitioner from the service as Head Accountant with effect from 31/07/1996, and further prays for directing the respondents to take the petitioner on duty as Head Accountant with effect from 31/07/1996 along with salary, increments, back-wages and other benefits.

    2. The petitioner at the relevant time was working as Head Accountant with the respondent No.1, departmental inquiry was initiated against one Shri P.S. Udawant, Shri N.L. Kundalikar a cashier and the petitioner on 27/03/1995 was issued the charge-sheet, as per the said charge-sheet, charge against petitioner was that the petitioner was guilty of dereliction of his duty by not verifying the character, honesty of Shri Kundalikar and intentionally committing breach of Rule 3 of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline), Rules, 1976. The allegations against one Shri P.S. Udawant were of similar nature, whereas Shri Kundalikar was accused of mis-appropriating a sum of Rs. 5,86,016.37 paise. The petitioner filed reply to the charge-sheet denying the allegations. The Executive Director of respondent No.1 appointed one Shri S.G. Muglikar, as an Inquiry Officer. The witnesses came to be summoned and the Inquiry Officer submitted the report. The Board of Directors agreed with the findings of the Inquiry Officer, and as such show-cause notice was issued to all three delinquents i.e. Shri P.S. Udawant, N.L. Kundlikar and the petitioner. After receipt of the reply, the Board of Directors of respondent No.1 passed an order of removing petitioner and Shri Kundalikar from service and four annual increments of Shri P.S. Udawant were permanently with-held. The petitioner has challenged the said order of removal before this Court.

    3. We have heard Shri M.D. Joshi, learned counsel for the petitioner, Shri R.P. Powar, learned counsel for the respondent No.1 and Shri K.B. Choudhari, Addl. G.P. for respondent No.2/State at length.

    4. Shri M.D. Joshi, learned counsel for the petitioner put-forth following prepositions :-

    i) The petitioner was not allowed the assistance of Shri Modak or any other person, during the course of the departmental proceedings and was also not supplied with the relevant documents, as such the inquiry is bad-in-law. According to him, the same tantamounts to violation of the principles of natural justice.

    ii) rule 8(2)) of the maharashtra civil services (discipline & appeal) rules, 1979 (here-in-after referred to as 'Rules, 1979) are not complied and as such the same vitiates the inquiry itself, inter alia the order of removal based on such inquiry is bad-in-law. The learned counsel for the petitioner relied on the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court, in a case of "Masuood Alam Khan-Pathan Vs. State of Maharashtar and others, reported in 2009 (5) Mh.L.J. 68."

    iii) There were no allegations of mis-appropriation against the petitioner, the allegations of mis-appropriation were only against Shri Kundlikar and Shri Kundlikar had also accepted his guilt, he had also deposited the amount. Only allegation against the petitioner was that the petitioner was negligent in not verifying the character and honesty of Shri Kundlikar. The charge against the petitioner and Shri P.S. Udawant were similar. But Shri P.S. Udawant was imposed a minor punishment i.e. his four increments are only with-held. Whereas the petitioner is ordered to be removed from service and there is discrimination.

    iv) The punishment imposed is too disproportionate to the charge levelled against the petitioner.

    5. Shri R.P. Powar, learned counsel for the respondent No.1 strenuously contended that :-

    i) In the present case, compliance of Rule 8(20) of the Maharashtra Civil Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1979 is not mandatory, keeping in view of the facts of the present case. No prejudice is caused to the petitioner by non-compliance of said Rule.

    ii) The principles of natural justice were followed, proper opportunity was given to the petitioner.

    iii) The charges levelled against the petitioner are proved and his conduct was not that befitting a person holding such a responsible post as Head Accountant, and as such the punishment imposed is proper.

    iv) This Court cannot sit in appeal over the departmental proceedings and as such may not interfere with the findings in the departmental proceedings and consequent punishment.

    v) The employer had lost faith in the petitioner. It is on record that petitioner has connived with Shri Kundlikar and the employer has rightly dismissed the petitioner.

