AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 7, and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2)(1) of Prevention of Corruption and vigilance Act.
  • Section 7, and 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of Prevention of Corruption Act. P.W.8
  • SECTION 7 PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • Section 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of Prevention of Corruption Act
  • Section 374 r/w Cr.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 7, and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2)(1) of Prevention of Corruption and vigilance Act.
  • Section 7, and 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of Prevention of Corruption Act. P.W.8
  • SECTION 7 PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • Section 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of Prevention of Corruption Act
  • Section 374 r/w Cr.P.C

    A. Ramasamy v. State By Inspector Of Police, Vigilance Anti-Corruption Divisin, Pudukkottai

    (Prayer: Criminal Revision Case filed under Section 374 r/w Cr.P.C against the judgment dated 29.08.2000 rendered in S.C.No.2 of 1994 by the additional District Judge cum Judicial Magistrate, Pudukkottai.)

    This Revision has been filed against the judgment dated 29.08.2000 rendered in S.C.No.2 of 1994 by the additional District Judge cum Judicial Magistrate, Pudukkottai.

    2. The gist of the case is as follows:

    i) P.W.2 is a resident of Mazhaiyur. He had 1.75 acres of land. He purchased land of 35 Kuzhi from one Arumugam in the year 1986 for Rs.3,150/- In order to transfer the patta for the said land in his name, he applied to Tahsildar, Alangudi, P.W.5, Swaminathan. The petition given by P.W.2 was forwarded to the accused by P.W.5 with a direction to send his recommendation within 15 days. Then P.W.2 along with his brother P.W.3 approached the surveyor's office. The predecessor of the accused demanded Rs.2,000/- for changing the patta in his name. After his transfer, P.W.2 approached the accused, who also assured to come and measure the land in 2 or 3 days. Then, in his absence, the accused came and measured the land in the presence of P.W.1's brother, Thangaiah and asked him to send his brother P.W.2 to the office. P.W.2 went to Taluk Office. At that time, accused demanded Rs.1,000/- for change of patta in his name. After bargaining, though P.W.2 agreed to give Rs.500/-, he was not willing to give bribe. On 17.01.1994 at about 2.30 p.m. P.W.2 and P.W.3 appeared before P.W.6, the Inspector, Prevention of Corruption, Pudukkottai and gave a complaint to him.

    ii) On receipt of the complaint, he registered a case in Crime No.1 of 1994 under Section 7 of Prevention of Corruption Act. First Information Report is Ex.P.10. Then to trap the accused, he obtained oral permission from the Commissioner. He requested Aathmanathan (P.W.4) and Madanagopal, to be the witnesses for the trap and he introduced P.W.4 to P.Ws. 2 and 3. He gave the complaint to them for perusal. Both of them perused the complaint and understood the nature of complaint. P.W.6 explained about the details of trap and the characteristics of phenolpthalein test as well as its use in a trap to Aathmanathan and Madanagopal. Then he asked the complainant,P.W.2 whether he brought the amount. P.W.2 produced currency notes of demnomination of three hundred rupee notes and four fifty ruppees notes, M.Os.1 and 2. Then P.W.6 applied chemical powder on either side of the currency notes and gave it to P.W.2 and instructed him not to touch the currency notes till the same was handed over to the accused. P.W.4, Aathmanathan, one of the trap witnesses was instructed to accompany P.W.2 and to watch the conversation between P.W.2 and the accused. He also instructed P.W.2 that after the demand and receipt of money by the accused, he should come out and give a signal by liting a match stick.

