Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • (2000 Edition) Delhi school Education Act, 1973 and Delhi School Education Rules, 1973
  • provisions of Rule 96 (9) of Delhi school Education Rules
  • Rule 43 of the Delhi School education Rules, 1973,
  • Sub-Rule 9
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • (2000 Edition) Delhi school Education Act, 1973 and Delhi School Education Rules, 1973
  • provisions of Rule 96 (9) of Delhi school Education Rules
  • Rule 43 of the Delhi School education Rules, 1973,
  • Sub-Rule 9

    Priti Sharma v. Govt. Of Nct Delhi

    S. N. AGGARWAL, J.

    (1) THE petitioner is B. A. B. Lib and has applied for her appointment to the post of Librarian against vacant post advertised by respondents No. 3 to 10 schools. She had applied pursuant to an advertisement issued by these schools for filling up of various teaching and non teaching vacant posts in their schools. It was mentioned in the advertisement issued by respondents No. 3 to 10 schools inviting applications from eligible candidates that the age, qualifications and pay scales for various posts will be as per Recruitment Rules of the Director of Education, Government of NCT, Delhi. The Recruitment Rules for the post of Librarian notified vide notification DE. 1 (10) (1)/86/e-1/43870-44830 Dt. 14-08-86 were circulated vide circular of Director of Education bearing No. DE. 15/act/in/59/93/rr/14680-14736, dt. 27. 10. 1993 and the same is annexed as Annexure-B at page 21 of the paper book. The petitioner was overage on the date she had applied for her appointment to the post of Librarian in the respondents No. 3 to 10 schools. Her date of birth is 21. 7. 1971 and in terms of the Recruitment Rules for the post of Librarian the age limit prescribed for direct recruitment to the said post is 18-30 years, relaxable upto 35 years as on 20. 7. 1986 for departmental candidates. But the petitioner being overage was not considered by the schools for her appointment to the post of Librarian and, therefore, she has filed the present writ petition seeking directions to respondents No. 3 to 10 to consider her candidature in terms of Recruitment Rules to the post of Librarian by granting her the benefit of age relaxation in terms of notification dated 1. 1. 1980.

    (2) THE notification dated 1. 1. 1980 on which the petitioner seeks to rely for grant of benefit of age relaxation is at page 22 of the paper book and is extracted below:-

    "no. F. 1/16/3/rands/79/ Dated 1st November, 1980 notification in exercise of the power vested in him under Rule 43 of the Delhi School education Rules, 1973, the Administrator is pleased to prescribe for women candidate a general relaxation for 10 years in the maximum age limited prescribed in the recruitment rules for recruitments to various posts of teacher in Delhi Schools. The Managing Committee shall, while considering women candidates for appointment to vacancies in their schools consider such candidates as per the revised ages limited for women candidates. (K. SETHURAMAN)DEPUTY SECRETARY (EDUCATION)''

    (3) MR. S. S. TIWARI, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner has contended that the post of Librarian is akin to the post of teacher and, therefore, according to him petitioner is entitled to age relaxation of 10 years beyond the maximum age prescribed in the Recruitment rules for the post of Librarian. It is submitted by Mr. Tiwari that in case the petitioner gets the benefit of age relaxation in terms of notification dated 1. 1. 1980 she comes within age and becomes entitled to be considered for her appointment to the post of Librarian in the respondents No. 3 to 10 schools.

    (4) MR. TIWARI has referred to the provisions of Rule 96 (9) of Delhi school Education Rules and relying on the same he has contended that the absence of word 'librarian' in Sub-Rule 9 imply intentment of the Rule making authorities that the post of teacher mentioned in Rule 96 (9) also includes the post of Librarian. Mr. Tiwari has further relied upon Part 'c' Form -V which deals with form of inspection. The contention of Mr. Tiwari is that reference to the contents of library facilities to be made part of the inspection report provided in Part 'c' at page 111 of book titled Akalam's (2000 Edition) Delhi school Education Act, 1973 and Delhi School Education Rules, 1973 would show that the Librarian is also required to impart teaching to the students in the school to inculcate in them the habit of general reading and to go to the library. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner has submitted that this Court may direct the respondents to grant the benefit of age relaxation to the petitioner also for her appointment to the post of Librarian as is granted to the women teachers for their appointment in the schools.

    (5) PER contra, Ms. Jyoti Singh, learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondents No. 1 and 2 has vehemently argued that the notification dated 1. 11. 1980 at page 22 of the paper book extends the benefit of age relaxation only to women teachers and not to the Librarians. She has also contended that the guidelines for post fixation in Government and Government aided schools separately provide for teaching staff and ancillary staff. She has placed on record guidelines for post fixation of teaching and ancillary staff of government and Government aided schools on record of this Court. A perusal of the said guidelines would show that the post of Librarian is included in the ancillary staff at Serial No. 7 of the said guidelines. The contention of ms. Jyoti Singh is that the post of Librarian cannot be equated with the post of a teacher because the nature of duties of both of them are quite different. She has also relied upon an unreported judgment of this Court in WP (C) No. 16051/2004 decided on 23. 09. 2008 wherein it was held that the post of Librarian cannot be equated with that of a teacher.

    (6) THIS Court having already considered the point as to whether the post of Librarian can be equated with the post of a teacher and decided the said question holding that the post of Librarian cannot be equated with that of a teacher, the question raised by the petitioner in the present writ petition is no longer res-integra This Court is of the opinion that the post of a Librarian by no means can be equated with that of a teacher. The post of Librarian falls in the category of non-teaching staff for which the maximum age prescribed in the Recruitment Rules is 30 years. It may be noted that the petitioner in the present writ petition has not challenged the vires of the Recruitment Rules applicable to the post of Librarian which have been notified by the Director of education to be strictly adhered to by the schools and in fact the petitioner herself has placed reliance on the said Recruitment Rules annexed along with the petition at page 21 of the paper book. Under the circumstances, I have no hesitation in holding that the petitioner is not entitled to benefit of age relaxation in terms of notification dated 1. 11. 1980 at page 22 of the paper book.

    (7) IN view of the above, I do not find any merit in this writ petition which fails and is hereby dismissed leaving the parties to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Priti Sharma v. Govt. Of Nct Delhi
    (Nov 21, 2008)