    6. The objection of the petitioner, that he was not provided the necessary documents and assistance of Shri Modak or other senior officer, is without any substance. The presenting officer was not a lawyer and whenever the petitioner asked for the documents, he was provided inspection of the same. From time to time the petitioner was given access and inspection to the documents, as such the objection of Shri M.D. Joshi, learned counsel for the petitioner on this count is unsustainable. Shri Powar has rightly pointed out the orders passed by the Inquiry Officer in that regard.

    7. The argument of Shri Joshi that Rule 8(20) of the said Rules, 1979 are not followed requires consideration. The said Rule 8(20) of Rules 1979 reads as under :-

    "(20) The inquiring authority may, after the Government servant closes his case and shall, if the Government servant has not examined himself, generally question him on the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence for the purpose of enabling the Government servant to explain any circumstances appearing in the evidence against him."

    On perusal of the said Rule, it is manifest that the said Rule mandates the inquiring authority to question the delinquent on the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence, so that the delinquent may get opportunity to explain any circumstances appearing in the evidence against him. In the present case, the delinquent has not examined himself. If the delinquent has not examined himself, in that case the Inquiry Officer is not left with any discretion but has to question the delinquent about the circumstances appearing against him. The use of the word shall shows that the said provision is imperative and the same is mandatory. In the first part of the said Sub rule the legislature has used the word 'may', but when the delinquent has not examined himself has used the word "shall", which itself clarifies that the word shall has to be considered as mandatory. The use of the word 'may' at one place and 'shall' at another place in the same rule would strengthen the inference that these words have been used in their primary sense, and that 'shall' should be considered as mandatory. The use of the word 'shall' therein as against 'may' shows that the same is mandatory. The use of the word 'shall' with respect to one matter and the used word 'may' with respect to another matter, in the same rule, would lead to the conclusion that the word 'shall' imposes an obligation. Whereas the word 'may' confers a discretionary powers. If, the delinquent has not examined himself, then it is obligatory on the inquiring authority to question the delinquent on the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence for the purposes of enabling him to explain any circumstances appearing in the evidence against him, and if the delinquent has examined himself, then the discretion vests with the Inquiry Officer to question the delinquent or not.

    In the present case, it is not disputed that the delinquent has not examined himself, in such circumstances it was mandatory for the Inquiry Officer to question the petitioner regarding the circumstances appearing against him. The said Rule has not been complied, and as such inquiry stands vitiated. The Division Bench of this Court in the case of "Masuood Alam Khan-Pathan Vs. State of Maharashtra & others" referred supra has also observed that rule of Audi Alteram Partem is pregnant in the sub-rule(20) of Rule 8, departure there from would tantamount to violation of natural justice. On this count itself the inquiry vitiates, there cannot be any doubt that by non observance of the said rule the petitioner could not get the opportunity to explain regarding the circumstances which were prejudicial to him in the evidence.

    8. The other argument of Shri Joshi, learned counsel for the petitioner that the allegations against the petitioner were only of negligence in not verifying the character and the integrity of Shri Kundlikar, and for the same he cannot be held for mis-appropriation. The punishment imposed upon him is shockingly disproportionate to the charge levelled against him. One Shri P.S. Udawant was also charged with the same allegation but to him a minor punishment was given. Whereas the petitioner is removed from service, he has been given the same punishment as is given to Shri Kundlikar who had misappropriated the amount needs consideration.

    9. Now, it is a settled position that Wednesbury principle of unreasonableness is substituted by the doctrine of proportionality. The Apex Court in a case of "State of M.P. & Ors. Vs. Hazarilal, reported in A.I.R. 2003 S.C. 1300" in para No.12 to 14 has observed thus :-

    "12:- Furthermore the legal parameters of judicial review has undergone a change. Wednesbury principle of unreasonableness has been replaced by the doctrine of proportionality. (See : Indian Airlines Ltd. Vs. Prabha D. Kumari : ( 2006) 1) SCC 67 : State of U.P. Vs. Sheo Shankar Lal Srivastava : (2006) 3 SCC 276 and M.P.Gangadharan and another Vs. State of Kerala and others : AIR 2006 SC 2360)."