    iii) At about 5.00 p.m. P.W.6, along with P.Ws 2 to 4, and Madanagopal proceeded to Alangudi Taluk Office in a Government Jeep. P.W.2 was also instructed that if anybody asked who is P.W.4, he should introduce him as his brother-in-law. The vehicle was stopped at Alangudi Bus stop and P.Ws 2 to 4 were asked to go to the Taluk office. Then they went to the Taluk office. At about 6.00 p.m. P.W.2 came outside and gave the agreed signal by burning the match stick. Then P.W.6 along with Madanagopal went inside the office. On seeing them the accused became nervous. Then P.W.6 enquired about the amount. He prepared Sodium Carbonate solution in two glass tumblers through the Head Constable, Gopinath. When the accused dipped his right hand fingers in the solution of one glass tumbler, and left hand fingers in the solution of another glass tumbler, there was no change in the colour of the solution. Then the mixture was collected in two separate bottles M.Os 4 and 5 and they were marked as 'R' and 'L'. When the accused was asked about the money received by him from P.W.2, he took a bag kept under the table and opened it and showed the money. Then P.W.6 took the currency notes and compared it with the numbers noted in the mahazar. Further, along with currency notes, there was one Official Memorandum Ex.P.4. When the said Official Memorandum was subjected to Sodium Carbonate Solution Test, it turned pink red. Then the said mixture was collected and sealed in a separate bottle M.O.5 and marked as 'B'. It was signed by P.W.6 and the trap witness, Madanagopal. Then P.W.6 asked the accused about the concerned file, for which he told that the entire file was with the Village Administrative Officer. But when P.W.6 searched the bag of the accused, he recovered the concerned file containing pages 1 to 20 under Ex.P.12(s). He also recovered currency notes of Rs.500/-, three bottles containing solution marked as 'R','L' and 'B', a memorandum and a rexin bag M.O.3 under mahazar Ex.P.5. P.W.6, trap witness Madanagopal and the accused have signed in it. A copy of the mahazar was given to the accused. On the same day, at about 7.30 p.m. P.W.6 arrested the accused. He prepared observation mahazar Ex.P.6 and the same was attested by P.Ws.4 and 6. He also prepared a sketch Ex.P.13. The personal Register maintained by the accused is Ex.P.14 for the period from 07.12.93 to 02.01.1974. Then he recovered one official memorandum Ex.P.15 under Ex.R.1, from the Tahsildar, Alangudi. Then P.W.6 went to the office and lodged a report against the accused and registered it in Crime No.1 of 1994 and recorded the statements of P.Ws 2 and 3. At that time, P.W.2 handed over a chit Ex.P.16 and also an unfilled form Ex.P.17, allegedly given to him by the accused. Then he released the accused on bail.

    iv) Further investigation was conducted by Govindarajan, P.W.8, Inspector (Prevention of Corruption and Vigilance Section). He recorded statements of P.Ws 2,3 and 4. On 02.08.1994 he recorded the statement of P.W.1 and On 10.05.1994 he recorded the statement of P.W.5. He obtained sanction from P.W.1 to prosecute the accused. He sent a requisition Ex.P.10 to send the M.Os 1 to 6 for chemical analysis.

    v) P.W.7 was the Assistant Director in Forensic Laboratory, who received a box along with a letter and case details from the Court under Ex.P.18. He found three glass bottles each containing 160 ml of pink colour liquid. On analysis, he found that the liquid contains mixture of phenopthalein and Sodium Carbonate. He sent his report Ex.P.19. After the receipt of chemical analysis report, P.W.6 filed charge sheet against the accused under Sections 7, and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2)(1) of Prevention of Corruption and vigilance Act.

    3. Before the trial Court, in order to bring home the offence against the accused, the prosecution examined P.Ws 1 to 8 and marked Exs.P.1 to P.20 and marked M.os 1 to 6.

    4. On consideration of evidence, learned Additional District Judge cum Chief Judicial Magistrate, Pudukkottai found the accused guilty and sentenced him to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for a period of one year and to pay a fine of Rs.3,000/- in default to undergo Simple Imprisonment for a period of six months for the offence under Section 7 of Prevention of Corruption Act and to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for a period of two years ` and to pay a fine of Rs.2,000/- in default to undergo Simple Imprisonment for a period of six months for the offence under Section 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of Prevention of Corruption Act and sentenced the imprisonment concurrently.

    5. Aggrieved by the said judgment, the accused preferred the present appeal.

    6. The point for consideration is:

    Whether the prosecution has proved its case beyond reasonable doubt?

    7. The Point: The accused is the Surveyor in the Taluk Office, Alangudi. He was arrested by P.W.8, for the offence under Section 7, and 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of Prevention of Corruption Act. P.W.8 obtained sanction order from P.W.1 for prosecuting the accused.

    8. Learned counsel for the appellant vehemently argued that sanction is not valid. For this, he relied on the decision reported in 1998 Cri.L.J.2178 (Abdul Khalit VS The State of M.P.) and argued that the sanction to prosecute the accused is devoid of materials. Learned counsel relied on the sanction order Ex.P.1 given by P.W.1, which reads thus:

    "Whereas I, Thiru M.S.Sakthivel, Asst.Director of Survey and Land Records, Pudukkottai, being the authority competent to remove the said Thiru A.Ramasamy from office, after fully and carefully examining the materials such as copies of F.I.R., statements of witnesses, mahazure and other records placed before me in regard to the said allegations and circumstances of the case, am satisfied that the said Thiru A.Ramasamy should be prosecution in a Court of Law for the said offence."