    "13 :- At this stage we may also notice the application of the Doctrine by the United Kingdom House of Lords in Seal (FC) (Appellant) Vs. Chief Constable of South Walves Police (Respondent) : ( 2007) 4 All. ER 177: Haung (FC) (Respondent) V. Secretary of State for the Home Department (Appellant) vs. Secretary of State for the Home Department(Respondent) (conjoined Appeals) : ( 2007) 4 All ER 15: Tweed (Appellant) vs. Parades Commission for Northern Ireland (Respondents) (Northern Ireland) ( 2007) 2 All ER 273: Belfast City Council (Appellants) Vs. Miss Behavin' Limited (Respondents) (Northern Ireland) ( 2007) 3 All ER 1007 and R (on the application of Countryside alliance and others) vs. Her Majesty's Attorney General and another ( 2007) 3WLR 922."

    "14 :- It is interesting to note that distinguishing between the traditional grounds of judicial review and the doctrine of proportionality, Lord Carswell in Tweed (Supra) after referring to previous decisions and authorities observed:

    "The starting point is that there is an overlap between the traditional grounds of review and the approach of proportionality. Most cases would be decided in the same way whichever approach is adopted. But the intensity of review is somewhat greater under the proportionality approach. Making due allowance for important structural differences between various convention rights, which I do not propose to discuss, a few generalisations are perhaps permissible. I would mention three concrete differences without suggesting that my statement is exhaustive. First, the doctrine of proportionality may require the reviewing court to assess the balance which the decision maker has struck, not merely whether it is within the range of rational or reasonable decisions. Secondly, the proportionality test may go further than the traditional grounds of review inasmuch as it may require attention to be directed to' relative weight accorded to interests and considerations. Thirdly, even the heightened scrutiny test developed in R V Minister of Defence, Ex p Smith ( 1996) QB 517, 554 is not necessarily appropriate to the protection of human rights."

    10. When Shri P.S. Udawant and the petitioner were charged alike, there was no reason for the respondent No.1 to discriminate between the two, nor any reasons are given to impose different punishment for both. The charge found to be proved against the petitioner is that the petitioner did not verify the character and integrity of Shri Kundlikar. For the same punishment of removal from service is too disproportionate and it does not satisfy the test of proportionality. On this count also the impugned order deserves to be quashed and set aside.

    11. Though we have come to the conclusion that the impugned order deserves to be quashed and set aside, but we are not inclined to order back-wages to the petitioner on the principle of 'no work no pay'. So also the petitioner has not pleaded or proved that during the relevant period, he was not gainfully employed. It has also been brought on record that the respondent No.1 establishment has ceased to function and all the employees in service have been given benefit of Voluntary Retirement Scheme. As such, we also do not pass any order of reinstatement, and the petitioner would be entitled only to the benefit of voluntary Retirement Scheme as were given to the other employees.

    12. In the result, we allow the petition and make Rule absolute and pass the following order :-

    The order of termination is quashed and set aside. However, since it is brought to our notice, that the respondent No.1's establishment has now ceased to function and all the employees who were in service have been given benefit of the Voluntary Retirement Scheme, we are not inclined to direct an order of reinstatement or the back wages. However, we direct the respondent No.1 to give benefit of Voluntary Retirement Scheme to the petitioner, on par with an equally circumstanced employee, treating the petitioner to be in the employment on the date on which the Voluntary Retirement Scheme was made applicable by the respondent No.1.

    13. Rule is made absolute in the aforesaid terms. However, there shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vijay S/O Shamrao Bhale v. Godavari Garments Ltd. Another
    (Jul 7, 2010)