    P.W.1 was examined to speak about the sanction order. P.W.1 was the Assistant Director of Survey and Land Records, Pudukkottai. His evidence would show that he perused the First Information Report, Statement of witnesses and other documents. He perused all the documents and satisfied and then only, he gave sanction Ex.P.1. His evidence would show that sanction order was issued by him properly. The learned counsel for the appellant/accused is not able to show any defect in the sanction order.

    9. This Court is of the considered view that the sanction order was passed after perusing relevant documents placed before P.W.1 and the sanction order is valid one and the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant that the sanction is not valid is not acceptable.

    10. P.W.2 purchased lands to an extent of 35 kuzhi for Rs.3,150/- from one Arumugam. P.W.3 is his brother. Both P.Ws.2 and 3 have approached the Surveyor, the predecessor of the accused for change of patta, for which he demanded a sum of Rs.2,000/-. Thereafter, he was transferred. Then P.Ws.2 and 3 approached the accused. Though he demanded Rs.1,000/- as bribe for change of patta in P.W.2's name, after bargaining, he agreed for Rs.500/-. P.W.5, Tahsildar on receipt of application of P.W.2, sent a communication to the accused directing him to send a report within 15 days. That report was not sent within 15 days. The accused demanded a sum of Rs.500/- and the same was not liked by P.W.2. So, he approached P.W.6., the Inspector, Prevention of Corruption and vigilance Section, Pudukkottai. P.W.6 requested Aathmanathan (P.W.4) and Madanagopal, to be the witnesses for the trap and he introduced P.W.4 to P.Ws. 2 and 3. He gave the complaint to them for perusal. Both of them perused the complaint and understood the nature of complaint. P.W.6 explained about the details of trap and the characteristics of phenolpthalein test as well as its use in a trap to Aathmanathan and Madanagopal. Then he asked the complainant, P.W.2 whether he brought the amount. P.W.2 produced currency notes of denomination of 3 hundred rupee notes and 4 fifty rupee notes, M.Os.1 and 2. Then P.W.6 applied chemical powder on either side of the current notes and gave it to P.W.2 and instructed him not to touch the currency notes till the same was handed over to the accused. P.W.4, Aathmanathan, one of the trap witnesses was instructed to accompany P.W.2 and to watch the conversation between P.W.2 and the accused. He also instructed P.W.2 that after the demand and receipt of money by the accused, he should come out and give a signal by burning a match stick. The accused demanded moneyfrom P.W.2. When the amount was given to the accused, he asked P.W.2 to put it in a bag. Then, at about 6.00 p.m. the complainant came out of the Office and gave the signal. Then P.W.6 accompanied with Madanagopal, went to the Office of the accused. On seeing them, the accused entered into the room of Tahsildar. On seeing the Police Officer the accused became nervous. He said that he did not receive the amount. Then a mixture of Sodium Bicarbonate was prepared in two glass tumblers and the accused was asked to dip his right and left hand fingers in the said solution. But the solution did not turn pink red. They were collected in two separate glass tumblers and marked as 'R' and 'L' under M.Os.4 and 5. Then the investigating officer asked the accused about the amount, for which, he took a bag from beneath the table and opened it and showed the amount. The investigating officer verified the number with the number notified in the mahazar. There was an Official Memorandum by the side of the said currency notes and when it was subjected to Sodium Carbonate Test, it turned into pink. The said mixture was collected in a separate bottle and marked as 'B' under M.O.6. Official Memorandum is Ex.P.11. When the investigating officer asked about the entire file, the accused said that the file was with V.A.O. But, when the bag of the accused was searched, the entire file containing 1 to 20 pages Ex.P.12(s) was available. Then he recovered the currency notes relating to this trap case, the official memorandum Ex.P.11, concerned file Ex.P.12 and the rexin bag M.O.3 under mahazar Ex.P.5. He arrested the accused at 7.30 p.m. Then he prepared observation mahazar Ex.P.6 and sketch Ex.P.13. He also recovered the personal register maintained by the accused under Ex.P.14. On the same day he recovered a Memorandum Ex.P.15 under Ex.D1 from Tahsildar, Alangudi. Then he went to the office and recorded the statements of P.Ws 2 and 3.

    11. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that there was no demand and hence, the prosecution is bound to fail. In support of his contention, he relied on the following decisions:

    "1.(2006) 2 M.L.J.(Cri) 12 (V.Subramaniam VS STate, by Inspector of Police, Vigilance & Anti-Corruption,Salem;

    (2) 2000 Cri.L.J.2273 (Smt.Meena Balwant Hemke VS State of Maharashtra) and

    (3) and argued that there was no demand and acceptance.

    12. Further he relied on II 1991(1) Crimes page 406 (Ale Hasan & Anr. VS State of U.P. and submitted that motive was not proved and the complainant cooked up a false case against the appellant.

    13. While analysing this case, in the light of the above decisions, it is clear that P.W.2 approached the accused to get patta for which he demanded illegal gratification. P.W.5 has categorically stated in his evidence that after the receipt of application from P.W.2 it was forwarded to the accused, and the accused must send his report within 15 days. But his evidence would show that the accused delayed it purposely. If really, the accused is not interested in getting money, he would have despatched the report within 15 days. So, his conduct would show that he has got motive to get illegal gratification. The evidence of P.W.2 would show that the accused demanded money. Since, he has got motive to receive illegal gratification, he delayed in sending the report. If he is proper in his duty, certainly, he would not have delayed in sending the report. Hence, the delay in sending the report would show that the accused had motive to demand illegal gratification. So, I find that the above said decision will not be helpful to him.

    14. Learned counsel relied on the decision reported in (i) 1988 Cri.L.J.1122 (Har Bharosey Lal VS STate of U.P.) (ii) A.I.R.1976 Supreme Court 91 (Raghbir Singh VS State of Punjab) (iii) 1998(1) Crimes 549 (MP) (Harishankar Vajpai VS STate of M.P.) (iv) 2005 M.L.J.(Cri) 864 (Ganga Kumar Srivastava VS State of Bihar) and (v) 1992 Supreme Court Cases (Cri) 290 and argued that there was no independent witness to prove the case of prosecution. Since P.W.2 and P.W.3, who is his brother, are interested witnesses and their evidence cannot be relied on.

    15. But as per the request of the higher official, P.W.4, who is the Senior Inspector in the Joint Registrar Office, Pudukkottai at the relevant point of time, went to the office of the Prevention of Corruption. He perused the complaint given by P.W.2 and he accompanied P.W.2 and he was present when the amount was given to the accused. He is an independent witness. Nothing was elicited from him to reject his evidence. He is not inimical to the accused. Absolutely, there is no evidence on record to show that he is not a competent witness or interested witness. Evidence of independent witness along with the evidence of P.W.2 would show that the demand of amount is true. Hence, the submission of the learned counsel for the appellant that the independent witness was not examined, is not correct.

    16. Learned counsel for the appellant relied on the decision reported in A.I.R.1975 Supreme Court 1432 (Sita Ram VS The State of Rajasthan) and argued that mere receipt of amount is not enough and the same has to be recovered from him. He also argued that the amount was recovered only under the table of Tahsildar. Further he submitted that there is no necessity for the accused to go to Tahsildar room. Evidence of P.Ws.2 and 4 would show that on seeing them, the accused entered into the room of Tahsildar. This was spoken by P.W.4 also. P.W.2 had spoken about the signal given by him and P.W.4 also had spoken about the intention of the accused. So, it is clear that the accused demanded money and the amount was given to him. But the accused cleverly asked P.W.2 to put the money inside the bag and keep it under the table. So, the accused is clever and intelligent enough to put the money into the bag which was in another room. When the investigating officer appeared and asked about the money, he became nervous. Then he handed over the bag to him. In the bag there was a memorandum and when it was put to phenopthalein test, it turned pink red. It is not denied by the accused. There is sufficient evidence to show that the money was put into the bag by P.W.2. Merely because the bag was not put to phenopthalein test it will not weaken the prosecution case.

    17. The accused relied on the Circular Ex.D.1 sent to the accused with a direction to conduct enquiry and sent a report within seven days. But, that circular will not strengthen the case of the accused. Evidence of P.Ws 2 and 4 is cogent, convincing and acceptable. There is demand of money and the accused received the money and the money was also recovered by the Investigating officer. The accused also had got motive to demand illegal gratification. There is no reason to reject the evidence of P.Ws 2 and 4. Hence, the prosecution proved the case satisfactorily. I do not find any illegality in the judgment of the Court below warranting interference by this Court.

    18. In the result, the appeal is dismissed. The judgment dated 29.08.2000 rendered in S.C.No.2 of 1994 by the Additional District Judge cum Judicial Magistrate, Pudukkottai.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    A. Ramasamy v. State By Inspector Of Police, Vigilance Anti-Corruption Divisin, Pudukkottai
    (Jul 17, 2007)